User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why "nerfs" and "berfs" are a bad idea (this is long, if you have ADD don't read it)
Page:
 
Stray Doug
offline
Link
 
Great post. Anyone whining about the "wall of text" is fail.

Intelligent discussion can't always be boiled down to bullet points (which OP has done anyway) without losing importnat nuance and adequate examples. This is a fundamental issue in the game, if you can't even spend 3 minutes reading the post, then why do you think anyone would care about your response?
Last edited Mar 7, 2009 17:10:36
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
This is a great post. I think you have posted, what many people have thought about (incl. me...). And it is not just the passing game, but it goes for all of GLB.
 
hnice
offline
Link
 
Last edited Mar 7, 2009 20:41:53
 
hnice
offline
Link
 
great post NO NERFING lets not forget that GLB is a business. if the majority of people who pay for your services want something they are going to get it
Last edited Mar 7, 2009 20:42:03
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Stray Doug
Great post. Anyone whining about the "wall of text" is fail.

Intelligent discussion can't always be boiled down to bullet points (which OP has done anyway) without losing importnat nuance and adequate examples. This is a fundamental issue in the game, if you can't even spend 3 minutes reading the post, then why do you think anyone would care about your response?


Agreed. I'm not sure if this is possible, but a mod should eliminate all the posts in this thread that aren't contributing to the discussion. That's part of the reason suggestions aren't getting implemented. This forum is a giant clusterfuck of good suggestions and bad ones...and in the end maybe 10% of the epic-deserving threads are moved to the epic suggestions forum (and lots of those just sit in there).
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
This is easily one of the best posts GLB has seen. Glad to see it stickied.

Now if we could only get team revenue and equipment costs and test server information readily available 90% of GLBs problems will be addressed and this game can be enjoyable again.
 
Torg
offline
Link
 
great post and i agree almost totally..the only think i think that should be added is a bit more use for other stats for all players...pure str running back should not be the answer. He needs to have vision, carrying, confidence, agility, speed all mean something to force a more balanced build which would in turn give the defense a much better chance to takle him. The rest is spot on..the qbs seem to always be throwing short..almost never does a guy catch a ball on the run and get some yac unless its a fade once in a while..even those the wr very often has to stop and come back to catch the dot.
 
Falseelk
offline
Link
 
Excellent post,noticed it in my game today that the receiver comes open and it takes the QB way too long to throw the ball.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Falseelk
Excellent post,noticed it in my game today that the receiver comes open and it takes the QB way too long to throw the ball.


It's not just that.

Even if he does throw the ball on time, he throws the ball to where the WR is, instead of where he's going to be, causing the pass to almost always be deflected.
 
kingofgod
offline
Link
 
To op:

About changing in the game. I would be happy if the game was left the way it is right now. I think this season has been great so far. All we need are dot colors

I believe the passing game is fine right now. People just dont have enough strength on their Qbs, so now that DBs can react their poor arm strength is making them not as effective.

imo
Last edited Mar 7, 2009 23:19:51
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stray Doug
Great post. Anyone whining about the "wall of text" is fail.

Intelligent discussion can't always be boiled down to bullet points (which OP has done anyway) without losing importnat nuance and adequate examples. This is a fundamental issue in the game, if you can't even spend 3 minutes reading the post, then why do you think anyone would care about your response?


I agree wholeheartedly with the OP and with the gentleman above. Nerfs and buffs reward behavior that should be looked down upon, basically whining and crying. If your dot is not performing up to what you'd like it to, study up on some of the successful builds at your position and remake them rather than asking Bort for yet another nerf. The nerfs end up causing a whole new series of problems anyway, better for everyone in the long term to just work out build issues and keep everything normal. There are occasionally small tweaks that can be made when something is totally out of wack sim-wise but for the most part buffing and nerfing just to appease the masses (or the subset that cries the loudest) is counter productive to the long term health of the game imo.

 
Link
 
Great post.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
extremely well put
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

bort

this is coming from what you said

try increasing the "mistakes" in pass d. that's worrisome, man.


It was just an idea for discussion. I have lots of them. Doesn't mean they all get implemented or used.


The problem is that historically, nerfing has been the main MO of how things get "fixed," when, in reality, that isn't a fix at all. I could see where very early (Alpha, ssn 1 and maybe even ssn 2) that needed to be done at times. However, since then, taking that route hasn't been a fix. Sure, it's easier that fixing the Sim. In this case, that'd amount to actually making QBs lead their WRs on a somewhat consistent basis (even just 60-70% of the time would be great), instead of the WR having to stop and wait for the pass, double back for it or just stop on their route all together such an alarmingly high %, as they do now.

You can't nerf players over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over (for accuracy, I'd keep going on, but you get the point) and then make comments like this:

Originally posted by Bort

"LOL I love how my comment of "Hey Koncorde let's test out some ideas" turns into "OMG YOU HAVE BROKEN EVERYTHING BY TYPING A SENTENCE."

I have an idea. Just chill out for a sec and let us...I don't know...try some ideas on the test server and see how they work. You can even follow along with the test game log! Talking about testing ideas =/= "my player is auto-nerfed today and destroyed."


Well, you can make that comment, but nearly anyone that has been involved with GLB's "history" is going to realize that the the smart money will be on nerfing. Hell, after your comment, Vegas would most likely put the odds somewhere around a 1000 to 1. Acting surprised or that ppl are being dumb for then believing the odds are good that you'll nerf CBs is a bit unfair, wouldn't you say?



continued from http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2234990&page=5 (don't see quoting this thread as an issue, since it wasn't locked for any rule breakage)

Last edited Mar 8, 2009 07:31:13
 
Snipeshow
offline
Link
 
+1 on the o-line thing.

The vision check made my OT double the DT, and let the DE go free. Why is the LOT doubling on a fucking DT?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.