User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - Item Crafting
Page:
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
I was thinking that the coach crafted stuff might be kind of crazy good, and balancing that could be bothersome, so I thought this might be better:

Perhaps you could do something like: you could train to have different abilities like "allowing the people you are coaching to choose which type of piece they are shopping for" (gloves, shoes, shirt, legs etc)

and possibly giving a boost to rolling a "good" piece of equipment (more %, + attributes, + nice SAs). And maybe an ability to get shopping tokens and distribute them to the players he coaches

rather than flat out making the equipment just helping them get a piece of advanced equipment. That way you wouldn't have to worry about balancing issues with new eq being added in
 
bigtony2tone
offline
Link
 
I fail to see how "crafting" items has anything to do with football.

Fixing the sim itself would eliminate any need for more advanced super-special magical equipment.
 
Mauler
Tsalagi
offline
Link
 
This game is turning more into a WOW with a term such as crafting. I have been around football most of my life & never heard that term used. I think it is time to stop with the kiddy stuff & stick to the basics of football. We have human Coaches already for AI, etc. & these Coaches with special powers will just distract from the game, be exploited in ways you do not see yet, etc. This should at least be voted on by each different League & only team owners in those Leagues can vote. However, before a vote is made each owner should be PMed exactly what you want to implement so they know what they are voting on, no excuses that way. This is the only fair way of implementing something like this that may just well alienate 80% of your business. A response would be nice from Bort himself about this!
Edited by Mauler on Sep 6, 2009 06:33:51
 
Triple_A
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Bort, please do not add coaching.... i am a loyal customer and addict of your game... but i think this could ruin it, i didnt really like veteran abilities, but it would not make as big of an impact as i expected it to make, but coaching staffs could ruin the game. this game is meant for builds and tactics to be dominant, but coaching will give higher leveled players the advantage again, sure anybody can get coaches.... but i just dont think this needs to be a part of the game, we already have coaches, they are called GM's, if you want, every agent could be given a job for the team and spend their SP's per team... that might work... but players i dont think will work.


 
aceinthehouse
offline
Link
 
Bort...this is unrelated to this thread topic and I apologize...but I didn't want to start an unecessary "coaching thread" bud.

So will you hear me out for a sec?

I read about 17 pages of your "coaching thread announcement page" and I noticed there are some who like the idea and many who are very upset that only older season 1 players will get the 1st crack at it.(yes,i also read that you were thinking about a minimum of level 35, to start out as well)

Here is my solution to your troubles bort imo...

FAME
----------------------------------
Have everyone who has the minimum number of fame points (be it 3? or whatever..1 game played) be able to retire and use that player to coach.

I have a guy who is 415+ days old,so my opinion is not biased here as you will see with my player flash Skywalker WR...

However,I do think it would be fair to apply this coaching opportunity for everyone.

HOWEVER...I do think if you use FAME as a prerequisite,this will allow those who have played since season 1 or 2 and have played 10 or 11 seasons to have a FAIR and upper hand in the coaching ranks as it should be.

So I believe the FAME that players have accumilated over the seasons should pply to their creation of their coach. I was thinking maybe creation points to start off in distribution.

If a guy wants to coach by retiring his guy after 1 game and 6 points in fame,then he can..no problem.He will just have to make do with 6 distribution points on his creation date. It's only fair.

If a guy retires after 10 seasons and has 1500+ fame,then he will get 1500 creation points to distribute.

This also rewards those who have played in higher leagues compared to those who have not, by the reward system in place for fame and what league you have played in...correct?

Another think bort...I think that if you have a player retired at a certain position like my WR for example and you want to coach Defense or something not applicable,you should be penalized or at least...not REWARDED for coaching a different position.

But if your player coaches the same position he played at for all those seasons,he should NOT be penalized or should be REWARDED for doing so...just my opinion on that bort.

I think if you use my analysis,I have provided for you here...you will find it to be fair for those who want to coach early,yet still maintaining the reward for those who have played for many seasons and have accumilated FAME over the seasons.

Otherwise...what is fame really good for and what is it's purpose in the game buddy?

Thank you for listening bort and I appreciate it bud!

ace



 
THUNDER49
offline
Link
 
This is a bad idea. It had some potential but by making it so complex it just alienates 90% of the GLB user base. People actually put in the work as coaches on here, their called gm's. They are the ones who game plan, and watch film, and come up with innovative plays. And now we are giving people credit for that, and letting them tip the balance of a game without even putting in the work. I wish I could just stop scouting opponents and instead just spend 5 scouting points and have it done for me. Not to mention all of the previous threads about the rich getting richer. This is only going to benefit the elite teams. This game was envisioned to be fun for people to play and spend a few hours a week on. If you get to the point where you are going to have to start gameplanning 18 hours a week just to have a chance to win and now you are recruiting coaches to make sure they sit down and have a pepsi with your star rb so he can break a few more tackles next game I would say its a little out of control and Bort doesn't need to be afraid to backtrack and go back on this. Just my opinion...
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Triple_A
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25

Bort, please do not add coaching.... i am a loyal customer and addict of your game... but i think this could ruin it, i didnt really like veteran abilities, but it would not make as big of an impact as i expected it to make, but coaching staffs could ruin the game. this game is meant for builds and tactics to be dominant, but coaching will give higher leveled players the advantage again, sure anybody can get coaches.... but i just dont think this needs to be a part of the game, we already have coaches, they are called GM's, if you want, every agent could be given a job for the team and spend their SP's per team... that might work... but players i dont think will work.




im surprised i have not seen the trolls who like everything bort suggests (:.
 
Link
 
Adding coaches (and all of the unneeded complexities that come with it) is a very bad idea.

We should have a poll on whether to implement it or not.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtony2tone
I fail to see how "crafting" items has anything to do with football.

Fixing the sim itself would eliminate any need for more advanced super-special magical equipment.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by BDawk
I think the whole thing sounds far-fetched, a coach making equipment. Maybe there could be a sort of implementation of a equipment facility or maybe a coach slot that deals with equipment.



I've read where Lombardi personally built every pair of shoulder pads that Bart Starr wore.

*eye roll*

Are we REALLY going to do this?
Edited by Larry Roadgrader on Sep 6, 2009 10:20:23
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Brandonhicks16
Well, how much would these equipment pieces cost(sp wise and money wise) and do you give them to the players?



I'm sure it involves going on quests, slaying dragons, and finding magical coins. The magical coins can then be given to the fairy princess who hands the player his golden helmet.
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Adding coaches (and all of the unneeded complexities that come with it) is a very bad idea.

We should have a poll on whether to implement it or not.


 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Down with coaches!!!!!
 
veepee
offline
Link
 
So, can someone explain this for me:

Many people have suggested that coach-creation *not* be limited to retiring 440d players. I'm not entirely sure whether that makes sense to me, but if coaches are truly going to be a large part of the game - indeed, in response to a suggestion that coaches be restricted from pro/WL for some period of time, I saw at least one mod argue that it would be unfair to exclude the elite of the game from the "largest" changes - it does strike me as odd that new players can't opt for this route at the outset, or after some nominal period of time in the game (based on fame/level/etc...).

The only reply I've seen that actually addresses this issue (i.e., why not create coaches from scratch), is that Bort, et al., don't want a whole crew of inactive level 1 coaches, since there are only 10ish coaching slots on any given team. How does this make any sense at all? There are fewer "slots" for virtually every other position -- while a team may hire up to 10 coaches, I've never seen any team with 10, or even 8 or 6 QBs, RBs, safeties, kickers, etc... Frankly, I doubt I've seen many teams with that many WRs. So, as noted above, can someone explain the rationale here? Am I missing something? Nobody is complaining about a glut of unhired QBs; why would we be worried about a similar glut of unhired coaches?
Edited by veepee on Sep 6, 2009 11:20:58
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
I'm not 100% against coaches in generals, but I am 100% against item crafting. I really, really hate this idea.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.