User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
No, I see it the numbers behind it completely. I did think that -5% was harsh for 480+, I didn't think the freezing decline was because those players got to keep their BT's and Training in their builds.

Even if ALL the math now evens out and I do understand that the 480 dots just had their 1st season of decline early...you think it's fair that a 479 dot who's been in the WL at lvl 74 for an entire season has his decline halved (which is = to what he gained through BT's and training TBH) gets 3 seasons of that frozen in time. While a 439 dot will stop training and getting BT's for 3 seasons from day 440?

Assuming that all of the numbers = out as far as value....you understand the 479 dot has a 1 season "play time" advtantage at the highest lvl vs. the 439 dot, right? that's my issue.

This ENTIRE argument was constructed by dominant teams with dominant 440-479 dots to make sure they could keep them at the top one extra season. They complained, Bort listened...that's my only problem.

Jrry, I'm not even debating the %'s..just the timing.

Look...two players..

1)

Creation day 4/49 enters WL in season 16 at 439 days old. he plays in World League season 16. end of season 16 he is 479 days old. His decline is halved which we now all agree = his training and BT's he accumulated over that one season. He is then frozen in time Season 17,18,19...and starts declining again in season 20. So he stayed in WL 4 seasons

2) Creation day 5/49 enters WL in season 17 at 439 days old. He plays in WL season 18,19,20 and then starts declining in 21.

According to all arguments the penalties now fit the crime, right? the problem is that dot 1 just played at the top of the game for 4 seasons (16,17,18,19) and dot 2 played there only 3 seasons (18,19,20). get it?

I honestly didn't care about the penalty %'s at all, but this entire argument in my eyes was to make sure that the existing top dots don't get an extra season at the highest level cuz it's not fair to everybody else. big surprise, everybody who argued for this new change has a selfish reason to do so. The vocal WL'ers have Borts ear for the most part and it gone done and honestly, it's a big FU to everybody that isn't them.

That's my real problem with this, the fact that they are allowed 3 seasons of plateau still and their penalty basically only deducts the gains they got through the extra training. Not cool.


You STILL don't get it...you restart getting vet points and training points after the extended plateau, so season 6 dots will be able to stay on top for an extra season after the extended plateau, while season 5 guys will have to retire, since they will go back to their 5% decline...

I didn't know this was so complicated.......
 
BP
offline
Link
 
anyway..in a few seasons this will all = itself out so I'm done with this thread fellas.....I don't think anything I've ever stated has really had any GLB effect except for suggesting those little stars next to the majors on your player page *pops collar*. I'm out cuz I have beer to drink...enjoy the rest of season 16 guys.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
anyway..in a few seasons this will all = itself out so I'm done with this thread fellas.....I don't think anything I've ever stated has really had any GLB effect except for suggesting those little stars next to the majors on your player page *pops collar*. I'm out cuz I have beer to drink...enjoy the rest of season 16 guys.


lol, that stars thing was a sweet idea. It's really helpful, since i can never remember which are the majors. Way better than the people who suggest gut reaction ideas without thinking them through and cause "small changes," which will force an entire season of dots to retire.

Anyway, I hope you understand that season 6 dots will be able to play their first season of decline at WL since they will get vet points and bonus tokens again, while season 5 dots will have to retire hte second the platea hits.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
No, I see it the numbers behind it completely. I did think that -5% was harsh for 480+, I didn't think the freezing decline was because those players got to keep their BT's and Training in their builds.

Even if ALL the math now evens out and I do understand that the 480 dots just had their 1st season of decline early...you think it's fair that a 479 dot who's been in the WL at lvl 74 for an entire season has his decline halved (which is = to what he gained through BT's and training TBH) gets 3 seasons of that frozen in time. While a 439 dot will stop training and getting BT's for 3 seasons from day 440?

Assuming that all of the numbers = out as far as value....you understand the 479 dot has a 1 season "play time" advtantage at the highest lvl vs. the 439 dot, right? that's my issue.

This ENTIRE argument was constructed by dominant teams with dominant 440-479 dots to make sure they could keep them at the top one extra season. They complained, Bort listened...that's my only problem.

Jrry, I'm not even debating the %'s..just the timing.

Look...two players..

1)

Creation day 4/49 enters WL in season 16 at 439 days old. he plays in World League season 16. end of season 16 he is 479 days old. His decline is halved which we now all agree = his training and BT's he accumulated over that one season. He is then frozen in time Season 17,18,19...and starts declining again in season 20. So he stayed in WL 4 seasons

I sure as hell don't agree that's CLOSE to equal to his training and BTs, if you could do the math. You'd agree. Also, he plays in the WL for 4 seasons 16 at a decline of 0-5%, 17, 18 and 19. So yep, 4 seasons.

2) Creation day 5/49 enters WL in season 17 at 439 days old. He plays in WL season 18,19,20 and then starts declining in 21.

He plays in the WL in S17, S18, S19 and S20 at a 0-5% decline...that's also 4 seasons.

According to all arguments the penalties now fit the crime, right? the problem is that dot 1 just played at the top of the game for 4 seasons (16,17,18,19) and dot 2 played there only 3 seasons (18,19,20). get it?

You left out S17, you are wrong, get it?

I honestly didn't care about the penalty %'s at all, but this entire argument in my eyes was to make sure that the existing top dots don't get an extra season at the highest level cuz it's not fair to everybody else. big surprise, everybody who argued for this new change has a selfish reason to do so. The vocal WL'ers have Borts ear for the most part and it gone done and honestly, it's a big FU to everybody that isn't them.

That's my real problem with this, the fact that they are allowed 3 seasons of plateau still and their penalty basically only deducts the gains they got through the extra training. Not cool.


I don't think you get it. You just laid out how you are WRONG. Read the bold.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
You STILL don't get it...you restart getting vet points and training points after the extended plateau, so season 6 dots will be able to stay on top for an extra season after the extended plateau, while season 5 guys will have to retire, since they will go back to their 5% decline...

I didn't know this was so complicated.......


Maybe I don't. Guess 1280 SAT's, a college degree from UC IRvine with Honors and 4 years running my own successful small business isn't smarts enough to understand on Online Football Sim

Guess I'll just shut up and let you geniuses figure things out..
 
GregB
offline
Link
 
Funny in a game played principally by males, that there would be so much whining and crying....
Funny, in a game around for so much time, that a change would be be made that is so obviously made for financial reasons...
Funny, that this game....this entity, and those that run it, have no vision and no foresight to where or how to take their game and instead change the game based upon the pulse of a few repetitively negative people who care only in how this change affects them in their pursuit for a trophy that has no real value to them, other than in E peen measurement.

This game, had so much promise, it took what was the best of role playing and meshed it with a great game in a beautiful sim.
People paid lots to move their alter-egos along, and its still plenty of fun to share the team aspect.

I truly hope that those that run this game put together a business plan and learn to stick to it, and not always be ruled by the squeaky wheels.
Edited by GregB on Jun 26, 2010 13:28:24
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Originally posted by nyfoot2003

You STILL don't get it...you restart getting vet points and training points after the extended plateau, so season 6 dots will be able to stay on top for an extra season after the extended plateau, while season 5 guys will have to retire, since they will go back to their 5% decline...

I didn't know this was so complicated.......


Maybe I don't. Guess 1280 SAT's, a college degree from UC IRvine with Honors and 4 years running my own successful small business isn't smarts enough to understand on Online Football Sim

Guess I'll just shut up and let you geniuses figure things out..


That would probably be best as you have demonstrated you don't understand what is going on.
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GregB
Funny in a game played principally by males, that there would be so much whining and crying....
Funny, in a game around for so much time, that a change would be be made that is so obviously made for financial reasons...
Funny, that this game....this entity, and those that run it, have no vision and no foresight to where or how to take their game and instead change the game based upon the pulse of a few repetitively negative people who care only in how this change affects them in their pursuit for a trophy that has no real value to them, other than in E peen measurement.

This game, had so much promise, it took what was the best of role playing and meshed it with a great game in a beautiful sim.
People made lots to move their alter-egos along, and its still plenty of fun to share the team aspect.

I truly hope that those that run this game put together a business plan and learn to stick to it, and not always be ruled by the squeaky wheels.


Amen
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Maybe I don't. Guess 1280 SAT's, a college degree from UC IRvine with Honors and 4 years running my own successful small business isn't smarts enough to understand on Online Football Sim

Guess I'll just shut up and let you geniuses figure things out..


Yes, please stick to reading comprehension and basic algebra.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
BTW...#2 should only have the 439 dot at 3 seasons...he plays 17,18,19 and then declines at 20...so I'm not wrong, it was a typo and that's obvious but yeah, whatever...lol
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
BTW...#2 should only have the 439 dot at 3 seasons...he plays 17,18,19 and then declines at 20...so I'm not wrong, it was a typo and that's obvious but yeah, whatever...lol


You are wrong. Let me lay this out for you again:
480 dots(S5) JUST PLAYED THIS ENTIRE SEASON IN THE WL WITH A 0-5% DECLINE. Are you attempting to say that S6 dots cannot? They have every ability to, it just depends on if teams want them(are they well built enough).
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 26, 2010 13:30:59
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
Yes, please stick to reading comprehension and basic algebra.


lol...funny, I lay a whole argument out and the same shills who are trying to convince people they just didn't get an advantage take one typo and tell me I'm wrong.

I'm not, you guys are TRANSPARENT....lol

Don't personally insult me BTW, if we met face to face you wouldn't say a thing...go play WOW or Red Dead Redemption little boy.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
BTW...#2 should only have the 439 dot at 3 seasons...he plays 17,18,19 and then declines at 20...so I'm not wrong, it was a typo and that's obvious but yeah, whatever...lol


He gets to play in the decline season. Season 20 is playable, since he will once again start to get training points and vet points.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Originally posted by nyfoot2003

Yes, please stick to reading comprehension and basic algebra.


lol...funny, I lay a whole argument out and the same shills who are trying to convince people they just didn't get an advantage take one typo and tell me I'm wrong.

I'm not, you guys are TRANSPARENT....lol

Don't personally insult me BTW, if we met face to face you wouldn't say a thing...go play WOW or Red Dead Redemption little boy.


You lay out a flawed argument lacking reasoning and math then you expect people won't tear it apart? lol BP, I really don't know how you haven't grasped what I am saying yet.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
lol...funny, I lay a whole argument out and the same shills who are trying to convince people they just didn't get an advantage take one typo and tell me I'm wrong.

I'm not, you guys are TRANSPARENT....lol

Don't personally insult me BTW, if we met face to face you wouldn't say a thing...go play WOW or Red Dead Redemption little boy.


Um, i wasn't. I was just kidding cause you said you got a 1280 on the SATs, which is basic algebra and reading comprehension. I don't care about typos or anything like that. It was nothing personal.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.