User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks



I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.


Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


Return man already gives you a "not fumble" bonus.


Not in our scrim it didn't.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


I much prefer David vs. Goliath to Sure Tackler. I figure if they aren't bigger, and aren't stronger, breaking a tackle isn't really a huge concern....and David vs. Goliath will always trigger when you need it, and allows you to tackle players that would be near impossible to tackle by rerolling.

Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


I think a carrying slider would be nice.
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.


Still adding carrying should 'fix both problems'. It's more a player issue than a sim problem, seriously.

Carrying not only helps to avoid fumbles but also to break tackles (right?), so if people only got it over 50, it'd cause problems to LBs.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


I much prefer David vs. Goliath to Sure Tackler. I figure if they aren't bigger, and aren't stronger, breaking a tackle isn't really a huge concern....and David vs. Goliath will always trigger when you need it, and allows you to tackle players that would be near impossible to tackle by rerolling.

Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


I saw a suggestion for another running tactic, that might be along those same lines. Where on one side you have "fight out yards, +fumble" and on the other you have "no extra yards, -fumble."

Would anyone take the +fumble one, though? An extra yard or 2 might be worth it, but only if you have the carrying to hang on.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Edit: ah, I misread. You think there needs to be a VA like "cover up?"


hell yes there needs to be. If there's a VA increasing fumbles, there needs to be something that the ball carriers can have to combat that. Otherwise it's skewed too far in one direction.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
I think a carrying slider would be nice.


Then you have people turning up their slider and completely negating a player's build though. Like when "Wrap up" pretty much guaranteed a tackle against a power back...it made power backs somewhat inferior, and made Tackling a joke attribute at best. Kind of worried that's what a slider would do...then instead of having 40-50 carrying, players would have 20 carrying with their slider maxed to never fumble.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Gyuri1


Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


I much prefer David vs. Goliath to Sure Tackler. I figure if they aren't bigger, and aren't stronger, breaking a tackle isn't really a huge concern....and David vs. Goliath will always trigger when you need it, and allows you to tackle players that would be near impossible to tackle by rerolling.

Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


I saw a suggestion for another running tactic, that might be along those same lines. Where on one side you have "fight out yards, +fumble" and on the other you have "no extra yards, -fumble."

Would anyone take the +fumble one, though? An extra yard or 2 might be worth it, but only if you have the carrying to hang on.


I never complain about anything that enhances tactics over fucking with builds. This would be an excellent addition because it would allow a team to set it depending on how many fumbles another taem is forcing. Adds another dimension to the tactics of the game, and those are always good for GLB.

There has to be a tradeoff though, always - setting it all the way to fight out yards should give an enhancement to breaking tackles or some such that is tangible, while setting it the other way should probably give a penalty to breaking tackles over what the player would have based on just his build.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 16:13:01
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Deathblade

Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out. There needs to be a downside to it, so there is risk/reward.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 16:11:59
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks



I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.


Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


Return man already gives you a "not fumble" bonus.


Return man works a lot more for WR and HB then CBs. So I chose not to use it.....guess im going to have to use it now even tho only about 50% of it works for CBs.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I saw a suggestion for another running tactic, that might be along those same lines. Where on one side you have "fight out yards, +fumble" and on the other you have "no extra yards, -fumble."

Would anyone take the +fumble one, though? An extra yard or 2 might be worth it, but only if you have the carrying to hang on.


Maybe not, but if it was "no break tackle, +-fumble" and "break lots of tackles, +fumble, the incentives may be better.

 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by Deathblade


Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out. There needs to be a downside to it, so there is risk/reward.


I'd think the near inability to break tackles when moved all out to cover up would be a pretty strong incentive for any build that invests in bruiser or slippery.

EDIT: And if you slowed down a little bit near impact, it would create an incentive for speed/elusive builds as well.
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 16:14:16
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
I'd think the near inability to break tackles when moved all out to cover up would be a pretty strong incentive for any build that invests in bruiser or slippery.


But then elusives could completely ignore carrying all together, and just put their slider to never fumble and lose nothing at all.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Gyuri1

I'd think the near inability to break tackles when moved all out to cover up would be a pretty strong incentive for any build that invests in bruiser or slippery.


But then elusives could completely ignore carrying all together, and just put their slider to never fumble and lose nothing at all.


That's kinda what I was thinking. It would need to slow you down to go for the cover up route. I don't think a speed boost for +break would be good, though. That's reward enough in itself.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gyuri1

Originally posted by Deathblade


Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?


That's a good idea. Although I like the idea of a cover up <----------------------------------> break tackle slider as well.


What if there was a tactic or something the player's AI that would make it move more and more towards cover up for each fumble you had? Perhaps cover up would slow you down a little when defenders are near, as well, since you'd be bracing for impact and not running all out.


That makes sense. And the degree to which they slow down could be affected by carrying, strength, and perhaps vision?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.