User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #2 > Canada AAA#2 West Power Rankings
Page:
 
Xiidaen
offline
Link
 
Excellent response. Especially the win and loss comment.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/17

1. Forumopolis Fighting Llamas (7-2-1, 93.3 [87.5 + 5.8])
2. Yukon Gold Rush (8-1-1, 92.2 [89.5 + 2.7])
3. North American NDL'ers (6-4, 90.5 [82.0 + 8.5])
4. Mooresville Anglers (6-4, 89.0 [88.8 + 0.2])
5. Saskatoon Raiders (7-3, 87.3 [92.4 - 5.1])
6. TSW Titans (5-5, 84.4 [80.9 + 3.5])
7. Thunder Bay Storm (8-1-1, 84.0 [90.6 - 6.6])
8. Moose Knuckle Island Sofa Kings (5-5, 82.8 [84.0 - 1.2])
9. Phoenixville Kings (5-5, 82.3 [80.2 + 2.1])
10. Mt. Oread Hawk Stars (7-3, 82.0 [93.3 - 11.3])
11. Abbotsford Miners (2-8, 81.0 [76.2 + 4.8])
12. Blacksburg Ballers (6-4, 80.6 [85.0 - 4.4])
13. Sudbury Spurs (2-7-1, 79.8 [78.8 + 1.0])
14. San Francisco Sucka Free's (2-8, 70.3)
15. Ottawa Chiefs (1-9, 70.2 [63.4 + 6.8])
16. Strathmore Devils (1-9, 24.9 [31.7 - 6.8])
Last edited May 17, 2008 07:19:21
 
godsize
offline
Link
 
I know it doesn't affect the rankings, but Abbotsford is actually 2-8, not 2-7. Just FYI. Great job with the rankings though.
Last edited May 17, 2008 06:58:35
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by godsize
I know it doesn't affect the rankings, but Abbotsford is actually 2-8, not 2-7. Just FYI. Great job with the rankings though.


So they are. Fixed.
 
phogphantim
offline
Link
 
I know this has been hashed and rehashed, but every power ranking in the history of the world takes record in as at least one criteria. Don't you think it's kind of ridiculous to have a 6-4 team #3 and a 7-3 team #10, one spot ahead of a 2-8 team?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by phogphantim
I know this has been hashed and rehashed, but every power ranking in the history of the world takes record in as at least one criteria. Don't you think it's kind of ridiculous to have a 6-4 team #3 and a 7-3 team #10, one spot ahead of a 2-8 team?


I'm not BJJ, but I'll give it a shot.

Not in GLB. This isn't real football it's an MMO sim. A bunch of info not readily available goes into determining the games, but unlike real football, it's always consistant (no Jessica Simpson curses here). BJJ's rankings are an effort to get a firmer grasp on things like: which team has the best builds, or which team gameplans best.

Also, Win-loss would be bigger if our leagues didn't have to many scrubs getting trounced at every turn. A team with an easy first half schedule might be 8-0 while I team playing 7 top half teams might be 7-1, but it's likely the 7-1 that's the better squad.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phogphantim
I know this has been hashed and rehashed, but every power ranking in the history of the world takes record in as at least one criteria. Don't you think it's kind of ridiculous to have a 6-4 team #3 and a 7-3 team #10, one spot ahead of a 2-8 team?


Not really. We have the GLB rankings for that.
 
JibJabz
offline
Link
 
Am I correct that the Hawk Stars can't do anything to move their score up, it can only go down?
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JibJabz
Am I correct that the Hawk Stars can't do anything to move their score up, it can only go down?


Unfortunately this is true. It's something I've been thinking about for a while now, and that I'm going to try to fix in the next version of my rankings. I don't know how I'll do so yet, though, I have a few ideas but I'm not convinced any of them are satisfactory.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
I would be worried about it if this ranking system determined who went to the playoffs. It's not a big deal. The system is flawed and BJJ knows it. He'll make changes to it and try something different next season. I'm just grateful theres actually somthing to read in Canada AAA#2 Western Conference. Thanks again and I hope you don't advance.
 
snoodmonger
offline
Link
 
Yeah, it sucks that the Hawk Stars can only drop in the rankings, but regardless, I still appreciate BJJ's work, and I enjoy the discussion in the thread.
 
Bob Probert
offline
Link
 
gg NDLers
 
WylieCowboy
offline
Link
 
Just like in the NCAA March Madness, a 12 will take out a 5 on Monday.

GO Ballers!
 
JibJabz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by JibJabz

Am I correct that the Hawk Stars can't do anything to move their score up, it can only go down?


Unfortunately this is true. It's something I've been thinking about for a while now, and that I'm going to try to fix in the next version of my rankings. I don't know how I'll do so yet, though, I have a few ideas but I'm not convinced any of them are satisfactory.


Just wanted to make sure. Agree with all the others that we still appreciate the work.
 
BIGmike61985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bob Probert
gg NDLers

GG.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.