User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
I find it humorous that the two loudest individuals, tossing around words like cheating/fraud/concealment/etc., both only have one player, own no team, and have made an (ostensibly) minimal financial investment as well as time devoted to recruiting/gameplanning (again, ostensibly).

I'm not sure if they're in the best position to extract from an ill-informed perception what constitutes an "advantage", and whether or not this is "cheating", yet they persist.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by wombat killer


Originally posted by sjmay





I can see that, and just refresh my memory, working on 3 hours sleep is wearing my patience down,

Where did I ever say that no one had the right to feel upset? I probably have said it wasn't rational, but I never denied the right to feel upset, I also have said that it hasn't mattered, in the past etc.


If you knew that, then why ask the question? Maybe its just me, but the impression I got from your post was you didn't feel people had the right to feel upset.



No, if that was the impression, it was falsely given,

It's more along the lines of the accusations without ANY basis, the constant whining that is prevalent from the forums, be it "the sim screwed me because I can't read the AI" to "the testers are evil and I want my money back, even though I have no idea at this point what they were able to do" etc,

Just take a step back, breathe, relax, and think about this, and realize that until you get all the facts, making "the sky is falling" statements, about anything, is idiotic at best.


I don't agree. Its not accusations without basis (except for that Zeke guy). Its accusations based on what we know testers have the ability to do (as confirmed by the testers).

I kept up with what Mike Rogers was saying which was that the advantage gained, was so slight, he personally did not feel there was an advantage, that he learned nothing from testing, that could not be gleaned from the sims themselves and reading the bug forum.

NOTE I am not saying he did not learn anything from testing.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Would you want to test prune candy for free?


Nope. You aren't testing for free either. You are receiving payment in the form of a decided advantage in the main game.


I'd really like it if you'd stop accusing TPat of taking advantage of his testing responsibilities with zero evidence whatsoever.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
.Originally posted by cbarge

I'd really like it if you'd stop accusing TPat of taking advantage of his testing responsibilities with zero evidence whatsoever.


Look, I have seen your posts and obviously you aren't the smartest person in your room right now....but the 'taking advantage' is INHERENT....(that means built in)....

It isn't an accusation, it is a fact....Once you have knowledge, you can not un-know it.... Once you know that having X in a stat makes Y SA work better, are you going to forget it?

Cbarge, you fail at logic.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 20:23:10
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
I understand what everyone is saying. Thorn never denied that there is the possibility that an advantage might be gained. He simply said that the benefit to GLB outweighs the potential advantages any particular user might gain and that bort went to great lengths to ensure that the people he chose to test were people who would not be testing for the sake of gaining an advantage but to genuinely make the game better for everyone.


So why not just let us know who the testers are? Why did the Bort/Admins/Mods try to hide and cover all of this up?

 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
You don't know. Ultimately how do you know you can trust anyone? Past experience and you make a choice. If you don't trust me that is your choice. Ultimately however bort trusts me and it's his and DD's game to administer. You pay for FPs, but if you don't like the way the business is run you don't have to continue doing business with them or you could protest as you are doing. I am not advising anyone to leave, but ultimately if you protest and your protest is not answered satisfactorily then you either live with it or take your business elsewhere. That is just a fact of life. At the end of the day you have to choose whether you trust bort to make good decisions, and if the answer is yes, fine. If the answer is no, then you have to again choose if your lack of trust is enough to get you to stop playing the game or not. I cannot really say anything more to persuade you than I already have nor can I say anything that will change the reality of that choice.


Last edited Feb 15, 2009 20:20:17
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
I find it humorous that the two loudest individuals, tossing around words like cheating/fraud/concealment/etc., both only have one player, own no team, and have made an (ostensibly) minimal financial investment as well as time devoted to recruiting/gameplanning (again, ostensibly).

I'm not sure if they're in the best position to extract from an ill-informed perception what constitutes an "advantage", and whether or not this is "cheating", yet they persist.


well I'm pretty pissed, have a trophy, pro team and a good amount of players. Can I count in you're credibility test?
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
I gave away over $200 of free flex points in competitions on the site. Pretty generous huh?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Ok, daughter is home, off again for the night,

Have fun with your wild accusations everyone.

Hope it makes ya sleep better.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Would you want to test prune candy for free?


Nope. You aren't testing for free either. You are receiving payment in the form of a decided advantage in the main game.


I'd really like it if you'd stop accusing TPat of taking advantage of his testing responsibilities with zero evidence whatsoever.


I'm not accusing him of taking advantage. I'm stating that he has received an advantage. Whether he chooses to use it or not is irrelevant.
 
Saerin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by tpaterniti


If I find out an SA doesn't work I am going to tell bort so he can change it so that it works.



And meanwhile are you going to put points in it?

Are you going to advise the players on teams you own/Gm to put points in it?

NO! You are going to save your points or put them somewhere else, while the rest of us get shafted.

This is the kind of unfair advantage everyone is pissed off about.....This is the reason everyone needs equal access to the test server.


but if through testing they can get it to work then he like many of us likely would put points in it. This makes the advantage you are so vehemently arguing about negligible
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
the two loudest individuals, both only have one player


I agree. If you don't pay hundreds of dollars to secondhand test this game, FUCK YOU. Shut up, nobody cares what you think.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by tpaterniti


If I find out an SA doesn't work I am going to tell bort so he can change it so that it works.



And meanwhile are you going to put points in it?

Are you going to advise the players on teams you own/Gm to put points in it?

NO! You are going to save your points or put them somewhere else, while the rest of us get shafted.

This is the kind of unfair advantage everyone is pissed off about.....This is the reason everyone needs equal access to the test server.


If he doesn't invest in it, and Bort fixes it, then he loses?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Originally posted by tpaterniti

I understand what everyone is saying. Thorn never denied that there is the possibility that an advantage might be gained. He simply said that the benefit to GLB outweighs the potential advantages any particular user might gain and that bort went to great lengths to ensure that the people he chose to test were people who would not be testing for the sake of gaining an advantage but to genuinely make the game better for everyone.


So why not just let us know who the testers are? Why did the Bort/Admins/Mods try to hide and cover all of this up?



inexperience is the word I would chose.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by tpaterniti


I want to keep playing because I like the game. I don't feel like I know more than anyone else. Saris has never been a tester and I think he knows a lot more about player building than me. Why would I test a game I have nothing to do with for free? Do you want to go spend hours of your life testing a game you can't play for free? And how well will you understand how to test a game you can't play?


Why do you mod for free?


To help people, and I don;t want compensation> I want the ability to play the game. I am not saying the advantage IS my compensation. Merely that it is illogical for someone to test something for free that doesn't pertain to him in any way whatsoever. Would you want to test prune candy for free?


So if Bort asked you to take a break from the game for a few seasons and do testing, what would you say?

I imagine there would be a fair amount of people who would do this. There are a lot of people who really like and support this game and would probably do it to help the game and be able to say they helped the game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.