User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Announced Changes > Change to Age Based League Structures Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Syphon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
Originally posted by Syphon

Thats kind of a bold statement. there is a 117 pages of mostly dissent. I believe that speaks to the fact that most agents disapprove.


This is the exact reason why there will be plenty of non-boosters to play each other.


Interesting point. but if you sort leagues by days you are stuck in your leauge with many boosting teams. aka teams 10-30 levels higher than yours. it will be no fun to get smacked around all the time. so why play??
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
In all reality it needs to be pyramid based, with a double rate promotion demotion system. Bottom 8 teams go down Top 4 move up. This allows teams to fight and slug it out for promotion. Who is the longest lasting Non-boost team/dot in the Pro level, etc...


I think the caps where invented since the pyramid structure failed.

I doubt there is anyway to make a league structure which is "fair" to everyone. Not in a gamer environment where there always someone that "games" the system.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
As far as my calculations go, and I may be way off, there will be at least 4-6 leagues for every age group. These are for Much older groups of players.

League#1 All Boost All the time. w/Top game planning

League#2 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#3 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#4 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#5 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#6-7 Bottom of the barrel: CPUs: Newbs: slowly shrinking til it is eliminated.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 26, 2010 15:05:04
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 26, 2010 15:02:00
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Syphon

Thats kind of a bold statement. there is a 117 pages of mostly dissent. I believe that speaks to the fact that most agents disapprove


Speaking of bold statements.

There is no way one can look at this thread as indicitive of most agents. I know on the team I co-own, I have talked with about a half dozen agents and they all think this is a great change, but they do not bother posting their approval as they don't want to endure the ridicule from the sky is falling crowd for stating such. They (foolishly perhaps) trust that GLB will do the right thing and their voice is not needed.

And another reminder that there are several anti's in this thread that have posted enough in this thread to account for many of those "117" pages themselves.
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Speaking of bold statements.

There is no way one can look at this thread as indicitive of most agents. I know on the team I co-own, I have talked with about a half dozen agents and they all think this is a great change, but they do not bother posting their approval as they don't want to endure the ridicule from the sky is falling crowd for stating such. They (foolishly perhaps) trust that GLB will do the right thing and their voice is not needed.

And another reminder that there are several anti's in this thread that have posted enough in this thread to account for many of those "117" pages themselves.


you included... how do you feel about your co-owned team jumping a level because your very own dots are off set in their creation date?

The main concern with everyone is the fact that not every feels it necessary to boost every season. The minute you create a dot, if you skip a boosting year you immediately fall behind 6 levels and 30 sp's but you will remain in a league with those same dots 6 levels higher than you. Right out of the gate you are toast unless you spend boat loads of money to boost. As i have stated before, i just added up all the Flex i have purchased and it is very damn close to $600. I am a fool and this change made me realize that. I spent $600 and i have never once boosted a dot to level 72, but i have boosted many dots to 60+. $600 could easily have doubled had i boosted every dot every year. The majority of the bitching is due to the money grubbing gold digging greed of GLB, not the lack of competition and small free agent base this change is going to make.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gbororats
Originally posted by sunder B

OMG, the sky is falling, the sky is falling, the sky is falling

Now I know why I tried avoiding this thread. I just hope that GLB does not again cave to the vocal minority.



so the sky is falling, how do you feel about the DPC being removed? arent you glad they changed that and arent removing it



I honestly don't care much eaither way. IMO the DPC is exploitable which is bad for the game. Until a OPC would be created (which may be on the NGTH list) along with hot reads and real audibles, I would have no problem with it being removed. That being said, I think restrcitng it is a decent compromise. I am willing to let it play out to see if it works.

But lets stay on topic, that's a different thread.
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B

I honestly don't care much eaither way. IMO the DPC is exploitable which is bad for the game. Until a OPC would be created (which may be on the NGTH list) along with hot reads and real audibles, I would have no problem with it being removed. That being said, I think restrcitng it is a decent compromise. I am willing to let it play out to see if it works.

But lets stay on topic, that's a different thread.


yeah, but you said you dont want GLB to listen to the vocal minority, did they not do that with the other change and that calmed a lot of people down.... just sayin...
 
JuniorV1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by Syphon


Thats kind of a bold statement. there is a 117 pages of mostly dissent. I believe that speaks to the fact that most agents disapprove


Speaking of bold statements.

There is no way one can look at this thread as indicitive of most agents. I know on the team I co-own, I have talked with about a half dozen agents and they all think this is a great change, but they do not bother posting their approval as they don't want to endure the ridicule from the sky is falling crowd for stating such. They (foolishly perhaps) trust that GLB will do the right thing and their voice is not needed.

And another reminder that there are several anti's in this thread that have posted enough in this thread to account for many of those "117" pages themselves.


I agree you can't judge a majority by this post but neither can you judge by six agents you've talked to. As for ridicule those of us who have spoke out against it, you know vocal idiots, are subject to the same ridicule. I also have been around long enough to know that almost any company and some individuals for that matter are out for what is best for them.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gbororats


you included... how do you feel about your co-owned team jumping a level because your very own dots are off set in their creation date?

The main concern with everyone is the fact that not every feels it necessary to boost every season. The minute you create a dot, if you skip a boosting year you immediately fall behind 6 levels and 30 sp's but you will remain in a league with those same dots 6 levels higher than you. Right out of the gate you are toast unless you spend boat loads of money to boost. As i have stated before, i just added up all the Flex i have purchased and it is very damn close to $600. I am a fool and this change made me realize that. I spent $600 and i have never once boosted a dot to level 72, but i have boosted many dots to 60+. $600 could easily have doubled had i boosted every dot every year. The majority of the bitching is due to the money grubbing gold digging greed of GLB, not the lack of competition and small free agent base this change is going to make.


Offset creation date does not bother me. Long term that's a problem with or without the new structure.

Same thing with skipping boosts. We have a couple agents on our team that missed a couple and we're cool with that. They will probably still be with us to darn near their plateau. Long term we know they won't get to 72 where we need to be and at some point long down the road they may need to be replaced. They know and understand this. We also have a couple of great agents that we will have to let go (including a player of mine) after season 19 because they are older than 90% of our team.

 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorV1

I agree you can't judge a majority by this post but neither can you judge by six agents you've talked to. As for ridicule those of us who have spoke out against it, you know vocal idiots, are subject to the same ridicule. I also have been around long enough to know that almost any company and some individuals for that matter are out for what is best for them.


FWIW, I never called anyone an idiot. Everyone is absolutely entitled to their opinion.

Of course I also know that 6 agents in not enough of a sample size for a realisitic view, I was just pointing out the same thing about this thread, no matter how many speak out against the change in this thread, it is still too small of a sample size compared to the active user base.

As far as the company doing what's best for them, perhaps I am naive, but I think they feel what is best for them long term is closing up possible exploits to make the game enjoyable for everyone and not just the WL or pro leagues. Some see this as financially doing what is best for them in the now, I look at this as fixing the game so that the long term financial success can be sustained without the people that quietly leave because they are tired of non competative games and having no chance of competing in a league in a league with players three years older than them. Too many agents have already given up on that battle and never came back.
Edited by sunder B on Oct 26, 2010 15:48:58
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
As far as my calculations go, and I may be way off, there will be at least 4-6 leagues for every age group. These are for Much older groups of players.

League#1 All Boost All the time. w/Top game planning

League#2 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#3 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#4 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#5 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#6-7 Bottom of the barrel: CPUs: Newbs: slowly shrinking til it is eliminated.


This is what I'm thinking. I have a feeling that with the way it's currently planned, you're going to end up with some non-boost leagues which might actually make people happy...perish the thought.
 
JuniorV1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by JuniorV1


I agree you can't judge a majority by this post but neither can you judge by six agents you've talked to. As for ridicule those of us who have spoke out against it, you know vocal idiots, are subject to the same ridicule. I also have been around long enough to know that almost any company and some individuals for that matter are out for what is best for them.


FWIW, I never called anyone an idiot. Everyone is absolutely entitled to their opinion.

Of course I also know that 6 agents in not enough of a sample size for a realisitic view, I was just pointing out the same thing about this thread, no matter how many speak out against the change in this thread, it is still to small of a sample size compared to the active user base.

As far as the company doing what's best for them, perhaps I am naive, but I think they feel what is best for them long term is closing up possible exploits to make the game enjoyable for everyone and not just the WL or pro leagues. Some see this as financially doing what is best for them in the now, I look at this as fixing the game so that the long term financial success can be sustained without the people that quietly leave because they are tired of non competative games and having no chance of competing in a league in a league with players three years older than them. Too many agents have already given up on that battle and never came back.


I realize you never called anyone an idiot, I was just pointing out that by speaking out we are ridiculed by some. So we agree that we can't know the majority or minority.

As far as closing exploits, choosing not to boost is not an exploit it's a choice to play how you want to.Not boosting to win games now, have more players, or simply because you can't afford to spend the money or choose not to on a game that changes as much as this one does. Boosting to make endgame and have a chance there. Just because someone spends their money boosting and I spend mine on more players or keeping my teams doesn't mean the game should be tailored to boosters.
Edited by JuniorV1 on Oct 26, 2010 16:04:01
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
As far as my calculations go, and I may be way off, there will be at least 4-6 leagues for every age group. These are for Much older groups of players.

League#1 All Boost All the time. w/Top game planning

League#2 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#3 Mostly boosting w/Good gameplanning

League#4 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#5 Mix of non-boosting good builds, with average and below boosting builds.

League#6-7 Bottom of the barrel: CPUs: Newbs: slowly shrinking til it is eliminated.


You're pretty much right on track here. People will say FAs will all go to the lower leagues...but honestly if those teams in the lower leagues could recruit top of the line boosters they already would have them and would not be in the low leagues to begin with.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorV1
Solution to what may I, a vocal idiot, ask?
.


I didn't call you an idiot (or anyone else recently). The solution to the problem that boosters were getting beat by non boosters who were 120 days older than them.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorV1

As far as closing exploits, choosing not to boost is not an exploit it's a choice to play how you want to.Not boosting to win games now, have more players, or simply because you can't afford to spend the money or choose not to on a game that changes as much as this one does. Boosting to make endgame and have a chance there. Just because someone spends their money boosting and I spend mine on more players or keeping my teams doesn't mean the game should be tailored to boosters


Well whether it is intentional or not, it is an exploit. There are reasons that all youth sports are segregated by age/grade up through the middle of high school. It is not until athletes are much older that age become less important .

I'll take 100 sophmore high school football or basketball teams and place them up against freshman teams from the same schools, I can promise you that most likely all of the sophomore teams will win.

Take that a step further to further extremes, last night the team I co-own played a team that is nearly 3 seasons older than us. That is the equivilant of a HS freshman team playing a 6th grade team and ridiclous that things like this have been allowed to go on for 18 seasons.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.