User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Bort answered Questions/Concerns about restructure here (after a few pages of complaints about thread-locking)
Page:
 
Nyr3270
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Originally posted by Adderfist



I see your level 53 DE and raise you a level 7 CPU OT


My money is on the level 7 OT


I'm sad because I have to agree with Dragon.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by Bort

.

Originally posted by fallingmercury




Bort, one thing that would help is if you actually enforced suggested levels. This would be a tremendous step.


Do you mean force players off a team when they are too high of a level? That doesn't sound like a good plan, really.


Why even have suggested levels then if they're meaningless?

No I wasn't suggesting booting players off teams. But penalize them and/or their team heavily if they sign an inappropriate player from now on. Or prevent the signing entirely even.

This would be a tremendous step in the right direction for this game.


What if there was a luxury cap or something for players over suggested?


What is a luxury cap? I'm assuming you're talking about a Luxury Tax In which case I think it's a good idea.


 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Adderfist

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Originally posted by Bort


.

Originally posted by fallingmercury





Bort, one thing that would help is if you actually enforced suggested levels. This would be a tremendous step.


Do you mean force players off a team when they are too high of a level? That doesn't sound like a good plan, really.


Why even have suggested levels then if they're meaningless?

No I wasn't suggesting booting players off teams. But penalize them and/or their team heavily if they sign an inappropriate player from now on. Or prevent the signing entirely even.

This would be a tremendous step in the right direction for this game.


What if there was a luxury cap or something for players over suggested?


What is a luxury cap? I'm assuming you're talking about a Luxury Tax In which case I think it's a good idea.




Yeah, I meant tax. I should probably take a break...I'm making dumb mistakes

Someone else mentioned, however, that some teams would gladly pay out the nose to have a higher level player. The tax would have to be pretty extreme, no?
 
Link
 
Hi Bort



RM
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
I don't think a tax would work then because teams (as was seen in the Gutted Pro thread) are very willing to lose and lose and lose in order to create a giant bank account and then spend like the Angels do (I'm a Yankees fan, shut up). The penalty has to be in-game somehow, and I do believe that you have afforded leniency by making the suggested levels very far apart in comparison to what most teams have in the league. There's no reason to add leniency by taxes, etc. when those players should. just. be. cut.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
I don't think a tax would work then because teams (as was seen in the Gutted Pro thread) are very willing to lose and lose and lose in order to create a giant bank account and then spend like the Angels do (I'm a Yankees fan, shut up). The penalty has to be in-game somehow, and I do believe that you have afforded leniency by making the suggested levels very far apart in comparison to what most teams have in the league. There's no reason to add leniency by taxes, etc. when those players should. just. be. cut.


I have always been very against forcing teams to break up just due to leveling up, though. If you start out under the required levels, and then gain enough levels to go over the suggested level for the league, maybe just because your team sucks and can't get promoted, you should have to leave your friends behind? If may seem fair, but it's also not very fun.
 
Link
 
Bort-

your mods are very biased in what they move to other forums (or who they ban).


Check gart's thread in blitz that is allowed to stay or tycoon's interview or anyone's rankings.

If I start any of those, they are immediately removed.

Hypocrites imo.


Just sayin.


edit: since I made this post, they decided to play fair again for once.

Edited by SteelersInsider on Jun 5, 2009 18:53:00
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla

I don't think a tax would work then because teams (as was seen in the Gutted Pro thread) are very willing to lose and lose and lose in order to create a giant bank account and then spend like the Angels do (I'm a Yankees fan, shut up). The penalty has to be in-game somehow, and I do believe that you have afforded leniency by making the suggested levels very far apart in comparison to what most teams have in the league. There's no reason to add leniency by taxes, etc. when those players should. just. be. cut.


I have always been very against forcing teams to break up just due to leveling up, though. If you start out under the required levels, and then gain enough levels to go over the suggested level for the league, maybe just because your team sucks and can't get promoted, you should have to leave your friends behind? If may seem fair, but it's also not very fun.
That can't happen, because of the nature of the suggested levels. You update the median every day, pretty much, and heap a giant window on top of that. So when a team levels up, the rest of the teams will level up within a few days of that, behind or forward. As a result, the median window will shift and capture that team's levels again if they were on the precipice.

In addition, if you are continually held back and as a result are say a L38 punter in a L24 league, then this level discrepancy hurts the league more than it would hurt the individual to be removed from the team. I contend the rights of fair play in the league are more important than the rights of the individual to stay with his friends (a strong right, indeed, but not strong enough).

As for a possible middle ground, I think stopping VAs and fame for being above suggested levels is a decent start. I think an even better scenario is to stop XP as well. That would force the player to make one of two decisions: stunt growth a bit until you are on the level with your team or leave the team to find real competition. That way the player has a choice: he can stay with his friends and have them catch up to him (because his growth is stunted) OR he can go ahead and play on his own if he really didn't care about that team to begin with. To implement this, that player would just have a "release myself" link at the top (which IMO players on teams whose owners are inactive for more than a week should have as well). Then the player says "ok I'll let them come up to me since we're buds" or "ehh I want to develop my player, I'll go elsewhere."
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla


I don't think a tax would work then because teams (as was seen in the Gutted Pro thread) are very willing to lose and lose and lose in order to create a giant bank account and then spend like the Angels do (I'm a Yankees fan, shut up). The penalty has to be in-game somehow, and I do believe that you have afforded leniency by making the suggested levels very far apart in comparison to what most teams have in the league. There's no reason to add leniency by taxes, etc. when those players should. just. be. cut.


I have always been very against forcing teams to break up just due to leveling up, though. If you start out under the required levels, and then gain enough levels to go over the suggested level for the league, maybe just because your team sucks and can't get promoted, you should have to leave your friends behind? If may seem fair, but it's also not very fun.
That can't happen, because of the nature of the suggested levels. You update the median every day, pretty much, and heap a giant window on top of that. So when a team levels up, the rest of the teams will level up within a few days of that, behind or forward. As a result, the median window will shift and capture that team's levels again if they were on the precipice.

In addition, if you are continually held back and as a result are say a L38 punter in a L24 league, then this level discrepancy hurts the league more than it would hurt the individual to be removed from the team. I contend the rights of fair play in the league are more important than the rights of the individual to stay with his friends (a strong right, indeed, but not strong enough).

As for a possible middle ground, I think stopping VAs and fame for being above suggested levels is a decent start. I think an even better scenario is to stop XP as well. That would force the player to make one of two decisions: stunt growth a bit until you are on the level with your team or leave the team to find real competition. That way the player has a choice: he can stay with his friends and have them catch up to him (because his growth is stunted) OR he can go ahead and play on his own if he really didn't care about that team to begin with. To implement this, that player would just have a "release myself" link at the top (which IMO players on teams whose owners are inactive for more than a week should have as well). Then the player says "ok I'll let them come up to me since we're buds" or "ehh I want to develop my player, I'll go elsewhere."


Sounds like sportsmanship that people went batshit insane over.

I suppose the suggested levels could just be de-facto signing caps as well, if they were set a little lower. Sort of a "floating" soft level cap for the technically uncapped leagues.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
I remember the sportsmanship issues, but weren't they mainly caused due to unbalanced leveling? That has been somewhat dealt with in all but the uncapped Minors (p.s. Cryptotich has a great re-naming of the leagues, based on the college ranks, since Minors sounds a bit insulting). The suggested levels definitely work very well, as they statistically capture most of the levels in a fair league. The real question is how to punish those who are not within those levels. To take away VAs and fame are sort of secondary slaps on the wrist. If being forced to be cut is too much, I think it is still rational to prevent XP gains so that their comrades may progress to their level. That way you weakly force players to play to their level but keep the friendship bridges intact. Weak force should help assuage any problems.

P.S. Sportsmanship was a good idea. I'm sad it's not implemented
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=844

How does this team get placed into a 49 suggested max level?!?!?!
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Well, in baseball, the yank's had to pay a 40% luxury tax.

Would you do that for the full team roster or just the individual player?
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=844

How does this team get placed into a 49 suggested max level?!?!?!
They got placed into an Uncapped level because they barely made the playoffs and got creamed. They should not have gone 10-6 and lost like that unless they're not able to compete with players on their level or even a couple of levels below them, which is what I suspect.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Well, in baseball, the yank's had to pay a 40% luxury tax.

Would you do that for the full team roster or just the individual player?


Maybe just something like some amount per level you have over, per player, or something along those lines.

It really would put a strain on those teams who have higher level players, but just can't seem to put it together and win, though. I've seen quite a few of those teams out there.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
I remember the sportsmanship issues, but weren't they mainly caused due to unbalanced leveling? That has been somewhat dealt with in all but the uncapped Minors (p.s. Cryptotich has a great re-naming of the leagues, based on the college ranks, since Minors sounds a bit insulting). The suggested levels definitely work very well, as they statistically capture most of the levels in a fair league. The real question is how to punish those who are not within those levels. To take away VAs and fame are sort of secondary slaps on the wrist. If being forced to be cut is too much, I think it is still rational to prevent XP gains so that their comrades may progress to their level. That way you weakly force players to play to their level but keep the friendship bridges intact. Weak force should help assuage any problems.

P.S. Sportsmanship was a good idea. I'm sad it's not implemented


I saw that suggestion for the Minor names - DivIA, Semi-Pro, etc? Not a bad idea.

The main issue people had with sportsmanship were: A) people like to game the system and it impeded that (good!) and B) it could unfairly penalize players who want to stick with their team, or teams who aren't good at tactics.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.