User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
Barry20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
My feeling is that while Bort's ideas to solve this problem are well-intended, they are not very practical, largely because they are gimmicky.

Simple Alternate Suggestion: Increase promotion/relegation to include more teams each season. Also make it possible for a team to be relegated 2 levels in one season, since there are so many of these gutted teams (and probably will be for a long time).

Current system: In each conference, 1 team (conf champ) is promoted and 2 teams are relegated.

Proposed system: In each conference, 2 teams (conf champ + reg season champ, or if those are the same then conf runner up) are promoted, and 4 teams are relegated. Last-place team is relegated 2 levels.

Of course there will need to be some tweaking to make the numbers work out right because of the team that moves down 2, but you get the idea.
I think this fairly aggressive approach has been shown to be justified. It's obvious that those who were afraid to have more than 1 team promoted and 2 demoted each season had underestimated the imbalance that would remain in the leagues.


I've seen this bashed a lot, but I honestly think this is the best approach, the main complaint I've see is that higher leagues lose too many teams due to the whole pyramid thing. My view is that the more teams that are relegated, the more prestigious the higher leagues become, it's much harder to stay there for long periods of time.

So I concur with this and think more relegations are required.

In the case of a team being sold, I think there should be an option for an existing player to take over as caretaker for the rest of the season, there will probably be cases where the team cohesion is just not there and it won't work, but my experience has shown that teams generally have a group of loyal players who would try and build together.

These options may conflict but I am just throwing ideas out there.
 
tejas
offline
Link
 
My suggestion is say a pro team is sold or gutted. Take this team to the BBB or lowest league. Then take the team with the best record for the AAA league and move them up to the pro. Then take the best team from the AA league that is below them on the latter. Like if AAA#1 get a team moved up take a team from AA#1 or AA#2. Then move a team A#1 or A#2 and so on and so on.

The restructuring should happen at day 0 in my opinion so that the people who boost do it and then we restructure. Also the boosting should be shut down imo after day 0 until atleast day 15 or day 20 then allow boosting again. This would stop players from boosting after the restructure and abusing it. Or you can only boost to a certain level until day 15 or 20.
 
Ehran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tejas
My suggestion is say a pro team is sold or gutted. Take this team to the BBB or lowest league. Then take the team with the best record for the AAA league and move them up to the pro. Then take the best team from the AA league that is below them on the latter. Like if AAA#1 get a team moved up take a team from AA#1 or AA#2. Then move a team A#1 or A#2 and so on and so on.

The restructuring should happen at day 0 in my opinion so that the people who boost do it and then we restructure. Also the boosting should be shut down imo after day 0 until atleast day 15 or day 20 then allow boosting again. This would stop players from boosting after the restructure and abusing it. Or you can only boost to a certain level until day 15 or 20.



Just put a hard cap in place on the leagues and say you can't be above XX level until the end of the season.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I kinda like this idea...Basically, though, the players are gutting themselves off the team if they wanted. I guess it would allow the owner a way out without having to deal with releases/trades, etc, and the headache that goes with it.

On a related note (not addressed to AcidBee):

I think the thing that some people are missing is that if the team has no owner, no GM's, and a bunch of players left on it, those players are going to come and complain about having to stuck on a CPU team, ALL THE TIME.

It sounds all well and good to say "your contract will run out at the end of the season" but what if my owner sells on day 1 or 2 of the season? I'm stuck on a CPU-owned team until day 40? People who have signed on human teams want to play on human-controlled teams with people they know, not in the D-League. We need to let them go if they want.


I'd say turn a mid season team basically into a D-league, where players can sign onto other teams.

As well as after the season, just eliminate the team, promote lower teams (some type of formula) and have new teams start from scratch at the bottom (just like when you create a player... you start at level 1, you don't get an abandoned level 20 player)

This way it creates incentives to do as well as possible in lower leagues to do well in the playoffs because they might get promoted still (even if they don't win the championship) if more teams are getting promoted. Technically adding to the opportunities of motivated owners that want to start from the ground-up.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barry20
Originally posted by TrevJo

My feeling is that while Bort's ideas to solve this problem are well-intended, they are not very practical, largely because they are gimmicky.

Simple Alternate Suggestion: Increase promotion/relegation to include more teams each season. Also make it possible for a team to be relegated 2 levels in one season, since there are so many of these gutted teams (and probably will be for a long time).

Current system: In each conference, 1 team (conf champ) is promoted and 2 teams are relegated.

Proposed system: In each conference, 2 teams (conf champ + reg season champ, or if those are the same then conf runner up) are promoted, and 4 teams are relegated. Last-place team is relegated 2 levels.

Of course there will need to be some tweaking to make the numbers work out right because of the team that moves down 2, but you get the idea.
I think this fairly aggressive approach has been shown to be justified. It's obvious that those who were afraid to have more than 1 team promoted and 2 demoted each season had underestimated the imbalance that would remain in the leagues.


I've seen this bashed a lot, but I honestly think this is the best approach, the main complaint I've see is that higher leagues lose too many teams due to the whole pyramid thing. My view is that the more teams that are relegated, the more prestigious the higher leagues become, it's much harder to stay there for long periods of time.

So I concur with this and think more relegations are required.

In the case of a team being sold, I think there should be an option for an existing player to take over as caretaker for the rest of the season, there will probably be cases where the team cohesion is just not there and it won't work, but my experience has shown that teams generally have a group of loyal players who would try and build together.

These options may conflict but I am just throwing ideas out there.


I agree on the option for an existing player to take over. On the team for which I am a GM, when the owner sold the team at the start of season 2, he let players be released if they wanted it. Enough players left to hurt us, but since one of the in-house players bought the team, a lot of players stayed also. We kept the team together for the most part and now in season 3 we have recovered and are doing well. If the team had been sold to just some random guy it would have completely fallen apart and been shredded by now. A lot of us made players specifically for that team so when it was sold the only reason we stuck around was because we knew who it was sold to.

Also, to elaborate more on the idea of increased promotions/relegations, which you and I agree on. I agree with you that the higher leagues are where it would be the biggest concern. But even there I think it would be fine.
Take a look at USA Pro. In the West, the last-place team (Dallas Destroyers) has the talent level of a USA AA team, have only scored 12 points total in 11 games, and have 15 chemistry to boot. In the East, the last-place team (Beantown Gearheads) have even less talent, have only scored 9 points total in 11 games, and are below 60 chemistry. These two teams may have enough active players that they might not want to move down 2 levels, but if they did move down 2 levels it would be good for the competiteness both of the league they are leaving and the league they are going to.
Now let's look at the other 3 teams in the bottom 4 of each USA Pro conference. Records between 1-10 and 3-8. The top team of that group has talent comparable to the 8th place team in their conference, but they have 67 chemistry. They are good enough that they probably don't want to be relegated 1 level, but at the same time it really wouldn't be a bad thing if they were.
Now look at the top team in the same conference (West) in the league below (USA AAA#1). They (Fresno) are 11-0, have higher level players than the 8th-placed team in USA Pro, they went 18-1 last year and they only missed promotion last season because they lost in the conference finals to a team (Dayton) that they had beaten in the regular season (a team which is now 8-3 in USA Pro).
Last edited Jul 3, 2008 16:32:10
 
Dee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
My feeling is that while Bort's ideas to solve this problem are well-intended, they are not very practical, largely because they are gimmicky.

Simple Alternate Suggestion: Increase promotion/relegation to include more teams each season. Also make it possible for a team to be relegated 2 levels in one season, since there are so many of these gutted teams (and probably will be for a long time).

Current system: In each conference, 1 team (conf champ) is promoted and 2 teams are relegated.

Proposed system: In each conference, 2 teams (conf champ + reg season champ, or if those are the same then conf runner up) are promoted, and 4 teams are relegated. Last-place team is relegated 2 levels.

Of course there will need to be some tweaking to make the numbers work out right because of the team that moves down 2, but you get the idea.
I think this fairly aggressive approach has been shown to be justified. It's obvious that those who were afraid to have more than 1 team promoted and 2 demoted each season had underestimated the imbalance that would remain in the leagues.


I think thats great, especially the part with the bottom team getting a double relegation. Thats much needed!
 
Arawn
offline
Link
 
So when are we getting new teams?
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I've seen this idea floated around several times in several threads, and I do kinda like the idea of everyone starting with the same clean slate, bottom rung, when you get a team. There are some issues with the idea, though, so I'm just sort of collecting the various versions of this idea in one spot for discussion.

Basically the idea I've seen is:

When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

Now, help me figure out solutions to the problems that haven't been worked out with the idea, to see if it's even feasible:

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.


As usual it's a dilemma trying to get these things right. Right now the cupcakes are beyond ridiculous. 77-0 is bad enough, but the teams winning by over 200 are destroying the competitive balance between the conference for trophies. It makes them a joke when a guy gets 5 KR TDs in one game, and is markedly worse than another guy but gets to take that gold trophy with him to free agency.

I think too many people want to own a team just to own a team and quickly find it's not for them when they can't succeed or realize it's work. If you made it more of a privilege to own a team, and had less incentive to sell, it would significantly lower turnover. Of course the whiners will be out in droves, but as usual, sometimes you just have to tell them "It's for the good of the game, so deal with it."

Not allowing a flex refund for the current season of ownership is one way to encourage people to stick it out.

Players on the waiting list should be on the list for either A) New Teams only or B) A team for which they already have a player. That will absolutely deter some of the gutting. There's always going to be that mad dash of free agency mania with a change-over, but if it's your OC or DC taking over, it's curbed a little.

Forcing an owner to nominate a vice-president of the team to take over in the event he is inactive for a set period of days is another way to avoid some of the issues with inactivity if you don't allow mid-season sales.

I don't see any way that a team can be automatically booted from the league or another team called up working in mid-season. It seems like a logistical nightmare.

It's a dilemma, like I said, but I think the answer starts with enhancing pride of ownership, make it that much tougher and more rewarding to own a team, and having a decent parachute in place when the inevitable comes and it's time for an owner to hang it up.

We went a little too willy-nilly giving out teams like candy. Some guys abuse it by trying to run every colluding ruse they can think of, some guys want to put in zero effort, and some guys play with their shiny toy for two weeks and quit with a slight cost in flex.

I know no one wants to hear this, but the flex prices for a season of ownership are far too affordable. You can own a team for a few seasons for less than the cost of boosting and maintaining a skill player.

 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Man, I hear alot about new owners gutting teams. Well I got some perspective on that:

1) If I had to do over again, I would of stripped the whole team of its players and started over completly. Three reasons:
A) At first, they were supposed to sell to a friend, that they just signed, so he wasn't on the team for more then a day or two.
B) I had alot of trouble with the former owner and his coordinators. Gone off the bat (buh bye).
C) Then I had the slick buddies, who tried to sellout our game plans the first 6 games. So, after the chemistry grace period they got real vocal and started alot of shit on the team forums.

What I would of missed: A couple great agents that have become coordinators, and doing a great job of it.

But, the damage done by idiots far outweighs what I would of missed. So, when I see a new onwer totally gut a recycled team, I cant blame them. I tried my best, but some agents are complete assholes. I got well over 20 players, and I have had to resort to bringing in a couple of them, and I really tried to have none. But, some agents just dont like change, and can completly gum up the works. So dont lay all this stigmatism on a new owner gutting a team as a bad thing. If I had to do all over again, I would of done the same exact thing as they do. I had my chemistry grace period, and it could of been painless, but some agents will wait I have found out, to make you move them after it will damage your team. I put up move immediately thread in the team forum, no signups. They started that shit after the grace period ran out.

So, I am all for an option to take over a recycled team on the signup for the waitlist, but then have it completly stripped of all players. Let the new owner start over from scratch. And, the team will work it's way down through relegation, if they are overmatched. It's no biggy. It's not like their aint cupcakes in all the leagues anyways. Just let the promo/releg system work them to were they hit their equilibrium. As games go on, the players will get stronger, and if it's a pro team, they move down to AAA in a season, but now those players are level 17-21's, they may not be a top 5 team, but they probably wont be a bottom 2 team either. So, they have a chance to get back to Pro in a couple seasons. It's not a big deal. And it dont totally destroy their standings either.

If someone wants to start over, then allow an option to have their team, if not new, to be recycled to the bottom rung. If they dont want that, then they dont have to check the box to be at the bottom. It should totally be user choice. Not some regulation that says, "you suck, you have to start over automatically".

There are alot of owners out their in higher level leagues that still cant find thier ass from a hole in the ground. So, you think you are better then a new owner? Just let it be the owner choice.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LithoMan
Man, I hear alot about new owners gutting teams. Well I got some perspective on that:

1) If I had to do over again, I would of stripped the whole team of its players and started over completly. Three reasons:
A) At first, they were supposed to sell to a friend, that they just signed, so he wasn't on the team for more then a day or two.
B) I had alot of trouble with the former owner and his coordinators. Gone off the bat (buh bye).
C) Then I had the slick buddies, who tried to sellout our game plans the first 6 games. So, after the chemistry grace period they got real vocal and started alot of shit on the team forums.

What I would of missed: A couple great agents that have become coordinators, and doing a great job of it.

But, the damage done by idiots far outweighs what I would of missed. So, when I see a new onwer totally gut a recycled team, I cant blame them. I tried my best, but some agents are complete assholes. I got well over 20 players, and I have had to resort to bringing in a couple of them, and I really tried to have none. But, some agents just dont like change, and can completly gum up the works. So dont lay all this stigmatism on a new owner gutting a team as a bad thing. If I had to do all over again, I would of done the same exact thing as they do. I had my chemistry grace period, and it could of been painless, but some agents will wait I have found out, to make you move them after it will damage your team. I put up move immediately thread in the team forum, no signups. They started that shit after the grace period ran out.

So, I am all for an option to take over a recycled team on the signup for the waitlist, but then have it completly stripped of all players. Let the new owner start over from scratch.


Some good points. Also this is all the more reason to make promotion and relegation more aggressive as a way of dealing with gutted teams. If you think a team can compete in the higher leagues after starting from scratch, you are crazy. One relegation won't be enough.
Last edited Jul 3, 2008 21:17:35
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by LithoMan

Man, I hear alot about new owners gutting teams. Well I got some perspective on that:

1) If I had to do over again, I would of stripped the whole team of its players and started over completly. Three reasons:
A) At first, they were supposed to sell to a friend, that they just signed, so he wasn't on the team for more then a day or two.
B) I had alot of trouble with the former owner and his coordinators. Gone off the bat (buh bye).
C) Then I had the slick buddies, who tried to sellout our game plans the first 6 games. So, after the chemistry grace period they got real vocal and started alot of shit on the team forums.

What I would of missed: A couple great agents that have become coordinators, and doing a great job of it.

But, the damage done by idiots far outweighs what I would of missed. So, when I see a new onwer totally gut a recycled team, I cant blame them. I tried my best, but some agents are complete assholes. I got well over 20 players, and I have had to resort to bringing in a couple of them, and I really tried to have none. But, some agents just dont like change, and can completly gum up the works. So dont lay all this stigmatism on a new owner gutting a team as a bad thing. If I had to do all over again, I would of done the same exact thing as they do. I had my chemistry grace period, and it could of been painless, but some agents will wait I have found out, to make you move them after it will damage your team. I put up move immediately thread in the team forum, no signups. They started that shit after the grace period ran out.

So, I am all for an option to take over a recycled team on the signup for the waitlist, but then have it completly stripped of all players. Let the new owner start over from scratch. And, the team will work it's way down through relegation, if they are overmatched. It's no biggy. It's not like their aint cupcakes in all the leagues anyways. Just let the promo/releg system work them to were they hit their equilibrium. As games go on, the players will get stronger, and if it's a pro team, they move down to AAA in a season, but now those players are level 17-21's, they may not be a top 5 team, but they probably wont be a bottom 2 team either. So, they have a chance to get back to Pro in a couple seasons. It's not a big deal. And it dont totally destroy their standings either.

If someone wants to start over, then allow an option to have their team, if not new, to be recycled to the bottom rung. If they dont want that, then they dont have to check the box to be at the bottom. It should totally be user choice. Not some regulation that says, "you suck, you have to start over automatically".

There are alot of owners out their in higher level leagues that still cant find thier ass from a hole in the ground. So, you think you are better then a new owner? Just let it be the owner choice.


Some good points. Also this is all the more reason to make promotion and relegation more aggressive as a way of dealing with gutted teams.


I got no problem with more aggressive promo/rleg system. I just think it should be the new owners choice if they want to do it the hard way or easy way. My main point is no matter what, all team should be CPU when the new owner takes over.

Here, I can edit my response too. You think a team cant start over from scratch and be competitive? I tell ya what, we would be alot more competitive if the team would of beens stripped and I didnt have the chemistry hit because of dildo agents screwing up the team. If I had no choice, and wouldnt of had to worry about being a dick and getting rid of them all, and had no choice but to recruit from scratch, this team would be alot better off. I wouldnt be in the 20's on chemitry right now. And, that is more important then anything. I should of just been the dick and traded them all away, and started over. If anything, I could of built my stadium a hell of alot better then it is right now and be a hell of alot more competitive next season.

So, ya. One relegation probably could of been enough. Season 4 is a whole new season. Alot can change.
Last edited Jul 3, 2008 21:42:21
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Some of the ideas in this thread go so far beyond overkill its just plain stupid.

Simple solutions work best.


Just allow new owners to 'opt into' a Voluntary demotion system.
Teams will be demoted to the lowest league.

(Future refinements might include option for demotion to a league of similar average Level that includes a trade embargo up until Game 8, allowing teams to drop 4 levels and still be competitive but not outmatch teams, for situations where the owner was also half the team, but those that remain would beat up on any lower league teams, and thus saving a teams from 'Self Gutting' after sale.)

Utilise the Play Offs to allow full final standings, the losing teams from each round would face each other to produce a Rank of 1-8 in each division.
Use this as promotion order.

As a solution to the problems it also increases the competitive aspect of the game, and extends the season.

You can already dictate if you want to own a New or PreOwned team.
Now you have the choice of running the PreOwned team for the remainder of the season, or droppng down the leagues.
 
Waltang
offline
Link
 
The problem with this is that when teams get a new owner, its case by case as to there ability to be competitive.

My suggestion would be to make a couple changes to the relegation process.

#1 - Determine which teams get relegated by calculating the win percentage of teams under current ownership rather than season record. This way, a team that gets gutted mid season will get marked for relegation over a team that can actually win a couple games in the current league. (On a seperate note, it would certainly not hurt to increase the number of relegated and promoted teams for a couple seasons to get the leagues balanced out a little better.)

#2 - Take all of the teams that are marked for relegation and rank them based on their average level. Then assign them back to the leagues based on that, where the highest 4 relegated teams are sent to AAA, the next highest 8 relegated teams sent to AA, etc. If its important to keep the Zeta and Alpha teams seperated, then just calculate and reassign them seperately.

By performing relegations in this manner, a team that gets horribly gutted can drop 2-3 leagues if necessary to get them to the leagues they should be in quicker. Some teams may get assigned back to the same level league that they were relegated from, but this wont really hurt anything. Its hard to imagine it happening, but a check could also be put in to prevent a team from ever being promoted in this manner. The losing teams from the confernce championships could also be ranked by average level in each division and be promoted should a higher level league need an additional team to move up.
 
masskillz
offline
Link
 
The whole problem about giving someone the idea about do they want a gutted team or not is they really don't know until they get it. When I got my team I got a gutted team and I didn't know that's what I was going to get, but even if they would have told me I would have still taken it (unless I would have known about all the new teams being released). But my whole point is these new owners have no idea just how bad it can be, why in the world would you choose to take over a gutted team when you can get a new team in a comparable division and actually have a chance to win and winning is what all the free agents want anyways. That's why the New Africa Leagues had a much easier time recruiting free agents than established division gutted teams, because they knew in Africa they could win right away!

These reasons are why I am in strong support of all teams changing ownership be sent to the bottom of the league and every other team in the division moved up a spot(I guess you could base this on records using the playoffs for the final 1-16 rankings) during the off-season. That is the only way you are going to actually be able to get a good response out of the current promotion/relegation system we have in place. The way it is set up now the leagues are going to take for ever to balance out because all the relegation slots are going to the gutted and change of ownership teams who trade a lot of the teams players when they take over to get the ones they want. I just missed getting moved down last year and only had 2 wins and this year I am going to miss getting moved down again because of a team that dropped from AAA#1 last year to AAA#2 this year (25 game losing streak and counting). I'm sure next season someone else will not renew their team and someone else will take over, lose a bunch of players, lose a bunch of games and move down again. So how is that balancing out the division it's not it is just weeding out the teams that should be moved to the bottom anyways!
Last edited Jul 3, 2008 23:26:58
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LithoMan
I got no problem with more aggressive promo/rleg system. I just think it should be the new owners choice if they want to do it the hard way or easy way. My main point is no matter what, all team should be CPU when the new owner takes over.

Here, I can edit my response too. You think a team cant start over from scratch and be competitive? I tell ya what, we would be alot more competitive if the team would of beens stripped and I didnt have the chemistry hit because of dildo agents screwing up the team. If I had no choice, and wouldnt of had to worry about being a dick and getting rid of them all, and had no choice but to recruit from scratch, this team would be alot better off. I wouldnt be in the 20's on chemitry right now. And, that is more important then anything. I should of just been the dick and traded them all away, and started over. If anything, I could of built my stadium a hell of alot better then it is right now and be a hell of alot more competitive next season.

So, ya. One relegation probably could of been enough. Season 4 is a whole new season. Alot can change.


FWIW, I was editing my post while you were replying to it. I didn't know you had replied until after I had edited the post. I'm glad you followed up though.

To answer your question, you are correct, I think a team can't start over from scratch and be competitive. Not in any of the higher-level leagues I've been involved in (USA AA and Canada AAA) or any of the leagues above them.

I don't care what chemistry you have when the chemistry grace period is over. You aren't going to be able to field close to a full team before then, and by the time you do finish fielding the team your chemistry will be shot anyway. Besides that, chemistry is the least of the problems for a team starting over in a higher-league league...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.