User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > UGLY GAME 4s - We think something is wrong with the passing in the sims
Page:
 
Sanderval
offline
Link
 
Ranting about QB performance aside.. i'd really like to know is this going to stay, or is it going to change, because like a lot of other people, i have a game plan i have to worry about. And since this last change was made with no notice, if i want to make an informed decision about my game plan, I'd like to know if it's going to stay or if its not or if it will be reviewed & changed later or what.. no one has said anything either way yet. I could have missed it.. if so i'd be grateful if someone could repost it or point me to it.
 
TDCumm16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Boble

a LVL 2 QB against a LVL 2 defense should get about the same numbers than a LVL 12 guy goin against a LVL 12 defense.


nah...thats like saying 2 even peewee teams should have the same comp percent as two evenly matched college football teams.

Thats just not the way GLB works.



I am going to have to disagree with this because every player started as a rookie last season...

Imagine if the NFL eliminated all veterans next season and every professional team was forced to fill their rosters with rookies. The best 1500 NCAA players would be drafted and paid to play. What kind of stats could we expect in season 1 and 2 when these players were now the lowest level of the NFL? Well, since every player came in as a rookie I would expect the season 1 and 2 stats to be pretty comparable to the stats they put up as NCAA players. The best NCAA QBs throw in the high 60's and low 70's so I think the "pre-changed" simulation wasn't that far off (if off at all).

Sounds like a few well intended changes had a larger than anticipated negative impact. I understand it can be difficult to admit a mistake, but I think this is a time to acknowledge the issue and rectify the problems in the games that were simmed.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Curufin
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach

You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.


Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.


Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 

KEY WORDS
Thats just not the way GLB works.

This isn't the NFL.




Last edited May 2, 2008 17:13:20
 
Will2k
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach
Originally posted by Curufin

Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach


You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.


Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.


Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.


It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.
 
fightfreak
offline
Link
 
LOL, yeah, when his qb gets f'ed over in the next game with a 13% completion rate we can tell him that...
Last edited May 2, 2008 17:15:04
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach

Originally posted by Curufin


Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach



You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.


Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.


Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.


It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.



That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it.
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rossmc
Originally posted by Donner

Yeah, passing must be borked:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=12335

If you are too lazy to click the link, here's the line:

Brendo Salisbury:

Plays: 102
Completions: 40
Attempts: 65
Yds: 435
Percentage: 61.5
Y/A 6.7
Hurry: 3
Sack: 0
Sack Yds: 0
Int: 1
TD: 5





Wow, one QB compared with 200. Must be nothing wrong


Cool. I must be wrong. Now post all 200 QBs stats for game 4, their attributes and the team's advanced energy settings. Not that I don't believe you.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Will2k
Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach

Originally posted by Curufin


Originally posted by NewEnglandCoach



You guys are overreacting.. it's not even that big of a deal, seriously.


Have you looked at some of the replays? The passes aren't anywhere within a 10 yard radius of a WR.


Okay, yet my QB is a higher level, and had a decent pass pct. Even though it was 51.2, he went 7/13, I'm still going to call that successful.


It's ok guys. Because his player did well, means nothing else is wrong.


Yeah, and more to the point - his high level qb threw all of 13 passes. My guy's first 13 passes were high percentage too. I wish the few people who's QBs had decent games would admit that it's possible that whatever the perfect storm of changes that screwed up the vast majority of QBs in the league obviously will not affect a few lucky qbs who happened to have certain builds or play in certain circumstances.

 
Sanderval
offline
Link
 
If you could compile stats you could also compare the avg qb % across diff leagues for weeks 1-4. %'s should improve as players progress, rosters fill, tactics are improvised etc. Not always of course, but generally speaking. At the very least they should remain close. But if there is a significant drop off in this week not indicative of a pattern, in different leagues, at the same time, that would indicate a problem. No non tedious way for us to easily accumulate that data tho..
 
Link
 
Let me Restate this:
That's not what I said. I'm supporting Bort's claim that higher level QBs are prone to do better. Meyton Panning had a REALLY good game, leading his team to a 112-0 victory in the same league. He's also the same level as mine. There's more evidence supporting the claim. I can deal with the realism, I'm not tripping about it. Meyton Panning's QB THREW 46 Times, and still had 63. That's more supporting evidence that Bort's claim could be correct.

Edit: I think this will make games more realistic? 112-0? Give me a break, yeah right.
Last edited May 2, 2008 17:22:04
 
E-A-G-L-E-S
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17

KEY WORDS
Thats just not the way GLB works.

This isn't the NFL.






Doesn't matter what kind of football you play, right now, LB, RB, and the linemen are the only important positions on the field. Defensive Secondary...Wideouts...TEs...QBs...None of it matters if you change the passing game.
 
JRock7485
offline
Link
 
Donner, your a retard. If EVERYONE is complaining, just because 2-3 QB's had an good game doesnt mean everything is fine. Im actually not sure why you even posted, when you are just showing that you have no idea whats going. Now, go check the qb raiting from last game of every single qb out there, and you tell for yourself if something is wrong or not.
 
Rossmc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner
Originally posted by Rossmc

Originally posted by Donner


Yeah, passing must be borked:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=12335

If you are too lazy to click the link, here's the line:

Brendo Salisbury:

Plays: 102
Completions: 40
Attempts: 65
Yds: 435
Percentage: 61.5
Y/A 6.7
Hurry: 3
Sack: 0
Sack Yds: 0
Int: 1
TD: 5





Wow, one QB compared with 200. Must be nothing wrong


Cool. I must be wrong. Now post all 200 QBs stats for game 4, their attributes and the team's advanced energy settings. Not that I don't believe you.



If you really don't think the change is significant, please look at my QB's first 3 games of the season and then his fourth.

 
Link
 
Upping the passing will result in continuous 112-0 blowouts that are a bore to see. 112-0? Please, give me a break.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.