User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Announced Changes > Change to Age Based League Structures Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Syphon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Game has been through tons of changes. Each time for the better and each time attracting the village idiots. Make your case of why this isn't a good idea. Give Bort feedback other than I want my $10 I invested into this game. Or the I quit! Why are you quiting? Because the free service you've all enjoyed isn't so free anymore? Or wait because you might have to actually play even competition for once? This doesn't kill non boosters one bit.....in fact in some ways it makes it a better game for them.


This is drivel, how does it make it better. I seriously question anyone in support of this. Think long term. if you don't think that you need new customers, than this is a good idea. but, if you make a new persons dot un-competitive from the start than there is little encouragement to stick around and enjoy the rest of the game....like this wonderful fourm...

Business 101. the larger the funnel, the more clients you end up with. By instituting this change you are basically putting a lid on you "funnel"
 
JuniorV1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
Game has been through tons of changes. Each time for the better and each time attracting the village idiots. Make your case of why this isn't a good idea. Give Bort feedback other than I want my $10 I invested into this game. Or the I quit! Why are you quiting? Because the free service you've all enjoyed isn't so free anymore? Or wait because you might have to actually play even competition for once? This doesn't kill non boosters one bit.....in fact in some ways it makes it a better game for them.


First enough changes to qualify for a beta game which they claim it is and people don't pay to play beta games.

Second better in your eyes maybe and once again offensive.

Third if you would have bothered to read all the post plenty of people have given their reasons why it isn't a good idea.

Fourth plenty of people are giving feedback read the posts and if I invested in this game where is my share of the profits.

Fifth if you look at my teams you'll see I don't dominate, maybe partially because I don't care to, and that I have boosters and non-boosters on my team. Same holds true for my own players.

For the last tell me how it makes it better for me who as I've said have spent $334.49 or an average of $19.67 in the past seventeen months.
 
MVP Rodgers
offline
Link
 
I really like the new format for the leagues even though it will suck for my team personally.

My team has everyone created the same day on day 40/41 but a couple guys were created on day 35.

Because we have a couple players created 5 days early we will suck until we reach the pros because we'll be basically in a league 1 higher up from the age of all of our players except those couple.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
We already have given reasons. A full team of non-boosting dots costs just as much as 4 boosting dots.


How does that fix the broken one sided leagues below pro?
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
Is the league promotion system changing each season with this. Are there going to be age based league shakeups each season?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
How does that fix the broken one sided leagues below pro?


Age caps added on to the current level caps would fix it. Just don't make everyone have to be the same age. As long as the training bonus is not greater than the amount of SPs you can get from boosting then there is not a competitive advantage either way and it would be fun for everyone.
 
thejoe2k8
offline
Link
 
Why not just leave the structure where it's at? There's already issues with level 25 teams playing in Cap 18 leagues that just happened to be unfortunate incidents. Sure you can have different "tiers" for players of a certain age and skill level, but isn't this the initial platform for the Capped Leagues? How long will it take before the Age tiers get out of sync and we see Elite 60's playing medium 30's?

Just leave it alone. If anything, grab some agents willing to try their hands at this, let it run for a couple of seasons in its own league (much like Pee Wee) and then if it goes off unhitched, GLB has solid ground to stand on and a successful program. If this kind of testing happened more often (instead of behind the curtain), GLB wouldn't have near the complaints that it has now.

 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorV1

For the last tell me how it makes it better for me who as I've said have spent $334.49 or an average of $19.67 in the past seventeen months.


You will have far fewer blowout games each season makes it better for you. I like to think of my GLB spending as an entertainment value per game. Currently most leagues below pro are lucky to have 4 competitive games per season due to ridicuous imbalance that has been allowed far too long.

Given your $20/month example, that's like paying $5 for one competitive game. With the new system, I don't think it is unreasonable to expect 12+ competitive games per season so it is a far better entertainment value for you.

----------------------------------------------------------------

It's funny how the people upset like the sky is falling are quick to point out that (in their opinion) those that agree with the decision to change don't realize how bad it's going to be. The same exact thing can be said for those upset about the decision. We can all look at the theory and jump to our own conclusions on whether or not it will benefit the game. People will decide this is more about the money than it is to better balance ALL the leagues, and they have their right to that opinion. I pesonally disagree that it will be worse, but NO ONE knows for sure until it is rolled out. (I still remember all of the rage quit threats about CPU players being overpowered, yet no team of CPU's went on to win anything because they weren't overpowered, just improved enough to make games vs CPU's entertaining instead of laughers)

I can tell you I personally know many agents that left the game (yes they spent money as well) because it was no fun playing in unbalanced leagues and having little competition each season. That trend would surely continue if this change were not implemented. So for all of those threatening to rage quit, chances are you are a small percentage of those that may have soon or have already quietly quit if things were left the same way.

 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
This doesn't kill non boosters one bit.....in fact in some ways it makes it a better game for them.


 
NUNYO
offline
Link
 
Team owners will just build teams on the day that puts them one day away from the upper league and be a half to full season older than the rest of the league. The extra training will help them, now if they are all put into the same league then it will be a good thing. I personally don't care how the structure is as long as the compition is even. I would love to play in a league and have to game plan for more than 2-6 games at most.

No matter what though you'll have your guys crying, teams run by bad GMs will sign guys with high effective levels and get killed by GM that know what they're doing and the crying will begin that this system isn't fair!!!!

Good luck Bort and Catch making a whine free decision!!!!

I say lets give it a try!
 
Dadx4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gary.
Is the league promotion system changing each season with this. Are there going to be age based league shakeups each season?


Yep
 
JuniorV1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
Originally posted by JuniorV1


For the last tell me how it makes it better for me who as I've said have spent $334.49 or an average of $19.67 in the past seventeen months.


You will have far fewer blowout games each season makes it better for you. I like to think of my GLB spending as an entertainment value per game. Currently most leagues below pro are lucky to have 4 competitive games per season due to ridicuous imbalance that has been allowed far too long.

Given your $20/month example, that's like paying $5 for one competitive game. With the new system, I don't think it is unreasonable to expect 12+ competitive games per season so it is a far better entertainment value for you.

----------------------------------------------------------------

It's funny how the people upset like the sky is falling are quick to point out that (in their opinion) those that agree with the decision to change don't realize how bad it's going to be. The same exact thing can be said for those upset about the decision. We can all look at the theory and jump to our own conclusions on whether or not it will benefit the game. People will decide this is more about the money than it is to better balance ALL the leagues, and they have their right to that opinion. I pesonally disagree that it will be worse, but NO ONE knows for sure until it is rolled out. (I still remember all of the rage quit threats about CPU players being overpowered, yet no team of CPU's went on to win anything because they weren't overpowered, just improved enough to make games vs CPU's entertaining instead of laughers)

I can tell you I personally know many agents that left the game (yes they spent money as well) because it was no fun playing in unbalanced leagues and having little competition each season. That trend would surely continue if this change were not implemented. So for all of those threatening to rage quit, chances are you are a small percentage of those that may have soon or have already quietly quit if things were left the same way.


I did some checking and if it's strictly age based someone that boosts that is the same age as my non-boosting level twenty-one toons are around six levels higher and up to ten effective levels higher so much for even competition.
Edited by JuniorV1 on Oct 26, 2010 14:25:01
Edited by JuniorV1 on Oct 26, 2010 14:23:48
Edited by JuniorV1 on Oct 26, 2010 14:23:19
Edited by JuniorV1 on Oct 26, 2010 14:22:50
 
groganite
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Originally posted by groganite

ok plowed through a ton of this have yet to see a compromise offered .
i have non boosting and boosting players i own
my team has some old and some young players basically got to say screw my agents to keep the team together S20

instead of hard capping by one players age why not go with the average age of a roster and hard capping that ? gives a few more seasons of viability for non boost etc and widens player pool to recruit from


Because when a Lv 73 ex-WL player will get 1000 yds/run in a single game against your team you will likely freak or ragequit.

The capped leagues always have some building strategy being better then the other. It was non-boosting > full boosting in the last ~10 season and now they switch it around.

I don't like the change (mainly since boosting players can enjoy the uncapped leagues which is closed for the non boosters) . But
- Anyway you cap a league you generate a strategy how to dominate it. Meaning that part of the user base is happy and part is angry.
- If the caps are not hardcap (one player no exception), then there will always be team abusing the loop hole to gain advantage. This make most user angry.


did not rage quit or cry when my non boosting no CE required team wound up in elite 22 #1 the first season those were implemented (over my conference and league champs which boosted) and was used as a doormat for two seasons . did not quit or cry about making the playoffs to be crushed by 16-0 SSB teams later , did not cry about the archetypes.and retire
just trying to offer a middle ground .
not everyone cries when things do not go the way they want them, to go
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by groganite
did not rage quit or cry when my non boosting no CE required team wound up in elite 22 #1 the first season those were implemented (over my conference and league champs which boosted) and was used as a doormat for two seasons . did not quit or cry about making the playoffs to be crushed by 16-0 SSB teams later , did not cry about the archetypes.and retire
just trying to offer a middle ground .
not everyone cries when things do not go the way they want them, to go


I usually get more invested, when I am more invested.
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JuniorV1


I did some checking and if it's strictly age based someone that boosts that is the same age as my non-boosting level twenty-one toons are around six levels higher and up to ten effective levels higher so much for even competition.


But you are missing the part where it will still be separated by elite/competitive/regular. The long term non boosters and SSB's will wind up in the regular leagues playing against each other. If non-boosting is as prevalant as everyone in this thread is claiming, there will be plenty to have the own unofficial non-boosting leagues. You cannot say this won't happen until it plays out.

2 things are for sure going to come out of it, either there are not nearly as many non-boosting dots/teams as people in this thread are claiming, or there will be enough to fill entire regular leagues against each other.
Edited by sunder B on Oct 26, 2010 14:21:41
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.