User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by creeker22

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Just demote the worst team from each zeta/alpha conference from each league. Problem solved.


Who would replace them?


USA Pro obv, they're the best after all.


Thank you for finally admitting it.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

No, I don't see an issue. Do you mean something along the lines of a OPL team getting demoted and instead of ending up in the OPL where they can dominate, they end up in the SAPL or USAPL where they will struggle? So we should skew the system and get rid of good teams out of the Pro League so lesser teams don't end up in tough leagues? Isn't the point of GLB tough competition? Sorry if I don't think teams should be put where they know they can win.


What if a USAPL team gets demoted to OPL, it has an easy pass back to the WPL it wouldn't have otherwise had.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by creeker22


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Just demote the worst team from each zeta/alpha conference from each league. Problem solved.


Who would replace them?


USA Pro obv, they're the best after all.


Thank you for finally admitting it.



I know! What was I thinking? All those times they lost they were just letting the other team feel better about themselves!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Gart888



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




Originally posted by chronoaug





I still don't understand. So you're already admitting opl, seapl, wepl, and eepl are shitty? People here are trying to say otherwise. They shouldn't worry if they actually perform. The shittier regions don't need handicaps, they just need to play well.


Ok, let's try it this way:

If you promote an equal number of teams:

Half the WPL is shitty and it sucks.

If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.


Free market imo. Start with equal, let the world league define itself over time by relegating the non playoff teams and promoting equally to replace them.


So then:

Originally posted by



If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.



Gotcha. Those 32 teams are sure gonna have fun though.


wat

i don't think you understand my proposed system.


Hmmmm, upon further reading, I did make a mistake, good catch.

What will actually happen is some sort of neutered mix of both problems. OPL will still have to get a champion in, so that'll help keep some tiny amount of interest, but that team will still be weak, so it'll be fodder the next year.

Your system is awful...and it's about the best possible suggestion. There's a lesson in there for all of us.


If you're in the OPL, avoid the WPL?
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by Gart888



Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder




Originally posted by chronoaug





I still don't understand. So you're already admitting opl, seapl, wepl, and eepl are shitty? People here are trying to say otherwise. They shouldn't worry if they actually perform. The shittier regions don't need handicaps, they just need to play well.


Ok, let's try it this way:

If you promote an equal number of teams:

Half the WPL is shitty and it sucks.

If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.


Free market imo. Start with equal, let the world league define itself over time by relegating the non playoff teams and promoting equally to replace them.


So then:

Originally posted by



If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.



Gotcha. Those 32 teams are sure gonna have fun though.


wat

i don't think you understand my proposed system.


Hmmmm, upon further reading, I did make a mistake, good catch.

What will actually happen is some sort of neutered mix of both problems. OPL will still have to get a champion in, so that'll help keep some tiny amount of interest, but that team will still be weak, so it'll be fodder the next year.

Your system is awful...and it's about the best possible suggestion. There's a lesson in there for all of us.


But if all these leagues would wither and die like you said, but there is still always 1 team being promoted (under Garts system...I think). Then wouldn't that attract at least ONE team to give it a shot for the easy entry to the World League?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by jrry32


No, I don't see an issue. Do you mean something along the lines of a OPL team getting demoted and instead of ending up in the OPL where they can dominate, they end up in the SAPL or USAPL where they will struggle? So we should skew the system and get rid of good teams out of the Pro League so lesser teams don't end up in tough leagues? Isn't the point of GLB tough competition? Sorry if I don't think teams should be put where they know they can win.


What if a USAPL team gets demoted to OPL, it has an easy pass back to the WPL it wouldn't have otherwise had.


So...? That team deserves to make it back up if they are the best team in the OPL at the time.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Voltron


Originally posted by creeker22



Originally posted by ImTheScientist




Just demote the worst team from each zeta/alpha conference from each league. Problem solved.


Who would replace them?


USA Pro obv, they're the best after all.


Thank you for finally admitting it.



I know! What was I thinking? All those times they lost they were just letting the other team feel better about themselves!


Because all those times they won mean nothing!
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Gart888


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by Gart888




Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder





Originally posted by chronoaug






I still don't understand. So you're already admitting opl, seapl, wepl, and eepl are shitty? People here are trying to say otherwise. They shouldn't worry if they actually perform. The shittier regions don't need handicaps, they just need to play well.


Ok, let's try it this way:

If you promote an equal number of teams:

Half the WPL is shitty and it sucks.

If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.


Free market imo. Start with equal, let the world league define itself over time by relegating the non playoff teams and promoting equally to replace them.


So then:

Originally posted by




If you promote based on league strength:

The lesser leagues lose teams and interest, wilt and die.



Gotcha. Those 32 teams are sure gonna have fun though.


wat

i don't think you understand my proposed system.


Hmmmm, upon further reading, I did make a mistake, good catch.

What will actually happen is some sort of neutered mix of both problems. OPL will still have to get a champion in, so that'll help keep some tiny amount of interest, but that team will still be weak, so it'll be fodder the next year.

Your system is awful...and it's about the best possible suggestion. There's a lesson in there for all of us.


But if all these leagues would wither and die like you said, but there is still always 1 team being promoted (under Garts system...I think). Then wouldn't that attract at least ONE team to give it a shot for the easy entry to the World League?


There are 2 teams from each league.

 
Polorl69
offline
Link
 
what if we just renamed USAPro "The World League" would that end all of this?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Polorl69
what if we just renamed USAPro "The World League" would that end all of this?


I prefer USLAP
 
Link
 
Just lose all the countries and make one huge bracket...isn't this what is happen by instituting a world league? It will now become a huge bracket versus 8 small brackets.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
But if all these leagues would wither and die like you said, but there is still always 1 team being promoted (under Garts system...I think). Then wouldn't that attract at least ONE team to give it a shot for the easy entry to the World League?


Right, that's exactly what I said. Gart was right, I'd misread something in his proposal. It doesn't really change anything, but the problems did shift a bit.

Now, we'll get a shitty League with one or two teams that care, but they'll still be bad by WPL standards. Every league needs a Det. Lions though, so that's good.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Voltron


Originally posted by creeker22



Originally posted by ImTheScientist




Just demote the worst team from each zeta/alpha conference from each league. Problem solved.


Who would replace them?


USA Pro obv, they're the best after all.


Thank you for finally admitting it.



I know! What was I thinking? All those times they lost they were just letting the other team feel better about themselves!


Well, you can sit here posting scrimmages of top 3 other Pro teams pulling off a win vs. a top USA PRo team and at the same time, I can post scrimmages of 1 win USA Pro teams beating other league's defending champs...which is a lot worse looking in retrospect.

 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Just lose all the countries and make one huge bracket...isn't this what is happen by instituting a world league? It will now become a huge bracket versus 8 small brackets.



Pangaea league! Make it happen.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by jrry32



No, I don't see an issue. Do you mean something along the lines of a OPL team getting demoted and instead of ending up in the OPL where they can dominate, they end up in the SAPL or USAPL where they will struggle? So we should skew the system and get rid of good teams out of the Pro League so lesser teams don't end up in tough leagues? Isn't the point of GLB tough competition? Sorry if I don't think teams should be put where they know they can win.


What if a USAPL team gets demoted to OPL, it has an easy pass back to the WPL it wouldn't have otherwise had.


So...? That team deserves to make it back up if they are the best team in the OPL at the time.


...so simply by virtue of a lucky draw, they should get the spot back easier than they otherwise would.

At least you admit it, not much to argue I suppose.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.