User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This was the best suggestion on how to balance extreme attributes...
Page:
 
charwh
offline
Link
 
If you're traveling a fixed distance, say 10 miles, the difference in time between 5 and 25 mph is 96 minutes. The difference between 135 and 155 mph is only 34 seconds. not equal by a magnitude of 167.

it's like saying a speed of 0 is equally close to a speed of 20.



 
charwh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
You are wrong about this for a variety of reasons.

You would be right if the two players were engaged in a 100 m dash and this were a track meet game....but it's not.


There are a whole host of areas where the amount of speed you need is related to things other than the speed of an opposing player.




He would actually be right if the players raced for a given period of time to see who went the farthest total distance, and you didn't care if someone went twice as far or only say 10% farther, but only cared about the difference in the number of feet they traveled.

Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 17:48:48
Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 17:47:30
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

It is.


Also not true, depending on how you think about it.

If the race is measured in ticks, the 5 vs 25 scenario creates a tremendous gap relative to the speed of the players.

If the race is measured in GLB distance scales, the two players are practically in the same spot relative to (for instance) getting to the spot where a ball is throw down field.

Not nearly the same.

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by charwh
He would actually be right if the players raced for a given period of time to see who went the farthest actually.



Only if the distance between them at the end of the race were independently meaningful. The measure that is meaningful is the amount of time the slower takes to close the distance between the two, as you note.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by charwh
He would actually be right if the players raced for a given period of time to see who went the farthest total distance, and you didn't care if someone went twice as far or only say 10% farther, but only cared about the difference in the number of feet they traveled.



Exactly.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
You are wrong about this for a variety of reasons.

No, I'm really not. This: "a 20 point difference in the speed attribute produces the same difference in actual speed within the sim, barring other factors like energy." is an absolutely correct statement. You're arguing something related yet separate.

Originally posted by tautology
If the race is measured in ticks, the 5 vs 25 scenario creates a tremendous gap relative to the speed of the players.

For instance, with this comment you're going back to percentages. The actual difference in distance over a period of 5 ticks would be exactly the same between 5 and 25 as between 105 and 125. It's the same gap, but obviously that gap is a much smaller percentage of the total distance traveled in the second pairing. The percentage doesn't matter, though. You're not any closer to making the tackle, because the gap between is exactly the same in both cases.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

For instance, with this comment you're going back to percentages. The actual difference in distance over a period of 5 ticks would be exactly the same between 5 and 25 as between 105 and 125. It's the same gap, but obviously that gap is a much smaller percentage of the total distance traveled in the second pairing. The percentage doesn't matter, though. You're not any closer to making the tackle, because the gap between is exactly the same in both cases.


True, but WRs often slow down at the time of the catch. If a defender is 3 yards away from the WR who is no longer moving or has significantly reduced his speed, then the WRs top speed no longer matters. What matters is how quickly the defender can close that 3 yard gap before he gets back up to a speed greater than the defenders.

So while a WR with 150 speed vs. a CB with 130 speed may create the same amount of separation as a WR with 120 speed vs a CB with 100 speed, the distance is more significant in the second case because it now takes longer for the CB to cover that distance if/when the WR has to slow down.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by B-T-A
I think LB'ers have more speed usually than CB's, usually you see CB's at 115 Speed/100 Agility, but LB'ers at 130 Speed, 80 Agility.


urnotdoinitrite
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

For instance, with this comment you're going back to percentages. The actual difference in distance over a period of 5 ticks would be exactly the same between 5 and 25 as between 105 and 125. It's the same gap, but obviously that gap is a much smaller percentage of the total distance traveled in the second pairing. The percentage doesn't matter, though. You're not any closer to making the tackle, because the gap between is exactly the same in both cases.


Not true, and your argument is specious within the context of GLB.

Consider:

If your HB travels 20 yards per tick and my LB travels 17 yards per tick and you try to run a pitch, you will not get around me because you can't create enough physical separation before you hit the sideline...you will be in my tackling radius.

If you moved 4 yards per tick and I moved 1 yard per tick, you would create enormous separation by the time you hit the sideline and would be well out my reach.


Use the same logic for a pass play....in one case you gain a 1.5 yard separation on a 10 yard route....which I will easily close as you try to make the catch ( or before the ball can arrive). In the other case, you create a gap of 6 or 7 yards, which I will likely not be able to close after you make the catch.


The difference is enormous in terms of actual play. I use extreme examples to illustrate the point, but I think you get the idea.

In GLB actual game terms, speed does not have the sorts of impacts you imply.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Quick and easy to implement. There would be forum rage, but there will be about any change to equipment. Halving is by far the best option if anything is going to be done to EQ.


Except the the whole "18 seasons worth of balancing" being thrown out the window.

I agree.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Except the the whole "18 seasons worth of balancing" being thrown out the window. I agree.

I'm just talking about the change itself, not the consequences. You're absolutely correct that it would necessitate more changes, as would any substantial change to equipment. But compared to limiting how much you can have in EQ (which would require some AEQ resets, plus screw over min/maxed builds), halving is quicker and easier.


Originally posted by Rage Kinard
True, but WRs often slow down at the time of the catch. If a defender is 3 yards away from the WR who is no longer moving or has significantly reduced his speed, then the WRs top speed no longer matters. What matters is how quickly the defender can close that 3 yard gap before he gets back up to a speed greater than the defenders.

Fair point.


Originally posted by tautology
Not true, and your argument is specious within the context of GLB.

What I said is absolutely, 100% true. I keep pointing out that you are arguing against something I am not saying. It is undeniably accurate to say that "a 20 point difference in the speed attribute produces the same difference in actual speed within the sim, barring other factors like energy," but I am not saying that it would cause no changes in the sim. In fact, I'm counting on it producing changes, otherwise there is no point to making them at all.

For instance, in a separate thread I made the point that a 20 point gap in strength totals is much less likely to produce a pancake if both strength totals are relatively low than relatively high. Or, to complement your example, if a free safety is frozen by a pump fake, then the higher speeds from current equipment can create much more distance from the receiver because the speed factor is compounded by time. So a 150 speed WR might be impossible to catch after the FS is frozen for X ticks, whereas a 130 speed WR might be reachable depending upon the FS's position further upfield. Meanwhile the biggest effects would come between match-ups with equipment in different attributes, such as the all speed blitzing LB versus the no speed OL. With halved equipment, the OL is more likely to have time to move out and reach the blitzer.
Edited by jdbolick on Oct 21, 2010 19:23:33
 
broncohead
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
Originally posted by jpjn94

Couldn't another option be to link attributes together to reduce how high they could go?

e.g. You can't go higher than 70 in Speed without having 40 in Agility.

You could even at a third attribute to some like the example above you would need a min of 20 in Stamina. Those attributes could be linked all the way up. Then players would be forced to have say 80 in Agility to have 140 in Speed.




Good suggestion but I think it would be better to limit the amount of EQ or AEQ in one attribute. Make it 15-20
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
I think limiting how people create players is a way for people who suck at this game to try and get others down to their level. Only problem with this is, it creates an even larger gap, because with every change GLB makes the top 1% adapt and gain an even bigger edge over the avg users and we get even less parity
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Best way to balance extreme attributes is to make the sim that punishes them for their shortcomings in other areas, not by artificially forcing limits on them.


^ this.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.