User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > nfratami says: Endorsements - There Needs to Be More Than 1 Given Per Position
Page:
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by groveboy101
Drago, what is your whole problem with more than one person getting an endorsement deal?


I don't have any problems with more than one person getting an endorsement deal. One per position is fine... I'd even be ok with one for RG's, one for LG's and the like...

I just don't want to see the game dilluted to a level where every team you're playing against is getting an endorsement deal - even on a sliding scale. When we get to that, which is essentially what NappyF here is suggesting, what's the f'ing point?

Why not just create a new item we all can wear if that is the road we're going down.

As it stands, there are things which are far worse with the game than needing "multiple endorsement deals per position" - go check out the CPL forums for one.

Those are my basic two points... NappyF and I are obviously on opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to what we suggest. I just took offense to his first reply to me where he said, "You don't understand (how the distribution of the pieces will work)." When the truth to the matter is that neither of us understands how it will work. We both probably have ideas, and some are likely better than others... but to lay the framework for your suggestion on a fallacy, and then when opposition to your suggestion becomes evident, suggesting that your framework is perfect - yea, that don't fly in the house of Drago.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago

I don't have any problems with more than one person getting an endorsement deal. One per position is fine... I'd even be ok with one for RG's, one for LG's and the like...


Then our opinion isn't really that much different.

Originally posted by nfratami

You could have the lottery take the top 5 selected for each position and make items 1-5 deteriorate in quality from 1 to 5. I'm sure you guys could have some other ideas.


I said that initially, but was open to good suggestions on what would work best. I just think when you look at the fact that there can 160ish LBs in a league that giving out 1 award is goofy.
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Hopefully Bort has had a chance to read this plan!
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 77racing
Hopefully Bort has had a chance to read this plan!


prob not, there hasnt even been a mention of endorsements this offseason has there?
 
Montclaire
offline
Link
 
Per league, I'd implement something like:

~3-5 National endos, regardless of position: i.e. Tomlinson/Manning for Nike/Sony
1 per position, national like above, but less impactful.
X per position, but 'regional'

Then just keep tiering it down until you get the guys that have to be identified in local car dealership commercials for you to recognize them.

There are ~640+ players in each league. Even if 200+ get awarded, that would be less than 1/3. Enough to have a cache, but still be accessible/possible for a lot of people to get any enjoyment from it.

The bonuses could range from +SA/+attribute, to one or the other, or +bonus% to individual training options. Peyton Manning gets +3 to any SA and attribute of HIS choice. Lesser nationals get pre-chosen bonuses, maybe +2 to each and pre-determined. All the way down through +1 to SA OR attribute, again either of agent's choice and then pre-determined. Back-up LBs hawking for the local car dealership get a 10% each time they train attribute X. The cash bonus get tiered the same.
Last edited Feb 17, 2009 23:41:59
 
NiteRider
offline
Link
 
Absolutely love this idea. +1000
 
riptide1977
offline
Link
 
why not just state that players who earn awards are only eligible for endorsements and do the lottery that way. 3 endorsements are handed out to the top 3 players at each position in that league. The trophy place determines the number you would multiply the fame by such that:

1st place = multiplier of 3
2nd place = multiplier of 2
3rd place = multiplier of 1

For example, lets say you have a QB and his fame is 900, he took 1st in passing yards and 2nd in TD's thrown. the equation would be:

(900 fame)*[(3)+(2)] = 4500 votes....The (3) is for 1st place and the (2) is for second place.

Now lets say there is another QB with a fame of 850 took 3rd in passing, 3rd in TD's, this is how that would look:

(850 fame)*[(1)+(1)] = 1700 votes....The (1) is for 3rd place and the (1) is for 3rd place.

This gives a larger separation between the two QB's and what would, in real life, be the better QB. Why multiply them then divide, because if you divide it gives a bigger advantage to players who only get 1 trophy. Multiplying them weeds through those circumstances. The QB rating takes this into account which is a factor in the fame category. The same would apply for all other positions.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
If Brady Quinn can horn in on Peyton Manning's commercial monopoly, well...you get the idea. One per position per league. Not so great. The sliding scale idea sounds rational and doable. I'm all for it.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Bump.
 
daniel09hilde
offline
Link
 
isn't it fame earned in that season not fame overall
 
riptide1977
offline
Link
 
I think it is fame overall. We had a team get relegated and their QB had a fame of 700 after game 1 and his team lost by 70 points. That's why they have the suggested levels, which make no sense either.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by riptide1977
why not just state that players who earn awards are only eligible for endorsements and do the lottery that way. 3 endorsements are handed out to the top 3 players at each position in that league. The trophy place determines the number you would multiply the fame by such that:

1st place = multiplier of 3
2nd place = multiplier of 2
3rd place = multiplier of 1

For example, lets say you have a QB and his fame is 900, he took 1st in passing yards and 2nd in TD's thrown. the equation would be:

(900 fame)*[(3)+(2)] = 4500 votes....The (3) is for 1st place and the (2) is for second place.

Now lets say there is another QB with a fame of 850 took 3rd in passing, 3rd in TD's, this is how that would look:

(850 fame)*[(1)+(1)] = 1700 votes....The (1) is for 3rd place and the (1) is for 3rd place.

This gives a larger separation between the two QB's and what would, in real life, be the better QB. Why multiply them then divide, because if you divide it gives a bigger advantage to players who only get 1 trophy. Multiplying them weeds through those circumstances. The QB rating takes this into account which is a factor in the fame category. The same would apply for all other positions.



The problem with this is that winning the big game is rarely the best comparison of players.....it is the best comparision of complete teams. Would anyone in their right mind think that Willie Parker is somehow better than Tomlinson or Westbrooke? Dude, has two SB rings where the other two have zero, but I sure don't see FWP doing any national ads of any kind, do you? For that matter, is Roethlishomo better than Warner in really any way? "The winner gets a bonus" to then in turn make him better is just plain a BAD idea on several levels......
 
fastlane269
offline
Link
 
Why not restrict the lottery to the ten most famous players per position in their league? It would simulate real life much more closely in that no third stringer on a terrible team will somehow end up with an endorsement.

Only the top crust guys get endorsements in real life and that should be reflected in GLB.
 
riptide1977
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Originally posted by riptide1977

why not just state that players who earn awards are only eligible for endorsements and do the lottery that way. 3 endorsements are handed out to the top 3 players at each position in that league. The trophy place determines the number you would multiply the fame by such that:

1st place = multiplier of 3
2nd place = multiplier of 2
3rd place = multiplier of 1

For example, lets say you have a QB and his fame is 900, he took 1st in passing yards and 2nd in TD's thrown. the equation would be:

(900 fame)*[(3)+(2)] = 4500 votes....The (3) is for 1st place and the (2) is for second place.

Now lets say there is another QB with a fame of 850 took 3rd in passing, 3rd in TD's, this is how that would look:

(850 fame)*[(1)+(1)] = 1700 votes....The (1) is for 3rd place and the (1) is for 3rd place.

This gives a larger separation between the two QB's and what would, in real life, be the better QB. Why multiply them then divide, because if you divide it gives a bigger advantage to players who only get 1 trophy. Multiplying them weeds through those circumstances. The QB rating takes this into account which is a factor in the fame category. The same would apply for all other positions.



The problem with this is that winning the big game is rarely the best comparison of players.....it is the best comparision of complete teams. Would anyone in their right mind think that Willie Parker is somehow better than Tomlinson or Westbrooke? Dude, has two SB rings where the other two have zero, but I sure don't see FWP doing any national ads of any kind, do you? For that matter, is Roethlishomo better than Warner in really any way? "The winner gets a bonus" to then in turn make him better is just plain a BAD idea on several levels......


Good Points, but you really have no idea if Willie Parker was offered a deal or not. How many times has an athlete turned down an endorsement deal to be on the cover of a video game because they believe it is cursed. Eli Manning has endorsements but there are a half dozen better QB's in the league than him. He has the endorsement because of the hype and because of who his family is. Hell, McNabb's mom has more air time with Campbell soup adds than McNabb himself. In GLB you can't base it on talent because that eliminates all stats and only focuses on build. In which case what is the point of fame?

As for the trophies, I was referring more to the individual trophies, not the team trophies. You can have players take 1st in categories and never go beyond the first round. Championships are certainly the wrong way to go about it, but a player who leads the league in yards thrown and TD's certainly should have a much better shot at getting an endorsement. I would be really pissed if i found out that the worse QB in my league got an endorsement because the CPU selected one of his 105 fame votes.
 
Link
 
prepare to be disappointed... many crappy players will be getting endorsements this season if the way it is "selected" is not changed...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.