User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brutus Buckeye
This has turned into the biggest cluster F* I have ever seen. WOW People see conspiracy around every corner.

Bort and the testers I commend you for trying to do things right.


Thank you for your Mod/Admin/Tester application. It will be reviewed at a later time. Thanks again for applying.
 
Mithra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by LordEvil

I was wondering when someone would bring up the fact that testers now have an advantage using the defensive play creator that many others do not have. Uh advantage much?


But people aren't setting up clone teams of their own team, and trying to figure out how to utilize the D play creator.

They are trying wacky overload formations and such, trying to find EXPLOITS before they happen live. Then, Bort fixes it. A LOT of the testing is being done with CPU players or players with very strange builds to find exploits there.


Why didn't you explain this pages ago, if this is correct?
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by Mindfreak


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Catullus 16




Originally posted by Bort





- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.


We dont words like "sorta" coming out of the main person's mouth.


Good thing he followed it up with more words that helped to further explain the situation.



Good thing some of the testers said they can adjust builds.


No need for flippancy, I was taking issue with that particular gripe.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mithra
Originally posted by Bort

- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


This is not what has been described by at least one person who said they were a tester. What was described was the ability to make players. Could you explain the discrepancy?

Testing is a good thing. Transparency is a good thing. A transparent and full explanation of the testing that was done and how it was done will, IMO, quiet most people's concerns. Your post here and some of Thorn's info would have been good starts if they had been revealed beforehand


Last edited Feb 13, 2009 18:42:16
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Catullus 16


Originally posted by Bort



- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by DrkSandman


Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 18:42:34
 
Skeptikal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Brutus Buckeye

This has turned into the biggest cluster F* I have ever seen. WOW People see conspiracy around every corner.

Bort and the testers I commend you for trying to do things right.


Thank you for your Mod/Admin/Tester application. It will be reviewed at a later time. Thanks again for applying.


 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


It wouldn't work. The question is why is the information gleaned from this testing kept secret from the rest of the paying userbase?
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mithra
Originally posted by DrkSandman

Originally posted by LordEvil


I was wondering when someone would bring up the fact that testers now have an advantage using the defensive play creator that many others do not have. Uh advantage much?


But people aren't setting up clone teams of their own team, and trying to figure out how to utilize the D play creator.

They are trying wacky overload formations and such, trying to find EXPLOITS before they happen live. Then, Bort fixes it. A LOT of the testing is being done with CPU players or players with very strange builds to find exploits there.


Why didn't you explain this pages ago, if this is correct?


To clarify. They CAN'T do this. Or they AREN'T doing this. Because there is a big difference. And if the answer is AREN'T how do you know? And hopefully the answer isn't "because they are upstanding members of the GLB community who would never try to take advantage of this situation"
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Catullus 16



Originally posted by Bort




- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


I see no issue with this, if an exploit is found by a tester it is fixed so the testers arent really getting an advantage
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by jamz

Originally posted by DrkSandman



Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.

He fiddles while rome burns

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Bort



Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


It wouldn't work. The question is why is the information gleaned from this testing kept secret from the rest of the paying userbase?


Because nothing has been found yet that can be used?
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Catullus 16




Originally posted by Bort





- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


I see no issue with this, if an exploit is found by a tester it is fixed so the testers arent really getting an advantage


+1
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by jamz

Originally posted by DrkSandman



Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?

/sarcasm


Curiousity, I already know of 2. I could care less either way we went 8-8. It's just interesting to me is all. PM me if you like, I'm not implying anything.


Oh, I know bro. But, as Bort said - releasing the names of the testers right now would just lead to flaming, massive PMs, etc.

Which, is really shitty because I'm telling you that some of these guys have been busting their asses to do good for the game.

That's why I'm so irritated. I understand people's concerns, but they really have nothing to worry about.


I agree 100%. Some of the guys involved have really been putting in a lot of time and effort to try and help me out as I try different stuff, and I really don't want to see them get dumped on.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Catullus 16



Originally posted by Bort




- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.



Sorta? Yes or no. Can testers build or adjust players?


Yes, we can create player prototypes to add them to test teams. Hmm...let's see. Somehow we are supposed to test the game without being able to create players and know what their abilities are? How in the heck would that work?


You are missing the point. No one has issues with testing. Its who is testing and what knowledge they can gain. Is that really so hard to understand?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.