User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why the hell should I HAVE to remember to have my Punter return kicks against gutjobs?!?
Page:
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis
Smaller roster limit + everyone gets max xp IMO. If you have 45 players and you don't play backups you're fucked, but I do think you can get away with it with 55 guys.


Agreed, the only people I've seen against max XP are the ones who forget that this is a frickin' game and confuse reality with make believe.
Edited by Dub J on Dec 13, 2009 17:10:17
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
But at least he can only do it for 1 season. Right now, he can do it for 4 seasons. That's an improvement.




Also, keep in mind that it's also impossible for the police to stop me from going to my next door neighbor's house and killing him with a butcher knife right now. But the police CAN arrest me for it afterward and punish me for my crime... which makes me think twice about committing that murder in the first place.

If you knew that gutting your team on Day 1 could mean getting banned from the game with no refund, would you still do it? A few people still would: we call them "assholes." But a lot of the other people who are doing Day-1 gutjobs right now would think twice about it, and you'd cut way down on the number of Day-1 gutjobs.


Maybe,

But again, do you really want to severely limit player movement, because that in essesnce is what you are doing,

Imagine this,

Medellin is Pro, we have gotten our asses kicked the past 2 years, say at Game 6 or so, we haven't won a game, I as an asshole get tired of it, start thinking about next year, so I trade these guys for cash, release others, sign younger LVL 10 builds that are well built, etc,

Am I gutting, or retooling?
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by foofighter24

In season, you can certainly limit player movement to 10 players. Allowing somone to gut their roster via cuts or cash trades is easily preventable.


Only if you severely hamper player movement,

You really want to prevent player movement in a football sim where recruiting/teams are a MAJOR part of the game?


In season, how many competitive teams are moving more than 10 players? It could be that you are allowed to make as many trades as you like, but you are only allowed to make so many trades that are of the gutting variety. (example: player for cash, or player for players that are under the league minimum)
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
And that is easily handled by using league minimums for trades.


Except there aren't league minimums, and there won't be,

See, you keep adding restrictions onto this problem, maybe now you see where I am going with this,

Ok, let's add in that league minimum,

So, Most PRO teams are at a LVL 50-LVL 70, average, so I trade my LVL 70's for LVL 50's, and then I use the bare minimum, I think it's 40, so let's go with that,

I then cut 10 from there, that's 30 reg, players, 10 cpu players, is that a gut?
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Novus

But at least he can only do it for 1 season. Right now, he can do it for 4 seasons. That's an improvement.




Also, keep in mind that it's also impossible for the police to stop me from going to my next door neighbor's house and killing him with a butcher knife right now. But the police CAN arrest me for it afterward and punish me for my crime... which makes me think twice about committing that murder in the first place.

If you knew that gutting your team on Day 1 could mean getting banned from the game with no refund, would you still do it? A few people still would: we call them "assholes." But a lot of the other people who are doing Day-1 gutjobs right now would think twice about it, and you'd cut way down on the number of Day-1 gutjobs.


Maybe,

But again, do you really want to severely limit player movement, because that in essesnce is what you are doing,

Imagine this,

Medellin is Pro, we have gotten our asses kicked the past 2 years, say at Game 6 or so, we haven't won a game, I as an asshole get tired of it, start thinking about next year, so I trade these guys for cash, release others, sign younger LVL 10 builds that are well built, etc,

Am I gutting, or retooling?


That is gutting.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
LOL true, but not really a component of a true gut job I thought.


Oh, well no...teams just sell.

But I see the whole "well, we are selling anyway, so what the hell, let's get some lulz" going up if teams can only sell in a small timeframe.
Edited by Deathblade on Dec 13, 2009 17:15:45
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Foo,

No it's not, I am definitely retooling, I know I suck this year, so I want to do right by the guys who stuck with me, so I am offering them a chance to pick their destination, and those that can move, I will, and I am retooling with younger, better builds, with the intention of moving down.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by foofighter24

And that is easily handled by using league minimums for trades.


Except there aren't league minimums, and there won't be,

See, you keep adding restrictions onto this problem, maybe now you see where I am going with this,

Ok, let's add in that league minimum,

So, Most PRO teams are at a LVL 50-LVL 70, average, so I trade my LVL 70's for LVL 50's, and then I use the bare minimum, I think it's 40, so let's go with that,

I then cut 10 from there, that's 30 reg, players, 10 cpu players, is that a gut?


Yes, you are making no effort to compete.

In AA, AAA, Pro, or World league, there need to be minimum levels, and consequences for gutting. It should be a privilege to play in those leagues. If you are making no effort to compete, your roster should be cut and you get dropped to a 13-cap.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Foo,

No it's not, I am definitely retooling, I know I suck this year, so I want to do right by the guys who stuck with me, so I am offering them a chance to pick their destination, and those that can move, I will, and I am retooling with younger, better builds, with the intention of moving down.


If you have the intention of moving down, you should declare that intention prior to the season. Cut the players and move down. Don't wreck the competition in leagues that are supposed to be the top of the game.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Maybe,

But again, do you really want to severely limit player movement, because that in essesnce is what you are doing,

Imagine this,

Medellin is Pro, we have gotten our asses kicked the past 2 years, say at Game 6 or so, we haven't won a game, I as an asshole get tired of it, start thinking about next year, so I trade these guys for cash, release others, sign younger LVL 10 builds that are well built, etc,

Am I gutting, or retooling?


Since it's mid-season, that's gutting, not retooling. And if I were Bort, my response would be to take your team away from you and ban you from owning another team. And if you already knew that's how I'd respond, you'd think twice about gutting mid-season, wouldn't you?

If you were actually re-tooling, you would take your lumps and finish out the season, pocketing that Pro-League cash along the way. Then, at the END of the season, you would let contracts expire, trade away guys with long-term contracts for extra cash, sign your well-built Level 10 guys, and get demoted to a capped-minor league. THAT is retooling.

Emptying your roster mid-season is gutting. Period.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Speak of the devil. 11 of 16 games won 255+ to 0
http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=46
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
If you have the intention of moving down, you should declare that intention prior to the season. Cut the players and move down. Don't wreck the competition in leagues that are supposed to be the top of the game.


I didn't know prior to the season, we were gonna get our asses kicked for the 3rd year, so you want me to give up on the season, prior to the season?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Since it's mid-season, that's gutting, not retooling. And if I were Bort, my response would be to take your team away from you and ban you from owning another team. And if you already knew that's how I'd respond, you'd think twice about gutting mid-season, wouldn't you?

If you were actually re-tooling, you would take your lumps and finish out the season, pocketing that Pro-League cash along the way. Then, at the END of the season, you would let contracts expire, trade away guys with long-term contracts for extra cash, sign your well-built Level 10 guys, and get demoted to a capped-minor league. THAT is retooling.

Emptying your roster mid-season is gutting. Period.


I bet you 50% of the people would disagree with you.

 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Speak of the devil. 11 of 16 games won 255+ to 0
http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=46


+ a 250-0
what a competetive league
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
I didn't know prior to the season, we were gonna get our asses kicked for the 3rd year, so you want me to give up on the season, prior to the season?


You're going to have to make a decision at the beginning of the season: can I succeed in this league, or am I probably just going to get my ass kicked for the 3rd season in a row?

That's life. If you guess correctly, you benefit. If you guess incorrectly, you pay a penalty.

Sure gives you a good incentive to make better guesses, doesn't it?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.