User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Preseason Games: Kinks / Bugs? Acknowledged
Page:
 
Beenie
offline
Link
 
Check our last game:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=79403

We had 24 Attempts. But only 4 of them were thrown to a WR?!
Any explanations on that problem?
 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XUMuskie85


I did that for my WRs and CBs depth chart.

Here were my play counts (although we were favoring backups the entire 2nd half):
WR1 (low 40s stamina): 44
WR2 (low 30s stamina): 51
WR3: 39
WR4: 57
WR5: 39

I don't really get how my WR#1 was out so much in the 1st half, but otherwise everyone seemed to sub well in the 1st half. I don't have exact numbers because I didn't go through each play, maybe I'll do that now...


THANK YOU!
Please, more examples the better. Then we know what to do.
So it SEEMS like it works, although favoring backups might def. have skewed it. But hopefully others will confirm.
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Here we go:

I charted it for the 1st half but first a couple of caveats:
1. Our depth chart is slightly different than the example (due to WR3 and WR4 being similar in ability)
WR1: WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR2: WR2, WR1, WR4, WR3, WR5
WR3: WR3, WR4, WR5
WR4: WR4, WR5
WR5: WR5
2. We force starters in the redzone, so this gave WR1+2 about 8 more plays and WR3 about 2 more plays than normal (although these may have been made up for the next drive when WR1+2 were out the first few plays.

So plays for the first half before favoring backups:
WR1: 33
WR2: 33
WR3: 25
WR4: 23
WR5: 3

May need to do something to get WR5 more time...
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 12:24:50
 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beenie
Check our last game:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=79403

We had 24 Attempts. But only 4 of them were thrown to a WR?!
Any explanations on that problem?


Nope.

Check your AI Tactics though. And then check your advanced AI. A LOT of people have been setting 1 or 2 things wrong that will make drastic changes. And remember, if you're using the Advance AI, the sim goes from top to bottom. So if your 1st or 2nd input happens a lot, then the sim will ALWAYS choose that play and never get to your 3rd, 4th inputs and so on. E.g. - 2nd and 4 - 2nd and 8 short pass to FB/TE. That would probably account for 30% of your total plays.

But double and triple check your settings and then post with specifics. Then Bort can go in and say... "Wtf? Ok, fixed." or "Idiot, check harder next time and fix your 3rd input."
 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XUMuskie85
Here we go:

I charted it for the 1st half but first a couple of caveats:
1. Our depth chart is slightly different than the example (due to WR3 and WR4 being similar in ability)
WR1: WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR2: WR2, WR4, WR3, WR5
WR3: WR3, WR4, WR5
WR4: WR4, WR5
WR5: WR5
2. We force starters in the redzone, so this gave WR1+2 about 8 more plays and WR3 about 2 more plays than normal (although these may have been made up for the next drive when WR1+2 were out the first few plays.

So plays for the first half before favoring backups:
WR1: 33
WR2: 33
WR3: 25
WR4: 23
WR5: 3

May need to do something to get WR5 more time...


AWESOME. Thank you!
Although I'm sure ppl would still like a couple more confirmations, it seems that that answers any and all questions regarding WR1-5 and CB1-5. When we run our sim tomorrow morning I'll be sure to post also.

Try putting your WR5 on both ST's and maybe put them at 3rd on the WR1 depth
Or cut them
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snaza
Originally posted by XUMuskie85

Here we go:

I charted it for the 1st half but first a couple of caveats:
1. Our depth chart is slightly different than the example (due to WR3 and WR4 being similar in ability)
WR1: WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR2: WR2, WR4, WR3, WR5
WR3: WR3, WR4, WR5
WR4: WR4, WR5
WR5: WR5
2. We force starters in the redzone, so this gave WR1+2 about 8 more plays and WR3 about 2 more plays than normal (although these may have been made up for the next drive when WR1+2 were out the first few plays.

So plays for the first half before favoring backups:
WR1: 33
WR2: 33
WR3: 25
WR4: 23
WR5: 3

May need to do something to get WR5 more time...


AWESOME. Thank you!
Although I'm sure ppl would still like a couple more confirmations, it seems that that answers any and all questions regarding WR1-5 and CB1-5. When we run our sim tomorrow morning I'll be sure to post also.

Try putting your WR5 on both ST's and maybe put them at 3rd on the WR1 depth
Or cut them


Haha yeah, after I typed that I realized my count didn't include special teams, where WR5 is a starter on one and a backup on the other. Besides, we usually kill teams so the backups get a lot of time
 
Link
 
Originally posted by XUMuskie85
Originally posted by Snaza

Originally posted by XUMuskie85


Here we go:

I charted it for the 1st half but first a couple of caveats:
1. Our depth chart is slightly different than the example (due to WR3 and WR4 being similar in ability)
WR1: WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR2: WR2, WR4, WR3, WR5
WR3: WR3, WR4, WR5
WR4: WR4, WR5
WR5: WR5
2. We force starters in the redzone, so this gave WR1+2 about 8 more plays and WR3 about 2 more plays than normal (although these may have been made up for the next drive when WR1+2 were out the first few plays.

So plays for the first half before favoring backups:
WR1: 33
WR2: 33
WR3: 25
WR4: 23
WR5: 3

May need to do something to get WR5 more time...


AWESOME. Thank you!
Although I'm sure ppl would still like a couple more confirmations, it seems that that answers any and all questions regarding WR1-5 and CB1-5. When we run our sim tomorrow morning I'll be sure to post also.

Try putting your WR5 on both ST's and maybe put them at 3rd on the WR1 depth
Or cut them


Haha yeah, after I typed that I realized my count didn't include special teams, where WR5 is a starter on one and a backup on the other. Besides, we usually kill teams so the backups get a lot of time

I don't know if this is on topic or not, just saw that my owner posted. So Muskie, did you know that the starting SS got a few plays in at corner even though we have that filled out the same way?
 
Craw33
offline
Link
 
Don't Know if this has been brought up. But I think it is a major flaw in the Defense AI. It will not save my options for 0WR 0WR always defaults back to 0WR 6WR so I am in goalline defense almost all game. Tried Updating and saving as preset.
 
pat2007
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I found what was most likely the culprit for a lot of drops a couple hours ago - I changed the way the ball behaves when you tip it. Before, it was much more likely to get tipped straight up or "bobbled" then just go flying off away from the receiver. This meant that the receiver basically got multiple chances to catch the ball, instead of just one.

I started thinking about it, though, and I think I kind of like the old "bobbling" for lower catching guys, so I changed it back. It's still harder for them to catch the ball, and it means they have to slow down or stop to reel it in, while the higher catching guys can just catch it in stride and keep going.
 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snaza


I AM however getting annoyed by all the people posting here w/o reading the WHOLE thread! Or atleast the OP for god's sake.
Most of your questions have been answered right there.
YES, broken tackles are up and will stay up.
YES, drops will happen more this season. I think it's high and will be tweaked, but they'll still be up.
Tackling on the Dline is GOING to be better b/c a lot of them have a high tackling number, so you WILL have more TFL's this season.
That double LB on the RB is NOT right and thank you for posting the examples.

The LB running away from the QB IS wrong. Example, thanks.
pumph, throw your example of the 48 seconds left play up there.
A CB is allowed to be in the path of a WR and the WR would have to go around him, maybe that's what the sim is thinking. But Bort did change how blocking, players bumping each other, and all that reacted to the sims. So it may get tweaked.


Nice work on the resume. Altough i think as long as we don't get an official announcement from either Bort or DD i think everything said will be considered assumption.

edited for typo

Last edited Jul 30, 2008 14:20:07
 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pat2007
Originally posted by Bort

I found what was most likely the culprit for a lot of drops a couple hours ago - I changed the way the ball behaves when you tip it. Before, it was much more likely to get tipped straight up or "bobbled" then just go flying off away from the receiver. This meant that the receiver basically got multiple chances to catch the ball, instead of just one.

I started thinking about it, though, and I think I kind of like the old "bobbling" for lower catching guys, so I changed it back. It's still harder for them to catch the ball, and it means they have to slow down or stop to reel it in, while the higher catching guys can just catch it in stride and keep going.


Thanks pat! That explains a lot of the drops Anyway you could EDIT that and get a link in there to the post?

EDIT - found it http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=717445

neverdodge, I totally agree. I'll never claim to be the truth, but intelligent and researched assumptions are better than ppl who just throw their 2cents in there IMO. Hope some people got useful info from all that.
Seems they might've though as I just came back after 3 hours and only a couple posts are up.
Stromstarhammer, I'm HOPING that was because you guys were beating them badly and so your D was on the field more. Looking at it your D was NOT on the field more, but they did throw the ball 41 times. Hopefully that's why your CB's were tired, forcing a SS to play CB for a play or 2.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 15:47:46
 
Bladow
offline
Link
 
here is an interesting one.

Missed tackle when the ball was incomplete

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78495&pbp_id=330823

 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bladow
here is an interesting one.

Missed tackle when the ball was incomplete

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78495&pbp_id=330823



I don't think it's a bug, you know what i THINK happened?
The defender hit the WR so hard the ball came out before he made a 'Football Move' as they say in the NFL.
So, WR catches the ball and shakes of a DB while catching it and then gets popped by another DB causing the ball to pop out - ruled incomplete and not a fumble. Maybe the coach even challenged it
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 15:45:26
 
Fealty
offline
Link
 
Well this would explain the increase in missed tackles.
 
thebeils
offline
Link
 
Dropped 6 passes in the first game. Lv 21 with 55 catch attribute.
Every drop was on a curl route, with my WR facing the QB (or so it would seem from the orientation of the little circles...)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.