User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tackling: The most useless attribute?
Page:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
My first DT, his tackling bar just turned green.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=2039897

10 tackles and 0 missed tackles.

He is a beast!


He's a beast because the guys he's tackling have no attributes above 40 yet except for speed. Your DT has a a lot of strength which helps the tackle roll, and just enough tkl that he is outrolling guys with little agility or carrying yet.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
My WR will have over 84 catching and my backs will have over 84 carrying. They do that because they are a possession WR and a powerback. Perhaps if you want to be a tackling DT you should have a lot of tackling and other tackle making skills (VAs, SAs, %AEQ), much like my WR will have other catching skills and my backs will have other tackle breaking skills. The game isn't played in a vacuum. If you want to be really good at something, you have to commit to that path in all aspects of your build.


Frankly, I think how you've built your two players *should* be how dots should have to be built. But the sim is such that 60 or 70 catching/carrying is generally enough, and that's why 110 speed is considered too little.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Frankly, I think how you've built your two players *should* be how dots should have to be built. But the sim is such that 60 or 70 catching/carrying is generally enough, and that's why 110 speed is considered too little.


If you want a speed WR, sure. Anything less than 135 speed is too little and 70 catching is plenty with catch ball AEQ. But for a possession WR, 115 speed, 95 catching, 80-90 jumping, catch ball AEQ, Mr. Reliable, Possession WR, Slot Machine, Maxed RR and SH is another viable build plan. Would a possession WR with only 70 catching, no AEQ and speedster VAs work? Absolutely not. So why should a tackling DT with 70 tackling, break block AEQ (but not make tackle), and no tackling SAs make every single tackle?

Another point that should be made: this game isn't designed so that it is possible to make a build that succeeds 100% of the time. If it were possible to make a DT that never misses a tackle, every team would have one and HBs would be complaining about never breaking tackles. The game has to be balanced between the two.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Frankly, I can't understand why Bort can simply give us the attributes that impact each football event ie:

Blocking - Primary attributes (Blocking, Strength) - Secondary attributes (vision, speed, agility) - Tertiary (confidence, stamina, jumping)
Primary (25% or greater importance)
Secondary (10-25% importance)
Tertiary (less than 10% importance)
Heck, he could even rank each skill for an event - Blocking, Strength, Agility, Vision, Speed, Stamina, Confidence.

Etc.

I know that most people have some idea what goes into each roll, but there is no reason we couldn't get an official statement explaining the rules of the game - I can understand that he wants to keep the formulas a secret - fine, no problem, but in every RPG I've played, you know specifically what attributes effect each event, and in many, you actually get a percentage number shown for each event (I believe there was a long thread explaining how this worked in Fallout about five seasons ago.)

The secrecy has got to be the most irritating thing about this game. Especially since with the sim changes, anything you learn this season may well be meaningless the next. It's frustrating as hell.

T
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

My first DT, his tackling bar just turned green.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=2039897

10 tackles and 0 missed tackles.

He is a beast!


He's a beast because the guys he's tackling have no attributes above 40 yet except for speed. Your DT has a a lot of strength which helps the tackle roll, and just enough tkl that he is outrolling guys with little agility or carrying yet.


True, but he is playing against guys about 10 levels higher than him atm. I am really suprised he has any tackles at his lower level.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Another point that should be made: this game isn't designed so that it is possible to make a build that succeeds 100% of the time. If it were possible to make a DT that never misses a tackle, every team would have one and HBs would be complaining about never breaking tackles. The game has to be balanced between the two.


That's where the RNG comes in. Given equal skills and 1000 tackle attempts, the numbers should about equal out (but it potentially they could all go one way.) I've no problem with an RNG, as long as I can understand how to max out my chances to succeed at a specific task. Rather than keeping this a secret, it would make sense to make it impossible to be great at everything, and instead make the game more about choices - NT A matches up well against HB B, would own HB A, but would fail miserably against HB C. Right now, that doesn't happen, or if it does, we have no idea why it would happen, which leads to frustration and inactive accounts.

T
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Do people STILL not understand Tackling?

The more you have in Tackling, the larger your tackling radius. The larger your tackling radius, the more tackles you attempt. Those tackles on the outside of your radius will be missed at a higher rate.

Add in things like Diving Tackles and Jumping, and even more missed tackles.

Of course, without the points in Tackling, Diving Tackle, and Jumping you wouldn't have attempted those tackles. You also wouldn't have attempted many of the ones you made. And you wouldn't have slowed down many of the HB's you missed tackles on so your team mates could make the tackle.

Get a grip people...


I'm thinking that this is the biggest reason why skills like Tackling and Catching are misleading. The more you have in them, the more likely you will succeed, but the more likely you will attempt the skill beyond it's capability, hence failing more often as well.

Personally, I don't think the radius should be impacted by Tackling or Catching, or it should be impacted minimally. Agility, Vision, and Jumping should be the biggest factors in how big your radius is for either of those skills.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Another point that should be made: this game isn't designed so that it is possible to make a build that succeeds 100% of the time. If it were possible to make a DT that never misses a tackle, every team would have one and HBs would be complaining about never breaking tackles. The game has to be balanced between the two.

I don't think anyone expects to own a DT (or any other defensive player) who never misses a tackle.. but keep in mind that for front-7 players in GLB, there's very few counting stats out there - in an average game, you're probably getting about 4-8 counting stats (~4 tackles, 1-2 PDs, 1-3 sack/hurries) at most. If nearly half of your tackles are missed, that's a huge drain on your stats, which can be very frustrating.

Take an NFL (or college) caliber DT - he's big, strong, reasonably agile, not very fast, probably has good tackling technique. He doesn't have to move around that much, because he takes up prime real estate and plugs up the run game. Missed tackles by a DT would likely stem from being out of position, and occasionally from an elusive back's move (not as common, since DTs generally play in a crowded area, so there's not that much space for shifty running). Now, take a GLB DT. He's huge - but that doesn't help him any, his dot still takes up no space. He has to be ridiculously strong or he'll get pancaked every play. He has to be ridiculously agile or he'll never get the burst to push into the backfield. He has to be fast or he'll never catch a ball carrier or reach the QB. He has to be a crazy-good tackler or he'll get run over by power backs and run around by agile backs. In order to provide a function similar to an NFL DT, a GLB dot would probably need 120+ strength, 100+ tackling, 90 +agility, and 80+ speed - and that's completely ignoring the need for stamina, confidence, vision, and SAs.

In real life, defenders aren't as fast or agile as the players they chase. The idea is that every defensive player works together to contain skill position players - gap discipline, angles, double coverage, disguised / delayed blitzes or coverage drops, and so on. Sadly, this doesn't happen in GLB - defensive dots don't seem to be at all aware of where other defensive dots are. As long as this happens, defensive dots will never be able to get the stats they need to maintain their side of the equation, and thus, will forever be frustrated with missed tackles, blown coverages, bad INT attempts, an the like.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crawly

I don't think anyone expects to own a DT (or any other defensive player) who never misses a tackle.. but keep in mind that for front-7 players in GLB, there's very few counting stats out there - in an average game, you're probably getting about 4-8 counting stats (~4 tackles, 1-2 PDs, 1-3 sack/hurries) at most. If nearly half of your tackles are missed, that's a huge drain on your stats, which can be very frustrating.

Take an NFL (or college) caliber DT - he's big, strong, reasonably agile, not very fast, probably has good tackling technique. He doesn't have to move around that much, because he takes up prime real estate and plugs up the run game. Missed tackles by a DT would likely stem from being out of position, and occasionally from an elusive back's move (not as common, since DTs generally play in a crowded area, so there's not that much space for shifty running). Now, take a GLB DT. He's huge - but that doesn't help him any, his dot still takes up no space. He has to be ridiculously strong or he'll get pancaked every play. He has to be ridiculously agile or he'll never get the burst to push into the backfield. He has to be fast or he'll never catch a ball carrier or reach the QB. He has to be a crazy-good tackler or he'll get run over by power backs and run around by agile backs. In order to provide a function similar to an NFL DT, a GLB dot would probably need 120+ strength, 100+ tackling, 90 +agility, and 80+ speed - and that's completely ignoring the need for stamina, confidence, vision, and SAs.

In real life, defenders aren't as fast or agile as the players they chase. The idea is that every defensive player works together to contain skill position players - gap discipline, angles, double coverage, disguised / delayed blitzes or coverage drops, and so on. Sadly, this doesn't happen in GLB - defensive dots don't seem to be at all aware of where other defensive dots are. As long as this happens, defensive dots will never be able to get the stats they need to maintain their side of the equation, and thus, will forever be frustrated with missed tackles, blown coverages, bad INT attempts, an the like.


I'll just do this point by point instead of writing out an essay.

1. To the first paragraph: I think that's one of the primary reason why defensive players cost less than most offensive players--less stats equal less costs. I don't think that has much relevance though to whether a DT should be missing or making tackles.

2. To the second paragraph: I think that is more of a problem with GLB as a whole than with DTs tackling. Offensive players have a huge incentive to build to one extreme. Because of this defensive players have to try and build to all extremes--an impossible task. So they have the choice between trying to be good at everything or trying to be really good at one, maybe two things, and weak and a lot of other stuff. Right now we don't see many pure tackling DTs because to do so would make them incredibly weak to the pass and to speedier backs.

3. Once again, that is an issue with GLB as a whole. Bort needs to figure out a way for DCs to build a defense that can work together and stop the more extremely built offensive players. Until then we are always going to see 150 speed WRs burning 100-120 speed CBs who can't afford to go that fast because they also have to be able to stop 100 catching WRs and RBs.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 5thyearcock
Well, you're correct in that if you had tackling as your 1st or 2nd highest attribute you wouldn't be missing many tackles, but that's because the dot would never come close to touching the ball carrier.


1st post of yours I have ever agreed with
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Frankly, I can't understand why Bort can simply give us the attributes that impact each football event


he don't know
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
Originally posted by tsherr

Frankly, I can't understand why Bort can simply give us the attributes that impact each football event


he don't know


oh shit!
Edited by Phantom_Opera on May 6, 2010 09:46:06
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
One thing that could help ease the issue of missed tackles - don't count a tackle as 'missed' as long as the tackler is still being dragged, and until the runner has taken at least one step (one tick?) after the 'missed tackle'. If a runner is held in place by a would-be tackler and someone else cleans up, that's not a missed tackle (and I think in most levels of football, it's also credited as a half-tackle).
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Why the hell are we seriously trying to figure out all of the possible factors involved? I see it in black and white. The attribute is called "T A C K L I N G"...


tack·le
   /ˈtækəl or, for 2–4, ˈteɪkəl/ Show Spelled [tak-uhl or, for 2–4, tey-kuhl] Show IPA noun, verb,-led, -ling.

an act of tackling, as in football; a seizing, grasping, or bringing down.

It's a pretty concrete term... If it isn't the most important part, by a longshot, in a tackle roll, make a new attribute. Come up with a creative name like "helps you a bit in tackling"... Use that. If I build a punter, he can still punt well if I max out P U N T I N G... I don't have to softcap throwing and carrying to make it work as intended...



he got a point but maybe 84 isnt enough
 
Billy Corman
offline
Link
 
Look, Hurries matter and Hurries are an effect of the QB feeling pressure. My 340lb, 57 Speed NT leads our Competitive Minors Lv 46 League team in Hurries and is third in the League overall [he's first with a huge lead if "Blowout Adjusted" are taken into account]. His Tackling is 77+ base [no EQ].

That's gotta account for something.

I know, I know ... lolMinors, lolNon-EliteMinors, etc ...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.