User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
RascalRaidex
offline
Link
 
I think people are under the impression that this will make a HUGE difference in the character builds...

If the current attainable level is 65, thats only 195 more skill points total. With the soft caps, those get eaten up pretty dang quickly.To get one primary skill to 90... it takes like... 250 SP..

Okay.. with the 195 extra SP you might be able to get a single skill to 100, or get like... 2 skills to like... 85.. in your career... and then you decline... come on, a level 42, 6 year veteran safety with just above average speed, slightly above average agility and vision, slightly below average stamina, strength, tackling, and jumping, with barely any confidence who cant catch or hold on to the ball worth a damn just isn't right.... within his career he may learn to catch and hold on to the ball,kinda... or.. maybe he will get pretty dang good at tackling finally and put on a tiny bit of muscle.. all the "Superstar" player would do would be to allow you to maybe learn to catch and carry AND be able to tackle....It will allow you to get good at the skills that a safety should already be good at.

And as long as the FP cost increase was just initial, and not carried over to boosting costs (Superstar Creation cost x3, Boost cost x1) and there was a limit to how many per agent/team then it would be open to everyone... not just who has the most money or is willing to pay or whatever...

 
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by R.Williams34

Originally posted by quantofsol2008


People who are good at builds already have stars. People who are good at building and good at promoting their players already have superstars.

How many David Amazing's are there in GLB?


then good for them. this is a new way to make a new type of superstar


So this basically rewards people who are willing to spend the money because they want to get more SPs since their normal builds aren't as good as other people's normal builds.



Exactly - this is a shortcut for people who aren't as good at the game but are willing to pay the extra money. It basically says, "If you stink at building good players, just pay a bit extra and your player will have an advantage over the other players at his position."

Isn't the point of a game that the best player wins? In this case, should the agents who are good at the game and already have their superstars be caught by the agents who are good at shelling out cash? This is just a lame shortcut IMO.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by quantofsol2008
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by R.Williams34


Originally posted by quantofsol2008



People who are good at builds already have stars. People who are good at building and good at promoting their players already have superstars.

How many David Amazing's are there in GLB?


then good for them. this is a new way to make a new type of superstar


So this basically rewards people who are willing to spend the money because they want to get more SPs since their normal builds aren't as good as other people's normal builds.



Exactly - this is a shortcut for people who aren't as good at the game but are willing to pay the extra money. It basically says, "If you stink at building good players, just pay a bit extra and your player will have an advantage over the other players at his position."

Isn't the point of a game that the best player wins? In this case, should the agents who are good at the game and already have their superstars be caught by the agents who are good at shelling out cash? This is just a lame shortcut IMO.


well if you dont have the money, and/or cant afford it, that sucks. this is another way for bort to make money, to expand the game a bit further.

now what your saying is this is only for the shitty people who have money? hmmmm well here is a thought, idk where i came up with it or how i figured it out, but couldnt some one who has money also be good at building a player? holy shit i must be wrong i forgot every who sucks at GLB must have money to spend. its not just for rich punks no its for every one. if this gets made you have just as much of a chance to make a superstar and dominate the leagues as the next guy. average joe and billy bob both have the same shot to compete. if you dont have money to creat a super, o well.
 
Link
 
Regardless of whether you're good or bad at building, why should paying extra money give your builds a natural advantage over others'? The whole idea of the OP was to create "superstars", but "superstars" already exist.

I'm sure there will be good agents who are willing to spend, but should those who aren't be penalized? Good builders who aren't willing to spend the extra cash shouldn't be put at a disadvantage for it. In the end, I thought the point of a game was that you play to win, not pay to win.

 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RascalRaidex
I think people are under the impression that this will make a HUGE difference in the character builds...

If the current attainable level is 65, thats only 195 more skill points total. With the soft caps, those get eaten up pretty dang quickly.To get one primary skill to 90... it takes like... 250 SP..

Okay.. with the 195 extra SP you might be able to get a single skill to 100, or get like... 2 skills to like... 85.. in your career... and then you decline... come on, a level 42, 6 year veteran safety with just above average speed, slightly above average agility and vision, slightly below average stamina, strength, tackling, and jumping, with barely any confidence who cant catch or hold on to the ball worth a damn just isn't right.... within his career he may learn to catch and hold on to the ball,kinda... or.. maybe he will get pretty dang good at tackling finally and put on a tiny bit of muscle.. all the "Superstar" player would do would be to allow you to maybe learn to catch and carry AND be able to tackle....It will allow you to get good at the skills that a safety should already be good at.

And as long as the FP cost increase was just initial, and not carried over to boosting costs (Superstar Creation cost x3, Boost cost x1) and there was a limit to how many per agent/team then it would be open to everyone... not just who has the most money or is willing to pay or whatever...



First, 195 points in gigantic when you factor in that they will be able to get to soft caps faster using the bonus from every level:

Start at 20 from your rolling the attributes. 15 Free SP, need another 13 SP to push to first cap at 48. Normal player? 3 Levels. Superstar? 2 Levels.

48 to 62, you need 28 SP. Normal player? 6 Levels. Superstar? 4 Levels.

62 to 68, you need 18 SP. Normal Player? 4 Levels. Superstar? 3 Levels.

So, a Superstar will have an attribute to 68 four levels sooner than a normal player. That means they will get better per-level gains at that cap. And this is at the very least, with the 50% training bonus you will be able to raise things 1.5x faster while training meaning they won't even need as many SPs as the normal players.

Lastly, if everyone can make an unlimited number of Superstars and each team can have an unlimited number of Superstars.. everyone will be a Superstar and that means no one is a Superstar.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Just look at the builds with no training factored in (which makes it even more unbalanced).

Level 11:

Normal Player: 50 new SP, Super Player: 80 new SP.

Normal Player: Raises Speed to 68. 4 SP left over.
Super Player: Raises Speed to 68. 34 SP left over.

34 SP. That's enough to take the next attribute to the soft cap or train a special ability to maximum.



Last edited Dec 4, 2008 15:15:41
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


... why are we still arguing about this? let alone why is this an epic suggestion right now?
 
osutuba
offline
Link
 
I'm not reading through all 12 pages of this, but I thought I would offer a variant to the idea. I apologize in advance if any of this has already been mentioned

Why not make it something that is rolled for at character creation (say, on a roll of 100, 75-90=All-Pro and 91-100=Superstar)? The agent then has the option of paying extra FP = 50% of the normal cost to get the All-Star or 100% for Superstar. Agents also have the option to make a Superstar an All-Pro instead if they can't afford the additional cost.

Training options:
- All-Pro: Can spend 2 extra TP to turn basic training into Intense Training, plus get the option to get the Shopping Token. Can also spend 2 extra TP on Intense Training to have the ability to train a 3rd ability of your choice at normal bonus.
- Superstar: Same, but costs +1 TP to get the above listed benefits

Skill Points:
- All-Pros gain 1 extra SP at level. Superstars get 2 extra SP at level.

Drawbacks:
- All-Pros and Superstars are expected to perform at a high level; therefore, it requires more XP to level. All-Pros require 1250 XP to level, while Superstars require 1750 XP to level.
- Bonus Token boosts cost more, as they are often required to perform at a level that enhances the rest of the team. All-Pros require 6 BT to boost; Superstars require 8
- "The Michael Vick Effect": All-Pros and Superstars have a tendency to think they are better than everyone ... sometimes even thinking they are above the law. Every "off day", an All-Pro or Superstar has a chance to do something that effects the team's morale and chemistry. The chance is based on a calculation using their Confidence Score and a random number generated at character creation as the basis. The value calculated determines how much trouble (if any) and the consequent punishment (out for quarter(s)/half(ves)/game(s)/season). The effect on the team is calculated against the team's Chemistry score and the average Confidence of all the players on the team (except the effected All-Pro or Superstar). This means a team can be riding high and then crash and burn in the course of 2 days (hence "The Michael Vick Effect") All-Pros and Superstars gain NO XP when this effect occurs. Fan Support can also be effected by this.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Originally posted by Bort

I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


... why are we still arguing about this? let alone why is this an epic suggestion right now?


I prefer Bort's formulation, which is somewhat similar to something I'd proposed.

But I think that something along the lines of this suggestion is-- I'd hesitate to say "needed," but highly desirable.

Without it, we really won't see standout players. Those who have the best stats will be good builds with the right teammates and coordinators around them.

I prefer it to be random, as is Bort's inclination; but however it's done, we need guys who will stand out as great players.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by russdwright
I'm not reading through all 12 pages of this, but I thought I would offer a variant to the idea. I apologize in advance if any of this has already been mentioned

Why not make it something that is rolled for at character creation (say, on a roll of 100, 75-90=All-Pro and 91-100=Superstar)? The agent then has the option of paying extra FP = 50% of the normal cost to get the All-Star or 100% for Superstar. Agents also have the option to make a Superstar an All-Pro instead if they can't afford the additional cost.


In general, some good stuff-- but it can't be rolled at creation or people would just re-roll for what they want (and if you take away the re-roll, they'll go back to as it was before, retiring and remaking at creation).

Or...it could be rolled at creation but hidden until Level 20, at which time you start getting the extra points (although I'd figure it should just be rolled at Level 20).
 
RascalRaidex
offline
Link
 

"
First, 195 points in gigantic when you factor in that they will be able to get to soft caps faster using the bonus from every level:

Start at 20 from your rolling the attributes. 15 Free SP, need another 13 SP to push to first cap at 48. Normal player? 3 Levels. Superstar? 2 Levels.

48 to 62, you need 28 SP. Normal player? 6 Levels. Superstar? 4 Levels.

62 to 68, you need 18 SP. Normal Player? 4 Levels. Superstar? 3 Levels.

So, a Superstar will have an attribute to 68 four levels sooner than a normal player. That means they will get better per-level gains at that cap. And this is at the very least, with the 50% training bonus you will be able to raise things 1.5x faster while training meaning they won't even need as many SPs as the normal players.

Lastly, if everyone can make an unlimited number of Superstars and each team can have an unlimited number of Superstars.. everyone will be a Superstar and that means no one is a Superstar."



I don't like the idea of a training bonus, or having unlimited numbers of superstars, because yeah, that would make them crazy good and unbalance teams, but I really don't think its unreasonable that a player be able to be a great player, instead of just mediocre or pretty good, even.... At the end of their careers, players will be overall 65, maybe... no where near a Great player..... Some people are just gifted, like this kid...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQb-I6d-NNs&feature=related

At 12 he probably has more skills than a lvl 42 GLB running back...
Last edited Dec 7, 2008 00:27:54
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
This idea is premised upon the idea that every single player at GLB is the exact same ability, that there are no 'great players'.

I can't type 'Duh!' loud enough.
 
feedy
offline
Link
 
NOOOO Too many players per team if you want to do this. try 2, make it like 1 offensive 1 defensive for superstars. Then maybe 4 allstars per team. Think about it, how many teams out there have more than two SUPERSTARS, most real life teams only have 1, forget 5. i mean the pats have randy moss and tom brady and they went 18-1 last season. The cowboys are the only tea that come to mind with more than 2 superstars, with them being Williams, T,O, and Demarcus Ware.
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Terrible, terrible, terrible idea. This may be the worst suggestion I have ever read on this forum. It may even be worse then that one time some guy came in here and seriously wanted a "sexual orientation" option for his players.

That's how bad this idea is.
 
MBRavencane
offline
Link
 
If its so bad how come its in the Epic Suggestion thread moved by a Admin or Mod
Ree Ree.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.