Originally posted by BP
No, I see it the numbers behind it completely. I did think that -5% was harsh for 480+, I didn't think the freezing decline was because those players got to keep their BT's and Training in their builds.
Even if ALL the math now evens out and I do understand that the 480 dots just had their 1st season of decline early...you think it's fair that a 479 dot who's been in the WL at lvl 74 for an entire season has his decline halved (which is = to what he gained through BT's and training TBH) gets 3 seasons of that frozen in time. While a 439 dot will stop training and getting BT's for 3 seasons from day 440?
Assuming that all of the numbers = out as far as value....you understand the 479 dot has a 1 season "play time" advtantage at the highest lvl vs. the 439 dot, right? that's my issue.
This ENTIRE argument was constructed by dominant teams with dominant 440-479 dots to make sure they could keep them at the top one extra season. They complained, Bort listened...that's my only problem.
Jrry, I'm not even debating the %'s..just the timing.
Look...two players..
1)
Creation day 4/49 enters WL in season 16 at 439 days old. he plays in World League season 16. end of season 16 he is 479 days old. His decline is halved which we now all agree = his training and BT's he accumulated over that one season. He is then frozen in time Season 17,18,19...and starts declining again in season 20. So he stayed in WL 4 seasons
2) Creation day 5/49 enters WL in season 17 at 439 days old. He plays in WL season 18,19,20 and then starts declining in 21.
According to all arguments the penalties now fit the crime, right? the problem is that dot 1 just played at the top of the game for 4 seasons (16,17,18,19) and dot 2 played there only 3 seasons (18,19,20). get it?
I honestly didn't care about the penalty %'s at all, but this entire argument in my eyes was to make sure that the existing top dots don't get an extra season at the highest level cuz it's not fair to everybody else. big surprise, everybody who argued for this new change has a selfish reason to do so. The vocal WL'ers have Borts ear for the most part and it gone done and honestly, it's a big FU to everybody that isn't them.
That's my real problem with this, the fact that they are allowed 3 seasons of plateau still and their penalty basically only deducts the gains they got through the extra training. Not cool.
You STILL don't get it...you restart getting vet points and training points after the extended plateau, so season 6 dots will be able to stay on top for an extra season after the extended plateau, while season 5 guys will have to retire, since they will go back to their 5% decline...
I didn't know this was so complicated.......
No, I see it the numbers behind it completely. I did think that -5% was harsh for 480+, I didn't think the freezing decline was because those players got to keep their BT's and Training in their builds.
Even if ALL the math now evens out and I do understand that the 480 dots just had their 1st season of decline early...you think it's fair that a 479 dot who's been in the WL at lvl 74 for an entire season has his decline halved (which is = to what he gained through BT's and training TBH) gets 3 seasons of that frozen in time. While a 439 dot will stop training and getting BT's for 3 seasons from day 440?
Assuming that all of the numbers = out as far as value....you understand the 479 dot has a 1 season "play time" advtantage at the highest lvl vs. the 439 dot, right? that's my issue.
This ENTIRE argument was constructed by dominant teams with dominant 440-479 dots to make sure they could keep them at the top one extra season. They complained, Bort listened...that's my only problem.
Jrry, I'm not even debating the %'s..just the timing.
Look...two players..
1)
Creation day 4/49 enters WL in season 16 at 439 days old. he plays in World League season 16. end of season 16 he is 479 days old. His decline is halved which we now all agree = his training and BT's he accumulated over that one season. He is then frozen in time Season 17,18,19...and starts declining again in season 20. So he stayed in WL 4 seasons
2) Creation day 5/49 enters WL in season 17 at 439 days old. He plays in WL season 18,19,20 and then starts declining in 21.
According to all arguments the penalties now fit the crime, right? the problem is that dot 1 just played at the top of the game for 4 seasons (16,17,18,19) and dot 2 played there only 3 seasons (18,19,20). get it?
I honestly didn't care about the penalty %'s at all, but this entire argument in my eyes was to make sure that the existing top dots don't get an extra season at the highest level cuz it's not fair to everybody else. big surprise, everybody who argued for this new change has a selfish reason to do so. The vocal WL'ers have Borts ear for the most part and it gone done and honestly, it's a big FU to everybody that isn't them.
That's my real problem with this, the fact that they are allowed 3 seasons of plateau still and their penalty basically only deducts the gains they got through the extra training. Not cool.
You STILL don't get it...you restart getting vet points and training points after the extended plateau, so season 6 dots will be able to stay on top for an extra season after the extended plateau, while season 5 guys will have to retire, since they will go back to their 5% decline...
I didn't know this was so complicated.......






























