Originally posted by alfies
2) When a team has been gutted (not just sold, but gutted) you, Thorn, or DD can classify it as such, and those teams automatically move down to the bottom at the end of the season. So you promote and demote the top and bottom two non-gutted teams every season like you're currently planning to do, and on top of that you make additional promotions and demotions based on gutted teams. It may mean 4, 5, or 6 teams from one conference move up a season, but it will keep the bad teams at the lowest levels, and the good teams will move up. I guarantee the #4 team in AA is going to step into AAA and win games.
I like some of the points mentioned above. Allow me to expand on it.
Definitions
League - Africa, USA, Western Europe, Canada, etc...
Tier - Pro league, AAA, AA, A, BBB, etc...
Division - AA#1, AA#2, AA#3, AA#3, etc...
Conference - AA#6 West, AA#6 East, BBB#5 Alpha, BBB#5 Zeta, etc...
What we have here is a complex problem caused by poor ownership and poor sportsmanship. I believe that the current system of 2 best teams move up one tier and 4 worst teams move down one tier will eventually correct many of the problems after several/many seasons. However, defunct teams throw this system out of whack. I see two distinct, yet related problems here: Midseason ownership changes and League balance.
GLB is so new and has grown so quickly that there isn't enough difference between the top-teir divisions and the mid-to-bottom-tier divisions. E.G. I've seen teams in USA A that could compete in the USA Pro league. Another problem is that some divisions in a tier are full of tough teams, while others are full of crap teams.
You cannot ever reshuffle leagues/tiers/divisions/conferences mid-season for any reason. It would cause more headaches than it's worth. It's a horrible idea, even if a team is gutted and sold. The division/conference has to ride out the season with that team. However, something has to happen at the end of the season. But first how do you handle a team that must change ownership mid season...
When a team is sold mid-season, it should not get a new random owner. Instead:
1.) The computer immediately assumes ownership of the team, however, the team would retain it's human GMs until the end of the season. I.E. The human loses GM status automatically at the end of the season.
2.) As long as a human is the GM of a CPU controlled team, he should be given the option to buy this team. By giving the GM this option, you solve the problem of having to determine whether a team was gutted or not; the GM get to make that call. The GM assumes the responsibilites and whoa's of owning a gutted team exactly the same way it works today. One exception is that team chemistry does not reset and the team keeps rolling along as it did before.
3.) Should no GM step up and buy the team, all the remaining GMs would automatically be given the same teams controls (whatever is deemed appropriate) to manage the team even with a CPU owner. This is in case a team is actually competitive when it is sold and no GMs are able to buy the team. I.e. all remaing GMs already own teams.
4.) If no GMs remain (remember that GMs can remove themselves from the role) and no GM assumes ownership of the team, then the team is treated like a D-league team (in a real league). That way the existing players effectively become free agents, but they still get to play on a team and get experience since they can't go to the D-league. Their contracts are reset to end at the end of the season. The computer will make contract offers to free agents up to the average player level of the division it is in (more on APL later), but these contracts all end at the end of the season, unless the player level 7 or below. And the computer will fill out it's roster with CPU players where necessary.
5.) A potential problem with this plan: a GM might not relinquish control and trap players on a CPU team. Perhaps the players can vote 3-5 days after the CPU takes control whether or not to keep all of the GMs. The 3-5 days would give the GMs time to decide if they want to buy the team. After the vote with a simple majority, all of the GMs stay or the team becomes 100% CPU controlled. No matter how the vote turns out, the GMs lose their option to buy the team.
Now this creates a problem where the team ownership wait list would not budge until new teams are created in new leagues. This solution is effectively the same as moving the bad team with a new owner to the lowest tier (the D-league).
Solution:
1.) For each team sold mid-season and a GM does not become the owner, a D-league team is assigned a human owner, who plays out the remainder of the season in the D-league with the level 7 player cap and an existing roster. However the teams, chemistry wouldn't reset until later. Players on this team can no longer be signed away as free agents from this team, and their contract would automatically change to end at the end of the season.
2.) A new owner gets a team with players that want to play and players stuck on D-league teams are instantly on a real team. Also, the new owner gets to play against other teams and owners who are in the same position as they are instead of trying to make a team work in an already active and competitive league.
3.) Winning a D-league would decide who gets assigned to the real leagues first at the end of the season, so owners are more likely to get thier preferred league. This would provide incentive to play hard even in a temporary league.
4.) This would make the registration process for team ownership waitlist simple. Potential owners would have the option of taking over a D-League team, an expansion team, or first available. They would also list their top 3 league preferences.
At the end of the season:
1.) Calculate the Average Player Level (APL) for every human team. APL should be used to set level caps for every tier of divions and other things.
2.) The teams that were sold mid-season with CPU owners are moved to the D-League and have their cash flow and stadiums reset (teams sold to GMs would stay in the league they were in since they are human teams). The human players on these comuter teams would all become free agents.
3.) The regular team movement would kick in, the bottom four human teams move down and top two teams move up. Now this would open up more spots in a divison for teams from the lower tiers to move up into. The idea is to get the better teams into the higher divisions faster. Check out the following scenario:
3a.) Division AA#1 has 5 computer teams and 27 human teams at the end of the season.
3b.) The 5 CPU teams go to the D-league, the bottom 4 human teams move down to the lower tier divsions (A#1 & A#2), and the top 2 teams move up to the higher tier division (AAA#1).
3c.) The top two teams are replaced by 2 teams moving down from the upper-tier division (AAA#1), but the upper tier had 1 extra spot due to a computer team, so the number three team moves up as well. If there are ties, you can use APL as a tie-breaker.
3d.) Now a total of 10 teams from the lower tier divisions (A#1 & A#2) will move up to fill division AA#1 due to 5 CPU teams leaving, 4 bad teams moving down, and 1 additional good team moving up.
3e.) Then, divisions A#1 and A#2 would have extra teams to be filled by lower tier divisions.
4.) Ultimately, the human controlled D-league teams would fill the vacancies in the the lowest existing tier of a league. At this time, the team chemistry is reset and the grace period begins because the new owner could not sign players over level 7 previously.
5.) Calculate APL for each division (or tier).
6.) New tiers with expansion teams are added to leagues.
For at least the next few season I suggest an additional step: Lateral movements between divisions in a tier. After the all the teams are assigned to a division in a tier, use the Average Player Level (APL) of each team to shuffle all of the teams within a tier so that each division in that tier has the same APL. Then that entire tier would have a level cap based on the APL instead of each division having it's own level cap. This would potentially screw up rivalries, but as noted earlier, GLB is so new it currently suffers from a lack of balance. (In regard to rivalries, any team would gladly give up a rivalry to move up a tier.) Shuffling should try to keep existing divisions as intact as possible.
Player level caps.
The D-league should continue to have its cap at 7 and new tiers with expansion teams should keep level 13. Older tiers should have a cap too, but it should be based on the players in the league. This cap would remain until the end of the season and it would be a team APL cap instead of a player level cap. Perhaps the cap would be 2-3 levels above the APL of the division (or tier). Instead of preventing teams from signing players over the level cap, teams cannot sign a player unless the move keeps their team APL less than the cap. This would affect trades as well as FA signings. A team's APL should grow over the level cap as the season progresses. This would discourage, but not prevent, player movement later in the season.
Example 1: The cap is 16 and the teams APL is 15.2. The team wants to sign a level 22, and it raises the APL to 15.7. The transaction is accepted.
Example 2: The cap is 16 and the teams APL is 15.7. The teams wants to add a level 22, but the move would bump them over 16.1. The transaction is rejected. The team would have to sign some low level players to lower their APL in order to sign the level 22.
Example 3: The cap is 16 and the teams APL is 15.7. The team wants to cut a level 3, but the move bumps them up to 16.1. The cut is accepted, but the move costs three times the players level in chemistry penalties in addition to the normal penalties for cutting a player. Dropped players for inactivity would not have an extra chemistry penalty.
Example 4: The cap is 16 and the teams APL is 16.1. The team cannot sign any player over level 16; it can only sign players that will lower its APL below 16.