User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
hexone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
Originally posted by hexone

Originally posted by FBGProfessor


No one said you shouldn't do that. But if you are gutting a team in AAA or PRO and moving it to Africa or BBB, then you should pay a penalty. Originally posted by Dudeamis



Originally posted by crawlins




Originally posted by CroBot





Seriously, there goes everybody's recruiting efforts. There's such a thing as too much parity and this is it. Just because a player is in BBB and is level 19 DOES NOT mean that they're cheating, or that they're there to pad their stats. What's the fun in the game when all your recruiting work goes for naught and Bort is forcing everybody to be equal and boring?


OR...you could play against competitive competition. There is a reason they don't let High Schoolers play dodge ball with 1st graders...or are you saying thats fair too? Darn gym teachers forcing everyone to be equal!


So I shouldn't build the best team possible? I should just aim for middle of the road? What NFL team does that? What College team does that?





This also hurts teams that got a gutted team last season.


I don't see how unless you went out and somehow recruited player to replace the gutted players who are vastly superior to the average talent in the league. This seems very unlikely. Most gutted teams are below aveage and this should help them somewhat.


Check out the level of players I had from week to week, and see how each game I recruited atleast one better player. Then tell me you can't see this. Its called great recruiting. Other then in the offseason, all the players I recruited were brought in one player at a time.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 01:46:35
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Reposts from the suggestion thread:

Originally posted by
I can't believe that Bort is actually going to go through with this.

Many of us have payed money to make our players better, and now we are being penalized for it. UNbelieveable.

Bort, if you read this, I'd like to PM with you when you get past the busy stretch.


Originally posted by
My guard joined a BBB team right when it was created as a level 4. That's not douchey at ALL. If anything, that was LOW for BBB. Now, if I boost at the beginning of this season, I will be a level 18, and SURELY see an XP punishment. Teams have been gutted, and horribly low-leveled teams have dropped into my league by no fault of my own.

This plan punishes innocent players and does NOTHING to stop jerkoffs from dropping down with horribly over-leveled players... because people like that won't care about this change.


Originally posted by
Originally posted by Staners

Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.


This is ALREADY BEING DONE in the current XP leveling system. Now, people are actually being PUNISHED for boosting their players.

I hope there will be a way to buy back boosts and receive a refund.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by hexone

Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.


Like I said in the post, if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see little to no effect from this update. Things such as length of time with the team and in the league are all part of the formula I have worked out.

The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!

Ye of little faith, yeesh.

Seriously, though, all this concern really does prove to me that XP is the proper target. Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


It is good that the formula isn't being shown, too. I know a lot of people will ask for it, but the moment it is revealed is the moment people figure out just how to bend the system to their will.

But yeah, here's to hoping this helps with the problem of people just dominating the lower level leagues. Curious, though -- will the penalty get more and more severe the farther over the median you are?
 
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Unconquered


Just curious as to how this will affect my team. My team medium is certainly much higher then everyone in BBB 12 but it's because the GM's and I have done a hell of a job recruiting for two seasons now.


Yea man, you and your coordinators were working hard on the trading block forums this whole offseason. I gotta give you guys props for that.

Would hate to see your hard work get affected by this.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by hexone

Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.


Like I said in the post, if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see little to no effect from this update. Things such as length of time with the team and in the league are all part of the formula I have worked out.

The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!

Ye of little faith, yeesh.

Seriously, though, all this concern really does prove to me that XP is the proper target. Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


So the spirit of the game is to not try and field the best team? Should my oppoent's players get penalized because he out recruited me? No not at all. There are other ways to deal with this problem. You're cutting off your face, to spite your nose.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djfivenine
This is not the right area to target Bort!
I know this game has a big problem with the higher level team always winning. But averaging out the levels of the teams is NOT the answer.
It is the ability to give us more options for TACTICS!
3-4 defense, cover 2 defense, spread offense, power running offense, option offense.
Blitz options, special substitutions, better predictions for the other team's strategy.

If those things are implemented, teams will start winning because their owner and coordinators are smarter and they out witted the other team.

I, for one, will not feel good beating a higher level team if I knew this rule was the reason.


seriously this new rule is a waste of your time. Try making the game better instead of nerfing good recruiters.
 
jvacc26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jad6175
I love all the guys who are for this, didn't see one with a winning record. Guess that explains why they love the idea, now they get even with the guys who ourecruited them.
Also the guys who spent money every season boosting their guys, will let guys catch up to them who spent nothing at all. Real nice system ya got there. Maybe the NCAA will follow in GLB's footsteps, for now on USC, Floria, Texas, and Ohio St players will have to sit their blue chip prospects because Stanford, Baylor, Vanderbilt and Northwestern were complaining about getting killed every season.



I'm for it because I dont like watching people get owned in Pro league, gutting their team, moving to A league and winning a title the next year. Oh great you won a title, but lets face it, teams that do that are hacks that just aren't good enough for pro league.

All this is designed to do is make people of equal level play each other, not beat up on the smaller weaker kids. It's like the Patriots going to play Temple every week in some of these leagues.
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djfivenine
Originally posted by Unconquered



Just curious as to how this will affect my team. My team medium is certainly much higher then everyone in BBB 12 but it's because the GM's and I have done a hell of a job recruiting for two seasons now.


Yea man, you and your coordinators were working hard on the trading block forums this whole offseason. I gotta give you guys props for that.

Would hate to see your hard work get affected by this.


I traded 3 players (belonged to 2 agents) because they asked to be traded. Maybe you should look into things before you talk.

I SIGNED

Level 20 QB
Level 18 SS
Level 20 FS
 
Jericoholic
offline
Link
 
Bort ++
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dudeamis
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by hexone


Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.


Like I said in the post, if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see little to no effect from this update. Things such as length of time with the team and in the league are all part of the formula I have worked out.

The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!

Ye of little faith, yeesh.

Seriously, though, all this concern really does prove to me that XP is the proper target. Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


So the spirit of the game is to not try and field the best team? Should my oppoent's players get penalized because he out recruited me? No not at all. There are other ways to deal with this problem. You're cutting off your face, to spite your nose.


Your team? Spirit of the game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2835 are the types of teams I believe Bort is targeting
 
jad6175
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tciss
Originally posted by jad6175

I love all the guys who are for this, didn't see one with a winning record. Guess that explains why they love the idea, now they get even with the guys who ourecruited them.
Also the guys who spent money every season boosting their guys, will let guys catch up to them who spent nothing at all. Real nice system ya got there. Maybe the NCAA will follow in GLB's footsteps, for now on USC, Floria, Texas, and Ohio St players will have to sit their blue chip prospects because Stanford, Baylor, Vanderbilt and Northwestern were complaining about getting killed every season.



You missed me.



Do you not understand the concept that the good teams in college football have to recruit those players that make them so good from high school, competing with every school in the country?

Do you see the NCAA pentalizing those teams for recruiting powerhouses because teams like Northwestern, Stanford, Vanderbilt, and Baylor don't stand a chance against them?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


Good. Get rid of chemisty. It doesn't solve anything and it does not reflect ACTUAL team chemisty in any way.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hexone
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by hexone


Adding the rule for new signings is fine with me and I have no problem with that. This will actually help level out the playing field in 2 seasons. But enforcing it for everyone will just hurt loyal owners and players that put alot of money into this game, now instead of seeing a return on investment they are being punished for it.


Like I said in the post, if you are playing "within the spirit of the game" you will see little to no effect from this update. Things such as length of time with the team and in the league are all part of the formula I have worked out.

The whole point of this update: Don't gut and stack your team, and you won't have any problems!

Ye of little faith, yeesh.

Seriously, though, all this concern really does prove to me that XP is the proper target. Things like cash and chemistry have little effect on the problem.


Sounds good to me Bort. I have faith I was just a little shell shocked when I first read this. But if you are putting into consideration when the owner acquired the team, how long the players have been there, and if they were relegated or promoted the season before then I have no problems with it. I actually applaud an even playing field.


you don't see the NFL rushing in to break up the Patriots or the Colts do you? Nope as long as they stay under the cap they're fine.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
I'm still not understanding why teams that are stacked, rich and intelligent won't still dominate and win the playoffs? If they catch up to you, what will it matter? Your team will have gotten a huge lead and still most likely dominate the playoffs which I'm pretty sure is the goal.
 
Donbomba
offline
Link
 
This rule won't stop teams dominating lower level teams, all it does is slow player growth for the high level guys - As it should. Like other MMO's grinding on lvl 1 mobs will not let you lvl, neither should beating up on season 1 teams.

So hurry up and dominate and move up to the league where you all belong.

All this pissing into the wind about an unfair rule change is hilarious.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.