Originally posted by cubsluver22
http://glb.warriorgeneral.com/game/player.pl?player_id=4453416 We'll start with an easy one a Punter. Now open and post yours and let's all compareRJ Scrub Westbrook (Lv. 76 P)
Ht/Wt: 6'2", 250lbs
Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 100.36
Speed: 32
Agility: 60.58
Jumping: 67.58
Stamina: 49
Vision: 89.58 (+6)
Confidence: 90.36
Football Skills
Blocking: 8
Catching: 8
Tackling: 10
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 8
Kicking: 8
Punting: 156.36 (+49)
Special Abilities
Punting Abilities
Calm Nerves: 10
Hang Time: 10
Big Boot: 12
Additional Abilities
First Step: 0
Veteran Abilities
Soccer Star: 15
Football Genius: 11
Clutch: 15
Leg of Steel: 15
Nail in the Coffin: 15
Current Bonuses/Penalties
Vision: +4.6
Kicking: +0.36
Punting: +4.83
Learn to follow directions. You agreed to post all your tax statements, open all your builds, and screenshot your best DAI including all plays and packages. Instead I get a freaking punter? You're not holding up your end, and I'm not obligated to do ANYTHING until you fulfill your end of the bargain.
However, just because I'm a good guy I will give you some honest feedback on this dot, but don't expect I'm going to do it again until you completely hold up your end of the agreement. But for this dot I'll give you something:
Comparing my level 73 Punter to your level 76 Punter
Primary ability (punting) is about the same, yours (rounded) is 156 mine 155
Secondary ability your 100 mine 101
Third ability both 90
All my SAs are higher than all of yours
VAs are exactly the same except my dot has 1 more VA point than your dot
Otherwise there's what I would consider less important choices. For instance you've got 49 stamina where I stopped stamina in the 20's. In exchange I have some tackling ability and you've basically got none. My punter is a technician type whereas yours is a boomer type so we made different choices for our 2nd and 3rd abilities.
All of this may suggest that I would evaluate my dot as slightly better than yours given how seemingly similar they are on attributes while mine has an advantage on SAs/VAs and is only lvl 73 while yours is lvl 76. However, in actuality I consider your dot to be a bust and a much, much worse build than mine. It's not all about how many points you have it's about using those points in such a way that best benefits a team's chance of winning. Now you'll probably just poo poo these comments and suggest that I have no idea what I'm talking about but if you look at my KR/PR on CCIA I'm sure you'll notice that he's won the MVP the last 3 seasons running, all in Elite. When I'm game planning for an opponent and they have a P with a build like yours I get very excited and I win more MVPs. So I would evaluate your dot as a very poor build and my dot as a superb build. Which is going to be consistent with all your dots, because you don't build them with any deep understanding or insight into how your choices affect a team's chance to win. So unless you just get blind lucky on occasion you will always build far inferior dots to mine.