IMO, I think you guys are lumping Strength + Tackling together when they should really be set apart. Lets use an anology - say Bort's Power Back somewhat resembles Brandon Jacobs.
Tackling = your tackling technique - how adept you are at actually making a tackle.
Strength = the Strength of your actual tackle.
Think of most CB's, they have pretty decent tackling but low strength. Thus, when they go to tackle Jacobs, they wrap him up but he can still plow forward / fall forward for a few extra yards, because they don't have the strength to stop him in his tracks. However, on the flip side, if you have a guy with ridiculous strength running full speed at Jacobs, he may have the strength to take him down but not the art and will miss his tackle.
Therefore, I propose that Defenders should require a decent balance of both if they want to consistently stop backs in their tacks. With the way this game is structured and the realistic peak of your skills, it's unrealistic to force defenders to get 80+ Strength and Tackling to make a consistent tackle. However, I do believe that defenders who have 80 + tackling and very low strength should be able to make tackles consistently because, in reality, they would be the types of players to "Wrap-up" the legs - sure the Back would plow/fall forward for 3 or 4 extra yards but the tackle would still be made. Strength should determine the "Force" of the tackle, not the effectiveness of the tackle itself. If a back with 60 Str and 60 Speed goes up against a defender with 60 Str and 60 Speed and the tackle is successful, the RB shouldn't be able to fall forward for a few extra yards, but would rather be stopped dead in his tracks. That, in essense, is what Power Backs do - always fall forward.
That being said, Bort, I think what you should do is make 2 checks when a Defender attempts a tackle - a Tackling check (to see if the tackle will be successful) and then some sort of "Force" check (combining strength + speed) to determine whether the back is able to fall forward or trudge for an extra yard or so.
Before you all yell at me and flame me, think of this idea realisticly in the game. How many defenders actually have 80 + tackling? Most people soft-cap it and leave it at that. With 48 tackling, a Defender going up against Bort's RB should only have, say, 50% chance of making the tackle if he is first contact, with the 2nd having a higher chance due to some sort of "dimishing returns" factor. That way Power Backs are still able to break the first tackle 50% of the time, but won't be able to consistently break 3-4 tackles every down.
I know this post is long, even for me, and I find what happens is that you're inital thought gets warped a bit during the explanation... lol.