User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > ***OFFICIAL CPL THUNDERDOME THREAD***
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
no but seriously why are judges needed? We need "judges" in the form of everyone who posts here being able to equally vote. These judges can also self police the thunderdome thread and not count any random ffa retard trying to vote. In this way everyone gets to participate and there can be no favoritism.


Or bad poster votes like mine, feudel and klaw.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
no but seriously why are judges needed? We need "judges" in the form of everyone who posts here being able to equally vote. These judges can also self police the thunderdome thread and not count any random ffa retard trying to vote. In this way everyone gets to participate and there can be no favoritism.


how does that stop favoritism? in that case, the team who has the most active posters (or multis) gets more votes than teams with less active posters.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
no but seriously why are judges needed? We need "judges" in the form of everyone who posts here being able to equally vote. These judges can also self police the thunderdome thread and not count any random ffa retard trying to vote. In this way everyone gets to participate and there can be no favoritism.


Because I don't really feel like fucking reading 35 posts to determine which of them are the 17 votes that should count, 8 of those are from people who are less than mediocre posters, all so one guy can get a two day ban. I doubt that Serenity/VT feel like doing that either
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by klaw19

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by klaw19



hint: voting is subjective, morons. Public voting means very little. You can vote however you want and list any reason you want and there is no way you can prove otherwise. Unless you just assume anyone who votes in the minority is biased.


Hint: calling everyone who disagrees with you morons is very ignorant. Anyone who is not stupid can tell if Gart is consistently voting for the minority especially if they are known to be friendly with him on this forum. I am sure the people in the CPL can interpret whether or not he is being partial.


So what happens if his "buddies" aren't in the minority every time? What if there's more than one judge being impartial? Also, now a judge has a fear of voting for who he believes is a better poster if he knows how the others will vote. Sounds like an awesome system you have!


So what is your advice on the system or are you just here to bitch? It's hard to find a completely impartial system but you can tell if a judge constantly votes for friends or alliances like if say for example Hobos always vote for hobos. lolklaw


So now Hobos CAN'T vote for Hobos? Even if he believes the Hobo is the better poster? Rofl, sounds even awesomer dood!
 
DrunkenOne
offline
Link
 
make it a 7 day ban and have them less often. This shouldn't be a daily event like you apparently think it should be. imo
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
Compare that to a system with a set number of judges, which will clearly not include everyone. Thunderdomes will get stale if people feel like they can't participate in it. While it would be easier to determine a winner since its only like 5-7 people voting or whatever, that also increases favoritism.


I'm currently creating scarcity in the list of judges, so there's competition over them, so there's a semi-decent reason to get us off to our rocky start, because otherwise it'd take a season to get the first four or so Thunderdomes (which are going to be 'meh') out of the way.

It's like how you masturbate before sex so you don't blow your load within 15 seconds. It's less fun than the sex itself, but it's going to make the sex better.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by klaw19


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by klaw19




hint: voting is subjective, morons. Public voting means very little. You can vote however you want and list any reason you want and there is no way you can prove otherwise. Unless you just assume anyone who votes in the minority is biased.


Hint: calling everyone who disagrees with you morons is very ignorant. Anyone who is not stupid can tell if Gart is consistently voting for the minority especially if they are known to be friendly with him on this forum. I am sure the people in the CPL can interpret whether or not he is being partial.


So what happens if his "buddies" aren't in the minority every time? What if there's more than one judge being impartial? Also, now a judge has a fear of voting for who he believes is a better poster if he knows how the others will vote. Sounds like an awesome system you have!


So what is your advice on the system or are you just here to bitch? It's hard to find a completely impartial system but you can tell if a judge constantly votes for friends or alliances like if say for example Hobos always vote for hobos. lolklaw


So now Hobos CAN'T vote for Hobos? Even if he believes the Hobo is the better poster? Rofl, sounds even awesomer dood!


Reading comprehension ftw

Look at the word "always" then rethink your statement.
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by DrunkenOne

no but seriously why are judges needed? We need "judges" in the form of everyone who posts here being able to equally vote. These judges can also self police the thunderdome thread and not count any random ffa retard trying to vote. In this way everyone gets to participate and there can be no favoritism.


Because I don't really feel like fucking reading 35 posts to determine which of them are the 17 votes that should count, 8 of those are from people who are less than mediocre posters, all so one guy can get a two day ban. I doubt that Serenity/VT feel like doing that either


You don't have to read it... go outside ONE TIME, nerd.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by DrunkenOne

Compare that to a system with a set number of judges, which will clearly not include everyone. Thunderdomes will get stale if people feel like they can't participate in it. While it would be easier to determine a winner since its only like 5-7 people voting or whatever, that also increases favoritism.


I'm currently creating scarcity in the list of judges, so there's competition over them, so there's a semi-decent reason to get us off to our rocky start, because otherwise it'd take a season to get the first four or so Thunderdomes (which are going to be 'meh') out of the way.

It's like how you masturbate before sex so you don't blow your load within 15 seconds. It's less fun than the sex itself, but it's going to make the sex better.


Wat

you actually do that?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by klaw19
Originally posted by Gturtle

Originally posted by DrunkenOne


no but seriously why are judges needed? We need "judges" in the form of everyone who posts here being able to equally vote. These judges can also self police the thunderdome thread and not count any random ffa retard trying to vote. In this way everyone gets to participate and there can be no favoritism.


Because I don't really feel like fucking reading 35 posts to determine which of them are the 17 votes that should count, 8 of those are from people who are less than mediocre posters, all so one guy can get a two day ban. I doubt that Serenity/VT feel like doing that either


You don't have to read it... go outside ONE TIME, nerd.


And yet you sit here on the internet on a Friday night. lolklaw
 
DrunkenOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by DrunkenOne

no but seriously why are judges needed? We need "judges" in the form of everyone who posts here being able to equally vote. These judges can also self police the thunderdome thread and not count any random ffa retard trying to vote. In this way everyone gets to participate and there can be no favoritism.


Because I don't really feel like fucking reading 35 posts to determine which of them are the 17 votes that should count, 8 of those are from people who are less than mediocre posters, all so one guy can get a two day ban. I doubt that Serenity/VT feel like doing that either

lol, you dont feel like reading 35 posts? Ffs, the thread will probably be 35 PAGES long, and you will read every one of them.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gart888
Originally posted by Gturtle

Originally posted by DrunkenOne


Compare that to a system with a set number of judges, which will clearly not include everyone. Thunderdomes will get stale if people feel like they can't participate in it. While it would be easier to determine a winner since its only like 5-7 people voting or whatever, that also increases favoritism.


I'm currently creating scarcity in the list of judges, so there's competition over them, so there's a semi-decent reason to get us off to our rocky start, because otherwise it'd take a season to get the first four or so Thunderdomes (which are going to be 'meh') out of the way.

It's like how you masturbate before sex so you don't blow your load within 15 seconds. It's less fun than the sex itself, but it's going to make the sex better.


Wat

you actually do that?


If she's hot, yes.
 
klaw19
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by klaw19

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by klaw19



Originally posted by jrry32




Originally posted by klaw19





hint: voting is subjective, morons. Public voting means very little. You can vote however you want and list any reason you want and there is no way you can prove otherwise. Unless you just assume anyone who votes in the minority is biased.


Hint: calling everyone who disagrees with you morons is very ignorant. Anyone who is not stupid can tell if Gart is consistently voting for the minority especially if they are known to be friendly with him on this forum. I am sure the people in the CPL can interpret whether or not he is being partial.


So what happens if his "buddies" aren't in the minority every time? What if there's more than one judge being impartial? Also, now a judge has a fear of voting for who he believes is a better poster if he knows how the others will vote. Sounds like an awesome system you have!


So what is your advice on the system or are you just here to bitch? It's hard to find a completely impartial system but you can tell if a judge constantly votes for friends or alliances like if say for example Hobos always vote for hobos. lolklaw


So now Hobos CAN'T vote for Hobos? Even if he believes the Hobo is the better poster? Rofl, sounds even awesomer dood!


Reading comprehension ftw

Look at the word "always" then rethink your statement.


Exactly, if a hobo was the better poster twice... and the judge votes again for the better poster (hobo) it will look fishy. Way to provide an incentive to vote for the crappy poster. You would make a great economist. Not.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
Originally posted by Gturtle

Originally posted by DrunkenOne


no but seriously why are judges needed? We need "judges" in the form of everyone who posts here being able to equally vote. These judges can also self police the thunderdome thread and not count any random ffa retard trying to vote. In this way everyone gets to participate and there can be no favoritism.


Because I don't really feel like fucking reading 35 posts to determine which of them are the 17 votes that should count, 8 of those are from people who are less than mediocre posters, all so one guy can get a two day ban. I doubt that Serenity/VT feel like doing that either

lol, you dont feel like reading 35 posts? Ffs, the thread will probably be 35 PAGES long, and you will read every one of them.


35 pages of entertaining Thunderdome = easier to read than 35 posts of boring people trying to rationalize why they think what they think.
 
DedJVE
offline
Link
 
THEY"RE BREAKDANCE FIGHTING!!!!!!!!!! TO THE DOME!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.