User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Booster4324
Incidental would imply there isn't an actual problem.

Congratulations, you got it in one!
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Originally posted by Booster4324

Incidental would imply there isn't an actual problem.

Congratulations, you got it in one!


Congrats for joining Bort in ignoring the actual problem. Despite massive evidence to the contrary. I can understand why he would. Acknowledging the problem could cost him massive amounts of cash. What's your excuse?
 
LionsFan0513
offline
Link
 
Not going to both reading this whole thread....

But my team only has 3 fumbles lost, and only like 6 fumbles all year....
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Well, you think I am ignoring something, I think you you are ignoring the fact that last seasons stats have no relevance whatsoever to this seasons, not because Bort made any changes, but because player builds have changed on both sides of the ball, and because something called a random number generator is involved in anything related to gameplay in GLB.

Originally posted by Booster4324

Edit - Oh and how many times does a competitive RB at any level fumble once a game? Speaking pure reality, obviously not GLB.

And since when has reality had any relevance to what happens in GLB?

And before you accuse me once again of ignoring something that is not an issue, check out my RB and then tell me again I am not aware of fumbles this season. Is there an issue? Sure there is, but unlike you I don't see the solution in making changes to the engine but making changes to my players build. MAybe you should try that one ...

 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Well, you think I am ignoring something, I think you you are ignoring the fact that last seasons stats have no relevance whatsoever to this seasons, not because Bort made any changes, but because player builds have changed on both sides of the ball, and because something called a random number generator is involved in anything related to gameplay in GLB.

Originally posted by Booster4324


Edit - Oh and how many times does a competitive RB at any level fumble once a game? Speaking pure reality, obviously not GLB.

And since when has reality had any relevance to what happens in GLB?

And before you accuse me once again of ignoring something that is not an issue, check out my RB and then tell me again I am not aware of fumbles this season. Is there an issue? Sure there is, but unlike you I don't see the solution in making changes to the engine but making changes to my players build. MAybe you should try that one ...



Ahh I get it, you are a fan boi. Why is it that my RB that gave up 1 fumble all of last season gave up 3 to -8s and -10s? Bort broke something, it is that simple. Ask yourself this, why is it that guys could make 50 yard FGs with more regularity that PATs? Why is it that the excuse for drops for receivers is that they are going after uncatchable balls?

Oh and to answer your question I dumped a bunch of points in Carrying to soft cap it. He promptly fumbled twice.

BTW I replied like that to someone else when he walked into the conversation without reading the thread. I think that a game based on professional football should have some semblance to reality. Maybe that is just me.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 18:52:26
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Everyone complaining about fumbles is dead on.

I had a game against a much weaker opponent where we fumbled 6 times. I talked with the owner of the team (who happens to own all of the players on that team) and asked him if he did anything special for the game. Turns out he didn't -- no bonus tokens, no special game planning, and all of his defensive players were set to wrap-up!

While the code may not have changed, it's obvious that players with higher levels (and therefore higher skills) are ruining the sim in ways that Bort hadn't predicted, much like defensive ends with 80 speed/agility and not much else are dominating the game in an unrealistic manner. Too bad nobody wants to look into any of these issues.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I really haven't seen an increase in fumbles. Both my backs have 9 fumbles combined this season, and this is on a team that runs a LOT.

Why do people always feel the need to blame the sim? My guess is most people who have "fumblitis" fall into one of 2 categories.

1) Low carrying - all of the position forums I always see people saying "carrying isn't that important...it should be good in the 30s." If you're a HB, carrying is you main job on the field...it should be AT LEAST to the soft cap (if you're a reasonable level).

2) Low stamina - If you're tired, you're going to be fumbling more often. Stamina keeps you playing at a higher level, and will not only improve your overall game, but keep you from fumbling also.

This is coming from someone who had a back who fumbled 19 times in a season a couple seasons ago. I made the necessary adjustments, and he hasn't been fumbling very often at all.
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I really haven't seen an increase in fumbles. Both my backs have 9 fumbles combined this season, and this is on a team that runs a LOT.

Why do people always feel the need to blame the sim? My guess is most people who have "fumblitis" fall into one of 2 categories.

1) Low carrying - all of the position forums I always see people saying "carrying isn't that important...it should be good in the 30s." If you're a HB, carrying is you main job on the field...it should be AT LEAST to the soft cap (if you're a reasonable level).

2) Low stamina - If you're tired, you're going to be fumbling more often. Stamina keeps you playing at a higher level, and will not only improve your overall game, but keep you from fumbling also.

This is coming from someone who had a back who fumbled 19 times in a season a couple seasons ago. I made the necessary adjustments, and he hasn't been fumbling very often at all.


I posted my stats. Bort himself said that he wasn't sure why it happened unless I was tired. Only my guy had 19 carries and a 35 stamina...
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I really haven't seen an increase in fumbles. Both my backs have 9 fumbles combined this season, and this is on a team that runs a LOT.

Why do people always feel the need to blame the sim? My guess is most people who have "fumblitis" fall into one of 2 categories.

1) Low carrying - all of the position forums I always see people saying "carrying isn't that important...it should be good in the 30s." If you're a HB, carrying is you main job on the field...it should be AT LEAST to the soft cap (if you're a reasonable level).

2) Low stamina - If you're tired, you're going to be fumbling more often. Stamina keeps you playing at a higher level, and will not only improve your overall game, but keep you from fumbling also.

This is coming from someone who had a back who fumbled 19 times in a season a couple seasons ago. I made the necessary adjustments, and he hasn't been fumbling very often at all.


1. Happening to high carry guys too
2. Happening very early in games as well.
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Booster4324
Ahh I get it, you are a fan boi.

Gotta love it,l so anybody who happens to disagree has to be a fan boi? Name calling, the refuge for those that have no real arguments ...

Originally posted by
Why is it that my RB that gave up 1 fumble all of last season gave up 3 to -8s and -10s? Bort broke something, it is that simple.

Maybe you should look at the other side of the equation too on occasion, and not just focus on your end of it. Of course it couldn't possibly be the case that some LBs who did not cause fumbles last season did something to change their build and are causing more because of that, maybe even unwittingly? I know what some LBs on my teams did that do cause more fumbles this season than they did in the past. Most of them have a certain thing in common, but of course in your mind it is out of the question that LBs who adjusted their build are the cause of increased fumbles, because they just stayed put and are exactly the same as last season, right?

And it could not possibly be the case that last season you got lucky with the RNG and this season you don't? No, of course the only possible and acceptable explanation has to be that Bort made some changes that he won't admit to :rolleyes I don't know about you, but I found that Bort was rather forthcoming in the past when he made changes to the engine that did not quite work out as intended. But of course this time it's different, right, because you say so and provide some incidental evidence?

Originally posted by
Ask yourself this, why is it that guys could make 50 yard FGs with more regularity that PATs? Why is it that the excuse for drops for receivers is that they are going after uncatchable balls?

Could you kindly show me where I stated that there wasn't an issue with extra points? Would be very interesting to learn what I type while sleepwalking. We were talking about fumbles, right? So I somehow miss the relevance of mentioning kickers and extra points or wide receivers and drops in this context, care to enlighten me?
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Booster4324
Originally posted by Zickzack

Well, you think I am ignoring something, I think you you are ignoring the fact that last seasons stats have no relevance whatsoever to this seasons, not because Bort made any changes, but because player builds have changed on both sides of the ball, and because something called a random number generator is involved in anything related to gameplay in GLB.

Originally posted by Booster4324



Edit - Oh and how many times does a competitive RB at any level fumble once a game? Speaking pure reality, obviously not GLB.

And since when has reality had any relevance to what happens in GLB?

And before you accuse me once again of ignoring something that is not an issue, check out my RB and then tell me again I am not aware of fumbles this season. Is there an issue? Sure there is, but unlike you I don't see the solution in making changes to the engine but making changes to my players build. MAybe you should try that one ...



Ahh I get it, you are a fan boi. Why is it that my RB that gave up 1 fumble all of last season gave up 3 to -8s and -10s? Bort broke something, it is that simple. Ask yourself this, why is it that guys could make 50 yard FGs with more regularity that PATs? Why is it that the excuse for drops for receivers is that they are going after uncatchable balls?


But you have nearly twice as many carries this season compared to last season with 5 games to go, so not sure why you keep using that as part of your argument.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B

1. Happening to high carry guys too
2. Happening very early in games as well.


Can you show me some examples of it happening really early with high carry guys?
 
Sahoj
offline
Link
 
My guy is up in fumbles.. but man, the collisions he gets into with guys..

Those dots sure do rattle this season, I can understand why he drops it now
and then.
 
Doggg4
offline
Link
 
Maybe I am thinking too simplistic, but last year power backs seemed like they were breaking 20 tackles a game. Defensive players as a whole had neglected tackling as a relavent stat. So as a counter a lot of defensive players last year went to wrap up tackling. So last year, low tackiling + wrap up = less fumbles. Now this year, defensive players have had the chance to boost 6 levels, plus natural leveling and at least I know with my guys, pumped a lot into tackling. So this year, defensive players have much higher tackling and a lot are back on to power tackling, so that would equal a greater chance of fumbles. I think RB's are now on the other side of the equation, carrying is the stat that got left behind and what the guides say, or what people thought was a good amount, really isn't.
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doggg4
Maybe I am thinking too simplistic, but last year power backs seemed like they were breaking 20 tackles a game. Defensive players as a whole had neglected tackling as a relavent stat. So as a counter a lot of defensive players last year went to wrap up tackling. So last year, low tackiling + wrap up = less fumbles. Now this year, defensive players have had the chance to boost 6 levels, plus natural leveling and at least I know with my guys, pumped a lot into tackling. So this year, defensive players have much higher tackling and a lot are back on to power tackling, so that would equal a greater chance of fumbles. I think RB's are now on the other side of the equation, carrying is the stat that got left behind and what the guides say, or what people thought was a good amount, really isn't.


Bingo!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.