User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > Instead of supressing the problem, work together for a solution
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Commander
some of these rules are insane. "don't insult staff"?? are you fucking kidding me? if the staff blows, then I should be able to talk about it.


It's like being told not to insult Hitler's 2nd or 3rd in command
Last edited Dec 16, 2008 19:30:56
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Commander
some of these rules are insane. "don't insult staff"?? are you fucking kidding me? if the staff blows, then I should be able to talk about it.


I insult President Bush all the time and I don't get arrested and tried for treason.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Warren Buffett
Originally posted by GIEFF

Then maybe you should only suspend people when their actions result in a net degradation in the site experience for all users?


But GIEFF! That makes too much sense!


 
฿ones
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by jrry32

Oh no you didn't Asheme!

Just being honest. I didn't support Voltron or Bones when their names came up (multiple times) for modhood.

As I said then, it was nothing personal (and I liked both of them as posters), but I didn't think, of all the possible candidates, that they would handle the responsibilities of being a moderator better than others could. And I had my reasons. And most of them proved themselves to be true.

But nobody listens to me.

I'm sorry I disappoint you Ashmeme
Please PM me ways I can improve my performance.
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warren Buffett
Originally posted by Commander

some of these rules are insane. "don't insult staff"?? are you fucking kidding me? if the staff blows, then I should be able to talk about it.


It's like being told not to insult Hitler's 2nd or 3rd in command


There's a difference between criticizing their actions and just down right insulting them and attacking them. Insulting and attacking mods/other people doesn't help fix a thing.
 
Link
 
hooty hoo
Last edited Dec 16, 2008 19:40:06
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
Originally posted by Warren Buffett

Originally posted by Commander


some of these rules are insane. "don't insult staff"?? are you fucking kidding me? if the staff blows, then I should be able to talk about it.


It's like being told not to insult Hitler's 2nd or 3rd in command


There's a difference between criticizing their actions and just down right insulting them and attacking them. Insulting and attacking mods/other people doesn't help fix a thing.


Question is, does it HURT a thing?
 
Link
 
I have a suggestion. Remove the mod tag from ever mod that has it bc they aren't anything special.

The money that is being paid to buy flex points with that Bort Recieves could be used to hire a small staff of 5-8 people(and no I'm not saying hire the mods as staff members) I'm saying hire 5-8 outside people and give them Admin status and do away with the hole mod tag.

This would give everyone a fresh start as we would know NOTHING about the new Admins and they would know nothing about us posters and things that have happend in the past.

Everyone should get 1 warning and then if you go over the line after the warning it should be a perma ban and no questions asked as everyone would know what is expected of them.
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
Conclusion: Mods need thick skin. If you are soft do not bother being a mod.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ฿ones
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by jrry32


Oh no you didn't Asheme!

Just being honest. I didn't support Voltron or Bones when their names came up (multiple times) for modhood.

As I said then, it was nothing personal (and I liked both of them as posters), but I didn't think, of all the possible candidates, that they would handle the responsibilities of being a moderator better than others could. And I had my reasons. And most of them proved themselves to be true.

But nobody listens to me.

I'm sorry I disappoint you Ashmeme
Please PM me ways I can improve my performance.


How about not trying to be something you aren't? Just be yourself and be mature and if you can't be mature...then don't try to be...step down because if you can't be mature then you can't be a mod.

 
wesmiley
offline
Link
 
SERENITY FOR PRESIDENT TBH IMO!
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Voltron
If I suspended everyone everytime they broke the rule about harassing other people and attacked me I'd just end up with 39472394327 threads screaming abuse and too many hate PMs.


And shouldn't you take a note on this? The more rules you add, the more work you have to do. While this isn't, by defition, a bad thing for the site it turns out that it is. It ruins the user experience with all the petty rules and random inforcement. You ban people for saying "ALINJ" but let that idiot run around posting "ancient" again and again. Does that seem right?
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by GIEFF

Then maybe you should only suspend people when their actions result in a net degradation in the site experience for all users?


How do you judge that? That is giving even more judgement to the mods. Me disagreeing with you could be considered a net degradation in the site for all users by a mod that dislikes me.



How is you disagreeing with me a negative? I'm talking about things like spam in content-based forums, posting racism or pornography, or out-of-line personal attacks where the recipient actually wants it to stop.

Things that are obviously causing people to be less likely to continue to play the game. Incidentally, over-moderation is another of those things that can make people less likely to continue to play the game, which is really stupid, considering the whole point of it is to do the exact opposite.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
I have a suggestion. Remove the mod tag from ever mod that has it bc they aren't anything special.

The money that is being paid to buy flex points with that Bort Recieves could be used to hire a small staff of 5-8 people(and no I'm not saying hire the mods as staff members) I'm saying hire 5-8 outside people and give them Admin status and do away with the hole mod tag.

This would give everyone a fresh start as we would know NOTHING about the new Admins and they would know nothing about us posters and things that have happend in the past.

Everyone should get 1 warning and then if you go over the line after the warning it should be a perma ban and no questions asked as everyone would know what is expected of them.


You actually think Bort will spend his money on the game and hire more staff? He's needed an extra programmer for seasons now...has that happened?
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar
Originally posted by Voltron

Originally posted by Warren Buffett


Originally posted by Commander



some of these rules are insane. "don't insult staff"?? are you fucking kidding me? if the staff blows, then I should be able to talk about it.


It's like being told not to insult Hitler's 2nd or 3rd in command


There's a difference between criticizing their actions and just down right insulting them and attacking them. Insulting and attacking mods/other people doesn't help fix a thing.


Question is, does it HURT a thing?


Yes, it's disrespecting the site and the people who are trying to help make it better. It may not hurt anything but it's very very very far from helpful.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.