Great idea
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
thunderdoozer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cedo
For players against, i hope you will not complain against higher level come to your league and win the championship... That's a way to avoid that. I think is the better idea i heard, not the best because no one seems to be able to find it (or even it exists...)
I'm the GM of a team in the lowest league possible (BBB), so this situation is relevant to me. There is no possible way for a team to load up on players that are way above average without decimating their chemistry. They will lose anyway. Add that to the fact that high level players, in general, don't want to play in the lower leagues. Add that to the fact that lower level teams cant AFFORD to upgrade to all high-level players.
What you get is maybe a terrible team with a ringer or two that can't afford to pay the salaries to make a team that is solid top to bottom... unless all of the players are the owner's or GM's (and they pay them minimum), but there are no rules against that.
If anything, there should be:
1. No players greater than level 10 signed to new leagues.
2. Higher minimum wage for players that are owned by the team owner (this is a ridiculously unfair advantage now).
3. Team minimum wage by league (to discourage gutting and this crap: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1563 )
The problem isn't the team that is skillful enough to fill up with great players. The problem is the team that doesn't put any effort into recruiting and improving and then cries that everything is unfair.
We have seen that the XP system levels everything over time. So, block high levels in new leagues, and let the rest work itself out. No more punishments to teams/players for playing the game.
For players against, i hope you will not complain against higher level come to your league and win the championship... That's a way to avoid that. I think is the better idea i heard, not the best because no one seems to be able to find it (or even it exists...)
I'm the GM of a team in the lowest league possible (BBB), so this situation is relevant to me. There is no possible way for a team to load up on players that are way above average without decimating their chemistry. They will lose anyway. Add that to the fact that high level players, in general, don't want to play in the lower leagues. Add that to the fact that lower level teams cant AFFORD to upgrade to all high-level players.
What you get is maybe a terrible team with a ringer or two that can't afford to pay the salaries to make a team that is solid top to bottom... unless all of the players are the owner's or GM's (and they pay them minimum), but there are no rules against that.
If anything, there should be:
1. No players greater than level 10 signed to new leagues.
2. Higher minimum wage for players that are owned by the team owner (this is a ridiculously unfair advantage now).
3. Team minimum wage by league (to discourage gutting and this crap: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1563 )
The problem isn't the team that is skillful enough to fill up with great players. The problem is the team that doesn't put any effort into recruiting and improving and then cries that everything is unfair.
We have seen that the XP system levels everything over time. So, block high levels in new leagues, and let the rest work itself out. No more punishments to teams/players for playing the game.
Painmaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by Piemaster
Originally posted by Cedo
For players against, i hope you will not complain against higher level come to your league and win the championship... That's a way to avoid that. I think is the better idea i heard, not the best because no one seems to be able to find it (or even it exists...)
I don't think there is a perfect solution, or somebody would have thought of it by now. It's just a case of finding the best one out of all those that have been thrown out there. This is why Bort is creating all these threads, to see which ideas people can find obvious flaws with, which are good and which might be good with modifications.
Somebody gets it!
Originally posted by Cedo
For players against, i hope you will not complain against higher level come to your league and win the championship... That's a way to avoid that. I think is the better idea i heard, not the best because no one seems to be able to find it (or even it exists...)
I don't think there is a perfect solution, or somebody would have thought of it by now. It's just a case of finding the best one out of all those that have been thrown out there. This is why Bort is creating all these threads, to see which ideas people can find obvious flaws with, which are good and which might be good with modifications.
Somebody gets it!

Painmaker
offline
offline
If the "expected price" for tickets and concessions were hugely different (say, $1 in BBB = $1.50 in A = $2 in AA = $2.50 in AAA = $3 in pros, or even more of a difference if need be) then player salaries would force the issue. You could also have every player's salary automatically bump up to their current "minimum" salary every offseason to address concerns of long-term salaries being too unbalancing.
This would help economics to drive the solution. The prospective downside is that it becomes very difficult to develop stadiums at the lower levels so upward progress would be slowed by needing to spend more seasons at each level in order to afford being competitive. That may be a reasonable price to pay in order for market forces to become the driving factor in the pyramid structure.
This would help economics to drive the solution. The prospective downside is that it becomes very difficult to develop stadiums at the lower levels so upward progress would be slowed by needing to spend more seasons at each level in order to afford being competitive. That may be a reasonable price to pay in order for market forces to become the driving factor in the pyramid structure.
jaytda4th
offline
offline
Bort why mess with XP... just make it so that if you are a high level player you take a huge morale hit by playing with lower levels
like if a NFL guy was playing in some scrub league their morale would def. go down.
Make the person lose 5-10 moral for each game they are involved in.
like if a NFL guy was playing in some scrub league their morale would def. go down.
Make the person lose 5-10 moral for each game they are involved in.
PinTBC
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by BartRock
He's not talking about entire teams. He's talking about individual players. Your level 12 player in a league with an average of, say, 10 won't be affected at all. That level 18 player, however, would be.
Yep.
Bort,
I really like this idea.
PinTBC
Originally posted by BartRock
He's not talking about entire teams. He's talking about individual players. Your level 12 player in a league with an average of, say, 10 won't be affected at all. That level 18 player, however, would be.
Yep.
Bort,
I really like this idea.
PinTBC
KellerFox
offline
offline
Im on par with serenity's suggestion, ive spent the last 12 hours or so mulling over this concept and I am sure im addimate in my position but I dont really want to take the time to fully develop it in a post. Players shouldnt get penalized, but I would love to see a bonus (perhaps even larger than 15%) for lower level players playing against higher levels. Sure this would encourage power leveling, but it would be the quickest and fairest solution to evening out the levels.
Ill use the new African team im on as an example. A few buddies and I started decided about a month ago that one of us was getting a team and that because we have such a strong core group of guys who enjoy playing on the same team as each other that we would stick together. We got organized early and starter recruiting from other people we know on the game and put together a fairly decent roster. Our team is looking alot better than most of the teams in our conference, however their are a few comparable. Is it our fault that these teams didnt plan ahead? Is it our fault we got a Africa AAA team as opposed to a Pro? We joined the team we were delegated by the site in order to stick together as a group and now we are hearing we might be punished for it despite the fact that our intentions werent to "pwn n00bs" as the Borts first post suggests (not directed at us specifically).
For the most part, relegation will move teams out of mismatched conferences in a season or two. I feel the Admins as well as everyone else just needs to be patient. The only other viable solution I can think of is doing a one time redistribution of all of the teams within a said region. Perhaps get the teams average level then the top 32 teams become Pro, the next 32 AAA#1 and so forth. I understand this would cause complaining amongst developed teams, but it is the only way to absolutely solve this problem and solve it now. Otherwise I think we need to let the game ssystem autocorrect this as it was intended to when built, perhaps with the addition of bonus xp for lower leveled players in tough situations.
Ill use the new African team im on as an example. A few buddies and I started decided about a month ago that one of us was getting a team and that because we have such a strong core group of guys who enjoy playing on the same team as each other that we would stick together. We got organized early and starter recruiting from other people we know on the game and put together a fairly decent roster. Our team is looking alot better than most of the teams in our conference, however their are a few comparable. Is it our fault that these teams didnt plan ahead? Is it our fault we got a Africa AAA team as opposed to a Pro? We joined the team we were delegated by the site in order to stick together as a group and now we are hearing we might be punished for it despite the fact that our intentions werent to "pwn n00bs" as the Borts first post suggests (not directed at us specifically).
For the most part, relegation will move teams out of mismatched conferences in a season or two. I feel the Admins as well as everyone else just needs to be patient. The only other viable solution I can think of is doing a one time redistribution of all of the teams within a said region. Perhaps get the teams average level then the top 32 teams become Pro, the next 32 AAA#1 and so forth. I understand this would cause complaining amongst developed teams, but it is the only way to absolutely solve this problem and solve it now. Otherwise I think we need to let the game ssystem autocorrect this as it was intended to when built, perhaps with the addition of bonus xp for lower leveled players in tough situations.
jprietman
offline
offline
I support 1-4.
As for being "punished" for playing lower level teams...
I think if you feel that it is "punishment" to gain less XP for winning against inferior teams, then you deserve the punishment. The whole point of this idea is to prevent POWER GAMING, meaning, prevent people from playing for XP instead of Championships.
If you are a player who is focused on winning a Championship, then you shouldn't worry at all about getting less XP for playing a gutted team. After all, all of your rival teams in your conference have to play them too, right?
As for being "punished" for playing lower level teams...
I think if you feel that it is "punishment" to gain less XP for winning against inferior teams, then you deserve the punishment. The whole point of this idea is to prevent POWER GAMING, meaning, prevent people from playing for XP instead of Championships.
If you are a player who is focused on winning a Championship, then you shouldn't worry at all about getting less XP for playing a gutted team. After all, all of your rival teams in your conference have to play them too, right?
FairForever
offline
offline
I thought about this overnight, and it makes no sense at all.
The best teams should get promoted, right? Now, if you're reducing their xp, they're slowly falling behind the league ABOVE them. That is a recipe for getting relegated right away.
I don't mind a slight XP boost for playing above your skill level, but to punish those who've been on a team for continuity is quite unfair.
Think about it this way. A lot of players who are level 14/15 started at the 1st offseason, and have not changed teams. In a lot of these leagues, these players, if early boosters, could be punished by getting reduced XP. Isn't there a problem with this?
The best teams should get promoted, right? Now, if you're reducing their xp, they're slowly falling behind the league ABOVE them. That is a recipe for getting relegated right away.
I don't mind a slight XP boost for playing above your skill level, but to punish those who've been on a team for continuity is quite unfair.
Think about it this way. A lot of players who are level 14/15 started at the 1st offseason, and have not changed teams. In a lot of these leagues, these players, if early boosters, could be punished by getting reduced XP. Isn't there a problem with this?
People would farm XP. For example, I could sign a team of players for 1 season in a Pro league. They all get killed and level up like crazy due to the superior competition. Maybe they are level 25 or so at the end of one season. Not sure. Once their contracts expire at the end of that season we sign all new level 1s to play on that team and sign the people whose contracts expired to the main team. They are instantly super competitive after only 1 season. Rinse, wash, and repeat. this bypasses all the trade restrictions as well and all it would take is willing players, and 2 owners willing to cooperate.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 13:32:56
MrMoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by FairForever
This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.
The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.
Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.
The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.
Pretty much, this. I said it earlier, and I'll say it again. Penalizing my team because some people in Oceania A gutted their team would be very uncool, and ruin the game for me. Most of the team started with Samoa from an early level. Many of them have leveled up to 15-16 or so with the team. We've brought in free agents around that level this offseason and past offseason.
However, teams in Oceania A have disbanded. Brings down the league's average level. In the past season, 3 teams pretty much had to start over. This offseason, another two have. The average level of Oceania A right now is 12.4, and I'm sure those figures don't have the near-empty Cagayan Vindicators figured in. So I'd put it around 12 now.
Samoa's an average level of around 15. The problem is, there are a few other teams there around this average level. Only one of us can get promoted each year. However, if players start to get less XP for playing in the league, why would they want to stay with the team? I'd essentially be forced to gut my entire team and start from the ground up. As would the Las Vegas Super Bears, The Portland Rain, the Wollongong Hippos, the FF.com Inmates too. Sure, the league average would go down and games would be closer...but I'd be willing to bet you the four teams would just quit playing if they were forced to nuke their entire team and start over because people just went on to get more XP elsewhere.
I think the solution is to not allow any new signings above a certain cap, based on the league's level. If your league's average level is, say, 12, don't let anyone be signed at 150% of the leagues level -- 18. Don't restrict teams from re-signing players on their team, but don't allow a player outside of the league to enter if above that level. For new leagues, limit it to level 10 or so for the first season, then base it on the average level. Sure, there will be a few players who want to stay on a team that is being penalized for XP if it means winning a championship...but if half the team wants out, more are going to want out since the team will have to start over from square 1.
I'll be fully behind the idea of a penalty if leagues are all reorganized based on average level. I'd also be behind the idea of a penalty for any new leagues developed, since the teams would end up starting with one. But rewarding owners who aren't able to bring in the players seems kind of backwards to me. Note that I hate the idea of a hard level cap on anything, but it seems the idea of restructuring leagues based on current team level won't happen, so something to keep people from lobbying against teams that have assembled a great group of players needs to be done.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
People would farm XP. For example, I could sign a team of players for 1 season in a Pro league. They all get killed and level up like crazy due to the superior competition. Maybe they are level 25 or so at the end of one season. Not sure. Once their contracts expire at the end of that season we sign all new level 1s to play on that team and sign the people whose contracts expired to the main team. They are instantly super competitive after only 1 season. Rinse, wash, and repeat. this bypasses all the trade restrictions as well and all it would take is willing players, and 2 owners willing to cooperate.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
This too. A good team could just bring in a couple of friends, play them somewhere that they won't hurt the team, and just let them farm up XP.
This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.
The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.
Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.
The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.
Pretty much, this. I said it earlier, and I'll say it again. Penalizing my team because some people in Oceania A gutted their team would be very uncool, and ruin the game for me. Most of the team started with Samoa from an early level. Many of them have leveled up to 15-16 or so with the team. We've brought in free agents around that level this offseason and past offseason.
However, teams in Oceania A have disbanded. Brings down the league's average level. In the past season, 3 teams pretty much had to start over. This offseason, another two have. The average level of Oceania A right now is 12.4, and I'm sure those figures don't have the near-empty Cagayan Vindicators figured in. So I'd put it around 12 now.
Samoa's an average level of around 15. The problem is, there are a few other teams there around this average level. Only one of us can get promoted each year. However, if players start to get less XP for playing in the league, why would they want to stay with the team? I'd essentially be forced to gut my entire team and start from the ground up. As would the Las Vegas Super Bears, The Portland Rain, the Wollongong Hippos, the FF.com Inmates too. Sure, the league average would go down and games would be closer...but I'd be willing to bet you the four teams would just quit playing if they were forced to nuke their entire team and start over because people just went on to get more XP elsewhere.
I think the solution is to not allow any new signings above a certain cap, based on the league's level. If your league's average level is, say, 12, don't let anyone be signed at 150% of the leagues level -- 18. Don't restrict teams from re-signing players on their team, but don't allow a player outside of the league to enter if above that level. For new leagues, limit it to level 10 or so for the first season, then base it on the average level. Sure, there will be a few players who want to stay on a team that is being penalized for XP if it means winning a championship...but if half the team wants out, more are going to want out since the team will have to start over from square 1.
I'll be fully behind the idea of a penalty if leagues are all reorganized based on average level. I'd also be behind the idea of a penalty for any new leagues developed, since the teams would end up starting with one. But rewarding owners who aren't able to bring in the players seems kind of backwards to me. Note that I hate the idea of a hard level cap on anything, but it seems the idea of restructuring leagues based on current team level won't happen, so something to keep people from lobbying against teams that have assembled a great group of players needs to be done.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
People would farm XP. For example, I could sign a team of players for 1 season in a Pro league. They all get killed and level up like crazy due to the superior competition. Maybe they are level 25 or so at the end of one season. Not sure. Once their contracts expire at the end of that season we sign all new level 1s to play on that team and sign the people whose contracts expired to the main team. They are instantly super competitive after only 1 season. Rinse, wash, and repeat. this bypasses all the trade restrictions as well and all it would take is willing players, and 2 owners willing to cooperate.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
This too. A good team could just bring in a couple of friends, play them somewhere that they won't hurt the team, and just let them farm up XP.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 13:37:12
FairForever
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
People would farm XP. For example, I could sign a team of players for 1 season in a Pro league. They all get killed and level up like crazy due to the superior competition. Maybe they are level 25 or so at the end of one season. Not sure. Once their contracts expire at the end of that season we sign all new level 1s to play on that team and sign the people whose contracts expired to the main team. They are instantly super competitive after only 1 season. Rinse, wash, and repeat. this bypasses all the trade restrictions as well and all it would take is willing players, and 2 owners willing to cooperate.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
Couldn't have said it better. At least the first part. To be honest, I'm not exactly sure what you're trying to say in the second part.
Thanks nonetheless. An alternative solution would be much better.
People would farm XP. For example, I could sign a team of players for 1 season in a Pro league. They all get killed and level up like crazy due to the superior competition. Maybe they are level 25 or so at the end of one season. Not sure. Once their contracts expire at the end of that season we sign all new level 1s to play on that team and sign the people whose contracts expired to the main team. They are instantly super competitive after only 1 season. Rinse, wash, and repeat. this bypasses all the trade restrictions as well and all it would take is willing players, and 2 owners willing to cooperate.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
Couldn't have said it better. At least the first part. To be honest, I'm not exactly sure what you're trying to say in the second part.
Thanks nonetheless. An alternative solution would be much better.
MrMoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by tpaterniti
People would farm XP. For example, I could sign a team of players for 1 season in a Pro league. They all get killed and level up like crazy due to the superior competition. Maybe they are level 25 or so at the end of one season. Not sure. Once their contracts expire at the end of that season we sign all new level 1s to play on that team and sign the people whose contracts expired to the main team. They are instantly super competitive after only 1 season. Rinse, wash, and repeat. this bypasses all the trade restrictions as well and all it would take is willing players, and 2 owners willing to cooperate.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
Couldn't have said it better. At least the first part. To be honest, I'm not exactly sure what you're trying to say in the second part.
Sounds like he is pretty much saying that a player would be forced out of a league with a level cap/system that penalizes them for being over a certain level. It would break up teams.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
People would farm XP. For example, I could sign a team of players for 1 season in a Pro league. They all get killed and level up like crazy due to the superior competition. Maybe they are level 25 or so at the end of one season. Not sure. Once their contracts expire at the end of that season we sign all new level 1s to play on that team and sign the people whose contracts expired to the main team. They are instantly super competitive after only 1 season. Rinse, wash, and repeat. this bypasses all the trade restrictions as well and all it would take is willing players, and 2 owners willing to cooperate.
Also the biggest problem with level CAPs in my opinion is that the best part of GLB is team community, which level CAPs necessarily break up by making people want to leave their current teams once they reach a certain level. I don't see how this addresses that problem. Football is a team game and this game should be set up to foster team play, not to destroy it.
Couldn't have said it better. At least the first part. To be honest, I'm not exactly sure what you're trying to say in the second part.
Sounds like he is pretty much saying that a player would be forced out of a league with a level cap/system that penalizes them for being over a certain level. It would break up teams.
FairForever
offline
offline
By the way, I just checked... the average USA Pro level is 16. There's a level 24 kicker. Does that mean that the kicker is now penalized for playing in the top league?
bballpurdue22
offline
offline
I couldn't read through all 12 pages of posts, but the system now isn't too bad. Everyone knows what to expect XP-wise. Almost all my guys (10 out of 11) are on friends teams from work or new friends made on Goal Line. I don't really want to have to split them up to move to a team where I am not loosing lots of XP from sticking (1) to my contract and (2) with my friends.
From what I've noticed, the players with the highest levels are the people boosting (duh right) which means these are the people that are paying for the site. I would be very careful on making changes to XP that will hurt higher level players. I understand parity, but the trading fairness and free agent market help prevent one of the new teams from signing all level 10+ players. To trade a level 9 from one of the teams I GM for cash costs a minimum of around $85K. With a starting cash of $500K that limits teams quite a bit.
From what I've noticed, the players with the highest levels are the people boosting (duh right) which means these are the people that are paying for the site. I would be very careful on making changes to XP that will hurt higher level players. I understand parity, but the trading fairness and free agent market help prevent one of the new teams from signing all level 10+ players. To trade a level 9 from one of the teams I GM for cash costs a minimum of around $85K. With a starting cash of $500K that limits teams quite a bit.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 13:41:18
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























