User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
But it can't be permanent--its got to be temporary training gains, or it takes the LONG TERM BUILD out of the agent's hand and places it at the mercy of whatever good/crappy coach they signed with.


Back to the training bonuses. What if they only improved training a certain skill by no more than 5% depending on the current training projected increase. For example my G has an Approx. Normal Training percent of +3% for blocking. A coach could improve that by 2% making it +5%. However he has an Approx. Normal Training percent of +11% for speed. So the coach could improve it by 3% making it +14%.

That would really not change the build too much imo.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of a really famous coach increasing ticket sales (what you can charge).
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'd still like to see more position specific coach abilities. As in a retired LB has the ability to be a LB coach. He spends his dinero on equipment or bonuses that affect the LB corps, w/ some that reach across D-Line perhaps.

My one fear is that coaches become overpowered and have too much influence on a game or a player's growth. Keeping the bonuses player specific or position specific (within the coaches range) is a definite need.

I don't like coaches changing a player's growth (boosting training percentages and such).
Edited by Mat McBriar on Sep 3, 2009 22:42:59
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
For those of you who don't want a coach to affect training or in-game performance: what the hell is a coach to do? Training players and coaching them in game is exactly what a coach does.

I agree that a coach shouldn't make a player get magically faster for one game, that coach could point something out in the opponent's offense/defense that improves the player's playmaking (e.g boost to vision/stamina/confidence).

yeah, signing with a bad coach hinders you, but it no way hinders your long-term build. most people only sign 1 season contracts anyway because a bad owner could affect your build (you get benched and lose as season of xp).

Having good/bad coaches actually enhances a team's ability recruit. A great way to turn around a crappy team would be to go and hire the best coaches out there.


I don't think people are saying they don't want in-game performance affected, in fact most of us are advocating for it. We're just advocating against permanent training/stat/SA/VA benefits. True, a bad owner/OC/DC can hurt your build, but that just proves the point we're making: some people already build farm teams to ensure they get MaxXP every single game during the first season or two when the XP gains are large. If coaches are able to help your build in a permanent way, farm teams for coaches to do this would spring up like weeds. That would only hurt the game.
 
RobertRJS
offline
Link
 
dunno if mentioned.


they could purchase new plays in the playbook. at least on offense.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, let's say each coach has a set amount of training points per season.

What if the could assign one of his unlocked trainable options to a particular player by spending some, and it give that guy a +X bonus to whatever the attribute is. Then if he wants to change it to somebody else, it costs him more training points. Eventually he'd run out if he kept changing it around.


Yeah under that system once a trainer was bought for a player there would be no refunds and the player would have the bonus for the designated period of time.


However, there is a different mechanic I've seen used in a few games called Concentration. Basically in a concentration system if each +5 strength bonus had a cost of 10% of a coach's concentration bar, he could give 10 players at one time that bonus. If later on he were to remove the bonus from 4 players his bar would return to 40%, since he'd regained that much concentration.

In theory it makes sense since a coach can only focus on so many players at a time.
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 22:46:55
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 22:45:37
 
Wei Wu Wei
offline
Link
 
This may have already been suggested:

Coaches can spend money on (fill in the blank) to allow for intense training combos players aren't already allowed to access.

Coaches have a prestige rank that allows for training boosts when players under their domain (lbs, cbs, qbs, etc) train certain intense training combos - precision passer QB coach gives bonus to training throw/vision, which might make training some of these combos more lucrative at higher levels when the point of diminishing returns slows down the training of those "sets."

A coaches prestige determine the number of resettable VPs each off season.

A coaches prestige is gained/lost based on the teams wins/losses. The more you win the more prestige and vice versa.



 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

But it can't be permanent--its got to be temporary training gains, or it takes the LONG TERM BUILD out of the agent's hand and places it at the mercy of whatever good/crappy coach they signed with.


Back to the training bonuses. What if they only improved training a certain skill by no more than 5% depending on the current training projected increase. For example my G has an Approx. Normal Training percent of +3% for blocking. A coach could improve that by 2% making it +5%. However he has an Approx. Normal Training percent of +11% for speed. So the coach could improve it by 3% making it +14%.

That would really not change the build too much imo.


In your example, the blocking bonus is effectively 67%. That is huge. As I said earlier, I think there is more than enough neat stuff being thrown around to avoid the can of worms permanent build help would be.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Wei Wu Wei
This may have already been suggested:

Coaches can spend money on (fill in the blank) to allow for intense training combos players aren't already allowed to access.

Coaches have a prestige rank that allows for training boosts when players under their domain (lbs, cbs, qbs, etc) train certain intense training combos - precision passer QB coach gives bonus to training throw/vision, which might make training some of these combos more lucrative at higher levels when the point of diminishing returns slows down the training of those "sets."


This has been a major point of discussion over the past like, 4 pages or so. It's a terrible idea.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
F

yeah, signing with a bad coach hinders you, but it no way hinders your long-term build. most people only sign 1 season contracts anyway because a bad owner could affect your build (you get benched and lose as season of xp).




Yet another problem, however, is that agents don't sign their players with a "coach"--they sign they with teams. So a team could have a WELL RESPECTED "coach"...and then have a disagreement that leads to that "coach" departing the team before they ever played a down.

I just can't stress this enough: "Coaches" should have ZERO effect on a player's long-term build.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I'd still like to see more position specific coach abilities. As in a retired LB has the ability to be a LB coach. He spends his dinero on equipment or bonuses that affect the LB corps, w/ some that reach across D-Line perhaps.

My one fear is that coaches become overpowered and have too much influence on a game or a player's growth. Keeping the bonuses player specific or position specific (within the coaches range) is a definite need.


Coaches will only be able to affect limited number of players for the positions that they coach. An O line coach only works with OL players, etc.

You gave me an idea, though, that I don't know why I hadn't thought of already: targeting players of the same position the player played for coaching could give better bonuses, or there could be an additional skill only available for use with same-position players. I don't know what it would be, but it sounds good to me.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
I just can't stress this enough: "Coaches" should have ZERO effect on a player's long-term build.


I agree.
 
Wei Wu Wei
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
This has been a major point of discussion over the past like, 4 pages or so. It's a terrible idea.


Yeah the page count was flying by so fast I gave up on trying to read them all and just jumped to the end.

My bad
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
I don't think people are saying they don't want in-game performance affected, in fact most of us are advocating for it. We're just advocating against permanent training/stat/SA/VA benefits. True, a bad owner/OC/DC can hurt your build, but that just proves the point we're making: some people already build farm teams to ensure they get MaxXP every single game during the first season or two when the XP gains are large. If coaches are able to help your build in a permanent way, farm teams for coaches to do this would spring up like weeds. That would only hurt the game.


I honestly don't think it would hurt the game to have permanent training increases. I think it would only add more strategy to it. And farm teams already exist - the current promotion scheme only reinforces it. Adding coaches will not make it any more prevalent than it already is.
 
fbfan18
offline
Link
 
In all seriousness - I think this needs to be viewed while you are coming up with ideas for Coach's.......

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dV-DO8WAq5g

because that is a true Coach....... lemme know what you think Bort!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.