Originally posted by drifter
How are you coming up with such a low advantage?
5 seasons x 3 boost per year = 15
Daily Experience = 40*75 (conservatively) = 3000
That's 18 levels by the time the shelved player plays his first play, compared to 4 levels for the player who starts immediately. Now, over the next 10,000 plays the shelved player will gain experience a little lower than the boosted player but not really that much. Conservatively once again, let's say a player starting at 4 will gain 3 levels per year average (not including boosting). Since the shelved player started at a higher level we'll say he gains 2 levels per year from this point on (and I think it wouldn't be that big a disparity, but none of us really know how exp works at higher levels).
Because the daily XP is exponentially less as you go up in level. FREX, "common" sense would tell you that a boosted player would be 15 levels higher than a non-boosted player after five seasons. Not so. I took a spreadsheet, and did the progression of experience - assuming that lvl 1 earns 100/day, lvl 2 = 96/day, lvl 3 = 92/day, and so on. That led to the following stats, assuming two players who sat on the bench, one boosting on the last day of each season, and one not:
Day/Season_______Unboosted___Boosted
Season 1, Day 40_____Lvl 4_____Lvl 7
Season 2, Day 40_____Lvl 7_____Lvl 13
Season 3, Day 40_____Lvl 10____Lvl 18
Season 4, Day 40_____Lvl 13____Lvl 22
Season 5, Day 40_____Lvl 15____Lvl 26
Now, that's using my above assumptions for XP earning. I think it's actually worse than that, because the XP my players earned last night didn't equal what I though it should - FREX, in my progression, I have lvl 7 as earning 74 XP a night, but my lvl 7s only earned 73 xp last night. Same with my lvl 9 - my progression said I should have earned 68 xp, I only earned 65 xp. I'll update my spreadsheet in a day or so, after I've confirmed some of the numbers.
Anyway, that's two players who are NOT playing. My gut feeling tells me that a player who is playing will be at least 3-5 levels above a non playing one at the end of those same five seasons, and since the progression gets harder as you go up in level, by the time you hit 10 seasons, they'll probably be the same level. So any advantage is only in the "additional" seasons.
Now, one thing I didn't account for is any boosting done in those additional seasons, which does up the advantage. On the flip side, while we know the difference in quality between a level 1 and a level 15 QB is substantial right now, we also know that as you progress, stats and abilities get more expensive to increase - so the difference between a level 40 and a level 50 QB may not be so big. But we wont' know that until someone gets there.
Originally posted by Malachorn
I love how you guys keep trying so hard to make this sound like the answer.
You guys say yourselves that it would "only" be a five level experience in the end, if you sit on the bench. Drifter reminds you of boosting, which you conveniently forgot... what about all that?
There is no way around it.
This system would benefit the guys that aren't playing in the beginning of their careers and storing up levels.
It's a ridiculous way to "fix" things and isn't a real fix. It just creates DIFFERENT problems. Problems that I actually think are even more absurd and potentially even more destructive to the game.
It's only ridiculous if you don't combine it with some sort of aging system. Once you add some sort of aging, then it makes just as much sense as a 10 season career cap.
Given that every thing else is exponential, if you making aging effects exponential as well, then any benefit from sitting on the bench at all goes away.