User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
And the point of FP is, you don't boost your players or buy them equipment. Why would I continue to try and figure out false statements from someone who thinks it's good logic to create more worthless players instead of making the one's he has useful.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 16:02:22
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by essteeay
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

Originally posted by Catullus 16


Originally posted by OSU_Ed



You made no valid point. You not buying FP does mean your opinions are less important. And I do have 5 players because I don't feel like creating 50 worthless players I don't boost.


here... let me try to dumb it down for ya:
- under the new system, it now takes disproportionately longer for higher-level players to see the effect of their training.

additional places where you're wrong:
- i obviously do buy FP.
- i'm fairly confident i have bought more than you.
- but even though i'm the only one between us with the right to suddenly make this a plutocracy, i'm not going to. if you have an argument to make, have it stand on its own merits... don't hide behind your self-inflated wallet.

the other thing your missing here is the fact that i've been agreeing with you all along... and that post i made (the one you still don't understand) was actually in support of arguments you were making earlier. sheesh...


Same thing the low level players will see when they're high level players. So, you're not making a real point. Higher levels should get less results from training. That's the way it's been and that's the way it should continue to be.


But now it's even slower, because it takes even longer for higher players to get less. It's *not* the same as it's been.


It doesn't matter if it's the same as it's been if it's a scale thing. It's a changing game. It's about whether it gives some and unfair advantage over others.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 16:04:59
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by Catullus 16
the other thing your missing here is the fact that i've been agreeing with you all along... and that post i made (the one you still don't understand) was actually in support of arguments you were making earlier. sheesh...

Same thing the low level players will see when they're high level players. So, you're not making a real point. Higher levels should get less results from training. That's the way it's been and that's the way it should continue to be.

excellent point against an argument i never made. look, this "conversation" will go a lot better if you abandon your starting point that anyone who dares disagree with you is automatically a moron. how about you afford me just a little respect and instead assume that i'm not going to get tripped up by blazingly obvious facts.

again, the entire point of that post was to support a point you were making earlier. so thank you for violently agreeing with me, i guess... but how about you calm down, stop typing, take a deep breath and read.

Originally posted by essteeay
But now it's even slower, because it takes even longer for higher players to get less. It's *not* the same as it's been.

exactly.
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by essteeay

Originally posted by OSU_Ed


Originally posted by Catullus 16



Originally posted by OSU_Ed




You made no valid point. You not buying FP does mean your opinions are less important. And I do have 5 players because I don't feel like creating 50 worthless players I don't boost.


here... let me try to dumb it down for ya:
- under the new system, it now takes disproportionately longer for higher-level players to see the effect of their training.

additional places where you're wrong:
- i obviously do buy FP.
- i'm fairly confident i have bought more than you.
- but even though i'm the only one between us with the right to suddenly make this a plutocracy, i'm not going to. if you have an argument to make, have it stand on its own merits... don't hide behind your self-inflated wallet.

the other thing your missing here is the fact that i've been agreeing with you all along... and that post i made (the one you still don't understand) was actually in support of arguments you were making earlier. sheesh...


Same thing the low level players will see when they're high level players. So, you're not making a real point. Higher levels should get less results from training. That's the way it's been and that's the way it should continue to be.


But now it's even slower, because it takes even longer for higher players to get less. It's *not* the same as it's been.


It doesn't matter if it's the same as it's been if it's a scale thing. It's a changing game. It's about whether it gives some and unfair advantage over others.


Dude, you JUST said "that's the way it's been and that's the way it should continue to be".

You know, I don't even know what your position is on the decimals/training bar. Why don't you lay it out for us in one short post, without any attacks or name-calling.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
And the point of FP is, you don't boost your players or buy them equipment. Why would I continue to try and figure out false statements from someone who thinks it's good logic to create more worthless players instead of making the one's he has useful.


worthless? are you referring to my laboratory of test players that i create/retire each season to test build theories? and who says i don't boost my non-test players or buy them CE?

seriously. you're so incredibly wrong here my only option is to assume that you now actually realize that fact and are desperately trying to dig yourself out of a hole. tell you what... i won't chalk this up on the scoreboard if you'll just stop embarrassing yourself.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed


It comes down to this. These 3 things should be the exact same entity:
- Fractional Points from leveling
- Fractional Points from before
- % Gained from Training

They should all be handled the exact same way. Whether it's displayed as a fraction or a bar. Whether it's counted in the sim or not.

I would vote for displaying in the bar and it counting in the sim.


 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
It's a changing game.


hey... would you look at that? ignoring the fact that you just contradicted yourself, i think you're almost to the point i was trying to make.

yes, it represents a change. so now the question is: was it a good change? compared to last season, this change disproportionately affects higher-level players (my original point).

i suppose it's worth asking: do you know what i mean by "disproportionately"? if so, then you'll recognize that i'm fully aware that lower-level players will eventually be in the same boat because these changes are across the board. so yes, every player is equally subject to the changes, but that doesn't mean that the changes affect players equally relative to how things were before the change.

which, of course, loops us back to the primary question: was it a good change?
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by essteeay
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

Originally posted by essteeay


Originally posted by OSU_Ed



Originally posted by Catullus 16




Originally posted by OSU_Ed





You made no valid point. You not buying FP does mean your opinions are less important. And I do have 5 players because I don't feel like creating 50 worthless players I don't boost.


here... let me try to dumb it down for ya:
- under the new system, it now takes disproportionately longer for higher-level players to see the effect of their training.

additional places where you're wrong:
- i obviously do buy FP.
- i'm fairly confident i have bought more than you.
- but even though i'm the only one between us with the right to suddenly make this a plutocracy, i'm not going to. if you have an argument to make, have it stand on its own merits... don't hide behind your self-inflated wallet.

the other thing your missing here is the fact that i've been agreeing with you all along... and that post i made (the one you still don't understand) was actually in support of arguments you were making earlier. sheesh...


Same thing the low level players will see when they're high level players. So, you're not making a real point. Higher levels should get less results from training. That's the way it's been and that's the way it should continue to be.


But now it's even slower, because it takes even longer for higher players to get less. It's *not* the same as it's been.


It doesn't matter if it's the same as it's been if it's a scale thing. It's a changing game. It's about whether it gives some and unfair advantage over others.


Dude, you JUST said "that's the way it's been and that's the way it should continue to be".

You know, I don't even know what your position is on the decimals/training bar. Why don't you lay it out for us in one short post, without any attacks or name-calling.


Yup, a person working out for the first time should gain more than someone who's been working out for years. It should stay the same that you gain more at lower levels. The scale of how much does not need to stay exactly the same.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
It comes down to this. These 3 things should be the exact same entity:
- Fractional Points from leveling
- Fractional Points from before
- % Gained from Training
They should all be handled the exact same way. Whether it's displayed as a fraction or a bar. Whether it's counted in the sim or not.
I would vote for displaying in the bar and it counting in the sim.


good lord, would you look at that... we agree:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1074214

way to piss on the wrong people, dude.
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

It comes down to this. These 3 things should be the exact same entity:
- Fractional Points from leveling
- Fractional Points from before
- % Gained from Training
They should all be handled the exact same way. Whether it's displayed as a fraction or a bar. Whether it's counted in the sim or not.
I would vote for displaying in the bar and it counting in the sim.


good lord, would you look at that... we agree:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1074214

way to piss on the wrong people, dude.


lol. I don't even know what's he's been arguing about.

So all three of us agree, except that I will again add that this solution makes the training bar pointless, and so we should eliminate the bar altogether.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Yup, a person working out for the first time should gain more than someone who's been working out for years. It should stay the same that you gain more at lower levels. The scale of how much does not need to stay exactly the same.


wow, do you honestly think that we don't get that? you're unbelievably arrogant.

just try this for a moment: pretend that everyone here is roughly as intelligent as you and is fully aware of all the relevant facts you're aware of. now... is it just even slightly possible that we have a point? can you step away from your ego just for a second and not automatically assume that we're confused about such an obvious fact?
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
disproportionately longer for higher-level players to see the effect of their training = lower-level players get some kind of advantage
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by essteeay
lol. I don't even know what's he's been arguing about.
So all three of us agree, except that I will again add that this solution makes the training bar pointless, and so we should eliminate the bar altogether.


yeah, i don't get it either. i try to agree with the guy and he assumes that i'm a moron... and instead of reading what i actually wrote, he somehow thinks i'm don't understand that higher skills have always gotten lower training returns than lower skills.

and yeah, now we're back to the question of what roles the training bars would play (where we were several pages ago). and, like i said before, they would be relegated to mere window-dressing... so the question becomes whether or not people like that cosmetic change. and, as i said elsewhere, i find the decimals easier to read than having to mouse-over the training bars... but to each their own greasemonkey script.

case closed?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
disproportionately longer for higher-level players to see the effect of their training = lower-level players get some kind of advantage


if you want to phrase it that way, fine... but any advantage lower-level players get would be a relative advantage (in relation to last season).
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by essteeay

lol. I don't even know what's he's been arguing about.
So all three of us agree, except that I will again add that this solution makes the training bar pointless, and so we should eliminate the bar altogether.


yeah, i don't get it either. i try to agree with the guy and he assumes that i'm a moron... and instead of reading what i actually wrote, he somehow thinks i'm don't understand that higher skills have always gotten lower training returns than lower skills.

and yeah, now we're back to the question of what roles the training bars would play (where we were several pages ago). and, like i said before, they would be relegated to mere window-dressing... so the question becomes whether or not people like that cosmetic change. and, as i said elsewhere, i find the decimals easier to read than having to mouse-over the training bars... but to each their own greasemonkey script.

case closed?


Meeting adjourned.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.