User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by TerrellOwns


This really doesn't address any of the legitimate concerns expressed in this thread.


I thought it covered most of them to be honest.


From what I gather, most people are concerned about testers having advanced information. Bort's post explicitly acknowledges that they do.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by pottsman

Originally posted by Bort


I have seen posts from some of the very users in this thread before stating that I should set up a test server, get some respected members of the community, and test things before they go live, which has not happened as thoroughly in the past with just me doing it. So I set that up a couple weeks ago, to get things going on testing the likely problems. I hope to use it as a staging server in general to test things a couple weeks before they go live, to find bugs and iron them out ahead of time. I would hope most people would see that as a Good Thing (tm).


Originally posted by pottsman


I'm only halfway through the thread, but I'm posting this now...

Isn't this the same board that constantly bitched about Bort not testing things enough? Now we're bitching that things get tested?




You are so right.


We love the fact that things are being tested. This is absolutely great.

The irritating part is that it's giving people that we're competing with an unfair advantage.

 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Its not that hard people. No one is bitching about there being a secret test server. Or that testing is going on. It is the fact that people playing the game are doing the testing and possibly getting information the rest of us don't.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Bort, this would be a very good thing, but somewhere around 100 pages ago Tpat said that they had the ability to modify player builds at will, run SIMs, and see how those players performed.

I completely agree 100% with what you posted. I've been a HUGE advocate of more testing. However, if people on the server have the ability to tweak builds and find out what's working best, that's what's creating this massive uproar. GLB is not most MMORPG's. A little information gleaned from the test server is enough to unbalance an entire pro league. That's 32 teams each shelling out around $200 in FP every season on the assumption they all have the same shot at winning.



This. People who supposedly know about it have already contradicted what you said Bort.
 
Thorn
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by pottsman

I hope. But when one says "testers aren't paid to...." it connotes that they are paid to do something else. So I just needed to be completely positive. And I felt a second post on that would clearly make him confess if he lied in that post 3 seconds earlier despite the obviousness of his first statement (not obviousness of a lie, obvious that it was there).


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2067898&page=111#17266254

I beat you to the comment but everyone ignored me.

Not to defend Thorn, but I've been around enough to spot someone emotionally flustered and just type something that appears to mean something other than it does while emotions are running high.

This is like saying "pottsman is not paying PackMan97 for sex". Ok, well...what are you paying me for? Nothing. Do you see what I mean?


Thanks Packer, I guess I should of been more specific on that, and hopefully I cleared up the issue on the next page in the thread.
-Thorn
 
McGrai37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mindfreak
Originally posted by McGrai37

Originally posted by Bort


We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


So testers aren't able to tinker with builds, only AI/playbooks?


But you cant take everyones word. He would be more interested at calming concerns right now than telling complete truth.


Eh I don't think it's that type of conspiracy. If they're not able to build their own test players, I think a lot of people (including me) would be much more understanding.
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by Gary_Hughes


Bort is on now. He will most likely be here any second.


LOL! That sad thing is the first thing I thought when I saw this thread is...what off season feature won't get added because Bort has to deal with this crap on a reactive basis.

Bort, in the future, much easier just to be open and transparent about stuff.


Never meant to not be transparent. I had even mentioned previously that I have a test server and would be getting people to help test the D creator. Today we just happened to have a company meeting planned, so I haven't really been around to respond, which is unfortunate because things tend to move at the speed of light when people are freakin' out.

Basically, there is a small group of users who have been asked to test updates before a general release for quality control purposes. People have been chosen based on being responsible community members and the system is set up to minimize any advantage a tester could get for his own team.

The people involved have proved their trustworthiness, football knowledge, and general helpfulness to me over time. Some are mods, some are admins, some are neither. None of them asked for access (which pretty much automatically disqualifies you in my mind), but instead were invited by me because I trusted them and their advice. To be honest, most of the testers involved have expressed to me that they are more interested in helping to see an improved game than actually playing it competitively at this point.

I'm not sure I want to give out the whole list, because I don't really want to open these people who are being so helpful up to the random flames and OMG HELP ME GET IN questions they would likely receive. It's up to them.

- Testers cannot take your data from the live site.
- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.

I have seen posts from some of the very users in this thread before stating that I should set up a test server, get some respected members of the community, and test things before they go live, which has not happened as thoroughly in the past with just me doing it. So I set that up a couple weeks ago, to get things going on testing the likely problems. I hope to use it as a staging server in general to test things a couple weeks before they go live, to find bugs and iron them out ahead of time. I would hope most people would see that as a Good Thing (tm).


That's all good and fine.

The big concern is, if people are allowed to freely adjust those prototype player builds, what's to stop them from gaining knowledge about player builds that normally take many seasons for a normal user to discover? Especially pertaining to those off-season "tweaks" you like to do.
 
Skeptikal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mindfreak
Originally posted by dpell

Bort, this would be a very good thing, but somewhere around 100 pages ago Tpat said that they had the ability to modify player builds at will, run SIMs, and see how those players performed.

I completely agree 100% with what you posted. I've been a HUGE advocate of more testing. However, if people on the server have the ability to tweak builds and find out what's working best, that's what's creating this massive uproar. GLB is not most MMORPG's. A little information gleaned from the test server is enough to unbalance an entire pro league. That's 32 teams each shelling out around $200 in FP every season on the assumption they all have the same shot at winning.



This. People who supposedly know about it have already contradicted what you said Bort.


 
Link
 
But tpat has already said you can.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Bort

- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.


just to clarify: are you saying testers can't create their own test builds?

this would alleviate quite a bit of the concern, although by no means all...


Sorta...we basically have a bunch of test teams with different prototypes we've set up, and we play them against each other with various AI settings and versions of sim code I upload.
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
This is an a BORT ion
 
jagerbolt
offline
Link
 
Bort said they have pre-made builds and run sims to find and take out bugs. Every single game has a testing department.

This is just like when the AEQ came into effect and there was a giant thread freaking out about 'magical equipment' and how the game is ruined.

/facepalm
 
junkie
offline
Link
 
People need something to do in the off-season, and b*tching and complaining seems to be the big thing...
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by jamz
Just curious how many of you Vaadwuur guys are testers?

Why? We got beat down in the conference finals. Good thing that inside knowledge helped us, right?
/sarcasm


Originally posted by Catullus 16
whether or not the testers were able to translate their insider information into success is irrelevant. even with complete information, you still have to deal with other people's builds/etc.

 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by Gary_Hughes


Bort is on now. He will most likely be here any second.


LOL! That sad thing is the first thing I thought when I saw this thread is...what off season feature won't get added because Bort has to deal with this crap on a reactive basis.

Bort, in the future, much easier just to be open and transparent about stuff.


Never meant to not be transparent. I had even mentioned previously that I have a test server and would be getting people to help test the D creator. Today we just happened to have a company meeting planned, so I haven't really been around to respond, which is unfortunate because things tend to move at the speed of light when people are freakin' out.

Basically, there is a small group of users who have been asked to test updates before a general release for quality control purposes. People have been chosen based on being responsible community members and the system is set up to minimize any advantage a tester could get for his own team.

The people involved have proved their trustworthiness, football knowledge, and general helpfulness to me over time. Some are mods, some are admins, some are neither. None of them asked for access (which pretty much automatically disqualifies you in my mind), but instead were invited by me because I trusted them and their advice. To be honest, most of the testers involved have expressed to me that they are more interested in helping to see an improved game than actually playing it competitively at this point.

I'm not sure I want to give out the whole list, because I don't really want to open these people who are being so helpful up to the random flames and OMG HELP ME GET IN questions they would likely receive. It's up to them.

- Testers cannot take your data from the live site.
- We have basically set up a bunch of prototype built players, and we've been running test games to find plays that cause problems with the current blocking AI and such. It's been helpful to find problems and address them, especially since I can be proactive and try ideas and get feedback on a daily basis from a group of people who are mature and helpful.

I have seen posts from some of the very users in this thread before stating that I should set up a test server, get some respected members of the community, and test things before they go live, which has not happened as thoroughly in the past with just me doing it. So I set that up a couple weeks ago, to get things going on testing the likely problems. I hope to use it as a staging server in general to test things a couple weeks before they go live, to find bugs and iron them out ahead of time. I would hope most people would see that as a Good Thing (tm).


So the testers do not have the ability to alter player builds?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.