User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > My chemistry dropped way lower than it should have.
Page:
 
timpjynx
offline
Link
 
and to be honest.. yeah, taking a -10 hit from 100 to 90 probably isn't that big a deal overall... but thats not necessarily the point.. the point is, wrong is wrong and personally i think its wrong... can't wait to see the day 24/25 thing -- i only wish it wasn't brought up until the 25th so that no backdoor coding takes place as a pre-emptive strike.. cause i've got pennies that bet trades on the 24th WILL go thru.. yep, just pennies
Last edited Aug 21, 2008 01:18:43
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
bump for bort
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
surprised at no response...
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
bort still hasn't logged in since Tuesday.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
I lost 2 chemistry yesterday for a trade going from 81 to 79... then 4 chemistry for SIGNING ONE Player... going from 79 to 75... then 3 chemistry for a trade that went through this morning... 75 to 72.

Also, for both days I did not get my +1 to chem for the day... I should be at 78 right now... not 72
 
Link
 
i signed a punter yesterday and lost like 5 chem on defense

b.s.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
What day did the trades go through? Day 19.
What day does double chemistry start? Day 19.
What does Bort suggest? Make your moves early in the season to avoid the extra hits.

You took the risk of taking a double chemistry hit when you made the moves. Is there ambiguity there, sure, you made a decent argument about 'Day 25 trades' a page or so back (I consider it a whining prevention tool because people wouldn't realize the connection and would think they could make trades on Day 24 only to find they'd already missed the deadline, personally).

The point is that you had 17 days without any ambiguity whatsoever about chemistry costs to make those moves and for whatever reason you waited until the last possible second & took the chance. Did you get screwed, maybe, is it anyone's fault but your own you were in position to be screwed, no.


Well, when you have a player wanting a trade, inactives show up at the wrong spot and you try to recruit for 2 weeks with no luck, read posts with questions on the chemistry get no response or the continued ambiguity on week 9/10, I would say I tried to do it early in the season, but the market for players is tough.

I'll accept the chem hit, but I think there needs to be consistency in the date/timing of trades with respect to the deadlines, and I think the documentation of those dates (processed or accepted) needs to be clarified...

This is not like the skill assignments and what makes a better player...I understand that needs some unknown quantity. This is an arbitrary trade deadline put in place to correct the unrestricted movement of players between teams. The rule should be clear and concise.

If chem hit is double for weeks 10-12 of processed trades, then the trade deadline, and off-season trading, should follow the same processed date rule, and it should be documented that way...
 
SlayerB
offline
Link
 
The Bangkok Authority Figures were affected by this as well. I traded away 3 inactive players for 3 active players and was hit with a 30 point chem hit!!! The trade was accepted on day 18, please address this Bort!
 
OSUDD
offline
Link
 
Bump for Bort
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Caledric
I lost 2 chemistry yesterday for a trade going from 81 to 79... then 4 chemistry for SIGNING ONE Player... going from 79 to 75... then 3 chemistry for a trade that went through this morning... 75 to 72.

Also, for both days I did not get my +1 to chem for the day... I should be at 78 right now... not 72


Working as intended in this case....
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by True Blue Titan
i signed a punter yesterday and lost like 5 chem on defense

b.s.


not possible if that was your only move. It would be a 4 chem hit
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SlayerB
The Bangkok Authority Figures were affected by this as well. I traded away 3 inactive players for 3 active players and was hit with a 30 point chem hit!!! The trade was accepted on day 18, please address this Bort!


It would either be 15 or 30, depending on when someone comes in to clarify the rules.
 
timpjynx
offline
Link
 
and i still think there should no penalty to the trader or the tradee when dealing an inactive player... if the inactive can simply be cut without penalty, why is there a penalty for trading them?

so again, to keep this bumped until an official response and/or update to documentation, i was expecting a -2 hit (adding a player), but instead received a -10... ((trading for a player (-2) + trading away an inactive player (-3)) x 2).. ouch.
Last edited Aug 21, 2008 10:26:28
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by timpjynx
and i still think there should no penalty to the trader or the tradee when dealing an inactive player... if the inactive can simply be cut without penalty, why is there a penalty for trading them?

so again, to keep this bumped until an official response and/or update to documentation, i was expecting a -2 hit (adding a player), but instead received a -10... ((trading for a player (-2) + trading away an inactive player (-3)) x 2).. ouch.


how long was the player inactive? It is only a free cut if they've been inactive for a week or longer I believe...might be even more than that.
 
timpjynx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by timpjynx

and i still think there should no penalty to the trader or the tradee when dealing an inactive player... if the inactive can simply be cut without penalty, why is there a penalty for trading them?

so again, to keep this bumped until an official response and/or update to documentation, i was expecting a -2 hit (adding a player), but instead received a -10... ((trading for a player (-2) + trading away an inactive player (-3)) x 2).. ouch.


how long was the player inactive? It is only a free cut if they've been inactive for a week or longer I believe...might be even more than that.




July 30th! that would be about 19 days, ironically enough... rule for free inactive cuts is 7 days...
Last edited Aug 21, 2008 10:49:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.