User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Announced Changes > Change to Age Based League Structures Discussion Thread
Page:
 
RufusBrutal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by JuniorV1


As far as closing exploits, choosing not to boost is not an exploit it's a choice to play how you want to.Not boosting to win games now, have more players, or simply because you can't afford to spend the money or choose not to on a game that changes as much as this one does. Boosting to make endgame and have a chance there. Just because someone spends their money boosting and I spend mine on more players or keeping my teams doesn't mean the game should be tailored to boosters


Well whether it is intentional or not, it is an exploit. There are reasons that all youth sports are segregated by age/grade up through the middle of high school. It is not until athletes are much older that age become less important .

I'll take 100 sophmore high school football or basketball teams and place them up against freshman teams from the same schools, I can promise you that most likely all of the sophomore teams will win.

Take that a step further to further extremes, last night the team I co-own played a team that is nearly 3 seasons older than us. That is the equivilant of a HS freshman team playing a 6th grade team and ridiclous that things like this have been allowed to go on for 18 seasons.



It's hilarious that you are trying to compare this game to real life.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RufusBrutal

It's hilarious that you are trying to compare this game to real life.


Glad I can amuse you.

So you think it is fair for team that are three seasons older to beat up on younger teams? Oh that's right, you don't want fair, you want an advantage or your taking your ball and going home.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B

So you think it is fair for team that are three seasons older to beat up on younger teams? Oh that's right, you don't want fair, you want an advantage or your taking your ball and going home.


I do love all the, "This new system will not be fair." arguments.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 26, 2010 16:37:22
 
JuniorV1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by JuniorV1


As far as closing exploits, choosing not to boost is not an exploit it's a choice to play how you want to.Not boosting to win games now, have more players, or simply because you can't afford to spend the money or choose not to on a game that changes as much as this one does. Boosting to make endgame and have a chance there. Just because someone spends their money boosting and I spend mine on more players or keeping my teams doesn't mean the game should be tailored to boosters


Well whether it is intentional or not, it is an exploit. There are reasons that all youth sports are segregated by age/grade up through the middle of high school. It is not until athletes are much older that age become less important .

I'll take 100 sophmore high school football or basketball teams and place them up against freshman teams from the same schools, I can promise you that most likely all of the sophomore teams will win.

Take that a step further to further extremes, last night the team I co-own played a team that is nearly 3 seasons older than us. That is the equivilant of a HS freshman team playing a 6th grade team and ridiclous that things like this have been allowed to go on for 18 seasons.


That is true but you're talking about real life and toons in a game that you choose how to build the way you want. What I'm saying is don't blame a non-booster for you choosing to build for endgame. To be honest I'm not 100% sure one way or another whether this is a good thing or not, do I think it will cure people working the system for outrageous wins or stats no. What I'm saying is pick a system and go with it I'm tired of changing the way I play every other season.

To Bigtisme once again I realize you didn't but another poster called anyone opposed to this change one and yes it was between your post and the one which you quoted of mine. I apoligize to anyone who thinks I meant they called me a vocal idiot it just really bugs me when people do that just because they don't agree with their opinion.
 
RufusBrutal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by RufusBrutal


It's hilarious that you are trying to compare this game to real life.


Glad I can amuse you.

So you think it is fair for team that are three seasons older to beat up on younger teams? Oh that's right, you don't want fair, you want an advantage or your taking your ball and going home.


So according to your logic, those on the team with the most money will have the best talent.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RufusBrutal
Originally posted by sunder B

Originally posted by RufusBrutal



It's hilarious that you are trying to compare this game to real life.


Glad I can amuse you.

So you think it is fair for team that are three seasons older to beat up on younger teams? Oh that's right, you don't want fair, you want an advantage or your taking your ball and going home.


So according to your logic, those on the team with the most money will have the best talent.

not answering your question until you answer mine. Is it fair to have teams with three full seasons more of training and bonus tokens competing againtst teams without those 3 seasons?

(I'll give you a hint, if you think it is fair you have zero credibility in this discussion)

Edit: LOL quote fail by me
Edited by sunder B on Oct 26, 2010 16:46:27
 
kb2120
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
Originally posted by sunder B


So you think it is fair for team that are three seasons older to beat up on younger teams? Oh that's right, you don't want fair, you want an advantage or your taking your ball and going home.


I do love all the, "This new system will not be fair." arguments.


For me, it isn't about fair or not It is about the players that will be left out. If you miss a boost or 2 one season or if you don't create during the offseason, you players will essentially be unwanted by any of the good teams and you will likely never have a chance for success at any of the minor league levels.
 
RufusBrutal
offline
Link
 
SP > TP
 
primetimebt
offline
Link
 
Worst idea by far. Why don't you just kill off the non boosters.?
 
baumusc
offline
Link
 
I really don't understand why you would have a minimum age limit. Am I missing something? I mean if a young player wants to play up a league what advantage is that to them? This just seems like it would make recruiting even harder than it already is because you are limiting the amount of players you can look at while recruiting by A LOT. Get rid of the minimum age requirements in my opinion. If a team wants to run in a 280 day capped league with a 220 day old player they should be allowed to. I really don't get this so I am obviously missing something because I know the powers that be at GLB always makes sense.
 
baumusc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kb2120
For me, it isn't about fair or not It is about the players that will be left out. If you miss a boost or 2 one season or if you don't create during the offseason, you players will essentially be unwanted by any of the good teams and you will likely never have a chance for success at any of the minor league levels.


I agree. I run a regular team where everyone boosts so for the most part this won't even affect us because 95% of our players were created in the same season, so I am not even talking about this as a non booster. I think this restructuring is going to kill off a lot of the player community that doesn't boost every season but for some reason I think that is what it might be meant to do. Big mistake in my opinion.
 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
life isn't fair, but dotball soon will be with all the non-boosters put in their place. Hooray for Bort.
 
Boogie21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
As far as my calculations go, and I may be way off, there will be at least 4-6 leagues for every age group. These are for Much older groups of players.

League#1 All Boost All the time. w/Top game planning

League#2 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#3 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#4 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#5 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#6-7 Bottom of the barrel: CPUs: Newbs: slowly shrinking til it is eliminated.


Who decides what a good build is? Just asking.
Edited by Boogie21 on Oct 26, 2010 17:45:43
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by baumusc
I really don't understand why you would have a minimum age limit. Am I missing something?


No.

With no reason to rot a player, or the need to have a place to train up a Boosting Dot, there is no reason to have restrictions any longer. A full time booster will be wanted everywhere, even if building for season 11.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boogie21
Who decides what a good build is? Just asking.


Bort and his sim.

Your team record will show you how well your OC/DC and player building is going.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 26, 2010 17:47:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.