User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs

So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs

So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.


Yep....I'm officially coining the phrase, "effective decline". The advantage in bonus tokens counts as a kind of "effective decline" even though it is not direct. I don't think it is significant enough to matter at all though IF you take away the decline % from the S5s
Thanks for doing the math though...It makes it very clear.
Edited by nyfoot2003 on Jun 25, 2010 22:03:05
Edited by nyfoot2003 on Jun 25, 2010 22:01:33
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
Originally posted by jrry32

Here is the math of BTs earned in a career, I only multiplied it by 40 day seasons(even though most seasons were 56 days):
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old = 1*120(new) + 11 * 48(old) = 648 BTs
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old = 1*120(new) + 10 * 48(old) = 600 BTs
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old = 2*120(new) + 9 * 48(old) = 672 BTs
8.0 3 new, 8 old 3*120(new) + 8 * 48(old) = 744 BTs

So the advantage gained by S5 on S6 is negligible(it's like 6-10 SPs) while S7 and on have an advantage that just grows.


Yep....I'm officially coining the phrase, "effective decline". The advantage in bonus tokens counts as a kind of "effective decline" even though it is not direct. I don't actually mind the fact that there is this effective decline, since the idea of a slight decline makes sense.


Yep, putting any decline on S5 players is ludicrous when you do the math. I think removing the VAs is more than enough. Thanks for pointing that out, I just wasn't seeing it.
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 25, 2010 22:02:29
 
Snickerling
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
If they take away the decline %, then there is reason to keep them even if they are slightly worse due to the bonus token disadvantage, but leaving the % in leaves no motivation to keep S5 dots and not just retire for flex.


Do you really see them making yet ANOTHER change to an official announcement and subsequent official announcement modification? I don't.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snickerling
Do you really see them making yet ANOTHER change to an official announcement and subsequent official announcement modification? I don't.


Are you new around here?



 
Snickerling
offline
Link
 
New enough, apparently, to think that they will want to avoid looking too silly by changing something they rushed out without complete forethought to correct something else they rushed out without complete forethought.
 
SeattleNiner
NINERS
offline
Link
 
thE NEW CHANGE BITESSSSSSS
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snickerling
New enough, apparently, to think that they will want to avoid looking too silly by changing something they rushed out without complete forethought to correct something else they rushed out without complete forethought.


Review the archetype announcementS again.
 
Snickerling
offline
Link
 
I'll be pleasantly surprised then, if the 5% doesn't stay 5%. But right now I'm expecting it to stay 5%... which IMO, effectively kills the player pool for another season.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
I love it. now can you change the second half of GLB's biggest problem- the game taking too long?
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Welp, all on same page for a bit


Looks to me like just stripping VAs on 441-480 and being done is the actual closest to "fair".





The math has been proven. GET THIS DONE!!!

Thanks Kur for proving what nyfoot was trying to explain, sorry bro, I just didn't get what you were saying....but, we were both arguing on the same side, your argument is just a helluva lot better
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
Dots I planned on keeping around under the original announcement: 7

Dots I plan on keeping around after the announcement changed: 0

That was going to translate to flex purchases to offset the retirement flex I wasn't going to get from dumping those 7 players. Not to mention our team had about 4 more guys lined up to stick around who won't be now.
Edited by sleepingazure on Jun 25, 2010 22:27:37
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mstr_October
The math has been proven. GET THIS DONE!!!

Thanks Kur for proving what nyfoot was trying to explain, sorry bro, I just didn't get what you were saying....but, we were both arguing on the same side, your argument is just a helluva lot better


Yeah, I had to just clear that up so people didn't keep claiming that S5 guys have a bonus token advantage over everyone. Another thing to keep in mind is that the sim constantly changes. For each season that you are stuck in plateau, that is 1 less season to adapt to the sim changes via boosts. that is another disadvantage that S5 guys have that people have not mentioned.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Welp, all on same page for a bit


Looks to me like just stripping VAs on 441-480 and being done is the actual closest to "fair".





pretty sure I said that about 80 pages ago. The 480's would have a slight training advantage and a BT advantage but it's close enough. 5% is overkill. Even 1% was probably too much.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
pretty sure I said that about 80 pages ago. The 480's would have a slight training advantage and a BT advantage but it's close enough. 5% is overkill. Even 1% was probably too much.


The point is that they don't have a bonus token advantage over season 7s, just season 6s. People were claiming that S5 guys would have 3 seasons of an advantage, but really it is only one, after which it becomes a disadvantage.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.