Originally posted by TrevJo
My feeling is that while Bort's ideas to solve this problem are well-intended, they are not very practical, largely because they are gimmicky.
Simple Alternate Suggestion: Increase promotion/relegation to include more teams each season. Also make it possible for a team to be relegated 2 levels in one season, since there are so many of these gutted teams (and probably will be for a long time).
Current system: In each conference, 1 team (conf champ) is promoted and 2 teams are relegated.
Proposed system: In each conference, 2 teams (conf champ + reg season champ, or if those are the same then conf runner up) are promoted, and 4 teams are relegated. Last-place team is relegated 2 levels.
Of course there will need to be some tweaking to make the numbers work out right because of the team that moves down 2, but you get the idea.
I think this fairly aggressive approach has been shown to be justified. It's obvious that those who were afraid to have more than 1 team promoted and 2 demoted each season had underestimated the imbalance that would remain in the leagues.
I've seen this bashed a lot, but I honestly think this is the best approach, the main complaint I've see is that higher leagues lose too many teams due to the whole pyramid thing. My view is that the more teams that are relegated, the more prestigious the higher leagues become, it's much harder to stay there for long periods of time.
So I concur with this and think more relegations are required.
In the case of a team being sold, I think there should be an option for an existing player to take over as caretaker for the rest of the season, there will probably be cases where the team cohesion is just not there and it won't work, but my experience has shown that teams generally have a group of loyal players who would try and build together.
These options may conflict but I am just throwing ideas out there.
My feeling is that while Bort's ideas to solve this problem are well-intended, they are not very practical, largely because they are gimmicky.
Simple Alternate Suggestion: Increase promotion/relegation to include more teams each season. Also make it possible for a team to be relegated 2 levels in one season, since there are so many of these gutted teams (and probably will be for a long time).
Current system: In each conference, 1 team (conf champ) is promoted and 2 teams are relegated.
Proposed system: In each conference, 2 teams (conf champ + reg season champ, or if those are the same then conf runner up) are promoted, and 4 teams are relegated. Last-place team is relegated 2 levels.
Of course there will need to be some tweaking to make the numbers work out right because of the team that moves down 2, but you get the idea.
I think this fairly aggressive approach has been shown to be justified. It's obvious that those who were afraid to have more than 1 team promoted and 2 demoted each season had underestimated the imbalance that would remain in the leagues.
I've seen this bashed a lot, but I honestly think this is the best approach, the main complaint I've see is that higher leagues lose too many teams due to the whole pyramid thing. My view is that the more teams that are relegated, the more prestigious the higher leagues become, it's much harder to stay there for long periods of time.
So I concur with this and think more relegations are required.
In the case of a team being sold, I think there should be an option for an existing player to take over as caretaker for the rest of the season, there will probably be cases where the team cohesion is just not there and it won't work, but my experience has shown that teams generally have a group of loyal players who would try and build together.
These options may conflict but I am just throwing ideas out there.






























