User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The time has come to remove the Click and Drag of the Defensive Line in the DPC
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
This thread fails...removing it would only cause more problems.
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by tdm13


Are you serious? Maybe you were in hibernation when all the top ranked teams in their conferences whined on these forums about losing to Islam? Championship games were Islam v Islam. Islam didn't work every time? Are you kidding? LOL


I also saw people saying OMG DONT NERF ISLAM FIX UR BUILDS!

And those people went on to post several dozen plays where the Islam HB would get 1 yard, or -1 yard on the play.


Several dozen in the same game or several dozen total? Let's hypothesize for a minute since I don't want to dig up games to prove this to you (I'm at work atm):

Islam would for 1 yard on 1st down. Then on 2nd/3rd/4th down, offense gets 3 yds each. First down. ETC.

So let's say that Islam works 75% of the time, while this works maybe 10% of the time (and it can't be consistently replicated). You're saying that this is still an exploit? Or are you saying that Islam wasn't an exploit? Either way, you're wrong.
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
1) I'm looking at a ton of replays that show both the T and G interacting with the DE. They're everywhere. Go back through old posts and you'll find dozens.

2) Sure people beat double teams on occasion. But they sure as hell don't get MORE effective when being double teamed. Yet you refuse to acknowledge how broken this is.


Right dozens... among hundreds if not thousands of plays.

I can't find the thread, but there is one that shows a RDE doing what you call an exploit. I looked thru the entire game, it happened twice, TWICE! You people pick out those but callously omit all the plays where they line up in the SAME SPOT and do NOTHING.

Re: DE vs ISlam it's not even close. Even is ISlam was stopped for one play, the next 3-6 would be good. Not like this where it's a handful of plays a game at best.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Originally posted by fallingmercury

1) I'm looking at a ton of replays that show both the T and G interacting with the DE. They're everywhere. Go back through old posts and you'll find dozens.

2) Sure people beat double teams on occasion. But they sure as hell don't get MORE effective when being double teamed. Yet you refuse to acknowledge how broken this is.


Right dozens... among hundreds if not thousands of plays.

I can't find the thread, but there is one that shows a RDE doing what you call an exploit. I looked thru the entire game, it happened twice, TWICE! You people pick out those but callously omit all the plays where they line up in the SAME SPOT and do NOTHING.

Re: DE vs ISlam it's not even close. Even is ISlam was stopped for one play, the next 3-6 would be good. Not like this where it's a handful of plays a game at best.


 
Link
 
Yes, that's right. Among hundreds of thousands of plays.

Or maybe dozens just among the plays where this formation was called. Either way.
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Yes, that's right. Among hundreds of thousands of plays.

Or maybe dozens just among the plays where this formation was called. Either way.


Which in the case of Islam, was the majority of formations called.


This is not an argument you can win. You're comparing something that cannot be replicated easily and works 10% to something that was easily replicated 75%-100% of the time and used to win championships at every division of GLB. We both know this is not an exploit, so stop calling it that. It's a bug, and a bug that doesn't need to be fixed. If this bug is fixed, then offenses need to be totally nerfed so that defenses can actually hold opponents below 28 points.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Yes, that's right. Among hundreds of thousands of plays.

Or maybe dozens just among the plays where this formation was called. Either way.


Which in the case of Islam, was the majority of formations called.


This is not an argument you can win. You're comparing something that cannot be replicated easily and works 10% to something that was easily replicated 75%-100% of the time and used to win championships at every division of GLB. We both know this is not an exploit, so stop calling it that. It's a bug, and a bug that doesn't need to be fixed. If this bug is fixed, then offenses need to be totally nerfed so that defenses can actually hold opponents below 28 points.


Okay, so it's a "bug that doesn't need to be fixed"?

Gotcha.
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by tdm13

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Yes, that's right. Among hundreds of thousands of plays.

Or maybe dozens just among the plays where this formation was called. Either way.


Which in the case of Islam, was the majority of formations called.


This is not an argument you can win. You're comparing something that cannot be replicated easily and works 10% to something that was easily replicated 75%-100% of the time and used to win championships at every division of GLB. We both know this is not an exploit, so stop calling it that. It's a bug, and a bug that doesn't need to be fixed. If this bug is fixed, then offenses need to be totally nerfed so that defenses can actually hold opponents below 28 points.


Okay, so it's a "bug that doesn't need to be fixed"?

Gotcha.


Yep. It doesn't need to be fixed. If it's fixed, that means that defenses are further unable to move toward the QB for a sack. Fixing the bug hurts defenses (ie: a nerf). Offenses put up massive numbers anyways, so what is useless whining about something that happens 10% of the time and doesn't affect outcomes that much?

If Bort plans to fix this bug, then he needs to fix the following things in conjunction:

1.) He needs to depower the O-Line with pancake abilities (needs a higher roll to be activated)
2.) The offense in general needs a huge nerf. Since the defense will be that much more powerless to rush the QB, the offense needs to take more time for plays to develop to counteract this nerf to the defense. Tone down all attributes on all players on the offensive side of the ball.

If these are not put in as well, then don't fix this bug either.
 
Link
 
I agree with you that the game is heavily slanted towards offense.

But I don't think we should rely on bugs for game balance.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
So I lined my DT up between the LG and the C, and he beat the double team http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587112&pbp_id=14881073

Fix bug plz
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
[

Yep. It doesn't need to be fixed. If it's fixed, that means that defenses are further unable to move toward the QB for a sack. Fixing the bug hurts defenses (ie: a nerf). Offenses put up massive numbers anyways, so what is useless whining about something that happens 10% of the time and doesn't affect outcomes that much?

If Bort plans to fix this bug, then he needs to fix the following things in conjunction:

1.) He needs to depower the O-Line with pancake abilities (needs a higher roll to be activated)
2.) The offense in general needs a huge nerf. Since the defense will be that much more powerless to rush the QB, the offense needs to take more time for plays to develop to counteract this nerf to the defense. Tone down all attributes on all players on the offensive side of the ball.

If these are not put in as well, then don't fix this bug either.


I agree with most of that. I think there is a bug in the way the DEs are accelerating out of the break block, but lining up in the gap is a separate issue. For me the sim will be right when OC's spend just as much time scouting as DC's. If the OC sees and effective pass rush in shotgun, than they should change to short passes. Right now they just want to run the AI without accounting for defense at all.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
So I lined my DT up between the LG and the C, and he beat the double team http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587112&pbp_id=14881073

Fix bug plz


Did the DT use a stack of Tunnel Vision to double-boost his speed and catapult into the backfield?

Failed post on your part.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
So I lined my DT up between the LG and the C, and he beat the double team http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587112&pbp_id=14881073

Fix bug plz


He has 2 sacks all season. The DT's SA's are designed for double teams. There are 5 Oline men and 4 Dline men. Someone is going to get double teamed.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by kurieg

So I lined my DT up between the LG and the C, and he beat the double team http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587112&pbp_id=14881073

Fix bug plz


He has 2 sacks all season. The DT's SA's are designed for double teams. There are 5 Oline men and 4 Dline men. Someone is going to get double teamed.


He's just trying to distort things. /ignore IMO.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by kurieg

So I lined my DT up between the LG and the C, and he beat the double team http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587112&pbp_id=14881073

Fix bug plz


He has 2 sacks all season. The DT's SA's are designed for double teams. There are 5 Oline men and 4 Dline men. Someone is going to get double teamed.


There are no double team SA's for dealing with pass blocking.




 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.