User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why the hell should I HAVE to remember to have my Punter return kicks against gutjobs?!?
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Since it's mid-season, that's gutting, not retooling. And if I were Bort, my response would be to take your team away from you and ban you from owning another team. And if you already knew that's how I'd respond, you'd think twice about gutting mid-season, wouldn't you?

If you were actually re-tooling, you would take your lumps and finish out the season, pocketing that Pro-League cash along the way. Then, at the END of the season, you would let contracts expire, trade away guys with long-term contracts for extra cash, sign your well-built Level 10 guys, and get demoted to a capped-minor league. THAT is retooling.

Emptying your roster mid-season is gutting. Period.


Not only would they disagree with you, they would laugh,

Let's say not LVL 10, but LVL 40, I watch the PLFT forum, I know we aren't competing now, I thought we were going to, so I trade a few LVL 66-70's for major cash, sign up the well built LVL 40's who I can groom a bit better, and I do that about 3-4 times, so now I have a roster of 20 LVL 65+'s, 15 LVL 40-43's, and 5-6 CPU's,

What is that now?
 
Mount Vernon
offline
Link
 
thread is tl;dr. but, max xp and make stamina a real attribute. Solves both problems.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
You're going to have to make a decision at the beginning of the season: can I succeed in this league, or am I probably just going to get my ass kicked for the 3rd season in a row?

That's life. If you guess correctly, you benefit. If you guess incorrectly, you pay a penalty.

Sure gives you a good incentive to make better guesses, doesn't it?


So you want teams to make a decision before they play to whether or not they can be competitive, what if it's their first time in AA, or AAA? etc?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
I bet you 50% of the people would disagree with you.



First of all, based on the responses in this thread, I think your 50% guess is WAY over reality.

Second of all, once upon a time, over 50% of the people of the United States of America thought slavery was okay too. They were still wrong.

Being in the majority doesn't make you right. Not even close.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
So you want teams to make a decision before they play to whether or not they can be competitive, what if it's their first time in AA, or AAA? etc?


Yes. Yes I do. That's life.

People who guess correctly will reap the rewards, and people who guess incorrectly will pay the price.

Again, it sure gives you a good incentive to guess correctly, doesn't it?



To expand on this, why should MY team have to pay the price just because YOU incorrectly thought you could be competitive in Pro this season? YOU should have to pay that price for guessing incorrectly, not me.
Edited by Novus on Dec 13, 2009 17:28:36
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
First of all, based on the responses in this thread, I think your 50% guess is WAY over reality.

Second of all, once upon a time, over 50% of the people of the United States of America thought slavery was okay too. They were still wrong.

Being in the majority doesn't make you right. Not even close.


LOL

I see, so having two different opinions, yours is right, mine is wrong? Especially on something compared to this?

BTW, you do realize that less than 10% of GLB visits these boards, let alone posts on them....
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus


Since it's mid-season, that's gutting, not retooling. And if I were Bort, my response would be to take your team away from you and ban you from owning another team. And if you already knew that's how I'd respond, you'd think twice about gutting mid-season, wouldn't you?

If you were actually re-tooling, you would take your lumps and finish out the season, pocketing that Pro-League cash along the way. Then, at the END of the season, you would let contracts expire, trade away guys with long-term contracts for extra cash, sign your well-built Level 10 guys, and get demoted to a capped-minor league. THAT is retooling.

Emptying your roster mid-season is gutting. Period.


I totally agree, and I also agree with the consequence, except they should be able to own again after a two season colling off period.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Yes. Yes I do. That's life.

People who guess correctly will reap the rewards, and people who guess incorrectly will pay the price.

Again, it sure gives you a good incentive to guess correctly, doesn't it?


No, it doesn't, and it definitely isn't the nature of the game,

IF that's the game you wanted, you surely picked the wrong one bud,

Think about what you are saying,

In a competitive sports simulation, you want a team, to guess if they are going to be competitive, before they play a single game in a new league? Are you on crack, or just like being obstinate?

Let's put it this way, uncapped team, goes to AA, does damn well, gets promoted to AAA, has to recruit 25 players they feel, in order to compete, so the owner recruits those 25 players, works his ass off, gets them, and his first 5 games in AAA gets absolutely crushed by an AVERAGE of 70,

You wanted him to know that BEFORE the season, that that was going to happen?

Really?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
LOL

I see, so having two different opinions, yours is right, mine is wrong? Especially on something compared to this?

BTW, you do realize that less than 10% of GLB visits these boards, let alone posts on them....


Irrelevant, and irrelevant.

You told me that you think over 50% of the users on GLB would disagree with me. You brought majority-thinking into this.

Majority-thinking is irrelevant. The majority can easily be wrong.

Move on.
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
I see, so having two different opinions, yours is right, mine is wrong? Especially on something compared to this?

BTW, you do realize that less than 10% of GLB visits these boards, let alone posts on them....


Keep in mind that the majority of that 90% that doesn't visit the boards don't have a clue as to what's going on.

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
I totally agree, and I also agree with the consequence, except they should be able to own again after a two season colling off period.


LMAO yes, because customers who you pretty much take money from for doing what they think is right for their team, are actually going to come back and try it again after 2 and a half months?????

Really?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
Keep in mind that the majority of that 90% that doesn't visit the boards don't have a clue as to what's going on.



I know that lol
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Irrelevant, and irrelevant.

You told me that you think over 50% of the users on GLB would disagree with me. You brought majority-thinking into this.

Majority-thinking is irrelevant. The majority can easily be wrong.

Move on.


Definitely, but on a subject that is based purely on opinion, calling one side wrong or right is idiotic at best.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by foofighter24

If you have the intention of moving down, you should declare that intention prior to the season. Cut the players and move down. Don't wreck the competition in leagues that are supposed to be the top of the game.


I didn't know prior to the season, we were gonna get our asses kicked for the 3rd year, so you want me to give up on the season, prior to the season?


Yes. I have trouble believing a good Pro owner can't evaluate about where his team stands. You are either non-competitive, competitive, or elite in your league. Are you telling me you don't know that before the preseason even starts?
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
On day -4 (after 2 preseason games), the staff should view all 25 AAA+ leagues.

If any team has lost a game by 100+ points, take a closer look.

If they don't belong in the league (easy judgement call to make... there are very rarely any border cases where a team tries and loses by 100+), MOVE THEM DOWN TO THE MINORS

Have AA owners put the option of "would accept AAA promotion." For every team you flag to move down, go review a "would accept promotion" and move the ones up who would do fine in AAA

Now you have open AA slots - but we had trouble filling these already.

To solve the problem of empty AA, we need to collapse a few regions into having only two AA leagues.

----

This would take a few hours, but completely clean up the AAA+ leagues when they should be cleaned up - stop looking on day 42. Go look in the preseason, see how rosters actually filled out, and who simply can't hang. Stop running the silly scripts and relying on owners to send you PMs to denote. NEWSFLASH: Owners who gut but don't sell are the same type who are very unlikely to request demotion.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.