Originally posted by Crawly
I don't think anyone expects to own a DT (or any other defensive player) who never misses a tackle.. but keep in mind that for front-7 players in GLB, there's very few counting stats out there - in an average game, you're probably getting about 4-8 counting stats (~4 tackles, 1-2 PDs, 1-3 sack/hurries) at most. If nearly half of your tackles are missed, that's a huge drain on your stats, which can be very frustrating.
Take an NFL (or college) caliber DT - he's big, strong, reasonably agile, not very fast, probably has good tackling technique. He doesn't have to move around that much, because he takes up prime real estate and plugs up the run game. Missed tackles by a DT would likely stem from being out of position, and occasionally from an elusive back's move (not as common, since DTs generally play in a crowded area, so there's not that much space for shifty running). Now, take a GLB DT. He's huge - but that doesn't help him any, his dot still takes up no space. He has to be ridiculously strong or he'll get pancaked every play. He has to be ridiculously agile or he'll never get the burst to push into the backfield. He has to be fast or he'll never catch a ball carrier or reach the QB. He has to be a crazy-good tackler or he'll get run over by power backs and run around by agile backs. In order to provide a function similar to an NFL DT, a GLB dot would probably need 120+ strength, 100+ tackling, 90 +agility, and 80+ speed - and that's completely ignoring the need for stamina, confidence, vision, and SAs.
In real life, defenders aren't as fast or agile as the players they chase. The idea is that every defensive player works together to contain skill position players - gap discipline, angles, double coverage, disguised / delayed blitzes or coverage drops, and so on. Sadly, this doesn't happen in GLB - defensive dots don't seem to be at all aware of where other defensive dots are. As long as this happens, defensive dots will never be able to get the stats they need to maintain their side of the equation, and thus, will forever be frustrated with missed tackles, blown coverages, bad INT attempts, an the like.
I'll just do this point by point instead of writing out an essay.
1. To the first paragraph: I think that's one of the primary reason why defensive players cost less than most offensive players--less stats equal less costs. I don't think that has much relevance though to whether a DT should be missing or making tackles.
2. To the second paragraph: I think that is more of a problem with GLB as a whole than with DTs tackling. Offensive players have a huge incentive to build to one extreme. Because of this defensive players have to try and build to all extremes--an impossible task. So they have the choice between trying to be good at everything or trying to be really good at one, maybe two things, and weak and a lot of other stuff. Right now we don't see many pure tackling DTs because to do so would make them incredibly weak to the pass and to speedier backs.
3. Once again, that is an issue with GLB as a whole. Bort needs to figure out a way for DCs to build a defense that can work together and stop the more extremely built offensive players. Until then we are always going to see 150 speed WRs burning 100-120 speed CBs who can't afford to go that fast because they also have to be able to stop 100 catching WRs and RBs.