User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The new promotion system
Page:
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
in the very deep leagues, it is likely to have 16 teams move up. If you are in USA BBB, there are many leagues above you that will be promoting extra teams. By the time you get down to the lowest level, it would not be unlikely to promote 16.


You have two leagues to fill it. Show me one place this might be true.

Let's take one chain for example. Assume the number next to the league is the number of teams that need to be replaced (that get moved to the bottom league). I'll be extreme.

Pro- 8
AAA- 8
AA- 8
A - 8

We have a total of 8 + 8*2 + 8*4 + 8*8 = 120 teams moving to the bottom league. But there are 16 leagues. That only averages out to 7.5 teams per league.

To get 16 teams moving up, we need to move down 256 teams. That would happen if 17 teams on average were gutted on each league. I don't see it happening.

 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinto
I don't like that a team could go 0-16 in the regular season, lose all but one post season scrimmage and tie that one, yet get promoted over a team that went 9-7 in the regular season, barely missed the playoffs and for whatever reason (bad luck with the sim, drew more difficult opponetns or whatever) lost their post season scrimmages. That seems wrong.

I know its semantics, but I guess we could change them from Post Season Scrimmages to 2nd Tier Playoffs, Losers' Bracket or something and it wouldn't seem so weird for scrimmages to determine the fate of your team. Kinda defeats the whole purpose/definition of what a scrimmage is all about.

Oh well, at least there's a plan laid out and we all know what the rules are. That's the most important part.


It won't happen. There's virtually no chance a team that doesn't make the playoffs moves up. There's an extremely low chance a team that loses in the first round of the playoffs even moves up.
 
kinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by kinto

I don't like that a team could go 0-16 in the regular season, lose all but one post season scrimmage and tie that one, yet get promoted over a team that went 9-7 in the regular season, barely missed the playoffs and for whatever reason (bad luck with the sim, drew more difficult opponetns or whatever) lost their post season scrimmages. That seems wrong.

I know its semantics, but I guess we could change them from Post Season Scrimmages to 2nd Tier Playoffs, Losers' Bracket or something and it wouldn't seem so weird for scrimmages to determine the fate of your team. Kinda defeats the whole purpose/definition of what a scrimmage is all about.

Oh well, at least there's a plan laid out and we all know what the rules are. That's the most important part.


It won't happen. There's virtually no chance a team that doesn't make the playoffs moves up. There's an extremely low chance a team that loses in the first round of the playoffs even moves up.


It probably won't happen, but it is possible and thats the concern.
 
BwareDware94
offline
Link
 
with playoffs wins, is it talking all time playoff wins or just this season?
 
Groucho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Taha19
check out south America A#7 and Africa A#6 ... in your opinion how many teams should get promoted?


It's almost impossible to predict since all contracts are now set to expire in the offseason, and we don't know how many owners will just let them lapse.
 
Taha19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pensfan

Yeah.. an already shitty promotion system got even worse for first year cap teams.


agreed!
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinto
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by kinto


I don't like that a team could go 0-16 in the regular season, lose all but one post season scrimmage and tie that one, yet get promoted over a team that went 9-7 in the regular season, barely missed the playoffs and for whatever reason (bad luck with the sim, drew more difficult opponetns or whatever) lost their post season scrimmages. That seems wrong.

I know its semantics, but I guess we could change them from Post Season Scrimmages to 2nd Tier Playoffs, Losers' Bracket or something and it wouldn't seem so weird for scrimmages to determine the fate of your team. Kinda defeats the whole purpose/definition of what a scrimmage is all about.

Oh well, at least there's a plan laid out and we all know what the rules are. That's the most important part.


It won't happen. There's virtually no chance a team that doesn't make the playoffs moves up. There's an extremely low chance a team that loses in the first round of the playoffs even moves up.


It probably won't happen, but it is possible and thats the concern.


Ok, so there might be a 1 in a million shot of it happening (a 0-16 team winning more scrimmages than a 9-7 team PLUS that many teams needing to advance). But who cares. If they are playing better at the end of the season, let them get promoted. Maybe the 9-7 team gutted midseason and is awful now. The promotion system isn't perfect, but its about as good as its going to get without completely redoing how the postseason games run.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pensfan
The biggest problem I have is with 13 Cap leagues. The conference champs in these leagues are barely able to compete moving up to the next tier to begin with without having to completely retool their team as it is.

Now we are taking even MORE 13 cap teams and throwing them to the wolves to be cupcakes next year?

Yeah.. an already shitty promotion system got even worse for first year cap teams.


QQ

This team was a first season capped league that got promoted into an uncapped league. http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4371

Oh noes! They lost 2 games!
 
kinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by kinto

Originally posted by tomcollins


Originally posted by kinto



I don't like that a team could go 0-16 in the regular season, lose all but one post season scrimmage and tie that one, yet get promoted over a team that went 9-7 in the regular season, barely missed the playoffs and for whatever reason (bad luck with the sim, drew more difficult opponetns or whatever) lost their post season scrimmages. That seems wrong.

I know its semantics, but I guess we could change them from Post Season Scrimmages to 2nd Tier Playoffs, Losers' Bracket or something and it wouldn't seem so weird for scrimmages to determine the fate of your team. Kinda defeats the whole purpose/definition of what a scrimmage is all about.

Oh well, at least there's a plan laid out and we all know what the rules are. That's the most important part.


It won't happen. There's virtually no chance a team that doesn't make the playoffs moves up. There's an extremely low chance a team that loses in the first round of the playoffs even moves up.


It probably won't happen, but it is possible and thats the concern.


Ok, so there might be a 1 in a million shot of it happening (a 0-16 team winning more scrimmages than a 9-7 team PLUS that many teams needing to advance). But who cares. If they are playing better at the end of the season, let them get promoted. Maybe the 9-7 team gutted midseason and is awful now. The promotion system isn't perfect, but its about as good as its going to get without completely redoing how the postseason games run.


As I said in my original post, its great that we know what the rules are, but, yes, it could be better. Use Borts playoff rules for the playoff teams. If it somehow gets past that, use the regular season standings, not the post season scrimmages.
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinto
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by kinto


Originally posted by tomcollins



Originally posted by kinto




I don't like that a team could go 0-16 in the regular season, lose all but one post season scrimmage and tie that one, yet get promoted over a team that went 9-7 in the regular season, barely missed the playoffs and for whatever reason (bad luck with the sim, drew more difficult opponetns or whatever) lost their post season scrimmages. That seems wrong.

I know its semantics, but I guess we could change them from Post Season Scrimmages to 2nd Tier Playoffs, Losers' Bracket or something and it wouldn't seem so weird for scrimmages to determine the fate of your team. Kinda defeats the whole purpose/definition of what a scrimmage is all about.

Oh well, at least there's a plan laid out and we all know what the rules are. That's the most important part.


It won't happen. There's virtually no chance a team that doesn't make the playoffs moves up. There's an extremely low chance a team that loses in the first round of the playoffs even moves up.


It probably won't happen, but it is possible and thats the concern.


Ok, so there might be a 1 in a million shot of it happening (a 0-16 team winning more scrimmages than a 9-7 team PLUS that many teams needing to advance). But who cares. If they are playing better at the end of the season, let them get promoted. Maybe the 9-7 team gutted midseason and is awful now. The promotion system isn't perfect, but its about as good as its going to get without completely redoing how the postseason games run.


As I said in my original post, its great that we know what the rules are, but, yes, it could be better. Use Borts playoff rules for the playoff teams. If it somehow gets past that, use the regular season standings, not the post season scrimmages.


That doesn't really help as much. Think about it this way. The two teams that lost the conference championship are tied with 2 playoff wins. Who should win? The team that came from an easier conference? Why use that when you can just play them head to head (in the post-season game)? Instead of calling them scrimmages, call them "3rd place games" and it would make more sense. It's still the same game, no matter what you call it. That will cover the first 8 teams that are moving up. I don't see many cases when more than 8 are moving up.

Using the regular season is pointless since it punishes the late boosters who are in better shape in the playoffs anyway.
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 13:55:15
 
Kyriakin
offline
Link
 
I think the point is that the scrimmages are yet to happen - whereas the regular season has pretty much passed.

It's fairer to have the key games after the announcement, not before

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

In each league:

1 x 4 playoff wins - Promoted anyway
1 x 3 playoff wins - Promoted anyway

2 x 2 playoff wins

4 x 1 playoff win

8 x 0 playoff wins

(It will go no further than that ever. In fact, I'd be surprised if many 1st round playoff-losing teams get promoted.)

16 x teams who never made the playoffs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If 1 extra slot is available - Scrimmage between two '2 playoff win' teams
If 2 extra slots are available - Easy. '2 playoff win' teams both go up

If 3 extra slots are available - 4-team scrimmage tournament.
If 4 extra slots available - Two scrimmage games involving the four '1 playoff win' teams
If 5 extra slots are available - 4-team elimination scrimmage tournament. Losers progress.
If 6 extra slots available - Easy. All 4 '1 playoff win' teams go up

If 7 extra slots available - 8 team scrimmage tournament

etc. etc.
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 14:01:11
 
douglasiv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Groucho
Yes, I would like clarification on whether teams can be promoted across conferences or not. The announcement implies that they can, but a post by Bort in this thread implies that that they'll stay in the same conference.


Good question
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kyriakin
I think the point is that the scrimmages are yet to happen - whereas the regular season has pretty much passed.

It's fairer to have the key games after the announcement, not before

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

In each league:

1 x 4 playoff wins - Promoted anyway
1 x 3 playoff wins - Promoted anyway

2 x 2 playoff wins

4 x 1 playoff win

8 x 0 playoff wins

(It will go no further than that ever. In fact, I'd be surprised if many 1st round playoff-losing teams get promoted.)

16 x teams who never made the playoffs

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If 1 extra slot is available - Scrimmage between two '2 playoff win' teams
If 2 extra slots are available - Easy. '2 playoff win' teams both go up

If 3 extra slots are available - 4-team scrimmage tournament.
If 4 extra slots available - Two scrimmage games involving the four '1 playoff win' teams
If 5 extra slots are available - 4-team elimination scrimmage tournament. Losers progress.
If 6 extra slots available - Easy. All 4 '1 playoff win' teams go up

If 7 extra slots available - 8 team scrimmage tournament

etc. etc.


What you are missing is the tiebreakers between the two feeder leagues. 7 slots really means 14 slots are available. It will probably be arbitrary between which league gets the "odd" spot if an odd number are available, but we don't have any better way to do it without adding a game to the schedule.

Bort hasn't stated whether or not the scrimmages will be scheduled as a "tournament". I don't think they can, since scrimmage games can end in ties. For the first 4 extra slots, it won't really matter, since there is only a 1 game tournament.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nats Kule
Step 1. Normal promotion/relegation, 1 up 2 down.

Step 2. All CPU and flagged teams are removed. Gaps are then filled in according to Bort's Rules of Promotion. Pro teams are filled by their two AAA, then the 2 AAA by the 4 AA on down the chain. Regular relationships apply (AA#3 Zeta and AA#4 Zeta fill AAA#2 Zeta, etc.)

Step 3. Teams that have been removed are then reset and added to the open spots in the lowest level in the region.


I still need clarification on this. Trying to update the wiki.

What happens if a sold team is already one of the bottom 4? Does the normal promotion/relegation or the moving to the bottom thing come first?
 
spotty
offline
Link
 
i have read a few post on here and i'm sure someone has brought this up but if i didnt make the playoffs why would i want to win my scrimmages to get moved up?...i think both teams would be playing to lose so they dont have to be moved up before they're ready...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.