User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
rhk065
offline
Link
 
maybe it should be a gradient instead of weight classes so people on the border aren't completely pissed that they built their rb to be a speed back and their barely into a higher weight class.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


It just seems like another pain in the ass thing to have to worry about rather than something that makes the user experience more fun.


So, more stuff to customize your character isn't fun?


He doesn't speak for all of us, tbh.

Or even many of us. This is a great idea. More realism and more diversity of players is a good thing.
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
So the strong get stronger based on the heavy weight bonus and the fast get faster based on the light weight bonus. I'm glad we see eye-to-eye on the whole Strength needs to be more important thing. But with this weight class stuff, I don't think I'm ever going to agree, not because I'm stubborn but because I have yet to hear a great reason as to why this will be useful. I firmly believe SP spending will cover all of our Strength/Speed problems once Strength actually has some value compared to Speed at some positions.


Yes, the strong get stronger and the fast get faster, but you also have to account for the strong getting slower and the fast getting weaker. The stronger, heavier HBs will be harder to bring down, but with their reduced speed, a lot more defenders will get the chance to try and tackle them. The lighter, faster HB's will be a lot faster, but since they aren't as strong, any time a defender touches them will be a tackle.

I know that this can be somewhat taken care of just by using SP now, but by just using the "SP can solve it" arguement, it encourages more cookie cutter builds (dumping SP into Speed/Agility in some magical ratio). Plus, the weight classes will make speed (roughly) position specific. A DT in the OMGweight class with 100 Speed will be significantly slower than a HB in the Heavyweight class with 100 Speed, who in turn will be significantly slower than a Lightweight CB with 100 Speed.

Also, just out of curiosity, what did you think of my suggestion where possible weight class options could be limited by the Strength of the player? It was just something I thought of spur-of-the-moment, but I think it might have some potential if the weight classes were introduced.
 
otto_g_2k8
offline
Link
 
Bort my man!!!! BEST IDEA EVER!
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
This is a great idea, I am all for anything that makes the game more "realistic." Would also encourage veteran players to be more active.
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Moving the target to another wall again eh?

 
jeffhuff
offline
Link
 
love the idea
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
As long as there's a mechanism in place to change your weight, I love this idea.
 
Jaegerwolf
offline
Link
 
This just makes too much sense NOT to do
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
I've been wondering when something like this would be brought up. Since when can a DT run just as fast as a speed HB or WR.

It definitely needs to be implemented.
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Excellent idea, 300lb o-linemen really shouldn't be able to sprint as fast as a 180lb WR.
Though will we be able to choose weights? If someone wants a 160lb DE or a 300lb HB will they be able to?
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 10:33:14
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I've always wanted height and weight to factor into attributes, and this is easier and more fair than changing soft-caps based on difference from the mean weight for that position (given that all weights are normally distributed).

Training to gain/lose weight as an adjunct in the same fashion as shopping/night out is a fantastic idea. Maybe allow 0.2% change per session? That would allow a 200-pound player to gain/lose approximately 16 pounds in a 40-day season.

Still, though, a 3.75 second 40-yard dash? C'mon, now.
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Class super heavyweight 261 - 300lbs : base 4.75s 40, +20% block bonus
Class OMGweight 301+lbs : base 5s 40, +30% block bonus


These would have to be modified so that all Guards all have +30% block bonus, for example.

Personally, there is no way I want to lose 10% of my effectiveness because I rolled a guard at 298 lbs, and I am sure there are others out there. There is no way 3 lbs give you a +10% advantage - so maybe a linear scale is better? That would be easy to code.

I appreciate you could make a 298 lb guard into a pulling guard, but not 6 seasons in. It is totally unreasonable to expect this from veteran players.

I appreciate that I am objecting from a personal perspective, but I'm sure there are several other agents out there in the same situation. If these limits are not carefully applied you will force several players into retirement, as they simply would not be able to keep up with their peers. To immediately impose a 10% disadvantage on certain players 250 days after their creation because of a random number generator used during player creation is a bit of a draconian change for me.

So, I'm all for the idea, but with carefully managed limits (or linear scaling) so some players are not put at an immediate disadvantage.
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
As long as there's a mechanism in place to change your weight, I love this idea.


Oh, I should have just said this!
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rhk065
maybe it should be a gradient instead of weight classes so people on the border aren't completely pissed that they built their rb to be a speed back and their barely into a higher weight class.


Or this!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.