Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by pottsman
Right now, picking TE1 and TE2 is obvious. No thought is needed on which one to use on a play. Do you really want any depth chart decision to be that obvious?
I see what you're saying and to a degree I agree. But my concern is that we'd just be replacing one type of obvious with another. Under this system there would only be two viable TE builds. Receiving TE's built to break tackles who also have decent blocking around the first cap, and Receiving Speed/agility TE's who also have decent strength/blocking around the first cap. While any TE who has very high natural blocking may as well retire.
I don't think so. I think that your first two builds will definitely be around, as they're basically around now already. There are the power TEs and the speed ones already, both enjoy some success to my knowledge. And yes, they will need to cap blocking now to be competent. But I think that the high blocking TE will survive. He'll already have high strength and agility, along with decent speed (since I'm assuming that a successful blocking TE is built as a cross between an OT and a fullback, going with raw numbers of 70+ strength and agility, 68ish blocking, 60s speed, and capped vision). Add in capped catching to that build and well trained carrying (high 30s), and you don't think that will be a build capable of running a few routes, forcing coverage? You lose some of the points you planned to put into SAs or extra vision and put them into catching. He won't be pulling in 50 catches, he won't be something that the DCs will gameplan to stop...but he will be someone that they're forced to cover. If you as an OC see a team ignoring blocking TEs in coverage, you have the tool available to throw to him a few times against a defense completely unprepared.
The problem is that in terms of blocking the difference between a power TE with first capped blocking and a blocking TE is very minimal, while the offensive difference between the two is enormous. The only reason that the blocking TE plays is because the area that he has the very slight edge in, is his only role on the team. Also I'm sorry but a receiver with 50 catching and 30 carrying is just not viable, especially the 30 carrying when they're covered by LB's. Also in order not to be a liability and forecast plays, TE's will need to have at least a reasonably balanced split between passing and running plays no more lopsided than 70/30 at least. You could argue that the blocking TE could stay in as a blocker for passing plays, but this isn't an effective strategy in the current sim. In most cases the additional blocker is unnecessary and the QB has one less target, making the TE a huge liability. So I guess the question is, why in the world would anyone ever keep a blocking TE when a power TE is excellent offensively and nearly as good at blocking?
Finaly I'm sure that a lot of people will argue that building a TE with less than 2nd capped Catching and 1st capped Carrying was unrealistic therefore they deserve to have their players destroyed. But the fact remains that these were builds that were effective in the version of the sim in which they were built. In terms of realism it's also unrealistic that kickers and punters have more strength than DE's. However, that's the effective way to build players in the current sim. Can you imagine the backlash if strength suddenly only affected a kicker or punters ability to tackle and FF's, while jumping was changed to leg strength? It's certainly more "realistic" but it destroys a lot of builds by an after the fact change.