User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Link
 
Profit sharing for the playoffs is the stupidest thing I've heard of.....

Why should barely active owners with a team full of cpus or farm teams get the money we need for upgrades on the stadium and equipment?

 
canes30
offline
Link
 
I think it should be home team gets 70% away gets 30%.

This is more balanced, but still makes you want to be a top 4 team.
 
canes30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stephenthegreat
Profit sharing for the playoffs is the stupidest thing I've heard of.....

Why should barely active owners with a team full of cpus or farm teams get the money we need for upgrades on the stadium and equipment?



Those teams don't make it to the playoffs.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Originally posted by Sao

It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


good idea here too




Wow, how short sighted. Sure make the top 4 when the current system is stacking the odds against you. The top 1-4 teams make a killing in the playoffs while 5-8 make squat. So now the 1-4 teams have even MORE money to improve their stadiums and rosters.. If I make it in as the #5 team, what do I get? 100k.. Wow, how far does that go... The #4 team makes millions.. Fair?? No..Your point is that everyone should build their stadium first to be competitive?? No one likes to lose... No owner who doesn't own virtually the whole team can tell their players, "hey, we are just gonna lose for the next 3 seasons because I am not getting FA's or higher level players so that I can be competitive in 4 seasons.."
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Originally posted by Sao

It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


good idea here too



I forgot to add where the 25% figure came from. Adding

A teams fanbase is static throughtout the year. A stadium is a stadium and represents how many of your fans attend games.

Given all stadiums differ even if slightly, let's assume an 8 plays a 1. The 1 has a larger stadium...lets say by 10K seats.

Why would more visiting fans get to go to the game on the road and make more money for the team when less go to see their own team play at home?

That's why I propose sales ONLY on the visitors stadium and at a 25% capacity. ITRW, 25% traveling fanbase is good. It might even be too high.

 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sao
It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by wombat killer


I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.


That's why I like an idea proposed earlier that awarded a piece of playoff revenue to be divided among the non-playoff teams.

A system that rewards top seeds with the lion's share, while still distributing income to lower seed and non playoff teams is in the best interest of the competitive nature of the leagues.


WRONG!!!


Thanks for making such a sound and respectable argument.
 
Sao
offline
Link
 

Crushr, did you even read the idea? Did you then take out a calculator and figure what 25% of your own stadiums capacity would be vs. 100K at a set playoff timeframe seating price?

Talk about short sighted.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by canes30
Originally posted by Stephenthegreat

Profit sharing for the playoffs is the stupidest thing I've heard of.....

Why should barely active owners with a team full of cpus or farm teams get the money we need for upgrades on the stadium and equipment?



Those teams don't make it to the playoffs.



+1

That seems to be one of the prevailing arguments and it has absolutely no merit. We aren't talking about gutted teams that can't make the playoffs. We are talking about owners who put in just as much time(in theory maybe more time)building a competitive team. Just because they end up #5 - 8 seeds is no reason to assume they are gutted or that the owner isn't doing all he can to win..
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 12:31:37
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stephenthegreat
Profit sharing for the playoffs is the stupidest thing I've heard of.....

Why should barely active owners with a team full of cpus or farm teams get the money we need for upgrades on the stadium and equipment?



DO you have barely active owners and CPU teams making the playoffs in your league?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by Sao

It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?


Ok. What about my plan of giving each of the away playoff teams their average $ amount of consessions to simulate merchandise sales? No tickets...
 
Sao
offline
Link
 
McGruff, read post just above yours.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sao

Crushr, did you even read the idea? Did you then take out a calculator and figure what 25% of your own stadiums capacity would be vs. 100K at a set playoff timeframe seating price?

Talk about short sighted.


Dude, there isn't any set plan.. this is a discussion. I have seen like 5 plans promoted here.. So what are YOU talking about? Would 100k be more than 25% of my revenue? NO! So how am I short sighted? My point is that the statement of " well make the 1-4 seeds and you'll get more money" is short sighted because of how the revenues are divied up in the playoffs. Sorry if that was too complicated of a point for you to get...

 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Sao


It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?


Ok. What about my plan of giving each of the away playoff teams their average $ amount of consessions to simulate merchandise sales? No tickets...


That idea has some merit, and make real life sense. Merchandise sales do increase with post season appearances and success.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Originally posted by Sao


It shouldn't be this hard.

Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.

Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.

You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.


FOr the sake of realism, why is the away team selling tickets to their stadium for a game that won't be played there?


Ok. What about my plan of giving each of the away playoff teams their average $ amount of consessions to simulate merchandise sales? No tickets...


In fact, In think this should be posted in the suggestions forum as a viable alternative to revenue sharing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.