User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Has there been any discussion of instituting NCAA overtime rules?
Page:
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock


Teams could do the same thing with the system we have now. What's your point?


The game ends. 15 minutes and it is over. There is no way to end the college system if people are not trying to win. In theory it could last forever.

Edit: it would be a ridiculous feedback loop.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 23:53:59
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock



Teams could do the same thing with the system we have now. What's your point?


The game ends. 15 minutes and it is over. There is no way to end the college system if people are not trying to win. In theory it could last forever.


So break it off at OT X. Ties aren't completely out of the question. GLB doesn't have to really follow any rules.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock



Teams could do the same thing with the system we have now. What's your point?


The game ends. 15 minutes and it is over. There is no way to end the college system if people are not trying to win. In theory it could last forever.

Edit: it would be a ridiculous feedback loop.


So limit it to a certain number of overtimes. No reason that can't be done.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
The idea is flawed for all of the reasons I gave.

There are ways to make it less flawed but it is still at its base flawed.

The idea allows for too many shenanigans.

The process we have works much better because it keeps teams from the above nonsense.
 
musky5
offline
Link
 
its better then first to score wins, imo
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
The idea is flawed for all of the reasons I gave.

There are ways to make it less flawed but it is still at its base flawed.

The idea allows for too many shenanigans.

The process we have works much better because it keeps teams from the above nonsense.


I addressed all of them I think.

Cap it at 3OT. Don't allow XP for overtime. No nonsense.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by czman

The idea is flawed for all of the reasons I gave.

There are ways to make it less flawed but it is still at its base flawed.

The idea allows for too many shenanigans.

The process we have works much better because it keeps teams from the above nonsense.


I addressed all of them I think.

Cap it at 3OT. Don't allow XP for overtime. No nonsense.


If you cap it at 3 there is no reason to do it. A lot more games would end in a tie and I am sure competitive teams do not want that..

 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Originally posted by czman


The idea is flawed for all of the reasons I gave.

There are ways to make it less flawed but it is still at its base flawed.

The idea allows for too many shenanigans.

The process we have works much better because it keeps teams from the above nonsense.


I addressed all of them I think.

Cap it at 3OT. Don't allow XP for overtime. No nonsense.


If you cap it at 3 there is no reason to do it. A lot more games would end in a tie and I am sure competitive teams do not want that..



There is absolutely a reason to do it because you let both teams play both phases of football. Your whole team playing their whole team to decide who wins. If after 3 OT periods you can't beat the other team and they can't beat you, well, that's the definition of a tie, and neither team deserves the win.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock


I definitely prefer the college rule


Crux of your reasoning. I have yet to see any real logical reason to change it. The system works fine.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 00:12:56
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Was there any debate about this, and has Bort spoken on it? I definitely prefer the college rule




You've been quite helpful in fleshing out this idea. I'm not sure what else you're trying to say here. I'm glad you figured out which part of that you were trying to post by your 3rd edit, though.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock



I definitely prefer the college rule


Crux of your reasoning. I have yet to see any real logical reason to change it. The system works fine.


Goodness another edit.

The logic is very simple. One half a team versus another half of a team is no way to settle a ballgame. Please refute this.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock


The logic is very simple. One half a team versus another half of a team is no way to settle a ballgame. Please refute this.


That is opinion. You have no facts or reasons except personal preference.

The facts are the college system is exploitable unless you completely change it so hardly resembles the college system.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock



The logic is very simple. One half a team versus another half of a team is no way to settle a ballgame. Please refute this.


That is opinion. You have no facts or reasons except personal preference.


And your opinion is "the system we have now works fine".

Powerful analysis.

If I build my team to be an offensive powerhouse, and that's how I win games, the current system *punishes* me for losing the coinflip.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock


One half a team versus another half of a team is no way to settle a ballgame. Please refute this.


There are not halfs to a team there is just a team.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock



One half a team versus another half of a team is no way to settle a ballgame. Please refute this.


There are not halfs to a team there is just a team.


You have to do two things well to win football games. You have to play good defense, and score on offense. You have to do both. OT only asks you to do one of these things. It changes the very makeup of the sport.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.