User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jrry32

I'll try to explain this to you. Under the new plateau system:
D401 - Same as before, no XP but you can train and get VAs
D441 - Different from now, now you get training points and VAs under the new system, you would go into a frozen plateau so no training and no VAs
Here is the hitch, players who started the season at Day 441 received training points and VAs all season...NO OTHER PLAYERS WILL RECEIVE TRAINING POINTS AND VAS AFTER DAY 441 UNTIL THEY DECLINE AFTER DAY 560. So the season where they got unfair gains is THIS SEASON. Do you understand now? It is this current season that is causing the problem, not any older season.


Nah, the dude's right. Right now, every dot has had 1 season in the new training system. So a 5.0 dot has had 11 in the old, a 6.0 10, a 7.0 9.

With this plateau:
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old
8.0 3 new, 8 old

So 5.0 has one extra season of old training.



Wow, yea, I see what you're saying.
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 25, 2010 21:46:06
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
i love this idea! LETS DO IT!



Quoted in the advisors forum (doesn't matter, DUCY?)
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Nah, the dude's right. Right now, every dot has had 1 season in the new training system. So a 5.0 dot has had 11 in the old, a 6.0 10, a 7.0 9.

With this plateau:
5.0 has 1 season new, 11 old
6.0 has 1 season new, 10 old
7.0 eventually has 2 seasons new, 9 old
8.0 3 new, 8 old

So 5.0 has one extra season of old training.


THANK YOU. Somebody can do math lol. Do you think a 50 bonus token advantage is equivalent to 2.5 or 5 percent accross the board? I don't think so at all.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
That wasn't the point he was making and that is common sense. The point he made is that the S5 dots only gained 16 BTs in their extra season which is wrong since this is the extra season other dots won't get and they gained 120 BTs. Which really does even out when you consider that the other generations will all have more seasons under the new system but yea, he's still not right on that one.


You still don't understand. IT is 16 bonus tokens under the old system, which was transferred into 48 under the new system. THen there is the fact that most dots didn't even know back in season 5 that AEQ was 100 percent the way to go since it was brand new. In reality i'd guess it's closer to a 30 bonus token advantage on average.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
Originally posted by jrry32

That wasn't the point he was making and that is common sense. The point he made is that the S5 dots only gained 16 BTs in their extra season which is wrong since this is the extra season other dots won't get and they gained 120 BTs. Which really does even out when you consider that the other generations will all have more seasons under the new system but yea, he's still not right on that one.


You still don't understand. IT is 16 bonus tokens under the old system, which was transferred into 48 under the new system. THen there is the fact that most dots didn't even know back in season 5 that AEQ was 100 percent the way to go since it was brand new. In reality i'd guess it's closer to a 30 bonus token advantage on average.


Check edit.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Welp, all on same page for a bit


Looks to me like just stripping VAs on 441-480 and being done is the actual closest to "fair".



Edited by kurieg on Jun 25, 2010 21:47:48
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jrry32

That wasn't the point he was making and that is common sense. The point he made is that the S5 dots only gained 16 BTs in their extra season which is wrong since this is the extra season other dots won't get and they gained 120 BTs. Which really does even out when you consider that the other generations will all have more seasons under the new system but yea, he's still not right on that one.


Nah, re-read, he was again talking about the much smaller bonus token accrual of hte old system.




Same, I re-read and edited. You guys are right. I didn't even think about it that way. I mean looking at it like that, the advantage they get is minimal over S6 builds and they actually are at a disadvantage to S7 builds.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Check edit.


Ok...NOw that you understand, do you admit that a 50 bonus token advantage isn't worth a 5 or even 2.5 percent accross the board. Then you consider the fact that S7 dots will have even more bonus tokens than S5 since they have an extra season under the new system, the only people getting screwed are season 6, but just slightly. Once S8 goes it's the S7 that gets screwed. Every single set of new players will have a bonus token advantage because they will have an extra season under the new system, until 11 season from now at least.

edit. just saw the post above. cool.
Edited by nyfoot2003 on Jun 25, 2010 21:49:19
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Welp, all on same page for a bit


Looks to me like just stripping VAs on 441-480 and being done is the actual closest to "fair".





I agree.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
Originally posted by jrry32

Check edit.


Ok...NOw that you understand, do you admit that a 50 bonus token advantage isn't worth a 5 or even 2.5 percent accross the board. Then you consider the fact that S7 dots will have even more bonus tokens than S5 since they have an extra season under the new system, the only people getting screwed are season 6, but just slightly. Once S8 goes it's the S7 that gets screwed. Every single set of new players will have a bonus token advantage because they will have an extra season under the new system, until 11 season from now at least.



Even when I thought it was 120 BTs I didn't think it was worth 5%, I thought it was worth 1.5% at most...now, it's not really worth anything when you consider S7 will actually have more BTs.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
I agree.


I can't beleive it took 100 pages for somebody to realize this..can GLB really not do math? lol
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
Originally posted by jrry32

I agree.


I can't beleive it took 100 pages for somebody to realize this..can GLB really not do math? lol


People can do math just fine, most(including me) were just not looking at it from the entire career point of view.
 
Snickerling
offline
Link
 
ExOriginally posted by jrry32
Even when I thought it was 120 BTs I didn't think it was worth 5%, I thought it was worth 1.5% at most...now, it's not really worth anything when you consider S7 will actually have more BTs.


Exactly... Early S5 dots just became worse than S7 dots... Why keep them around at all now? No one will want them if they can get a S7 dot that still has growth potential.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
People can do math just fine, most(including me) were just not looking at it from the entire career point of view.


I was kidding, but yeah. My point is people get caught up in the whole, "it's not fair" gut reaction without sitting down and calculating out whether it actually isn't fair or not. The reality is that there will still be an effective decline for the next 11 seasons as each subsequent dot to reach plateau has a 70 X # of seasons advantage over the players above him in bonus tokens based on the difference beteween the new and old training systems. In reality, it's slightly more.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snickerling
Exactly... Early S5 dots just became worse than S7 dots... Why keep them around at all now? No one will want them if they can get a S7 dot that still has growth potential.


If they take away the decline %, then there is reason to keep them even if they are slightly worse due to the bonus token disadvantage, but leaving the % in leaves no motivation to keep S5 dots and not just retire for flex.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.