User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by TerrellOwns

This is true. A tester who knows which SAs work before can make sure a player who invests skill points in that SA have not wasted them.


FYP


Or inspire Bort to fix Smooth Operator for the thousands of CB's wasting points in it.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by cbarge

Bort isn't handing out insider information.


What? You don't think access to a test server is tantamount to insider information? I guess there is no point continuing this discussion with you.


+1

 
Link
 
Well, I can kind of understand the secrecy thing, if I think about it from a "put yourself in their shoes" kind of perspective...
As soon as the whole GLB community sees who's testers won't those people be bombarded with thousands of PM's daily ,asking for advice and such?
I'm pretty much over being upset about the whole thing, as long as it's used to make this game better, it will hopefully have more positive, than negative, effects.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by TerrellOwns

This is true. A tester who knows which SAs work before the season begins can make sure players who they give information to invest skill points in the right SAs



fixed my post, thanks
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
The wall around my garden is 4ft high.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by mantis7

Originally posted by cbarge


In order to receive it, he'd have to take it in this situation. Bort isn't handing out insider information.


He DID take it..He took the position of tester...

How can he un-learn something he learned as a tester...?



Because he's being honest when he says he reports bugs.


Because.... he says so?
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by mantis7

Originally posted by cbarge


In order to receive it, he'd have to take it in this situation. Bort isn't handing out insider information.


He DID take it..He took the position of tester...

How can he un-learn something he learned as a tester...?



Because he's being honest when he says he reports bugs.


Ok , let us assume that he is...(Which you have no idea, BTW)

What about every other tester? Can you personally guarantee that all of them are honest?
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
In order to receive it, he'd have to take it in this situation. Bort isn't handing out insider information.


If in the course of "testing" you identify broken plays that obviously take advantage of the code then set your AI to run them, that is insider information.

WR screen out of the single back formation ring a bell?
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
The wall around my garden is 4ft high.

Interesting. Please go on.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by tpaterniti
If I find out an SA doesn't work I am going to tell bort so he can change it so that it works.

how long would/does it take for bort to fix an issue like that?

Discovering that it doesn't work so well or too well is the issue. Not the fixing. I would imagine the fix could be applied pretty quickly.


yeah, that's where i was heading with that question.

there are a lot of soft justifications for how the test server is/was structured... i think we're all more worried about the hard possibilities.

the next step on the argument i was trying to make: while the testers wait for bort to fix the SA, they're stuck in an ethical minefield... is that what they really want?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
The wall around my garden is 4ft high.



You tell me all the time if you have nothing constructive to say don't say it. Did you decide not to follow your own advice? Stick to the topic at hand.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
One of the things people are saying is testers are gaining knowledge through the act of testing. Knowledge that can be an advantage in knowing how the game works. This knowledge can't be "unlearned". It would be used when they build their players or give advice.

It doesn't have to be that testers are doing something devious. They don't have to be running tests for the sole purpose of cheating (although I realize some are saying that, but certainly not all).

I don't think in that situation it is calling in to question anyone's integrity.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by cbarge

Originally posted by mantis7


Originally posted by cbarge



In order to receive it, he'd have to take it in this situation. Bort isn't handing out insider information.


He DID take it..He took the position of tester...

How can he un-learn something he learned as a tester...?



Because he's being honest when he says he reports bugs.


Ok , let us assume that he is...(Which you have no idea, BTW)

What about every other tester? Can you personally guarantee that all of them are honest?


They're chosen to be testers in the first place because they have spotless records, so yeah with a fairly high degree of certainty, one can guarantee that they're not being dishonest.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by tpaterniti

If I find out an SA doesn't work I am going to tell bort so he can change it so that it works.


how long would/does it take for bort to fix an issue like that?


And THERE's the issue.

That and the following:

Say you find out that Tunnel Vision (or any other SA) works way too well once you get it past 7. So you tell Bort and he says he'll work on toning it down. You then stop putting points into tunnel vision for your DEs and tell your team to do the same. Everyone else keeps pumping it because it's so effective. A few weeks later people find out that tunnel vision is now useless and most people have invested 11 into the SA while you stopped at 7 and had an extra few weeks and 30 SP to spend elsewhere, while everyone else gets fucked by the lag.

That fair?

That's why anything you find out needs to be known by the public. How can you not understand that it was bullshit to try and do this with secrecy?
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
the next step on the argument i was trying to make: while the testers wait for bort to fix the SA, they're stuck in an ethical minefield... is that what they really want?


No, i wouldn't think so. At least any of them that weren't planning on using the information as an unfair tool...

This is precisely why I think the test server should be open to all.

This is a pay to play PVP game...

Equal and fair access to all....

What if you played a PVP game where some people who pay the same money as you had access to better technology...would you continue to play?
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 20:29:48
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.