User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Yes, we are aware the I slam play is frequntly cheesy and many teams are running it over and over. No, we are not updating things in-season.
Page:
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Skanker irl

I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.


owners only, though?


Owners only would be great, in my opinion. I'm sure owners have the general sentiment about how their team feels on this and if not they could get it with a simple thread in each team's private forum.
 
Link
 
Bort, not only do you need to implement "Play Recognition" where adequately-vision-equipped players respond to repetitive use of a single play, but you must add PLAYER RECOGNITION. Right now, offenses receive ZERO penalties for trotting out certain builds on running plays and then swapping them out for other build-types on passing plays. Were an offense to attempt that in REAL football, it wouldn't take two offensive series to know in advance what type of play was being run simply by peeking at who had entered the offensive huddle.
 
JHight
offline
Link
 
Bort, quick question regarding Defensive Play Creator:

Say it doesn't work out well because of defensive alignments causing instant sacks or whatever, do you have the fixes set up RIGHT NOW so that you can just simply take away the ability to move players around?

I bring this up because of I am curious if you are being pro-active against exploits or simply responsive in programming.
 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Rodion

Bort, is there a way for the game to enforce gentlemen's agreements over not using this broken play for this season's playoffs?

Say, both teams declare publicly they are not using it against each other (or they decide a number of max uses for the game) and then an Admin actually force a forfeit if they break the agreement (or cross the set limit)?


LOL, sounds like a support headache. It's possible, in theory.


The way I see it, many teams are facing a real Prisoner's Dilemma (game theory). I can really think of many owners that would like to play fair but get forced to use the exploit just to prevent a loss in case the other team chooses to exploit too (and that team is possibly another team that wants to play fair and will exploit as a prevention). If we allow these gentlemen's agreement Admin enforcement, we can "save" the playoffs by creating a way for the games to go unexploited. And if a certain team declines the agreement, then the other can exploit the slam without remorse of playing dirty.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Skanker irl


I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.


owners only, though?


Seens like a horrible road to go down. Then they are going to expect a poll for every change you think of. Just do what you think is right.


I think the poll would be about whether you disagree with mid-season changes or not, not about the actual change.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Skanker irl


I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.


owners only, though?


Owners only would be great, in my opinion. I'm sure owners have the general sentiment about how their team feels on this and if not they could get it with a simple thread in each team's private forum.


+1
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by by Bort

What's considered a "good" running game? Lots of people are used to 5, 6, 7 YPC being average on here, which is WAY too high - auto first down every 2 plays. Most runs against a good D should go for 2-5, not 4-7. Big runs in the NFL come from missed tackles or blown defensive play calls. If the box is stacked, we shouldn't be forcing teams to get 4 YPC just because it's a number to shoot for - that should shut down the run and make for some wide open receivers. The goal should be to force the defense to play more honest, through variety of plays and the passing game working well.




Last line... If you want defenses to be honest, the playbook needs a lot more options (which I read you are doing, yes). The I and especially Strong I passing plays while there are a FEW good ones, are just really hard to use EVEN WHEN THE DEFENSE IS CHEATING RUN.

Similarly, the shotgun and to less of an extent singleback heavily favor the pass.




Call me an uncreative coordinator, but as much as I scout, read defenses, etc., I usually come to the conclusion.. run out of I, strong I, pass out of shotgun, singleback, even when the defense is already thinking the same thing!


Hopefully the improvements to pitches and screens help fix this on their own, though, as I basically just delete those from my playbook without a second thought
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 18:15:57
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Skanker irl

I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.


owners only, though?


I'd probably go with owners only.

Most people who are coordinating own a team by now, so everyone who really has a concern with mid season changes (those who call the shots for their teams) would get a vote.

I can see some random people who aren't very involved with the game thinking "well yea, of course you should update the sim as soon as possible!" without thinking of the tactic and equipment consequences these changes have.

Also, by going owners only, you eliminate people from voting with all of their alternate accounts as well.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Bort, not only do you need to implement "Play Recognition" where adequately-vision-equipped players respond to repetitive use of a single play, but you must add PLAYER RECOGNITION. Right now, offenses receive ZERO penalties for trotting out certain builds on running plays and then swapping them out for other build-types on passing plays. Were an offense to attempt that in REAL football, it wouldn't take two offensive series to know in advance what type of play was being run simply by peeking at who had entered the offensive huddle.


I agree there should be some way to call D plays based on certain players being in the game. I don't know how the interface would work exactly, though.
 
Little Dragon
offline
Link
 
my thought is moral should play more of a major role I know if I hit Tom Brady or any QB a lot of times and we have all seen it their passing becomes erratic and they get happy feet. the same with RB he gets smacked enough he doesnt really have his heart set on running the ball so their should be a some kind of decline in performance it a player is constantly sitting on his backside or constantly being harassed.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Skanker irl



I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.


owners only, though?


Seens like a horrible road to go down. Then they are going to expect a poll for every change you think of. Just do what you think is right.


I think the poll would be about whether you disagree with mid-season changes or not, not about the actual change.



That is what this one is about. It will become expected for everything.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Cerneo
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Skanker irl
I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.

owners only, though?

Everyone imo.

I can set one up right now, if you gimme a minute.


i thought there was near consensus that there shouldn't be any major changes to the sim after mid-season.

what i think is up for grabs is whether there should be a mechanism in place for owners to vote on whether they want an exception.

so i would suggest a poll on that, instead.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Skanker irl


I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.


owners only, though?


Seens like a horrible road to go down. Then they are going to expect a poll for every change you think of. Just do what you think is right.


It is just a simple poll to help Bort know what his customer base is feeling.

Bort can use his own judgment on what to make/not to make polls about.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Skanker irl


I think it would be a good idea to poll GLB in order to see what everyone thinks about mid-season changes.


owners only, though?


Seens like a horrible road to go down. Then they are going to expect a poll for every change you think of. Just do what you think is right.


I generally agree with this point. In this case, though, Bort is saying the only reason he doesn't make midseason changes is b/c it's not what the public wants. Figuring out whether he's right about what the public wants isn't ridiculous.

That being said, I think if there is a poll it should clarify whether we're talking about any sort of mid-season change, or changes to address something that may have completely broken the sim (like in the I Slam case). I'd hate to see something as vague and problematic as the realism poll again.
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 18:17:02
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Bort, not only do you need to implement "Play Recognition" where adequately-vision-equipped players respond to repetitive use of a single play, but you must add PLAYER RECOGNITION. Right now, offenses receive ZERO penalties for trotting out certain builds on running plays and then swapping them out for other build-types on passing plays. Were an offense to attempt that in REAL football, it wouldn't take two offensive series to know in advance what type of play was being run simply by peeking at who had entered the offensive huddle.


Good post, but seems really complicated to code
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.