Originally posted by JT_HOOD the only way to run inside lately was to have cut block fire when the DT blew up the play. Still not sure 30% boost to pancaking will do much but I guess we're about to find out. Pancake hasn't been worth a damn in seasons, not sure 30% can fix it. 75% couldn't make Turn Shoulder relevant
Tough to say with turn shoulder since not many people really go all out on building such a build. Id just like to see oline get some cakes again. Game was a lot more fun when cakes were high and people could run the ball as an actual strategy.
Originally posted by JT_HOOD yeah, the 2 pass oriented VAs will be nice. 3 man/2 man rush sacks should be about dead. So you now have 2 more VA must haves on your O line builds
Well...the one is pass arch based. Not many people out there with pass arch G's and C's. Which was one of my reasons for suggesting it. Its pretty much retarded to build a pass arch at those positions right now. But you start adding some value VA's to them and people start rethinking some things.
Originally posted by bhall43 Originally posted by JT_HOOD
the only way to run inside lately was to have cut block fire when the DT blew up the play. Still not sure 30% boost to pancaking will do much but I guess we're about to find out. Pancake hasn't been worth a damn in seasons, not sure 30% can fix it. 75% couldn't make Turn Shoulder relevant
Tough to say with turn shoulder since not many people really go all out on building such a build. Id just like to see oline get some cakes again. Game was a lot more fun when cakes were high and people could run the ball as an actual strategy.
I had the 75% bonus and 7 in TTS - fired twice all season
Originally posted by bhall43 Who cares if the pancake/rev cake numbers end up comparable at the end? Seems pretty legit to me. Especially for those building for the running game.
I care, because the pancake/revcake numbers should be balanced around the sim with their being SAs and VAs that give a small but noticable boost. They should NOT be balanced around a VA, meaning everyone who doesn't have the VA gets 0 revcakes/pancakes. Its stupid. It makes the game impossible to balances across players that do and do not have the VA. It adds no player choice. It is a testament to the fact that bort still has no idea how to design VAs the work within the sim, and doesn't understand the mathematical power of +30% when you are battling 2 rolls.
+7.5% to blocking on pass plays for 15 VPs would be taken, yet we have a VA that is +30%? Um...ya...
+7.5% on 3rd down from Mr. Reliable would still be taken by WRs, yet it is +30%.
+15% to strength on run plays for OLine would still be taken, yet it is +15% to the weight in the rolls (effectively giving around 23%)
Its all bad bhall. I don't just care about results. How you get to those results matter, especially when you are talking about VAs that some people can have and some people can't. If everyone is going to have that VA, it is a complete waste and whatever bonus (if you think the sim should have it) should just be in the sim. This eliminates clear problem that when pass blocking, those with a +30% hold block VA can't just be "good" at holding blocks without those without it being awful at it.
Originally posted by reddogrw I had the 75% bonus and 7 in TTS - fired twice all season
The VA is gonna need like bb% equipment and good carrying to work, based on how breaking tackles works in GLB (things that no QBs have). The issue is not a +75% bonus being shitty, but rather it is how god awful the SA works in the sim.
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN +7.5% to blocking on pass plays for 15 VPs would be taken, yet we have a VA that is +30%? Um...ya..
It wouldn't be taken. You can get +7.5% to Blocking on all plays from Great Blocker.
I'm not saying your points have no merit. I do see what you're saying. But my point of view is that attribute VAs are dull and shouldn't be as good as situational VAs. I also think VAs are a decent way of balancing the game. There were too many 3rd down conversions, so 3rd Down Stopper helped to reduce them, if not necessarily by enough.
You might think that there should instead have been an arbitrary lowering of Pass Quality or something on 3rd down, but it seems better to me to give defenders a VA that they can choose to increase their chances of defending the play.
Some VAs become effectively mandatory and that lowers choice, and I get that. It's a very reasonable issue to have IMO. But that doesn't mean that every good VA, existing or added, needs to be toned down. If anything, it means there need to be more choices.
Originally posted by kostitsyn When adressing QB's progression... When in hell will you guys consider actually moving OUTSIDE the pocket for a scrambling QB?????
Originally posted by jdbolick No consideration about my request to divorce morale from turnover chance? I've been begging for this since May 2009, and it's why we occasionally have those games where a quarterback throws 12 interceptions in one game.
Pretty much. We who still have non archetype players had our chance to archetype them when they were rolled out. We chose not to for the attribute benefits. So have to deal with not getting either of the archetype VA's.