User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by OvechkinSCORES
Show their favored running and passing direction: Left, Middle or Right?


% of runs to each side would be good. It already happens in the PBR scout script. And it should be added into this as well. Being able to pull up and sort replay links also via monsterkill V2 with addon would be another great tool to add in.
IE: Pull up all singleback run left replay links. That way you can go through each one and watch to see which type/gap of run play it is.

This is already done via the scripts and should be incorporated into the game.

 
DeadKennedys
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
% of runs to each side would be good. It already happens in the PBR scout script. And it should be added into this as well. Being able to pull up and sort replay links also via monsterkill V2 with addon would be another great tool to add in.
IE: Pull up all singleback run left replay links. That way you can go through each one and watch to see which type/gap of run play it is.

This is already done via the scripts and should be incorporated into the game.



This= +1
 
Shart
offline
Link
 
Right now, if you go in there and put a little effort into scouting and game planning, you have a reasonable expectation that the OC has gotten a bit complacent in his game planning because let's face it, most DC's don't enjoy and/or want to put the time in to do it right So you have a reasonable expectation that the OC has gotten sloppy and predictable and you can shove the ball up his ass.

You make an "Easy Button" and that expectation goes away.

I'd say make it where it organizes basic info like team leaders and stuff like that, and maybe even does the same thing that MonsterKill provides, but let's not have the computer go thru and crunch out all the answers. Leave something for the players to use their noggin with. For many of us that's what the game is all about.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by Saris

Originally posted by pottsman



Right now, picking TE1 and TE2 is obvious. No thought is needed on which one to use on a play. Do you really want any depth chart decision to be that obvious?


I see what you're saying and to a degree I agree. But my concern is that we'd just be replacing one type of obvious with another. Under this system there would only be two viable TE builds. Receiving TE's built to break tackles who also have decent blocking around the first cap, and Receiving Speed/agility TE's who also have decent strength/blocking around the first cap. While any TE who has very high natural blocking may as well retire.


I don't think so. I think that your first two builds will definitely be around, as they're basically around now already. There are the power TEs and the speed ones already, both enjoy some success to my knowledge. And yes, they will need to cap blocking now to be competent. But I think that the high blocking TE will survive. He'll already have high strength and agility, along with decent speed (since I'm assuming that a successful blocking TE is built as a cross between an OT and a fullback, going with raw numbers of 70+ strength and agility, 68ish blocking, 60s speed, and capped vision). Add in capped catching to that build and well trained carrying (high 30s), and you don't think that will be a build capable of running a few routes, forcing coverage? You lose some of the points you planned to put into SAs or extra vision and put them into catching. He won't be pulling in 50 catches, he won't be something that the DCs will gameplan to stop...but he will be someone that they're forced to cover. If you as an OC see a team ignoring blocking TEs in coverage, you have the tool available to throw to him a few times against a defense completely unprepared.


The problem is that in terms of blocking the difference between a power TE with first capped blocking and a blocking TE is very minimal, while the offensive difference between the two is enormous. The only reason that the blocking TE plays is because the area that he has the very slight edge in, is his only role on the team. Also I'm sorry but a receiver with 50 catching and 30 carrying is just not viable, especially the 30 carrying when they're covered by LB's. Also in order not to be a liability and forecast plays, TE's will need to have at least a reasonably balanced split between passing and running plays no more lopsided than 70/30 at least. You could argue that the blocking TE could stay in as a blocker for passing plays, but this isn't an effective strategy in the current sim. In most cases the additional blocker is unnecessary and the QB has one less target, making the TE a huge liability. So I guess the question is, why in the world would anyone ever keep a blocking TE when a power TE is excellent offensively and nearly as good at blocking?

Finaly I'm sure that a lot of people will argue that building a TE with less than 2nd capped Catching and 1st capped Carrying was unrealistic therefore they deserve to have their players destroyed. But the fact remains that these were builds that were effective in the version of the sim in which they were built. In terms of realism it's also unrealistic that kickers and punters have more strength than DE's. However, that's the effective way to build players in the current sim. Can you imagine the backlash if strength suddenly only affected a kicker or punters ability to tackle and FF's, while jumping was changed to leg strength? It's certainly more "realistic" but it destroys a lot of builds by an after the fact change.
Edited by Saris on Aug 12, 2009 17:40:06
Edited by Saris on Aug 12, 2009 17:38:56
Edited by Saris on Aug 12, 2009 17:38:07
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

Favorite Play(s) ( top 5 most commonly called?) would be cool. I guess it takes some of the actual scouting out of things, but that's pretty basic.

Just something that would say "hey the Dallas Cowboys like to utilize 'x' play a lot".


Yeah, it could take a bit out of scouting, but it's true that even the fans know that "Wes Welker gets the ball a lot," or "they like to run to the weak side frequently."

What if we somehow built up a "tendencies" chart or something? Run vs pass, etc.


why don't you apply the monsterskill scout tool to this idea. if you give people the read out with links to replays, then the wear on the server should be less. and everyone greasemonkey or not has an opportunity to see the read out.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Tendencies chart sounds like a good idea.


Wouldn't want it to be too specific, and take all the scouting away from scouts, so it'd need to be limited somewhat as to what it showed.

I could easily analyze the playcalling from the team's last 3-4 games and get percentages for:

pass/run
inside/outside rushes
HB vs FB vs QB rushes
HB vs FB vs TE vs WR passes
Screen pass %
long/medium/short pass %
each play's % (too much info IMO)
probably other stuff

I think maybe some combination of those would be good?


this should include personnel. like a tab on the replay to see who lines up where.
 
Zumbo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
each play's % (too much info IMO)


I think that you should just have the top 5 plays in order. And include the team's season stats compared to league, i.e.

-----Passing-----
Passing: 3,000 Yds (3)
TD/INT Ratio: 6.8/1 (5)
Yards per Attempt: 7.0 (6)
Plays per Game: 60 (8)

-----Rushing-----
Rushing: 1,500 Yds (20)
Rushing TDs: 18 (10)
Yards per Rush: 5.6 (11)
Plays per Game: 48 (14)

-----Pass Defense-----
etc.

-----Rush Defense-----
etc.
 
bricecubs
offline
Link
 
looks good bort
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
top 4 favorite plays would be a cool feature. Don't know if it's been mentioned in this epic thread
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
If one like to have scouting tools the best is to generate an official version of the common PBP_filter, PBR_game_scout and Monsterkill.

Additional feature could be:
- Being able to use the PBP_filter for more than one game at once.
- Being able to run the PBR_game_scout on the results of the PBP_filter
- Adding offensive formation info (and if possible play name) to the play by play info, to allow filtering by them.
- Add (easy to see) defense info to the play by play like blitzing players. It will be extra helpful if one can tell the difference between a called blitz and a delayed blitz (when the offensive man stays to block).

Such tools are very useful for the offense too (specially if you can break plays by offense formation).
Edited by tragula on Aug 13, 2009 08:24:42
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I don't think you should bother. It will be too much work for marginally useful results. Focus on the sim IMO.
 
DeadKennedys
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I don't think you should bother. It will be too much work for marginally useful results. Focus on the sim IMO.


Did you ever scout in your life? It's a big pain in the ass at the moment.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by goseattle
How about a way to see like, their trade history and see who they signed also? I know there already is a tab devoted to it, but i could a section that says who they traded who in their past seasons, and who they have signed the past years and also who they have released?


The better to see if anyone recently traded away might have sour graps and want to squeal on builds?

A tad slimy IMO.

But a listing of who was traded/signed in the last 24 or 48 hours might be of interest. First and foremost to flag you to any changes in the squad that you might not have noticed if you had checked the roster earlier in the process. Possibly other uses too, like pointing out someone who might not have their tactics in line with the new team, or maybe an over looked depth chart hole etc.

Not a huge priority, but not useless.

But maybe just a tab to the normal trade history would suffice.

 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
There needs to be some form of actual scouting to go on. You shouldn't be able to have the ingame scout do all the work for you. It should only give you the tools to make it easier without giving you all the information.
I'm a big fan of having to put effort into a team and I like my GM's that show this as well. I don't like GM's that just run a script and go by that without actually breaking down the film their selves.



First off, like I said I am not against leaving SOMETHING for the workaholic/tinkerer type of player to do.

But you can not make the sim be a monumental chore to everyone to do basic scouting, and the stuff I listed is fairly basic.

Its one thing to feel good about doing your job at work, the sweat on your brow and the ache in your head or back giving you the physical feedback of a hard job done well.

Its another to expect that every 2 days from a game player.

Leave the monster chore games to the niche solo laptop game crowd where it belongs. In a MMO where the M hopefully stands for Megamultiplayer, you need to have a broader appeal and that means a more accessible game UI.

And since scouting is the one thing in the game that matters most thats not linked to the wallet of the player, it HAS to be streamlined some.

And frankly, what I just listed still leaves alot of room on the table for scouting game films. First off just saying HB Slam such and such is not going to tell you anything if you havent studied the game or the films. Secondly how quickly his guards or tackles are coming out to block for him, how fast or good his FB is etc, these are things that only eyeballing the film will tell you. Might be that knowing his super speed back sweeps right on every play and your placing your super speed LB to meet him is not going to work if he has a super monster FB lead blocking for him - you might need to look at the films to see that and put two or three tacklers on the flanks to soak up the outside blocking. And so forth and so on.

THAT would be a situation where the casual player (well the casual player who knows the playbook) will be able to scout effectively but not with genius, but the player who puts the elbow grease in (but with less time needed overall) can be a defensive genius and have an edge, but JUST an edge rather than utter and complete WTFpwnage because no one else can possible scout under the current system domination.

 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

P/Much
Anybody can read but only good GM's can breakdown gametape and discern what it is. Only dedicated GM's can give the time to help mold your team identity. Those are the Gm's I want and the one I try to be.
I don't want to be able to whipp a gameplan together in 5 mins. there is no skill in that.


First off your first statement would be equally true of a scouting page. Anyone can read it, but only some one who understands the game and the implications of what they are reading can break it down and discern what it is. So you should really have NO problem with this - unless what you really desire for some perverse reason is that all your GMs be college kids skipping classes or friendless OCDers sitting at the PC breaking down film and crafting playbooks 8 hours a day after work.

I do know how to break down films (on defense, I suck at OC) and I do spend OCD kinda hours at gaming. But due to RL constraints that means I usually only get a few hours to work on any given game and therefore do not have the time to fully break down the film AND implement the findings. Can't tell you how many times I am cramming in the last bit of film and then rushing to field a plan to meet it and the clock runs out before I am done, or I put in a play with a glaring hole in it because I do not have the time to properly "proof read" what I have done before kick off.

A scouting system that takes out the mundane repetition of data gathering would help me and presumably the many hundreds or thousands of others who have only as much time as I do, or more likely far less.
Edited by yello1 on Aug 13, 2009 11:19:33
Edited by yello1 on Aug 13, 2009 11:11:53
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.