User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
Then by all means retire them.



Why are they being locked in at any decline at all? It makes no sense. I explained earlier that there is no bonus token advantage. So what reason is there for the decline. Once again, there is the math.

Originally posted by Mstr_October
Originally posted by jrry32

Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs

So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.



 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
yup, well done guys.

very close to fair, a little on the harsh side, which makes more sense than a little on the other side.



now, gotta figure out with season 5 guys to re-sign.


How is htis even close to fair? Season 5 guys have 0 advantage if you take away their Vet points. The bonus token advantage isn't real.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
How is htis even close to fair? Season 5 guys have 0 advantage if you take away their Vet points. The bonus token advantage isn't real.


the 6-10sp's as you put it and 40ish days of training is a fair comprimise when you consider the max decline is 2.5%
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
the 6-10sp's as you put it and 40ish days of training is a fair comprimise when you consider the max decline is 2.5%


It is not 6-10 SP....It is 48 bonus tokens= 4 skill points, not 10. 40 days of training at level 70 gets you at Most like 2 or 3 skill points usually in a place that's not important. How is that fair? And season 7 guys have an even larger bonus token advantage than Season 5...should they be penalized.

Originally posted by Mstr_October
Originally posted by jrry32

Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs

So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.





Should a season 7 player be locked in a 4 percent decline because of their 70 bonus token advantage? I don't think so. So why are we locking in season 5 guys.
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
Why, at this point in the life cycle of the game, are you continuing to make new jerk reaction and changes to such a small % of the player base?

The changed announced yesterday is absolutely ridiculous.

Again, the initial plateau version, and the subsequent complaints, affect such a small % of the actual player base (dots).

It's completely unfathomable to me that you guys would continue to react to such a small group of vocal people in the forums.

Do what you do and stick with it. But quit pandering to people on such small issues as these.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
Originally posted by jbleich

the 6-10sp's as you put it and 40ish days of training is a fair comprimise when you consider the max decline is 2.5%


It is not 6-10 SP....It is 48 bonus tokens= 4 skill points, not 10. 40 days of training at level 70 gets you at Most like 2 or 3 skill points usually in a place that's not important. How is that fair? And season 7 guys have an even larger bonus token advantage than Season 5...should they be penalized.

Originally posted by Mstr_October

Originally posted by jrry32


Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs

So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.





Should a season 7 player be locked in a 4 percent decline because of their 70 bonus token advantage? I don't think so. So why are we locking in season 5 guys.


NY, that was the math I did COUNTING training. 6-10 SPs so there's no advantage, I really don't see a reason for any decline.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Originally posted by nyfoot2003

How is htis even close to fair? Season 5 guys have 0 advantage if you take away their Vet points. The bonus token advantage isn't real.


the 6-10sp's as you put it and 40ish days of training is a fair comprimise when you consider the max decline is 2.5%


I don't think you understand. It was 6-10 SPs when you add up bonus tokens AND training. And it's more like 6-8 SPs, that is negligible on any decent build.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
I don't think you understand. It was 6-10 SPs when you add up bonus tokens AND training. And it's more like 6-8 SPs, that is negligible on any decent build.


No matter how you slice it......2.5% is minimal
 
DotWars
offline
Link
 
nice job
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Originally posted by jrry32

I don't think you understand. It was 6-10 SPs when you add up bonus tokens AND training. And it's more like 6-8 SPs, that is negligible on any decent build.


No matter how you slice it......2.5% is minimal


No matter how you slice it...2.5% is far overkill on players that have almost not advantage over S6s and are at a disadvantage to S7s.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
terrible move. lvl 440+ dots, even if the math is now correct at 2.5%...have already been on top of the heap for an entire season, now they get a penalty that takes them back to lvl 440 value and 3 more seasons of plateau. Basically this move (even assuming the 2.5% penalty or half of decline penalty is mathmatically accurate..which isn't...) they just got a pass to stay at the top an extra season +.

Unfair to lvl 440- dots. This move just secured that the current best 10 WL teams will remain in World League probably until the end of 2010 with their current rosters with having to do absolutely no recruiting and not making way for up and coming dots.

I believe this move should just signal the end of World League. If you are cementing top teams in there by giving old ass reigning dots immortality heaped on the top dog status they already have enjoyed over the past season and which helped them to reach that level, just dissolve that league since the chances of new teams getting up there and sticking now is vastly reduced.

I just don't understand why such a drastic change was made based on the needs of maybe 2% of all existing dots that negatively effects the other 98% all the way down the line...because they are vocal and you like them?

Anyway, please don't change anything else right now...think we've all had enough for this week fellas.
Edited by BP on Jun 26, 2010 12:52:31
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
terrible move. lvl 440+ dots, even if the math is now correct at 2.5%...have already been on top of the heap for an entire season, now they get a penalty that takes them back to lvl 440 value and 3 more seasons of plateau. Basically this move (even assuming the 2.5% penalty or half of decline penalty is mathmatically accurate..which isn't...) they just got a pass to stay at the top an extra season +.

Unfair to lvl 440- dots. This move just secured that the current best 10 WL teams will remain in World League probably until the end of 2010 with their current rosters with having to do absolutely no recruiting and not making way for up and coming dots.

I believe this move should just signal the end of World League. If you are cementing top teams in there by giving old ass reigning dots immortality heaped on the top dog status they already have, just dissolve that league since the chances of new teams getting up there and sticking now is vastly reduced.

I just don't understand why such a drastic change was made based on the needs of maybe 2% of all existing dots that negatively effects the other 98% all the way down the line...because they are vocal and you like them?

Anyway, please don't change anything else right now...think we've all had enough for this week fellas.


I don't think you've understood this entire time, BP. I am assuming this is Bort's plan for the 480 dots:
Current 480 dots:
Hit 441 decline for a season(0-5% decline)
3 seasons of plateau
hit 600 second season of decline(5-10% decline)

New 440 dots:
hit 441 and 3 season plateau
560 1st season of decline(0-5% decline)
600 second season of decline(5-10% decline)

Do you still not see it? It is evened up, the 480 dots just went through their first season of decline BEFORE the plateau while other dots do it AFTER. And that 2.5% decline is completely ludicrous if you actually look at the math of what 480 dots gain. As for no one having a chance, lol. Teams of S6 dots will be better than S5 dots and S7 dots will be MUCH better than both.
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 26, 2010 12:56:13
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
ok, 2.5%. Thats better.

No more changes IMO
 
BP
offline
Link
 
No, I see it the numbers behind it completely. I did think that -5% was harsh for 480+, I didn't think the freezing decline was because those players got to keep their BT's and Training in their builds.

Even if ALL the math now evens out and I do understand that the 480 dots just had their 1st season of decline early...you think it's fair that a 479 dot who's been in the WL at lvl 74 for an entire season has his decline halved (which is = to what he gained through BT's and training TBH) gets 3 seasons of that frozen in time. While a 439 dot will stop training and getting BT's for 3 seasons from day 440?

Assuming that all of the numbers = out as far as value....you understand the 479 dot has a 1 season "play time" advtantage at the highest lvl vs. the 439 dot, right? that's my issue.

This ENTIRE argument was constructed by dominant teams with dominant 440-479 dots to make sure they could keep them at the top one extra season. They complained, Bort listened...that's my only problem.

Jrry, I'm not even debating the %'s..just the timing.

Look...two players..

1)

Creation day 4/49 enters WL in season 16 at 439 days old. he plays in World League season 16. end of season 16 he is 479 days old. His decline is halved which we now all agree = his training and BT's he accumulated over that one season. He is then frozen in time Season 17,18,19...and starts declining again in season 20. So he stayed in WL 4 seasons

2) Creation day 5/49 enters WL in season 17 at 439 days old. He plays in WL season 18,19,20 and then starts declining in 21.

According to all arguments the penalties now fit the crime, right? the problem is that dot 1 just played at the top of the game for 4 seasons (16,17,18,19) and dot 2 played there only 3 seasons (18,19,20). get it?

I honestly didn't care about the penalty %'s at all, but this entire argument in my eyes was to make sure that the existing top dots don't get an extra season at the highest level cuz it's not fair to everybody else. big surprise, everybody who argued for this new change has a selfish reason to do so. The vocal WL'ers have Borts ear for the most part and it gone done and honestly, it's a big FU to everybody that isn't them.

That's my real problem with this, the fact that they are allowed 3 seasons of plateau still and their penalty basically only deducts the gains they got through the extra training. Not cool.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
ok, 2.5%. Thats better.

No more changes IMO


I don't think you've read a single post other than your own.

How is 2.5 % fair considering:

Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs

So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.