User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vindictus
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

I would have thought this would have deserved an answer by now..........




I think the low carrying score answered it for Bort.


Learn to read.
 
Vindictus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
For the 6th time, allow me to reiterate the point of this thread:

The Return Specialist ability is currently a waste of skill points, as it has no noticeable affect on the abilities of a Kick Returning CB. Currently, any other player is better as a returner, because they can use their skill points in abilities like Juke or Headfake (WRs, HBs) that help on Offense as well, or can max strength to break tackles (OT) which also helps on Offense. If a corner back uses his points in Return Specialist, he not only makes himself less effective as a Returner (since the ability does nothing), he also makes himself less effective as a Defender, as he could have used those points for something else.

In summation: The Return Specialist ability sucks and needs to be fixed.


Tell you what I am for, an explicit explanation of what each special ability does to the game mechanics, the verbal explanation is nice and all but it doesn't help you know what it really does.
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vindictus
Originally posted by Arles

I challenge anyone to look at this guy's open build and tell me there's nothing wrong with KR/PR by CBs:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=31604

59 speed, 46 agility, 42 vision and 11 return spec!

Last season: 79 PRs, 14.3 ave
this season: 21 PRs, 8.7 ave

Same league, same team, same blockers. He might have been better off putting the 11 return spec points into jumping and then maybe he could leap over the ST gunners.


Your carrying is crap. Your strength is crap. Not only should your guy not be able to break any tackles, he should fumble at least 60% of the time. All your opponents this season, compared to last, are faster. That 8.7 avg has more to do with the distance their closing, not the distance you fail to close.

[whooshhh!]
That's the sound of the point of the post flying past your ears. First, he's not my player, just someone with an open build referenced earlier in the thread. Next, at no point did I say he should be breaking more tackles. My point was that if a player with 59 speed, 46 agility and 41 vision gets NO benefit from return specialist (averages 8.7 per PR), why even have it.

Return specialist reads:
"This CB is very adept at returning kicks and punts. The Return Specialist skill gives him a bonus to speed, agility and tackle avoidance when returning kicks."

Bolded part for your benefit. Tackle AVOIDANCE, not breaking tackles. If you have 50 agility and an 11 return spec, you should be able to AVOID a tackle every now and then (not break one).

It should read:
"You idiot. Your first mistake was making a CB a returner. Your next mistake was putting points here actually thinking it would help your guy avoid tackles and have better returns. You should have put these points into strength and carrying - then your PR may have had a chance at 1-2 "pinball" returns a game."
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 14:38:31
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vindictus
Originally posted by Yellow


Another person who has completely missed the point of this thread. I congratulate you.


OK I'll address your point more bluntly.

You have a 16 carrying, a 16 strength. Even if 11 return speck gave you a straight % break tackle chance over and above taking into consideration your opponents tackling and strength, you'd basically have an 11% chance to break a tackle.

And since it does take into account the opponents tackle, your 11 spec doesn't matter for breaking tackles in this regard.

Does the 11 spec come in handy for your speed and agil scores? Probably. Does it help break your tackles? Yes but your base chance is too low to matter atm. I would suggest training your carrying and spending skill points on it.


Perhaps Bort should change the boost to 110%
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
After looking through multiple return footage for roughly 10 different "return specialists", I've narrowed the problems down to these possibilities:

(Keep in mind, I'm not looking for CB to break tackles. I'm looking for them to return the ball in a speedy fashion and avg. MORE yards than a HB or WR who does not have the return specialist ability)

- Special teams players have now been coded to run in "lanes" rather than flock to the ball. This could have possibly been put in for the return team as well and is affecting the return man by having him run straight up the field rather than cutting to the right/left as he would in season 1-3.

- Most CB's will return set to elusive. There is a problem (admitted by Bort) with the elusive running style where the runner will pause and "dance" in one spot while he "decides" the best route to avoid a tackle.

- WR's and CB's have had speed nerfed (possibly all positions). This could be affecting the speed with which they return.

- "Super Vision" may no longer be triggering on returns.


Sure strength and carrying should help with the breaking of tackles but I think the goal with havinng a CB return a ball is to not be touched to begin with.


Bort - If this happens to be acknowledged, would you check the above mentioned possibilities.


Everyone else - In the mean time, try changing up the running style and/or just finding another guy on your team to return kicks/punts until this is dealt with. Endless arguing with one another isn't making this any better, especially when we're arguing about builds from 2 different points of view. A CB with 15 strength and carrying is NOT going to break many tackles and probably will fumble a bit BUT if he has 55+ vision/speed/agility and 5+ points into first step/change direction/return specialist he shouldn't HAVE to break many tackles to begin with. He should be a burst of speed right off the line, weave as much as possible when needed, and go down with a 20+ yard return every now and then. Not run 15-20 feet right up the middle of the field and get toasted.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 16:20:35
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
Yeah, my biggest issue is what is the return specialist supposed to do? Ie, how does it help? It sounds like people are saying you need 30 str and 30 carrying to get anything out of it. Whereas, I'm looking at it like a "juke" specially made for return guys (so, a high agility would be the main trigger).

If we atleast knew what return spec is supposed to do to help, that may help us figure out what we need to do with our player to maximize it. Right now, I see 8-11 return spec guys with 50 agility getting absolutely nothing from it.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CableJelly
After looking through multiple return footage for roughly 10 different "return specialists", I've narrowed the problems down to these possibilities:

(Keep in mind, I'm not looking for CB to break tackles. I'm looking for them to return the ball in a speedy fashion and avg. MORE yards than a HB or WR who does not have the return specialist ability)

- Special teams players have now been coded to run in "lanes" rather than flock to the ball. This could have possibly been put in for the return team as well and is affecting the return man by having him run straight up the field rather than cutting to the right/left as he would in season 1-3.

- Most CB's will return set to elusive. There is a problem (admitted by Bort) with the elusive running style where the runner will pause and "dance" in one spot while he "decides" the best route to avoid a tackle.

- WR's and CB's have had speed nerfed (possibly all positions). This could be affecting the speed with which they return.

- "Super Vision" may no longer be triggering on returns.


Sure strength and carrying should help with the breaking of tackles but I think the goal with havinng a CB return a ball is to not be touched to begin with.


Bort - If this happens to be acknowledged, would you check the above mentioned possibilities.


Everyone else - In the mean time, try changing up the running style and/or just finding another guy on your team to return kicks/punts until this is dealt with. Endless arguing with one another isn't making this any better, especially when we're arguing about builds from 2 different points of view. A CB with 15 strength and carrying is NOT going to break many tackles and probably will fumble a bit BUT if he has 55+ vision/speed/agility and 5+ points into first step/change direction/return specialist he shouldn't HAVE to break many tackles to begin with. He should be a burst of speed right off the line, weave as much as possible when needed, and go down with a 20+ yard return every now and then. Not run 15-20 feet right up the middle of the field and get toasted.


Great post.

I'm having the same trouble with my (70+ Speed, 50+ Agility, multiple points in Super Vision and Return Specialty) Cornerback. He has brought a kickoff back for TD this season, but his Punt Return average has been so bad (along with everyone else) that I took him off of Punt Returns, as it is a HUGE waste of my Stamina.

There is obviously a huge problem. I'm in the same league as last year, playing against similar competition, yet I boosted early in the season, while many others did not, yet my Punt Return average has still dropped almost 7 yards from this year to last.

Where is Bort?

I guess we have to get to 200 replies, 100+ isn't cutting it.

 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Returns have turned into nothing more than putting your best blockers in the middle and if the returner breaks a tackle, he's gone. My team went back2back2back KOs for TDs today using a power HB and FB. Thats 5 TDs in 2 games. Another team is using an OT and he's busted one. The problem is that players stay in their lanes and now there is no reason NOT to just plow up the middle of the field. CBs tend to be too weak to break the tackles needed for good returns now.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 17:38:27
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Here is an example of why ELUSIVE is broken:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=106977&pbp_id=2006869

My CB should have EASILY been able to jog into the endzone, but he instead waits around to be tackled.

Now, this is a joke.
 
Havok1769
offline
Link
 
From: Thorn
Date Sent: Aug 10, 2008 15:36:52
Subject: Re: CB's not real returners
Currently we're working on making sure the AI is working with no major bugs, from there I'd expect us to take a look at the special abilities which include the corner back tree.
-Thorn

---------- Original message ----------
From: Havok1769
Date: Aug 9, 2008 23:57:26
Subject: CB's not real returners
To: Thorn

Can we please have some sort of official response for this thread http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=753449 even some sort of 'It's being looked into' would be fine.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Thanks Havok, hopefully we can get Bort to come in and confirm this.
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
Appreciate it Havok. I'd take Thorn's word on this. He's come through on other issues (via PM) in the past. If this hasn't made it's way to Bort yet, I'm sure Thorn has pointed it out to him
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DAKING
Originally posted by sxewesley

Originally posted by DAKING


Originally posted by fate3283



Originally posted by DAKING




Originally posted by fate3283





Originally posted by DAKING






Montreal Knights star CB/KR/PR has been doing great at those spots
He has two KR returns and 2 picks (3 TDs on the season)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=31322

Returns:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110589&pbp_id=1541847 - KR
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110589&pbp_id=1547052 - INT
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110590&pbp_id=1976913 - KR

He has less than 50 speed
70 agility
8 in kr specialist and 2 in super vision


I love when people post this garbage, your CB is level 25 playing against a bunch of guys 10 levels lower than him, so you say you have a viable returner...

Even on the TD returns you ran in a STRAIGHT line until you were past the first defender, that is the main problem.

Return specialist is supposed to give a bonus to speed as well, why is it the CBs seem to run at the same speed when returning and when covering WRs?


Better edit your post and their team is great and I am sure their speed is higher than 49

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=3420


Look at the players on the KRs that were posted, the players on the field were 10 levels lower with one lvl 20, learn to read before you post please


Ok....SO?
Y'all are saying it is so bad, but he is returning and leading the league in Int and KR average
Put your O-Line on KRS and enter a FB and TE in the first 3 slots


Thanks for wasting 10 minutes of my life. I looked through your entire conference. The CB you keep pimping is level 25. There is one or two other level 25s in the ENTIRE conference.

Do not post here again with your worthless opinion. There is a clear bug here the needs to be addressed ASAP, we need zero posts from you and one post from Bort acknowledging the problem, that is all.


Who is the idiot that is crying cuz his crap CB cant return?
You not I
He is not one of the only three that are Lv 25


Your halfway decent CB who out levels everyone in your garbage league has nothing to do with this thread.

You are a moron.

At least someone has acknowledged that this might be looked at sometime in the future. That is a start at least.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crying Eagle
y'all stop whining and pump supervision up. agility also. wtf, to return a k/p for a good yardage, u need freakin awesome blockers. those int TD rarely happen, maybe once or twice per season.

anyways, here's my returner, featured in Tpat's guide.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=237402


My CB is exactly like yours, except for the part where his speed, agility, strength, carrying, vision and everything else are higher then yours.

So. with all due respect, shut the hell up.

 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
Originally posted by Crying Eagle

y'all stop whining and pump supervision up. agility also. wtf, to return a k/p for a good yardage, u need freakin awesome blockers. those int TD rarely happen, maybe once or twice per season.

anyways, here's my returner, featured in Tpat's guide.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=237402


My CB is exactly like yours, except for the part where his speed, agility, strength, carrying, vision and everything else are higher then yours.

So. with all due respect, shut the hell up.



You know the funny thing about Crying Eagle's CB, is that he is actually a lot worse in Punt Returns this year, when compared to last, but he doesn't even know it.

He only has 1 game this season that he averaged more in Punt Return average, than he averaged for the season last year. And that one game is a bit distorted, because he was able to score a TD. So without that TD, he is MUCH worse than last year, but he's just not bright enough to figure it out.

Besides, this guy only has 62 Speed at Level 25? And he thinks he's special, how funny.

The douche doesn't even know that his CB is garbage.

Last edited Aug 10, 2008 20:15:47
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.