User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Season 4 is over! What's in store for season 5 and beyond?
Page:
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Ok, my thoughts on the "limited intense training choices" :

I don't like em.... they seem entirely too random.
I'd much prefer either Players got to choose any combination they wanted, or that the list was developed in a way that didn't appear random.

Combinations that are clearly missing from a "limited" list:

Speed+Stamina
Agility+Confidence
Jumping+Tackling
Stamina+Confidence
Stamina+Carrying
Confidence+Catching
Kicking+Punting

Combinations that should be Deleted:

Confidence+Carrying
Confidence+Vision
Agility+Stamina

Originally posted by
The end result would look like:

Strength: Jumping, Blocking, Throwing
Speed : Agility, Tackling, Stamina
Agility : Speed, Blocking, Confidence
Jumping : Strength, Tackling, Vision
Stamina : Speed, Carrying, Confidence
Vision : Jumping, Throwing, Kicking, Punting
Confidence : Agility, Catching, Stamina

Blocking : Strength, Agility
Tackling : Speed, Jumping
Throwing : Strength, Vision
Catching : Confidence, Carrying
Carrying : Stamina, Catching
Kicking : Vision, Punting
Punting : Vision, Kicking


It isn't about having all choices possible - it's about making the choices that are available - balanced... atleast in some fashion. This list would be aesthetically pleasing, if nothing else.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rocomo
Originally posted by Llyranwyar

Originally posted by FBGProfessor


I agree. There were alot of ideas about items and this seems like the wrong way to go. Don't mind that players can buy items--but why turn it into RPG? Are there really that many kids playing the game? I would guess the core of people care more about being able to choose which side to run the ball.

The Rich Get Richer aspect is also a serious problem--there are so many ways in which the game does this and in the long run, you will lose owners and players when people realize they have no chance to compete. The success of a game like this, like the NFL, is parity. Parity also means that skill in tactics becomes decisive. We are moving further and further away from that IMO.

Originally posted by pumph



Originally posted by easycheez



current item

White Shirt
Basic white undershirt.
+2 blocking

what's the difference in being able to shop for it now and having to wait?




I'm okay with the changes but I'm saddened that the emphasis is on the RPG 'one game boost' items and not the ability to play call. I think that people with football knowledge should be able to actually create plays (to an extent) so that a grown-man with play calling know-how can outplay a 14-year old kid that has players with tons of boosting items.




AMEN.




AMEN.

One thing I liked about this game is that it was fresh and completely different from the RPG MMO's. It was browser sport MMO. I read the new introductions and my heart sunk. I remember thinking OMG Bort introduced "POTTING" into a athletic MMO. WTF. Then there are the special +1 stat items. It made me sick to think about having to get your 'blues'and 'Purples' for a starting position on the raid, I mean team. Don't try to be W.O.W.-sports.

I really think Bort should have been spending his time more wisely by increasing the flexibility and detail in plays and ironing out some old problems. I am assuming that most people who own teams and GM get far more enjoyment in developing their strategies and rosters to complement their play styles. Allowing players to customize their play styles further would only enrich the game.

Applying his energy toward figuring out how to 'grease the wheels' for promotion and relegations would have been a much better use of his time than revamping training. Training was useful and practical no matter what take you have on it. Despite your opinion on slow-building, the training aspect wasn't dragging the game down like the competition levels in leagues.

While there is room and perhaps demand for things like 'locker room' attributes, that is really just bells and whistles. More focus needs to be paid attention to the heart of the game and making that better first. Adding the 'everything else' in too soon will detract from the game. Its already hard enough for people to field teams, based on the experience of some friends. Really, isn't the 'locker room' attributes really the mentality of the agent behind the player? You already have the field general abilities in place.

I just think there is too much emphasis being placed on the periphery of the game before the play on the field has been worked out. Let the agents, GM's, and Owners create the drama through good competion and smack talk. If you keep upsetting the apple cart and force people to relearn aspects of the game every season, they're going to become disenchated and quit.





My opinion as well. I don't like the path this is heading. Won't be quitting the game over it by any stretch, as it's only one thing I dislike (besides the numerous old bugs and problems that still exist in the game). Such as:

- miserable clock management within 2 minutes.
- punters reported stats : broken since season 1 (and no inside the 20 stat?)
- economic reform this game so sorely needs
- gutting issue ( we really need more promoting/relegating teams, for competitiveness sake).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Ok, my thoughts on the "limited intense training choices" :

I don't like em.... they seem entirely too random.
I'd much prefer either Players got to choose any combination they wanted, or that the list was developed in a way that didn't appear random.

Combinations that are clearly missing from a "limited" list:

Speed+Stamina
Agility+Confidence
Jumping+Tackling
Stamina+Confidence
Stamina+Carrying
Confidence+Catching
Kicking+Punting

Combinations that should be Deleted:

Confidence+Carrying
Confidence+Vision
Agility+Stamina

Originally posted by

The end result would look like:

Strength: Jumping, Blocking, Throwing
Speed : Agility, Tackling, Stamina
Agility : Speed, Blocking, Confidence
Jumping : Strength, Tackling, Vision
Stamina : Speed, Carrying, Confidence
Vision : Jumping, Throwing, Kicking, Punting
Confidence : Agility, Catching, Stamina

Blocking : Strength, Agility
Tackling : Speed, Jumping
Throwing : Strength, Vision
Catching : Confidence, Carrying
Carrying : Stamina, Catching
Kicking : Vision, Punting
Punting : Vision, Kicking


It isn't about having all choices possible - it's about making the choices that are available - balanced... atleast in some fashion. This list would be aesthetically pleasing, if nothing else.


Just to expand with one that I would like to see, Tackling + Strength.
 
DirtyMouse
offline
Link
 
I am absolutely disappointed in the training choices listed for intense! With my current players I can only see my punter using intense training. If I had a kicker he would benefit from it also.
 
blitzerdog
offline
Link
 
So if 40*2=80/5= 16 Bonus Tokens per season, isn't that equal to 4 Skill points? So you could have 3 and 4/5's of a boost which over time adds up to a few extra boosts over 5 seasons. Which adds to the disparity between boosted and unboosted players. Which leads to more players leaving cause people are too good to compete. I guess the only positive I see is that the level 35 players are already 4 seasons into the old training, and can get only 12 and 4/5 extra boosts out of it instead of someone starting in S5 day 0 who can get a max of 16 extra boosts out of it. The proportion doesn't seem to work for the model. 64 and 80 don't make much of a difference. 304 and 380 do however. Those are the max points for someone who boosts(ed) 3 times a season for 16 and 20 seasons. Assuming that people have been here since Season 1. I'm going to list the possibility for 3xboosters per season. Tell me if something is wrong.


S1=304-30=274
S2=323-30=393
S3=342-30=312
S4=361-30=331
S5=380-30=350
The minus30 is for peak years

Maybe it will work but with the current algorithum set at +19 per season. It would take a while for the actual changes to be seen. This is all assuming the player's lifespan is set to 20 seasons.





 
seirus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Ok, my thoughts on the "limited intense training choices" :

I don't like em.... they seem entirely too random.
I'd much prefer either Players got to choose any combination they wanted, or that the list was developed in a way that didn't appear random.

Combinations that are clearly missing from a "limited" list:

Speed+Stamina
Agility+Confidence
Jumping+Tackling
Stamina+Confidence
Stamina+Carrying
Confidence+Catching
Kicking+Punting

Combinations that should be Deleted:

Confidence+Carrying
Confidence+Vision
Agility+Stamina

Originally posted by


The end result would look like:

Strength: Jumping, Blocking, Throwing
Speed : Agility, Tackling, Stamina
Agility : Speed, Blocking, Confidence
Jumping : Strength, Tackling, Vision
Stamina : Speed, Carrying, Confidence
Vision : Jumping, Throwing, Kicking, Punting
Confidence : Agility, Catching, Stamina

Blocking : Strength, Agility
Tackling : Speed, Jumping
Throwing : Strength, Vision
Catching : Confidence, Carrying
Carrying : Stamina, Catching
Kicking : Vision, Punting
Punting : Vision, Kicking


Coming from a college running back Vision and Confidence are extemely connected with each other, especially if you want to get in specifics such as zone running schemes and the such. But yeah, those two stats do go together.
 
drewd21
offline
Link
 
Can't say i'm overly impressed with all the new training stuff.

"Go shopping"..."night out on the town".....not really why i play this game but i suppose someone has to keep the kids happy

I feel sorry for people who have a lot of players to keep a check on, now that training has become so complicated....i mean when are you supposed to find time to run a team when keeping your players training regime up is so complicated?

Oh well
 
Landry Skins
Skinny Laundry
offline
Link
 
i agree. This will give an advantage to lower level players at the moment.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seirus

Coming from a college running back Vision and Confidence are extemely connected with each other, especially if you want to get in specifics such as zone running schemes and the such. But yeah, those two stats do go together.


I wasn't working with what "go together" because, in all reality, just about any 2 things should "go together"... probably strength and agility is the only combination I can't think of a training program to cover...

My list was based purely upon balancing the choices so that each attribute had a balanced number of choices.... and Primarily in ways that would fit patterns. My list is absolutely beautiful when looked at from a perspective of seeking patterns - cause it is full of them.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

Smoke and Mirrors Activated? Check.

Target 90% of players confused? Check.

Remaining 10% pretending to understand? Check

Money still rolling in?? GLB - we have a problem. The WoW kids don't seem to have the same disposable income as the previous adult players............

Shit - we need to activate 'Smoke and Mirrors' Phase II .................



Bitter and Jaded? Check.

Complaint but not constructive? Check.

Common theme or 1VB posts? Check.

Anything else? Thanks!


Tried to give suggestions in the past - lots of them, in a constructive manner? Check.

Experienced Beta tester who knows that this game isn't being beta tested? Check

Keep highlighting exploits that are/have been used by mods/alpha testers/senior players, yet get ignored by admins? Check

Simply asking for the BASIC problems within the core mechanics of the game to be addressed before even more complications are added? Check

There is a common theme to my posts Bort - that being that I seem to care more about the actual BASICS of this 'simulation' than all the bolt on stuff that keeps getting added. I aslo care that this place is, just like any other game, rife with people who cheat the f**k out of the game and you simply don't seem to care - as long as they're paying money, you seem to allow them to screw the game (and therefor other paying customers) over

You can keep adding lots of smokescreens to keep the kids happy, but I'd suggest you pay more attention to the adult opinions too - as there seems to be quite a groundswell who are seriously reconsidering whether they're going to continue to fund this little experiment.

You promised a football MMORPG. I think the consensus is that the football element is looking more and more like an afterthought.

I don't think I'm the only one who'd say that, as a football MMORPG, this game has immense promise - but as just another MMORPG, this game is too buggy, too random, too secretive and just too expensive.

As I've said all along Bort - this is your game to do with as you wish - but if it were my livelihood on the line, I wouldn't be so flippant with it........
 
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Tried to give suggestions in the past - lots of them, in a constructive manner? Check.

Experienced Beta tester who knows that this game isn't being beta tested? Check

Keep highlighting exploits that are/have been used by mods/alpha testers/senior players, yet get ignored by admins? Check

Simply asking for the BASIC problems within the core mechanics of the game to be addressed before even more complications are added? Check

There is a common theme to my posts Bort - that being that I seem to care more about the actual BASICS of this 'simulation' than all the bolt on stuff that keeps getting added. I aslo care that this place is, just like any other game, rife with people who cheat the f**k out of the game and you simply don't seem to care - as long as they're paying money, you seem to allow them to screw the game (and therefor other paying customers) over

You can keep adding lots of smokescreens to keep the kids happy, but I'd suggest you pay more attention to the adult opinions too - as there seems to be quite a groundswell who are seriously reconsidering whether they're going to continue to fund this little experiment.

You promised a football MMORPG. I think the consensus is that the football element is looking more and more like an afterthought.

I don't think I'm the only one who'd say that, as a football MMORPG, this game has immense promise - but as just another MMORPG, this game is too buggy, too random, too secretive and just too expensive.

As I've said all along Bort - this is your game to do with as you wish - but if it were my livelihood on the line, I wouldn't be so flippant with it........


This is about how all of USA AAA #2 feels. Why spend our money on this anymore when changes are going to randomly happen mid-season without warning? Why should we care about this game when it appears that the real problems aren't going to be addressed? I, like many others, plan on retiring players until they are all gone because I refuse to pay another dime to play this game until some real changes are being made.
 
MLA
offline
Link
 
Seems an unnecessary level of complication that is going to disadvantage all of those who enjoyed the simplicity. I agree with some of Chaos's sentiments in that I'm here because I want to MMO some football. If I want to RPG then you'll find me on WAR very soon. I'd much rather effort was expended on making the game work more like a simplified Front Office Football style sim instead of adding role playing elements.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

-There is a common theme to my posts Bort - that being that I seem to care more about the actual BASICS of this 'simulation' than all the bolt on stuff that keeps getting added.

-You can keep adding lots of smokescreens to keep the kids happy, but I'd suggest you pay more attention to the adult opinions too - as there seems to be quite a groundswell who are seriously reconsidering whether they're going to continue to fund this little experiment.

-You promised a football MMORPG. I think the consensus is that the football element is looking more and more like an afterthought.

-I don't think I'm the only one who'd say that, as a football MMORPG, this game has immense promise - but as just another MMORPG, this game is too buggy, too random, too secretive and just too expensive.


-Agreed. The sim should take precidence over all the add-ons. The fact that the big announcement this offseason wasn't improving the AI's or the gameplay, but instead about some add-ons that replace a system that wasn't broken and do nothing more then make things more complicated and distract people from the real issues is beyond sad, it's dissappointing.

-Agreed. I don't know exactly how much I have spent in this game, I could take an educated guess to say $400+ since Season 1, but the more the game keeps changing, and the less it gets better is starting to make me wonder if it is worth my investing money into it. I for one am not bought in by flashy gadgets so these new add-ons are useless to me. I have one more season of FP to buy and after that I have no promises to any teams, and can decide whether or not to continue funding Borts whims.

-Agreed. The football part of the game seems to slowly be becoming the secondary purpose of this. The sims now take a back seat to all th flashy add-ons and it's saddening.

-Agreed. The game has much promise, and I've enjoyed every season leading to this one... But now it seems like the game I've invested my time and energy in has taken a turn for the worse (like Star Wars Galaxies).

What bothers me the most is the overall apathy Bort displays for this. He doesn't care. He's throwing out all these crappy additions and seems completely unmoved by the fact that the sim is still not reaching its potential. I didn't believe those screaming "all Bort cares about is money" until these last two seasons where it seems he's more interested in distracting people and bringing in money then fixing anything.

Further, and this bothers me a lot too, Bort seems completely against unique builds. I mean, every time someone comes up with a unique build (pure speed, pure strength, pure agility, etc) or a unique way of building players (slowbuilding) Bort runs in and nerfs or eliminates it so people won't complain that their shitty "balanced" players aren't gods. He seems more interested in making sure everyone has the same build so no one can complain about supposed exploits then allowing realism into the game.
 
drewd21
offline
Link
 
I am tending to agree with what Chaos and Grim Truth are saying. Surely this off season Bort would have been better improving the AI rather than changing something that was not broken
 
Hobo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by 1VBChaos


-There is a common theme to my posts Bort - that being that I seem to care more about the actual BASICS of this 'simulation' than all the bolt on stuff that keeps getting added.

-You can keep adding lots of smokescreens to keep the kids happy, but I'd suggest you pay more attention to the adult opinions too - as there seems to be quite a groundswell who are seriously reconsidering whether they're going to continue to fund this little experiment.

-You promised a football MMORPG. I think the consensus is that the football element is looking more and more like an afterthought.

-I don't think I'm the only one who'd say that, as a football MMORPG, this game has immense promise - but as just another MMORPG, this game is too buggy, too random, too secretive and just too expensive.


-Agreed. The sim should take precidence over all the add-ons. The fact that the big announcement this offseason wasn't improving the AI's or the gameplay, but instead about some add-ons that replace a system that wasn't broken and do nothing more then make things more complicated and distract people from the real issues is beyond sad, it's dissappointing.

-Agreed. I don't know exactly how much I have spent in this game, I could take an educated guess to say $400+ since Season 1, but the more the game keeps changing, and the less it gets better is starting to make me wonder if it is worth my investing money into it. I for one am not bought in by flashy gadgets so these new add-ons are useless to me. I have one more season of FP to buy and after that I have no promises to any teams, and can decide whether or not to continue funding Borts whims.

-Agreed. The football part of the game seems to slowly be becoming the secondary purpose of this. The sims now take a back seat to all th flashy add-ons and it's saddening.

-Agreed. The game has much promise, and I've enjoyed every season leading to this one... But now it seems like the game I've invested my time and energy in has taken a turn for the worse (like Star Wars Galaxies).

What bothers me the most is the overall apathy Bort displays for this. He doesn't care. He's throwing out all these crappy additions and seems completely unmoved by the fact that the sim is still not reaching its potential. I didn't believe those screaming "all Bort cares about is money" until these last two seasons where it seems he's more interested in distracting people and bringing in money then fixing anything.

Further, and this bothers me a lot too, Bort seems completely against unique builds. I mean, every time someone comes up with a unique build (pure speed, pure strength, pure agility, etc) or a unique way of building players (slowbuilding) Bort runs in and nerfs or eliminates it so people won't complain that their shitty "balanced" players aren't gods. He seems more interested in making sure everyone has the same build so no one can complain about supposed exploits then allowing realism into the game.


wow..i strongly agree with how its very disappointing that the sim is taking a back seat. a true mechanic builds the engine 1st then puts on the bells and whistles.

HOWEVER
this is still a beta game and its could be cheaper if we all just had 1 player lolz.
also a season here isnt 16 weeks so worst case scenario is that season 6 he tweaks the crap outta the sim/ai?
just sayin take it easy on the dude this game is pretty sweet. its just still in its baby form and we all know that.

AND WE NEED A CHAT BOX/ROOM OF SOME SORT. LIVE TIME WOULD BE SUCH A HELP TO GLB.

HoBo
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.