User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
Page:
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by myd
It only takes one or two teams per league to take away the fun for the rest of the teams that play legit.


this. the game needs to be fair if they want me to get jazzed about playing and buying flex again.


as i've said before here and elsewhere, you can't rely upon the individual owners to "do the right thing". put some darn hard-caps in place to force the owners to choose if they wish to be loyal to agents and jump up a cap with their higher level players, or cut their over-cap players to stay in the lower cap. people will cheat to get their best opportunity to win- and we all know winning is more fun than losing anywhere. if there are no penalties in place to stop it, who is going to not cheat?

Working as intended? Maybe, but what you intended isn't happening.
Edited by Clarka3 on Sep 30, 2010 18:51:33
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
if we're going to keep the current promotion system- make the caps hard caps regardless of contract situation.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
I am still reading over this entire thread, but here are a few ideas I had. They both seem to work on paper/in my head.

Idea #1. ADJUSTED LEVEL

This helps balance the older player with many more training cycles with the younger boosting players.

I recommend having an adjusted level. This could be figured out with a quick sorting and averaging code Bort could come up with quickly. My example is as follows:

Adjusted level=(actual level*.75)+((Player age in days/4)*.25)

(I realize you could just divide player age by 16 and get the same answer, but this way shows how to get a 100%/1.0 number.)

The problem with this one is we cannot enforce simple actual level caps as it is

Idea #2 Age caps
If players are capped at age, combined with a small pyramid for each age capped league, players will all compete with like players for their entire career. all teams would sort up and down the pyramid while the pyramid moves closer and closer to uncapped leagues.

Newly created teams at the youngest cap would start out on randomly assigned leagues #1 #2 #3...etc. after one season the teams would be sorted by current tie breaking rules, and assigned to the appropriate league in the pyramid. So best record gets you in pro and so on and so forth.

Again, if you like these ideas say which one, and why.

If you do not like them please post why as well.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 5, 2010 09:57:43
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 5, 2010 09:57:34
 
Macabrevity
offline
Link
 
An age-based cap system kills the non-boosters, and the current system kills people for actually trying hard, as opposed to tanking it every other season, to secure a place in a lower-cap league.

Our team puts a lot of effort into game-planning, and seems to promote then double promote alternatively. Next season we will likely be in a cap that is 10 levels higher than our average dot. We'll win some games, but no real chance to do anything special, regardless of the amount of time we put into it. The current system almost begs us to go on auto-pilot and throw the season, which would ruin the fun for the rest of the league. Blowout wins against a team that's not even trying will quickly make the game not worth playing, and definitely not worth spending money on.

I think the current system allows a few sharks to swim in the goldfish bowl, which is really rough for teams playing to win every season.

I realize that at a certain point non-boosters have an advantage with older dots, but only when the team is on par level-wise with the boosters.

What about abolishing 'level' which is pretty meaningless anyway, and going with EL as the true rating of a dot and where it fits cap-wise. Then using the highest EL dot on a team to determine the lowest possible cap for that team? A teams record the previous season should be used to determine whether the squad goes into elite, competitive or regular.

I think that would make for some good competition across the board. With the current system you have teams going 0-16 followed by 16-0 and taking home hardware, and it has nothing to do with their coaches being any good. While good coaches are punished for over-achieving.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Macabrevity
An age-based cap system kills the non-boosters,


Every non-booster I see post begs for non-boosting leagues, where they can play like non-boosting teams. If all non-boosters ended up with other non-boosters at the bottom of the pyramid, how would that be killing them?

All they want is to implement LU into the main system, and stay out of the way of Boosting teams, or so they say.

P.S. Effective level is not level.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 5, 2010 13:17:32
 
Macabrevity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DONKEIDIC
P.S. Effective level is not level.


But it does show the overall value of the dot better than true level. A lower-level but older non-boosting dot that has the same EL as a younger boosted dot should have roughly the same value in the minors, assuming the agents know what they're doing. Whereas two level 22 dots, one older (non-boosted) the other boosted won't be equal thanks to the extra training put into the non-boosted dot.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
I'm not totally sold on effective level meaning more than average level. Ever notice there are just some teams you can't beat with a lower effective level or others that your team always beats that have a higher effective level than yours. Plus there are so many factors involved, I don't know if it's testable.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Macabrevity
But it does show the overall value of the dot better than true level. A lower-level but older non-boosting dot that has the same EL as a younger boosted dot should have roughly the same value in the minors, assuming the agents know what they're doing. Whereas two level 22 dots, one older (non-boosted) the other boosted won't be equal thanks to the extra training put into the non-boosted dot.


What I meant by "not level" is that an equally well built C,WR,QB,K,CB will not be the same level as each other. This mean you would start a team, and it would break up badly, or most players on the team would be vastly under leveled.

You didn't touch on what I said about non-boosters and their holier than thou stance, that all they want to do is play other non-boost teams, and not beat up on boosters.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 6, 2010 12:57:14
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 6, 2010 12:56:09
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Oct 6, 2010 12:55:55
 
ptompkins
offline
Link
 
*YAWN* do you guys actually think GLB is going to fix any of this stuff? Heck, we can't even block a field goal, fake a punt, get a two point conversion, put the ball from the 20 after a safety, on side kick, pass interference, block in the back, holding, and probably a lot more of "real" football.

And when you ask for things they implement stupid crap like free nachos, cheerleaders (happy endings extra), private jets, salary tax, league taxes. Heck, at leased if I had a losing team in the past as a team owner I could say "I'll pay for your equipment in the EQ fund" and keep a few guys around. Now noobs come into this game and expect to have a full stadium build after the first season, they think their players should automatically be level 70 instead of going through the normal build process.

Just be happy you have what you have. GLB will never get the promotion system down correctly. It's season 18, more than 2 years after this game went to BETA, and they still can't figure it out. It's pretty hard to do when they make so many dumb changes that cause people to leave.

And now you know why I won't buy flex points any more.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ptompkins
*YAWN* do you guys actually think GLB is going to fix any of this stuff? Heck, we can't even block a field goal, fake a punt, get a two point conversion, put the ball from the 20 after a safety, on side kick, pass interference, block in the back, holding, and probably a lot more of "real" football.

And when you ask for things they implement stupid crap like free nachos, cheerleaders (happy endings extra), private jets, salary tax, league taxes. Heck, at leased if I had a losing team in the past as a team owner I could say "I'll pay for your equipment in the EQ fund" and keep a few guys around. Now noobs come into this game and expect to have a full stadium build after the first season, they think their players should automatically be level 70 instead of going through the normal build process.

Just be happy you have what you have. GLB will never get the promotion system down correctly. It's season 18, more than 2 years after this game went to BETA, and they still can't figure it out. It's pretty hard to do when they make so many dumb changes that cause people to leave.

And now you know why I won't buy flex points any more.


QF leased
 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
I think that player age is the best way to go. But you will always have a variance even in that because of people building players at different stages of the season. But at least with the age method you are giving the advantage to the paying customers instead of the non-paying customers. I know that the non-boosters will cry foul, but it just makes good business sense to cater to the paying customers and not the non-paying customers.
 
SavageJ
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ilracefan
it just makes good business sense to cater to the paying customers and not the non-paying customers.


Not necessarily.

As GLB, you want everyone to be happy. Non-payers and payers alike can promote the game to others, provide players for rosters, post on forums, coach, coordinate, scout, and many other things that build up the GLB community. The stronger the community (ecosystem, if you prefer), the more revenue, or at least potential revenue.

Also, paying != boosting in every case. Some pay for teams, multiple players, and custom gear but don't boost. Yet another segment to consider.
 
VernonDavis85
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jaquizz Rodgers33
+1


 
Kloz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SavageJ

Also, paying != boosting in every case. Some pay for teams, multiple players, and custom gear but don't boost. Yet another segment to consider.


+1


Originally posted by Dustin.

Originally posted by Chysil

the root of the problem is that you promote a certain level of caps irregardless of what your player's levels are. If you are in a 14 cap league, and you are all level 14 at the start, if you don't make the playoffs you are promoted 1 cap (level 18), even though if you boost, all your players will be level 22. That's just crazy to me.

We have elite, competitive and regular leagues now. Why are we still promoting a # of caps based on how well you did?

Why not simply have a team promote into the lowest cap that they fit into. If your highest level player is level 30 than you go to a 32 cap league etc. You still have day 41 to cut people off your roster if you have a few guys that are higher level and would pull you into another cap.

then based on where you finished last season (conf champs vs playoff teams vs bottom of the barrel etc etc) you are placed in whichever league style fits your team (elite, competitive or regular)

it doesn't seem that hard to me...



+1

Originally posted by DONKEIDIC


Idea #2 Age caps
If players are capped at age, combined with a small pyramid for each age capped league, players will all compete with like players for their entire career. all teams would sort up and down the pyramid while the pyramid moves closer and closer to uncapped leagues.

Newly created teams at the youngest cap would start out on randomly assigned leagues #1 #2 #3...etc. after one season the teams would be sorted by current tie breaking rules, and assigned to the appropriate league in the pyramid. So best record gets you in pro and so on and so forth.

Again, if you like these ideas say which one, and why.

If you do not like them please post why as well.


-1



Originally posted by DONKEIDIC

Every non-booster I see post begs for non-boosting leagues, where they can play like non-boosting teams. If all non-boosters ended up with other non-boosters at the bottom of the pyramid, how would that be killing them?

All they want is to implement LU into the main system, and stay out of the way of Boosting teams, or so they say.


Big -1


Non-booster leagues call World League, Pro League, AAA and AA Leagues!
Edited by Kloz on Oct 11, 2010 02:14:00
Edited by Kloz on Oct 11, 2010 02:13:30
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.