User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
cybermacy
offline
Link
 
Look... In borts defense, I can only imagine how many people complain on a daily basis to him about changes made or not made. I doubt we will ever have a perfect finished product, but we do get to enjoy the gameplay and he does, however, try to appease the masses. Again... we are paying customers... he is just trying to make as many people happy as he can.

What the game does reward though, is the active player. Those of us who do read forums and pay attention, do see the changes... and react to them swiftly. I am happy so far this season with the result.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by kevindurant35

i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


Bort posted for at least the last half of Season 3 that Speed would lose its acceleration function to Agility, and that Wrap-Up would be nerfed.

If you didn't read anything he posted, I wouldn't call it anyone's fault but yours.


Sh-pow!
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by kevindurant35

i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


He did, you didn't get the memo, oh about the 7th game of season 3????


I think everyone got the memo. Most people are not complaining about the change, they are complaining about the extent of the change. And they are right, power running is way out of proportion right now. No one in the college or pro level breaks 15 tackles game in game out, but every power back in GLB is averaging that much. Heck, even QBs were running crazy earlier. For all those people complaining the game is unrealistic and wants to make it more "real", I don't think this is what they were looking for either. Balance, the the scale went too far.

As for all those people that hate speed builds. I'm sorry to break it to you all, speed is the #1 priority for most football teams. How many times do you hear coaches say "we have to get faster"? What are the first thing college recruiters look at when they scout? That's right, speed (other than lineman of course). What's the most talked about attribute at the combines? That would be someone's 40 time. For skill positions, speed is the #1 attribute. Can't tackle them if you can't catch them....
 
staggart
offline
Link
 
many great players break tackles they just arent as famous because guys who do alot of moves are more fun to watch... For instance who fills the stands and who wins games?

http://www.nfl.com/players/earnestgraham/profile?id=GRA186147

or

http://www.nfl.com/players/reggiebush/profile?id=BUS294963

Yeah.... one is a power runner who gets no hype because he is boring to watch
 
cybermacy
offline
Link
 
Jerry Rice only ran a 4.6 40 time
 
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by kevindurant35


i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


He did, you didn't get the memo, oh about the 7th game of season 3????


I think everyone got the memo. Most people are not complaining about the change, they are complaining about the extent of the change. And they are right, power running is way out of proportion right now. No one in the college or pro level breaks 15 tackles game in game out, but every power back in GLB is averaging that much. Heck, even QBs were running crazy earlier. For all those people complaining the game is unrealistic and wants to make it more "real", I don't think this is what they were looking for either. Balance, the the scale went too far.

As for all those people that hate speed builds. I'm sorry to break it to you all, speed is the #1 priority for most football teams. How many times do you hear coaches say "we have to get faster"? What are the first thing college recruiters look at when they scout? That's right, speed (other than lineman of course). What's the most talked about attribute at the combines? That would be someone's 40 time. For skill positions, speed is the #1 attribute. Can't tackle them if you can't catch them....


speed is fine as long as you can do more then run in a strait line and wave when ya get there. Thats why the other attributes come into play. agility makes you cut, vision makes you have a clue and tackling makes you be able to tackle etc... thats why olympic gold medalists dont automatically get NFL contracts.
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by kevindurant35


i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


He did, you didn't get the memo, oh about the 7th game of season 3????


I think everyone got the memo. Most people are not complaining about the change, they are complaining about the extent of the change. And they are right, power running is way out of proportion right now. No one in the college or pro level breaks 15 tackles game in game out, but every power back in GLB is averaging that much. Heck, even QBs were running crazy earlier. For all those people complaining the game is unrealistic and wants to make it more "real", I don't think this is what they were looking for either. Balance, the the scale went too far.

As for all those people that hate speed builds. I'm sorry to break it to you all, speed is the #1 priority for most football teams. How many times do you hear coaches say "we have to get faster"? What are the first thing college recruiters look at when they scout? That's right, speed (other than lineman of course). What's the most talked about attribute at the combines? That would be someone's 40 time. For skill positions, speed is the #1 attribute. Can't tackle them if you can't catch them....


Nobody breaks 15 tackles. I think you don't watch very much football. A broken tackle doesn't have to be a straight up face to face run the defender over, in most cases it is an arm tackle or a bad angle that just doesn't allow a defender to get the power runner to the ground. People choose how they want to build. Many of them chose to go power, like a Jerome Bettis. I watched plenty of games where he ran 3-4 guys over on single plays. Also, its the fault of builds, stop trying to make 70-80 speed LBs and DEs and focus more on the run stop.

If your a LB or DE and you want to be super fast and a pass rusher, you will not be as good stopping the run. The LBs and DEs built like the average NFL LB or DE with balanced strength, speed, agility, and tackling are doing fine.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by kevindurant35


i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


He did, you didn't get the memo, oh about the 7th game of season 3????


I think everyone got the memo. Most people are not complaining about the change, they are complaining about the extent of the change. And they are right, power running is way out of proportion right now. No one in the college or pro level breaks 15 tackles game in game out, but every power back in GLB is averaging that much.


Some come damn close, but in any event the linebackers and many of the safeties they face have 50-60 Tackling. They're facing a lot of them with 25-30 Tackling right now.

The builds currently in the game are causing the power running dominance.

Once we see enough LB's with soft-capped Tackling and most of their eq there, then we'll start seeing power backs less dominant. And they aren't as dominant as you think. Heck, in USA Pro half the teams are getting less than 3.5 pards per rush; in the NFL it's 4 yards per rush.

LB's will need to make choices, to go for Tackling and Strength to bring down power runners, or balance them more with Speed and Agility to defend passes and speed runners better, or Vision to fight Jukes and Head Fakes. But more will go for more Tackling and somewhat more Strength than have now, and at that point different types of runners will have more success against different types of teams based on overall team builds.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cybermacy
Jerry Rice only ran a 4.6 40 time


I'm not saying speed is the only attribute you need, I'm just saying of all the attributes for skilled positions, it is the most important attribute to a lot of the coaches and scouts.

Jerry Rice is special, and players like Tom Waddle can play in the NFL too. But that doesn't mean speed is not important.

BTW, 4.6 40 in the 80's weren't slow. Guys running 4.5s at the time were considered burners. Now there is a gazillion players can run 4.5.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by staggart
many great players break tackles they just arent as famous because guys who do alot of moves are more fun to watch... For instance who fills the stands and who wins games?

http://www.nfl.com/players/earnestgraham/profile?id=GRA186147

or

http://www.nfl.com/players/reggiebush/profile?id=BUS294963

Yeah.... one is a power runner who gets no hype because he is boring to watch


Other than Bettis, can you name another power back that have consistent 1000 yard seasons? Graham is a nice back, but he has 1,113 career rushing yards. Reggie Bush is one of the most HYPEd backs, but that doesn't make him a good example.

Power backs are rare because few can handle the pounding they take game in and game out. Even then, how many tackles does Graham break each game?
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
As a note - I checked the running plays in our game tonight - the LBs on both teams are still running away from the line of scrimmage on every running play I looked at (unless the player was blitzing).

Awesome. I'm really glad it was fixed a few days ago.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
I like the changes, bad builds finally caught up to people


Quit whining and leave already
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
I like the changes, bad builds finally caught up to people


Quit whining and leave already


Or fix your build. But quit whining because you didn't put enough tackling into your player and now he can't tackle.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CRich
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by kevindurant35



i will just like a heads up when you are "nerfing" stuff


He did, you didn't get the memo, oh about the 7th game of season 3????


I think everyone got the memo. Most people are not complaining about the change, they are complaining about the extent of the change. And they are right, power running is way out of proportion right now. No one in the college or pro level breaks 15 tackles game in game out, but every power back in GLB is averaging that much. Heck, even QBs were running crazy earlier. For all those people complaining the game is unrealistic and wants to make it more "real", I don't think this is what they were looking for either. Balance, the the scale went too far.

As for all those people that hate speed builds. I'm sorry to break it to you all, speed is the #1 priority for most football teams. How many times do you hear coaches say "we have to get faster"? What are the first thing college recruiters look at when they scout? That's right, speed (other than lineman of course). What's the most talked about attribute at the combines? That would be someone's 40 time. For skill positions, speed is the #1 attribute. Can't tackle them if you can't catch them....


Nobody breaks 15 tackles. I think you don't watch very much football. A broken tackle doesn't have to be a straight up face to face run the defender over, in most cases it is an arm tackle or a bad angle that just doesn't allow a defender to get the power runner to the ground. People choose how they want to build. Many of them chose to go power, like a Jerome Bettis. I watched plenty of games where he ran 3-4 guys over on single plays. Also, its the fault of builds, stop trying to make 70-80 speed LBs and DEs and focus more on the run stop.

If your a LB or DE and you want to be super fast and a pass rusher, you will not be as good stopping the run. The LBs and DEs built like the average NFL LB or DE with balanced strength, speed, agility, and tackling are doing fine.


I agree with what you are saying to a degree. Most of the broken tackles are arm tackles, that's why you don't see that many broken tackles in the NFL, few people try to arm tackle at that level. Besides, a tackle doesn't have to be a Steve Atwater tackle. DBs in the Pro or College level will rarely take a HB head on, they usually take their legs out, trip them up or push them out of bounds. So strength != broken tackles or missed tackles. There should be a balance among all major attributes to be effective.

Again, all I am saying is that right now, the game is not "balanced", power backs have it too good. The nerfing went too far.

BTW, I'm modifying all my HBs into combo/power backs. I adjust too. So no need to tell me to adjust.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

I like the changes, bad builds finally caught up to people


Quit whining and leave already


Or fix your build. But quit whining because you didn't put enough tackling into your player and now he can't tackle.


Fortunately for me most of my guys are balanced and most of them are in the teen levels so they can still adjust. But I can totally understand people complaining with their players in the mid 20 levels. It's much harder to change when you are level 25. It took 3 seasons for people to build these guys, you don't just change the rules drastically one day and tell them to scrap it or adjust. Instead of just flaming people, people needs to understand where everyone is coming from. I believe most of us posting here are trying to make the game better.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.